Excess Returns · · 1h 4m
The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This 2018 Again? | Barry Knapp
With Barry Knapp
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Barry Knapp argues the Fed is tightening into slowing earnings growth, a set-up he says closely resembles 2018, though he is not forecasting a repeat of the 1999-2000 hiking episode. He contends inflation is mainly fiscal, citing weak core goods and strong core services, and that the Fed is hiking on the wrong diagnosis, distorting small banks, small businesses and housing while the balance sheet still provides accommodation to large borrowers. On AI, he says hyperscaler capex has likely peaked, with the big four's shares falling about 11% and capex growth halving from roughly 125% to 60%, and that technology productivity gains are diffusing slowly. He is underweight tech and consumer staples, overweight financials and industrials, and holds substantial cash in case a 10-12% year-end pullback arrives.
Key takeaways
- Barry Knapp on US stock market outlook: Fed tightening into slowing earnings growth resembles 2018, so he is cautious on stocks near term.
- Barry Knapp on AI infrastructure & data centers: Hyperscaler AI capex growth will slow toward EBITDA growth; likely peak capex as financing costs rise.
- Barry Knapp on US rates & the Fed: Fed's rate and balance-sheet policy is distortive, restricting small borrowers while large ones benefit; needs rebalancing.
- Barry Knapp (bearish on Walmart): Walmart is really expensive and not growing, though he won't say buy or sell.
- Barry Knapp (bearish on The Procter & Gamble Company): P&G's 'killing it with AI' claim is unsupported by 0–3% organic growth.
What was said, by company and theme
27 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Walmart
Across the shows: 8 speakers in other episodes, 5 bullish and 3 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Walmart
Barry Knapp · Ironsides MacroeconomicsBearish
Walmart is really expensive and not growing, though he won't say buy or sell.
Walmart is his poster child for expensive defensives with little growth, which is why staples are unattractive. He explicitly does not do individual name analysis and will not say buy or sell Walmart, but his view is that the stock is really expensive and not growing.
“I'm not gonna tell you, buy or sell Walmart, but Walmart is really expensive and it's just not growing.”at 53:18
The Procter & Gamble Company
Across the shows: 4 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 2 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on The Procter & Gamble Company
Barry Knapp · Ironsides MacroeconomicsBearish
P&G's 'killing it with AI' claim is unsupported by 0–3% organic growth.
After P&G's earnings, a wealth manager pointed to management saying the company is killing it with AI. The headline reported organic growth of zero to 3%, and Knapp says he does not know the counterfactual of what would have happened without AI. Weak organic growth does not show the AI benefit management claims, so P&G is not a good place to be.
“They're killing it with AI with a zero to 3% earnings growth rate. I mean, organic revenue growth rate... I don't know what the counterfactual is. What would have happened without AI?”at 54:03
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Fed tightening into slowing earnings growth resembles 2018, so he is cautious on stocks near term.
Knapp argues the Fed is tightening into slowing earnings growth, which he says is decidedly similar to 2018. He compares it with late 1999 to 2000, when the Fed delivered five 25bp hikes and one surprise 50bp move, and things came unglued. He says he is not forecasting that scenario, but from a tactical next-couple-of-months view the core message is that the Fed is tightening into slowing earnings. He adds that a 2018-style equity pullback going into next year would make him a little more optimistic, but for now he sees a government financing problem, more labour displacement, peak AI capex and peak earnings growth.
“The Fed is tightening into slowing earnings growth. This is decidedly similar to what happened in 2018,”at 1:27
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Overweight industrials, betting a capex boom broadens to materials and energy.
He expects that a capex boom could broaden beyond AI into industrials and then materials and energy, and holds an overweight in industrials on that view. Broadening needs immediate expensing, a stable environment and a reopened credit channel for smaller firms. He argues that this broadening, not a recession or an AI collapse, is the constructive path for earnings.
“We've been overweight industrials on this idea that we will have a CapEx boom that will eventually broaden materials and energy.”at 50:44
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Expects a 10–12% year-end drawdown like 2018, holds healthy cash to deploy later.
Fed tightening into slowing earnings growth resembles 2018, and he thinks there is a good chance of an end-of-year drop of at least 10–12%, a move he describes as Santa not showing up. That is why he holds a healthy cash position. After such a decline he would look to deploy some of the cash, and he would consider positioning for slowing earnings if a decent equity pullback comes toward year-end, provided the economy avoids a crash.
“We have a healthy cash position right now because I do think there's a pretty good chance for that 2018 analog to unfold and have at least down 10 to 12% sort of end of the year, Santa doesn't show up this year kind of move.”at 50:54
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Underweight tech at about 27.5%; no return to market weight until earnings comps level out.
He has scaled back tech through the year and is underweight, not zero, since many clients are benchmarked to the Russell and S&P 500, where tech and comm services are about half the index. He holds tech at about 27.5% and comm services at about 5%. He is not a technology Luddite and thinks a position is needed, since AI could lead to a big productivity boom. But he will not return to market weight until the company earnings comparisons start to level out after lapping Q1 earnings, which he expects around the second quarter.
“The tech sector, I don't think you can get back to a market weight position until we lap first quarter earnings and the comps start to level out.”at 52:24
US inflation
Where everyone stands on US inflation
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
The Fed misdiagnoses inflation; fiscal spending, not energy, tariffs or AI demand, drives services prices.
The Fed cites energy prices through diesel transport costs, tariffs and AI-related demand as the causes of inflation. Those should show up in goods prices, but in the latest CPI core goods were the weakest of the three major categories, both annualised and month over month. Core services were the strongest, including supercore non-housing services, and rents sat in between. Knapp concludes the real source of inflation is fiscal policy, which pushes up services prices. Because the Fed is hiking on the wrong diagnosis, the tightening will leave a distinct mark on sectors like housing that are not driving the inflation.
“So the real source of inflation is fiscal policy, and that's what's putting upward pressure on these services prices.”at 9:39
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Trend inflation is 2.5–2.75%, not 2%; the 2% target was aspirational.
Trend US inflation is 2.5% to 2.75%, not 2%. The Fed's 2% target was introduced in January 2012 as an aspirational target to avoid 1930s-style deflation. What matters more is the standard deviation of CPI, which has a long-term median of about 60 basis points and is now about 50. If it falls to 30–40 basis points, even with a 3% trend inflation rate the environment is good for capex and can support about 15% earnings growth.
“Trend inflation in this country is not two. It's two and a half to two and three quarters.”at 41:26
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Inflation is mostly a fiscal phenomenon that becomes a problem when the Fed accommodates it.
Friedman's view that inflation is always a monetary phenomenon is wrong in his view. Inflation is mostly fiscal, becoming a real problem when the Fed accommodates the fiscal impulse. Post-WWII and 1960s–70s inflation came from a massive expansion of fiscal spending, with transfer payments rising from 5% of GDP to 13% in a decade. Inflation also took off in 2020–2021. Debt-crisis worries first manifest through inflation, so investors should watch the fiscal impulse. Cash checks are a band-aid, not a fix.
“Inflation is always and everywhere, mostly a fiscal phenomenon that becomes a real problem when the Fed facilitates it, right, or accommodates it or allows that fiscal impulse to wash through the markets.”at 58:03
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Fed's bond holdings ease rates for big borrowers while hikes squeeze small banks, businesses and homebuilders.
Knapp argues the Fed eased mainly through its balance sheet during the pandemic, buying Treasuries and mortgages, but tightened mainly through the policy rate and only passively unwound the balance sheet. That left the duration accommodation in place for high-quality investment-grade borrowers, lowering the term premium to roughly 65bp against about 1.25% before the financial crisis. Meanwhile the rate tightening fell disproportionately on small banks and small businesses; small-bank ROE is about double its 2000s level relative to large banks, which he calls a k-shaped distortion. The Fed's SOMA weighted average maturity is almost nine years against about 5.3 for outstanding Treasuries. He says it should shorten that duration to cut the long-rate subsidy for hyperscalers, and that the Fed is buying about 20% of the 10- and 30-year auctions. He notes the big banks were happy to see hikes because their reserve balances now pay interest.
“By only passively unwinding their balance sheet, they left that accommodation in place for investment grade credit borrowers... But that tightening fell disproportionately on small banks, small businesses.”at 15:44
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Fed's rate and balance-sheet policy is distortive, restricting small borrowers while large ones benefit; needs rebalancing.
Higher short-term rates squeeze small businesses, small banks, homebuilders and real estate developers, while large borrowers benefit from the Fed's bond holdings. The Fed created this imbalance and needs to fix it. He puts the neutral policy rate at about 3%. The balance sheet still provides at least that much accommodation, roughly 75 basis points in the back end, so raising the policy rate to 4% would still leave overall policy a little restrictive. He has called policy neutral since before the tightening began, but distortive.
“We do need to rebalance monetary policy as well so that it's just that credit channel is open to these mom and pop builders.”at 45:26
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
December projections could force a hawkish hike and a 2018-style reaction.
The Fed's Summary of Economic Projections in December is what to watch. If the forecasts move up sharply, that would signal a big hawkish hike and a reaction like December 2018, since the balance sheet is on autopilot. Chair Warsh will probably avoid saying much, so the projections matter more than the press conference. A 50 basis point surprise is not expected, though Waller floated it and no one else seemed on board.
“But a big hawkish hike because the summary of economic projections forecasts moved up sharply.”at 56:20
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
This year's rise in Treasury yields is mainly Fed policy path, not Treasury or hyperscaler supply.
Knapp says the 2025 rise in long yields had nothing to do with Treasury supply in the way the 2023 to 2024 move did. Hyperscaler credit supply contributed about 20% of the move to a 5.30% 10-year yield, with record issuance in March and heavy August supply. The main driver was the Fed. Expected cuts of 50bp in the December projections a year earlier have turned into likely hikes of 50bp. Two-year yields are up 137bp year to date, and he says a regression of rates on the policy path points to Fed policy as the driver. Knapp reads carry as the cost of capital, which the Fed has raised sharply.
“the real driver of rates this year was fed policy.”at 12:26
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
The 2022 bond rout was driven by the terminal-rate forecast jump, not the 75bp hike.
Looking back at September 2022, the 75bp hike was fully expected. The underappreciated story was that the Fed's terminal funds rate forecast rose 80 basis points. The Japanese intervened the next morning, buying yen for about $22–23 billion, and a couple of days later the gilt market imploded. The US mortgage market became bid-less, and the Fed had to start backing away from its tightening cycle. He argues the Summary of Economic Projections, not the policy move itself, is what drives bond market reactions.
“the Fed had to start backing away from their tightening cycle. That was driven by an 80 basis point increase in their terminal funds rate forecast, not this third consecutive 75 basis point rate hike.”at 55:53
US jobs & labor market
Where everyone stands on US jobs & labor market
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Falling labour churn is an underappreciated shaky base for wages, productivity and labour share.
Knapp says the headline payroll number is a three-basis-point residual, while about 10% of the labour market changes status every month. Using the Haltiwanger and Davis worker reallocation measure from JOLTS, which sums hires and separations over the labour force, reallocation is about 21%, implying the whole labour force turns over in about five quarters. Churn is falling steadily since the 2021 to 2022 reallocation surge. He argues churn drives real wage growth and productivity through job matching. Churn is now back at levels last seen in early 2013, when unemployment was 7.5%, hourly earnings grew under 2% and productivity growth was zero. He attributes the decline partly to Fed tightening crushing small business employment, and says the low labour share of income reflects workers not being more productive.
“labor churn has been falling steadily since the great reallocation from mid twenty one to mid twenty two.”at 29:26
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Labor churn and job switching, beyond headline payrolls, reveal wage and productivity prospects.
The headline payroll number misses how much labor market dynamism turns over and churns. That churn shows whether real wage growth and productivity gains will come, and those are the forces that ultimately drive earnings growth, which is what investors care about. Slowing job switching is therefore a key sign for the wage and productivity outlook.
“Number two is when you think about the labor market, you have to really look at how much the labor market... That labor market dynamism and how much it turns over and churns.”at 59:07
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
AI capex growth has peaked; higher yields and spreads hit the big four spenders' capex and credit.
Knapp says AI capex is rate-sensitive, which contradicts the view that the AI trade ignores rate policy. Between Q1 and Q2 earnings, when capex peaked for the big four spenders (Amazon, Microsoft, Google and Meta), their average share price fell 11%. Their credit spreads widened about 50bp against the index while the 10-year TIPS yield rose about 50bp. Capex growth then fell from about 125% in Q1 to roughly 60%, halving. The fallout showed in credit, particularly for the more leveraged AI infrastructure players. Combined with a financing problem for government debt and slowing earnings, he says peak capex and peak AI-related earnings growth are already behind us.
“We've got more displacement coming up. We've already had peak CapEx in the AI infrastructure build out. We've had peak earnings growth related to this.”at 35:55
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Hyperscaler AI capex growth will slow toward EBITDA growth; likely peak capex as financing costs rise.
Capex has reached roughly 100% of EBITDA or cash flow, so accelerating it further would require negative cash flow, which some companies already run. Between Q1 and Q2 earnings, the average AI capex stock fell 11%, credit spreads and the risk-free rate rose, and capex growth slowed to about 60%. Knapp expects capex growth to slow toward EBITDA growth of about 30% over time. Boards and CEOs with large stock holdings will be deterred by capex announcements that push shares down, and some states want to throttle data center build-outs, so he sees every reason to believe capex has peaked. He notes the slower pace may avoid a 2000-2002 style bust, where fiber capacity sat at about 20% utilisation for years until streaming absorbed it.
“I would offer the thesis that it'll probably slow to about their growth in EBITDA, so something more like 30 over time.”at 38:07
Banks
Where everyone stands on Banks
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Small-bank loan growth is much weaker than big banks; credit channel needs reopening.
There is a big dispersion in return on equity between small and large banks, and loan growth at small banks is much weaker than at big banks, based on weekly statistics. Real estate developers are the most acute example, but the weakness also shows up in employment and small business creation. Reopening the credit channel from small banks is needed so credit diffuses to smaller mom-and-pop manufacturers and builders, which requires rebalancing monetary policy.
“Again, we have this big dispersion between return on equity and small banks, and if you look at loan growth from small banks... it's much weaker than big banks.”at 45:02
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Overweight financials on deregulation and their role financing the AI buildout.
Bank regulatory policy is loosening regardless of the election, and Fed Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman has laid out the plan in detail. Banks also play a central role in financing the capex boom. For these reasons his portfolio is overweight financials.
“First of all, I've been overweight financials because of the deregulatory policy and the role in financing all of this.”at 50:38
Central banks outside the US
Where everyone stands on Central banks outside the US
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Global QE never clearly worked; Bank of Japan and ECB are trapped with huge bond and equity holdings.
Knapp argues the world fell in love with large-scale asset purchases. At one point about $18 trillion of debt yielded negative, and he says central bank theory ignored the paradox of thrift and the velocity effect of excess savings. He recalls that in 2008 Lehman could only sell Treasuries and MBS, so Fed purchases never helped deleveraging. He says he wrote in 2011 that the policy was counterproductive. The Bank of Japan owns equity ETFs, and the ECB's bond-buying facilitated massive developed-world government debt growth, with no easy exit for either.
“It's just stunning to me that central bank theory fell so in love with this tool that there's absolutely no evidence that it ever worked.”at 22:46
US deficit & government debt
Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Interest costs will soon exceed Social Security, and the Fed's hikes plus the debt ceiling worsen financing.
Knapp says the effective interest rate on Treasury debt is rising as the Fed hikes, and interest expense as a share of GDP is now the second-largest line in government spending. He expects it to exceed Social Security next year. The debt ceiling and a new budget negotiation with a Democratic Congress are coming. Gridlock is typically good for markets, but he says these fiscal pressures will force deals that probably involve more spending. He also argues investors are missing a likely Democratic pivot to taxing capital, since the labour share of income is at record lows and corporate and capital gains receipts are weak. A Republican president still opposes higher capital gains and corporate tax rates, so that fight is coming.
“interest expense as a percent of GDP is now the number two line item in government spending, and it will probably exceed Social Security next year.”at 24:49
AI & jobs
Where everyone stands on AI & jobs
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
AI productivity gains will take years to reach the broader economy; so far labour has not benefited.
Knapp uses the late-1990s tech boom as a template. In the first five years only tech, telecom and, as a fast follower, finance captured the productivity gains. Consumer goods such as Amazon and Walmart benefited later, and consumer services took another decade, with Starbucks needing about a decade to get a third of customers to use its app. He concludes technology adoption always takes longer than technologists expect. He points to BLS data: information technology employment fell 2.5% while wages rose almost 5%, so tech is culling workers and paying the rest more. Healthcare added about 2.5% employment with wage growth under 2%, which he reads as low-productivity hiring. He says displacement comes before the job creation, and he has seen no evidence yet that labour is benefiting.
“So the technology adoption always takes longer than the technologists believe.”at 33:36
Earnings & corporate profits
Where everyone stands on Earnings & corporate profits
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Trend earnings growth near 12.5% absent recession; he expects no recession next year.
The commonly quoted seven percent long-term earnings growth only reflects recessions. Excluding the six months before and the year after a recession, trend mid-cycle earnings growth is about 12.5%. Cycles run from about 9% (the 1950s and 2010s) to about 15% (the 1960s, 1990s and potentially the 2020s). The difference is capex: the 1950s were the worst postwar capex cycle, while the 1960s, 1990s and 2020s had supply-side tax reform and looser bank regulation. He expects a tougher but non-recessionary environment next year, with earnings growth settling down if the system does not crash, though year-on-year comparisons will look tough until the peak capex quarters are lapped.
“So trend earnings growth is more like 12 and a half, but there are cycles where it's nine, and the most prominent of those were the nineteen fifties and the two thousand and tens.”at 40:02
Manufacturing & industrial policy
Where everyone stands on Manufacturing & industrial policy
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Immediate expensing, not tariffs, should drive US manufacturing rebuild; China sourcing no longer pays.
Manufacturing in China to sell products in the US has no longer made economic sense since the early 2010s. Tariffs were not needed to reverse this. Making the tax code competitive and letting markets work would have done it, but politicians are impatient. Permanent immediate expensing on buildings and equipment is a very powerful incentive for factory build-out. A stable environment and reopening the credit channel from small banks is needed so the build-out diffuses to smaller manufacturers.
“that manufacturing in China to sell products in The US no longer made economic sense. We didn't need tariffs to do this.”at 43:37
US consumer
Where everyone stands on US consumer
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Consumption is slowing below trend; he stays underweight consumer-facing sectors.
Three-month annualised retail sales bottomed below 2% in January, surged to 9% in May, and have fallen every month since. Year-on-year consumption is growing about 2.5%, below its post-WWII trend of over 3%, while capex grows 11–12% against a trend of about 5.5%. Headwinds include slower immigration, government spending growth cut from 11% to 3%, tariffs and a gasoline price spike, partly offset by tax refunds from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. Consumers are the final customer, so consumption near trend is needed before businesses invest. He has been underweight consumer staples and discretionary since around Liberation Day.
“You've seen this deceleration of consumption. And if you look at it on a year on year basis, consumption's growing about two and a half percent right now. The long term trend is over three.”at 47:16
Consumer & retail
Where everyone stands on Consumer & retail
Barry Knapp · Ironsides Macroeconomics
Staples at 26x earnings for about 3% growth offer little defensive comfort; he avoids them.
Consumer staples trade at 26 times earnings with about 3% earnings growth, an above-average price for below-average growth, so he does not see them as a good hedge for tech and cyclicals. He notes that staples' 13–14% year-to-date gain is partly due to the unwind of long AI-theme, short-index quant positions in October, not fundamentals, which makes no sense to him, so he has not chased it.
“The staple sector for me is a great example. It trades 26 times earnings with about a 3% earnings growth rate. You're hitting an above average price for below average growth.”at 52:47
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- Walmart8 speakers · 5 bullish, 3 bearish calls
- The Procter & Gamble Company4 speakers · 2 bullish, 2 bearish calls
Topics
- AI productivity benefits
- AI productivity diffusion
- Fed December projections
- Fed forecast-driven yield moves
- Fed tightening versus earnings slowdown
- balance sheet and bond portfolio effects
- bank deregulation
- consumer staples valuation
- consumption slowdown
- earnings growth trend
- fiscal drivers of inflation
- hyperscaler capex growth
- inflation drivers
- inflation trend vs target
- interest burden and financing
- labor market churn
- market pullback and cash positioning
- quantitative easing legacy
- rate policy distortion across borrowers
- reshoring & factory build-out
- sector rotation
- small bank lending
- tech sector positioning
- valuation
- yield drivers
More from Excess Returns
- Who Pays for the AI Buildout? Two Bond Investors Take Us Inside the Debt Market · November 19, 2026
- From Poker Pro to Elite Hedge Fund Manager: David Orr on Investing, Risk and AI · November 17, 2026
- Show Us Your Portfolio: Meb Faber · November 15, 2026
- Fidelity’s Jurrien Timmer on AI Spending, Bond Yields and the Next Phase of the Bull Market · November 13, 2026
- Stock Investors Fear an AI Bubble. Bond Investors Fear Inflation. How Can You Diversify Without Selling Them? · November 12, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus