Excess Returns · · 1h 3m
The Three Poisons Behind the Sell-Off | Andy Constan on Why This Dip Is Different
With Andy Constan
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Andy Constan argues that the recent sell-off is driven by three pressures: rising net equity supply as corporations shift from buybacks to capex and new issuance (including Anthropic's IPO), high long-term rates that have persisted for months rather than spiking briefly, and earnings expectations that exceed what GDP growth can deliver to capital. He sees Oracle, neocloud data-centre issuers and government bond auctions as evidence that the market is struggling to absorb this debt and equity at good prices. He remains short equities, compares semiconductors' deflation to the Nasdaq's 2000 bubble, and treats gold and bonds as hedges to be added if policymakers respond or growth slows. He is sceptical that AI is priced at its true cost and says the bull case depends on paying, unsubsidised AI demand that translates into real productivity gains.
Key takeaways
- Andy Constan on Earnings & corporate profits: Corporate buybacks have collapsed as capex and issuance rise, removing a major source of demand for shares.
- Andy Constan on Anthropic: Anthropic still lacks the money for its compute obligations, so it will keep needing to raise capital.
- Andy Constan (bearish on Oracle): Oracle's stock has been hurt by its equity issuance, and its bond sales have widened its credit spreads.
- Andy Constan on US deficit & government debt: Government deficits are a major source of corporate profits, so flat deficits create a drag on earnings.
- Andy Constan on US rates & the Fed: The Fed can ease but is unwilling; cuts likely need a real slowdown or financial blowup first.
What was said, by company and theme
30 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Anthropic
Across the shows: 151 speakers in other episodes, 267 bullish and 130 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Anthropic
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Anthropic still lacks the money for its compute obligations, so it will keep needing to raise capital.
Andy says everyone knew Anthropic would get this money long in advance. Anthropic has guaranteed large compute obligations to providers and doesn't have all the money needed. Even with the new funds, it will keep issuing capital. That means continued supply to the market and continued financing pressure on the AI complex.
“they're gonna need a ton more money because they have a... compute obligation that they've guaranteed to compute providers, and they don't have the money for it.”at 14:40
Oracle
Across the shows: 33 speakers in other episodes, 10 bullish and 30 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Oracle
Andy Constan · Damped Spring AdvisorsBearish
Oracle's stock has been hurt by its equity issuance, and its bond sales have widened its credit spreads.
Andy uses Oracle as the first example of weak absorption of AI-related issuance. Its stock has been destroyed by issuance, and its corporate spreads have gone up dramatically because of its bond issuance. Investors are not absorbing this debt and equity at good prices, so the financing burden is weighing on the stock and the credit.
“Their stock has been destroyed by issuance. Their corporate spreads have gone up dramatically due to their corporate bond issuance.”at 21:47
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Long-term rates staying high, unlike past brief spikes, is what actually tightens conditions and slows the economy.
In recent years rate rises have repeatedly been reversed by policymakers once the economy looked weak, so yields never stayed high. A brief spike to 5% on the 10-year that falls back within weeks does nothing, because nobody transacts at those rates. Now borrowing rates have been high for months and are staying high, so borrowers actually face the higher cost. That persistence is what slows growth and poisons the economy.
“the dynamic today is that interest rates have not [topped] and are persisting at high levels. And that's what you need to actually shift the wind. That's what poisons the economy.”at 7:07
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Treasury auctions are clearing at poor prices, with yields rising on each deal and bond buyers underwater.
Andy tracks how each issue trades and what concessions issuers must pay. He says the deals aren't being done at good prices and Treasury isn't getting its deals done well. Yields rise with each issuance, and government bond buyers are nearly all underwater. He takes this as evidence the market is struggling to absorb the rising supply of debt.
“the deals are not getting done at good prices. Treasury is not getting its deals done at good prices. Interest rates are rising every time they do a deal.”at 23:09
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Heavier government and corporate bond supply will keep long yields higher for longer, not a quick V-top.
Governments globally need to borrow more than before. Foreign governments are raising military spending, which creates an inflection in global government bond markets. On top of that, capex-related corporate issuance and the ongoing US deficit add supply. Without a growth slowdown and an easing response from the Fed, that extra supply is enough to keep interest rates higher for longer. The long end has been above 5% for about two months, and he expects this to wear on the economy over months rather than reverse quickly.
“you layer on top of that increased supply, and that's enough to keep interest rates higher for longer.”at 42:21
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Bonds offer attractive yields now and would be a hedge if growth slides into a slowdown.
He says the market is offering bonds at relatively attractive yields. He would like to own bonds in case the world moves from a growth scare to a real growth slowdown, when yields would be expected to fall. He describes this as an ordering question: he wants to hold bonds and gold as hedges, and to stay short equities, if policymakers do not act. He does not say he currently owns them.
“Own the bonds in case the world does go from a growth scare to a growth slowdown.”at 52:27
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
AI capex is not projected to end in the near term, and it is funded by ongoing issuance.
Buybacks could return once capex ends and companies run out of uses for their cash. Andy says capex could eventually end, but it is not projected to end in the near term. He notes that forecasts are especially strong for those selling the picks and shovels of the buildout. Until then, capex keeps absorbing cash that would otherwise go to buybacks.
“eventually CapEx could end. It's not projected to end in the near term, and it's certainly not projected to end based on those who are selling picks and shovels.”at 16:56
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Neocloud data-centre providers' security issues have mostly traded around 50% below issue price.
Andy looks at the aftermarket performance of recent issues. He says the neocloud providers, the narrow data centre companies, have seen every issue they've done trade about 50% underwater. He argues this shows weak market absorption of the capital needed to build AI infrastructure.
“Every issue they've done is, you know, 50% underwater.”at 22:36
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Local opposition may push data-centre projects from states like Texas and Ohio toward other states.
Andy treats data centres as a local issue rather than a national one. He thinks states could push back, with Texas and Ohio as the obvious large data centre markets. He suggests projects destined for those states might look for different states instead. He is hedged and says the topic is probably outside his area.
“I think it's possible that states push back. Texas, for instance, being the most obvious one... Projects that had been destined for those states might look for states that are different.”at 38:16
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Data center siting obstacles are a road bump that won't stop AI, though they hurt builders short term.
Projects that were headed to certain states may have to look elsewhere because of local obstacles. He says this is a bump that won't stop AI, and that it has mattered for some companies building data centers in the short term. He thinks there are bigger issues, including security and the hacks that have been occurring, and the question of what humans do in a world with AI. Those matter more than data center construction.
“It seems to be a bit of a road bump that isn't going to stop AI. I think there are much bigger issues around security,”at 38:41
US deficit & government debt
Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Deficits and corporate issuance can be financed indefinitely by savers, but corporate debt needs more reliable repayment.
When the government runs a deficit, the money spent goes to private recipients, and savers buy the bonds that fund it. Those savings grow and finance the bond, so this cycle is self-financing. Corporations work the same way but cannot print money or force transfers, so they need reliable repayment. For now, the economy is in an issuance-and-investment phase in which money moves from retiring shares to building capex. That keeps asset prices low while still enabling spending.
“as long as people are willing to temporarily lend money at whatever interest rate, you can do this forever.”at 19:17
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Government deficits are a major source of corporate profits, so flat deficits create a drag on earnings.
Using the Kalecki-Levy profits framework, profits equal top-line revenue minus expenses, and government deficit spending is a significant source of that revenue. Growing deficits lift earnings growth, flat deficits leave earnings flat, and falling deficits drag on profits. Deficits are expected to stay large but stop growing, so they are flat and a drag on corporate profits.
“one thing that we have seen very clearly and they demonstrated is that government deficits are a source of profit.”at 32:57
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Treasury has given no sign of cutting coupon supply as a stimulus lever soon.
Bessent could ease financial conditions by reducing coupon supply, which would cut bond issuance and lower interest rates. That lever is available once a quarter, with the next opportunity around early February. But the quarterly refunding announcement gave no evidence that it is an imminent decision. Treasury kept auction sizes the same and guided toward issuing a lot without cuts. He expects the status quo until the economy weakens.
“the QRA didn't give any evidence that that's an imminent decision.”at 44:29
Earnings & corporate profits
Where everyone stands on Earnings & corporate profits
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Equity earnings expectations need more GDP growth than the economy can deliver, leaving too little profit pie.
Even rosy GDP projections, when split between labour and capital, give capital (mostly equities) less than the earnings expectations investors hold. Those expectations, rather than P/Es, are the real issue. Tech firms talk about double-digit growth for their own businesses, but that growth must come out of the GDP pie. So the pie cannot cover all the expected earnings, which means some winners take a large share and others get little.
“But earnings expectations are, and there's just not enough pie to fulfill all those earnings expectations.”at 6:07
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Corporate buybacks have collapsed as capex and issuance rise, removing a major source of demand for shares.
Corporations were a consistent net buyer of shares for years, so their buybacks reduced net supply. Now capex dominates their spending and they can't afford both capex and buybacks, so they cancelled buybacks. Companies are also issuing new stock, as with the Anthropic IPO, so net supply is rising. Andy sizes the shift at roughly a trillion dollars, moving net share reduction to flat. Holders must absorb the extra shares, which pressures prices. Employee-related repurchases don't reduce net supply, and discretionary buybacks are rare at current valuations. Buybacks may return only if capex ends or they run out of uses for cash.
“the big change is that corporations have no longer been able to afford both their business, which nowadays is dominated by CapEx, both their CapEx and their share buybacks. So one had to go, and they canceled share buybacks.”at 10:54
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Three pressures have turned the market from extreme growth optimism to a slowdown, and stocks are correcting.
Andy names three pressures: financing needs that compete with spending, earnings expectations that exceed what GDP can deliver, and persistently high rates. Together they shift the backdrop from optimistic, high-growth expectations toward weaker growth. He argues the outcome is not a recession but a sharp reversal of prior growth hopes. Markets have begun to correct since he published his paper, as they recognise this.
“those three things to me poisoning the karma and have shifted the karma to one in which we're going to get not the opposite, not a recession, but the opposite of what we had been getting, which is extremely optimistic, high growth expectations.”at 7:43
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Broad US equities remain short; expectations are too high and the market has not yet debubbled.
He says he is still short equities. The broad market still carries massive earnings and growth expectations that he does not think can be delivered, especially with rates high and asset supply rising. He compares it to the Nasdaq leading the S&P 500 in 2000. He says the S&P 500 is not debubbled, even though semiconductors have deflated, and the air has not come out of the broad market the way it has in chips. He expects a sideways-to-down path that depends on whether policymakers act, with stocks roughly three or four percent from where he expects that policy conversation to happen.
“The broader equity market is still got these massive expectations, which are not going to be able to be delivered.”at 58:17
US growth & recession risk
Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
A shrinking labour force and 2-3% productivity limits how fast GDP can grow, even with AI.
GDP grows from labour force growth plus productivity. The labour force has stopped growing because the border was closed, and developed-market birth rates are falling, so they add little. Productivity booms have historically lasted five to twenty years and raised output per worker by about 3% a year, and even major innovations like energy, the internet, and AI have reached only 2-3%. Andy notes an extreme scenario where machines make everything free, but this depends on capital and returns on capital, so it is years away. Tech firms' double-digit growth must come from the GDP pie, not expand it.
“we've seen the labor force stop growing as the border was closed and our birth rate, developed market birth rates have been falling, but are still positive.”at 25:39
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
A growth scare is underway and could become a real slowdown if asset prices stay depressed.
He reads the recent sell-off as a growth scare driven by lots of assets for sale, falling asset prices hitting savers, expectations of robust growth easing toward reality, and interest rates staying persistently high for months. A brief V-bottom in stocks does little harm because the wealth effect is short and most people barely notice. But if the S&P 500 stays near 7,000 and drifts sideways for three or four months, the wealth effect will slow spending. He says he is agnostic on whether the scare becomes a slowdown or a recovery, and that persistence is the test.
“So I think we're getting a growth scare and we'll see how it plays out.”at 46:08
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Leverage used to fund big purchases can force selling and cascade through equities when prices fall.
Andy describes how the large raise behind the Anthropic deal had to come from margin borrowing, since selling existing shares would just transfer the burden to other buyers. If the new position goes badly, the investor's other shares fall, and they must sell holdings to cut leverage. The forced sellers then need a lower price to find buyers, which triggers further selling. The same mechanism works in reverse when stocks are in demand, magnifying moves in both directions.
“when you lever up, if it doesn't go well, your other shares, for instance, start to fall... And so those sorts of things cascade.”at 13:31
Credit markets
Where everyone stands on Credit markets
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Spreads are widening across all issuers as heavy AI-related bond issuance is pushing them wider.
Andy examines spreads as a gauge of absorption. The most leveraged issuers, with the narrowest revenue and profit base to repay debt, are hit hardest by wider spreads. But even Google, which has the stronger balance sheet, is seeing its spreads widen. Everyone issuing is pushing spreads wider, which signals weakening demand for the debt.
“Google's spreads are widening too. Everybody that's issuing is hammering spreads wider.”at 23:57
AI pricing & unit economics
Where everyone stands on AI pricing & unit economics
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
AI is probably underpriced and heavily subsidised, so consumption would fall at real prices.
Andy argues it is unclear that AI is priced at its real cost, which means it could be heavily subsidised. Stories of people spending millions on tokens suggest that heavy users are paying far less than the true cost. Most people pay a few hundred dollars a month. If prices were several times higher, he doubts they would keep consuming as much, and they would have to cut spending elsewhere because wages aren't rising. Jack's example of a $200 plan running through $200 of tokens in 15 minutes at standard rates supports this.
“it's unclear to me that... AI is priced well, meaning it could be heavily subsidized.”at 30:09
AI & jobs
Where everyone stands on AI & jobs
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
AI productivity is not yet showing up in the economy because firms are not cutting staff.
Productivity means producing more output that can be sold. Most people are doing the same jobs with AI and aren't changing the rest of their work, so it isn't boosting margins. The current price could also mean a real productivity boom is not being captured. Andy says the boom isn't visible in the data because nobody is firing workers, so no one is getting the efficiency of doing more with fewer people.
“it isn't showing up as one because no one's firing workers, so no one's getting the efficiencies of being able to do more with one... As one person.”at 31:22
AI: overall outlook
Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Andy is very optimistic about AI's capabilities but doubts its pricing and profitability.
Andy is very optimistic about the capabilities of AI. His doubts concern pricing and when firms will start cutting the work they'd otherwise do, including firing workers. The test is whether customers can use AI profitably at prices that also reward the companies supplying it.
“I'm very optimistic about the capabilities of AI. I just don't know about the pricing.”at 31:36
US tax & spending policy
Where everyone stands on US tax & spending policy
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
A Democratic Congress facing a Trump veto is likely to lift deficits, with gridlock as the default.
Republicans lean toward less spending and less taxes, while Democrats want more spending and more taxes, so the two sides are in basic opposition. Trump's vetoes block any Democratic spending or tax plan, and cuts can't pass either. Andy expects a Democratic Congress to roll back some of the spending cuts from the One Big Beautiful Bill and avoid cutting taxes, which makes the agenda deficit-increasing. That is good for growth and bad for inflation. He is unsure whether Trump would allow it and his working assumption is that nothing gets done.
“So that tells me the Democrat agenda is going to be deficit increasing... And so that's good for growth. That's bad for inflation.”at 36:06
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
The Fed can ease but is unwilling; cuts likely need a real slowdown or financial blowup first.
He says the Fed has repeatedly eased at the first sign of trouble, such as a small drop in inflation, SVB failing, or repo tightness. Each time, inflation roared back. Waller, once a dove, now talks of hikes and says inflation has been above target for 68 months, and the committee is hawkish. He thinks policymakers are able to ease but do not seem willing. A cutting or QE cycle would need more than a growth scare, namely an actual growth slowdown or a financial blowup. Inflation also complicates a quick rescue.
“So they're able. I just don't think they're willing.”at 42:07
US housing
Where everyone stands on US housing
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Mortgage rates at 7.25% will start slowing housing, though the drag will take more than months.
Mortgage rates are at 7.25%, which he says will start to wear on people and slow housing activity. He does not expect a quick reversal. The high-rate drag is part of his view that persistently high borrowing costs will keep a lid on economic activity. The housing effect will take more than a few months to play out.
“Mortgages are at seven and a quarter percent. That's going to start slowing housing.”at 42:46
Gold & precious metals
Where everyone stands on Gold & precious metals
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Gold should do well if policymakers bottom stocks, though he's waiting for a lower entry price.
He owns gold for his beta and expects it to do well if equities bottom because of policy decisions. Those decisions would be bad for the dollar, good for gold, and bad for inflation. Gold and crypto are ahead of equities in realising that the central bank may not have investors' backs. He is looking to buy more gold in his alpha account at very attractive prices, but he thinks it is not there yet. He wants to wait and see whether the equity market stabilises first.
“If it v bottoms, man, gold's gonna do great.”at 53:03
US inflation
Where everyone stands on US inflation
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
Headline CPI will likely print negative soon, driven by a collapse in energy prices.
CPI contains a lot of gasoline, oil and other energy, and those prices have been crushed. That makes a negative headline CPI print likely, possibly as early as the next release. He thinks the Fed knows this and is still staying hawkish. He says investors should be prepared for policymakers to behave as they always have, but he does not know how they will respond.
“we're gonna get a negative CPI print, headline CPI print soon.”at 56:39
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Andy Constan · Damped Spring Advisors
The semiconductor bubble has popped; buying the dip after missing the rally usually fails.
He thinks semiconductors have just gone through a bubble popping. Given the rally and the severe correction since, it is hard to argue it was not a bubble. In his experience, investors who missed the upside and buy the dip on the way down in such a bubble lose a lot of money. He warns against that temptation for picks-and-shovels and the broader AI trade, and says the right approach in a bubble regime is to stay disciplined on risk and not lever up.
“I think we're on the other side of a bubble popping in semiconductors.”at 58:06
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
Topics
- AI capabilities vs pricing
- AI pricing and subsidies
- AI productivity gains
- Fed easing reluctance
- S&P 500 downside and expectations
- Treasury coupon supply lever
- auction absorption
- bond supply and higher-for-longer rates
- bonds as slowdown hedge
- buybacks
- capex duration
- compute financing
- data center siting
- data center siting and permits
- debt financing and crowding out
- debt-funded capex
- deficits and corporate profits
- earnings expectations vs GDP
- gold as policy hedge
- growth scare vs slowdown
- headline CPI energy-driven decline
- high long-term rates persistence
- leverage and forced selling
- market correction and growth expectations
- mortgage rates and housing slowdown
- neocloud issuance absorption
- potential GDP growth
- semiconductor bubble popping
- spending gridlock and deficits
- spreads and issuance concessions
- token monetisation and profitable demand
More from Excess Returns
- Who Pays for the AI Buildout? Two Bond Investors Take Us Inside the Debt Market · November 19, 2026
- The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This 2018 Again? | Barry Knapp · November 18, 2026
- From Poker Pro to Elite Hedge Fund Manager: David Orr on Investing, Risk and AI · November 17, 2026
- Show Us Your Portfolio: Meb Faber · November 15, 2026
- Fidelity’s Jurrien Timmer on AI Spending, Bond Yields and the Next Phase of the Bull Market · November 13, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus