Excess Returns · · 1h 1m

Fidelity’s Jurrien Timmer on AI Spending, Bond Yields and the Next Phase of the Bull Market

With Jurrien Timmer

Summary

Fidelity's Jurrien Timmer, on Excess Returns, argues that the AI trade is correcting because markets are questioning the financing model behind massive hyperscaler and frontier-lab capex, not the technology itself, with CoreWeave's CDS spreads compared to telecom credit in 1999. He notes the Magnificent Seven's payout ratio has collapsed from about 90% to 28% as capex absorbs cash flow, and that semiconductors are near the peak of a roughly 40-month earnings cycle. On rates, he argues that a rising term premium driven by inflation and fiscal risk, with real yields near 2.9%, threatens equity multiples, and that the 1994 and 2022 analogues frame the bear case. He sees the S&P 500 at about 18-19 times forward earnings, a narrow market where roughly 30% of stocks beat the index, and recommends global diversification and a view that the Fed will likely make one more cut in December rather than tighten.

Key takeaways

  • Jurrien Timmer on AI bubble & tech valuations: Markets question the financing model behind AI buildout, not the technology; AI names have corrected since June.
  • Jurrien Timmer on Earnings & corporate profits: Magnificent Seven's capex-heavy spending cuts shareholder payouts and caps their multiples; more payouts would lift them.
  • Jurrien Timmer on AI chips & semiconductors: Semiconductor earnings are peaking in their 40-month cycle; the picks-and-shovels phase is over.
  • Jurrien Timmer on US rates & the Fed: Less Fed transparency raises the term premium, pushing yields up and conflicting with Treasury's preference for lower yields.
  • Jurrien Timmer (uncertain on CoreWeave): CoreWeave's CDS spreads resemble 1999 telecom spreads from fiber-network builders; similarities are there.

What was said, by company and theme

30 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

CoreWeave

Across the shows: 95 speakers in other episodes, 33 bullish and 102 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on CoreWeave

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity InvestmentsUncertain

    CoreWeave's CDS spreads resemble 1999 telecom spreads from fiber-network builders; similarities are there.

    Timmer compares CoreWeave's CDS spreads, a read on the cost of financing AI infrastructure, with telecom spreads in 1999. Back then telecoms were the picks and shovels building fiber-optic networks, and he sees similarities in the credit signal. He does not say whether this is bearish. He presents it as a conversation starter that the analogy invites, not a forecast.

    “But then you look at [CoreWeave's] CDS spreads versus telecom spreads back then because they were the picks and shovels back then, right, building all the fiber optic networks. And there are similarities there.”at 47:15

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    S&P 500 is not expensive at about 18x forward earnings; investors don't pay up for peak growth.

    Investors pay about 18 times next-twelve-month earnings, several points below six months ago. Forward earnings estimates are up 38% from a year ago, and investors are unwilling to pay for growth at 40% or more because such second derivatives are hard to maintain. Rising rates also lower the present value of future cash flows. In 2021, investors paid high multiples for peak growth and then faced 2022. Today's multiple reflects that caution, so he does not think the market is expensive.

    “So I I I don't think the market is expensive here, but investors don't pay for for peak earnings, and that's what's happening.”at 8:06
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Current rate-driven pressure resembles 1994; if P/E falls to 16 despite strong earnings, stocks go sideways.

    In 1994 the Fed raised rates abruptly and bonds fell sharply, but earnings grew strongly, so stocks went sideways and fell about 10% twice. In 2022 rates rose from zero to over 5% and P/Es fell by a third, causing a 28% drop. Today rates have been rising until recently, and if long yields resume rising, pressure on P/E builds. If 20-30% earnings growth persists while P/E falls from 18-19 to 16, the market goes sideways, like 1994. That is the bear case, though probably not as negative as 2022.

    “So if earnings growth, which is at 30 to 40%, depending on which metric you look at, if that stays very strong, let's say 20 to 30%, and the PE goes from 18, 19 to 16, you get a a sideways market just like 94.”at 19:53
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Current market is in a melt-up resembling 1998–2000, which will eventually break apart.

    Timmer uses analogs as a road map rather than a forecast. He traces the 1990s internet boom: a 1995 start, a 1998 LTCM pause, then a vertical blow-off after a quick 20% drawdown with the Fed cutting. He sees the 2025 tariff-tantrum drawdown, a fast 21% hit followed by melt-up, as similar. The S&P has risen by the same amount over the same time since its 1998 low as it did to March 2000, so the market is rhyming. He expects the melt-up to eventually break apart.

    “And we're kind of in the throes of that melt up now, but you know it's gonna eventually break apart, but that doesn't mean that we can't study the slope of the trajectory.”at 46:37
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Mega-cap concentration makes the index fragile even though most stocks are in long-term uptrends.

    Timmer says concentration and interest-rate risk were the two main risks. The S&P is up 120% since the October 2022 cyclical bull, but only about 30% of its stocks have beaten the index year over year, which is very low and last seen in the late 1990s and early 1970s. If the top 10 stocks (40% of the market) and top 50 (60%) fall, the index falls, even though 72% of stocks were above their 200-day moving average while the S&P had gone nowhere since early June.

    “But only about 30% of the stocks in the S and P outperformed the index on a year over year basis. And that's very, very low... if 10 stocks are 40% of the market and the top 50 stocks are 60% on the market, if those stocks go down, the index is gonna go down.”at 52:18
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Secular bull returns were above average, so CAPE implies lower returns and less beta over the next decade.

    Timmer says investors have over-harvested beta since the 2009 secular bull, earning about 16% nominal over the last decade against a long-run average of about 10 to 11%. CAPE holds that a high starting valuation implies lower forward returns. Overlaying prior secular bulls suggests the next five to ten years will be less of a beta harvest, though not necessarily down years. Because the 150-year average is about 10%, returns cannot stay at 15 to 17% unless something permanently changes.

    “And the Cape model, which holds that the prevailing long term PE tends to have an inverse forward correlation to the next long period of returns... are not necessarily gonna be down years, but they're gonna be less. There's gonna be less beta going forward than we've experienced.”at 55:53

US Treasuries & yields

Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Rising bond yields compress equity P/E multiples, so stocks must reprice when yields reach stock earnings yields.

    Using the Fed model, the S&P 500 trades near 18-19 times earnings, roughly the same as the 10-year Treasury's bond P/E at about 5%. When safe assets are competitively priced, higher yields force stocks to reprice lower. Price is the residual of earnings and valuation, and valuations depend on rates. If yields rose to 6%, the S&P's P/E would need to fall to about 16, implying a drawdown that earnings growth would then have to offset.

    “But when the yields are the same or the PEs are the same, the stock market needs to listen, which doesn't mean that the stock market goes down if bond yields go up. It just means its PE goes down”at 15:07
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Higher term premium reflects inflation and unsustainable fiscal policy, not growth, pushing yields up.

    Rates have risen across the world, including in no-growth economies like Germany, France and the UK, so inflation and fiscal risk are the main drivers rather than growth. Inflation has been above the Fed's target since 2021 or 2022. Investors are pricing in a higher term premium because fiscal positions in the US and much of the world are unsustainable. The US won't go bankrupt, but deficits and debt are not a partisan issue and will persist. Once real rates pushed past the economy's speed limit, investors took notice.

    “So I think it's inflation, and I think it's fiscal risk. ... I think investors are pricing in a higher term premium because the fiscal status of this country and much of the world is not really sustainable.”at 21:09
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Stock-bond correlation will likely revert to positive while inflation runs above target, weakening bonds' hedge.

    The stock-bond correlation flipped from negative to positive in 2022, when inflation moved from below to above the Fed's target, and inflation remains well above target. Short-term correlations are negative now only because of a growth scare. With inflation sticky, he expects the correlation to revert to positive, so bonds may not cushion stock declines. Whether bonds hedge depends on whether the sell-off is a growth scare or a rate scare, and during rate scares bonds cause the problems.

    “that suggests that the correlation, even though right now, short term correlations have flipped negative because we have a growth scare, but my guess is that they will revert back to positive.”at 23:15
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Real yields near 2.9% make bonds attractive income assets, though they offer little diversification now.

    When yields hit 5.3%, the real yield was about 2.9%, which he calls generous and not seen in over twenty years. Bonds again provide income, so they have value, but they are not providing diversification right now. Real yields swung from about minus 2.5% five years ago to plus 2.5%. Bonds are a viable asset at these levels, though the inflation backdrop means they may not cushion stock declines.

    “when yields were 5.3% just a few weeks ago, the real yield was 2.9%. I mean, that's pretty that's pretty generous. We haven't seen yields like that in over twenty years, but you're not getting the diversification.”at 30:36
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Real yields above potential growth make debt unsustainable, and that partly explains the recent rate rise.

    Timmer compares real rates with the economy's sustained speed limit, potential real GDP growth of about 2 to 2.5%. He draws on Reinhart and Rogoff's debt-threshold work. Like a business borrowing at 8% while growing at 4%, debt becomes unsustainable when real rates run above growth. He never looks at rates in isolation, and he says this dynamic is part of the message of the recent rise in rates.

    “when one starts going above the other, you run into issues... And if it goes too far above, the debt becomes unsustainable, and that, I think, is part of the message of the rise in rates that we saw recently.”at 37:16

US inflation

Where everyone stands on US inflation

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Inflation is sticky at 3%-plus, not spiking; stocks can handle it, but multiples would compress.

    He does not expect a renewed inflation spike, but inflation is very sticky at 3% or more and has been above the Fed's target since 2021-2022. A Bloomberg TruFlation-style index tracking thousands of CPI inputs runs above 4%. The stock market can do fine at 3% or 4% inflation, but it means a lower multiple, so earnings must do more of the heavy lifting. Inflation above target also undermines the stock-bond correlation.

    “I don't see a renewed spike so much, but, you know, we are very, very sticky at, you know, three plus percent.”at 22:24
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    The Fed's focus on core inflation is hard to justify because food and energy drive Americans' experience.

    The Fed has always looked at core PCE rather than headline inflation, but this is harder to justify now. Food and energy are why many Americans feel the K-shaped recovery, and he believes that is a major reason for the midterm election outcome. Economists strip out those two components, but it is hard to ignore them.

    “the Fed has always looked at core inflation, core PCE, as opposed to headline. But I think that's a harder thing to justify because, you know, food and energy is why so many Americans are feeling, you know, that k shaped recovery.”at 24:48
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Fed will likely accept inflation around 2.5%, since reaching a true 2% would require too much tightening.

    Timmer notes the Fed has long flexed its target. Average inflation targeting and a 2.5% 'new 2' were discussed before COVID. Getting from roughly 2.5% to 2% would require extra restrictiveness, and mortgage rates are already about 7% amid an affordability problem, so the cost may not be worth it. He calls inflation in the mid-3s too high, but expects the Fed to call 2.5% a win and a two-handle good enough.

    “And so I think a two handle is probably gonna be good enough.”at 43:54

AI bubble & tech valuations

Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Markets question the financing model behind AI buildout, not the technology; AI names have corrected since June.

    AI names, including semis, memory, data centers and hyperscalers, have gone nowhere since early June and are correcting. Hyperscaler and frontier-lab capital demand is so vast that markets struggle to absorb it, and a major frontier lab is about to go public. Markets are therefore questioning the viability and sustainability of the financial model rather than the technology, a pattern he compares to the internet boom and 1873 railroads.

    “So the markets were already asking questions about the viability and the sustainability, not of the technology, but of the financial model, right?”at 2:39
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Tech valuations are far below 1999's levels because earnings are booming, unlike the unrealised 1999 earnings story.

    Timmer says the valuation side is totally different from 1999. Back then the market believed an earnings story that never materialized, and the S&P technology sector traded at about 70 times earnings. Today earnings are booming, so the tech sector P/E is around 18 or 19. Price action resembles the late 1990s, but valuations do not.

    “And of course the valuation side's totally different between now and 1999, because back then the market was believing the earnings story and it never materialized. And the S and P technology sector was trading at a 70 PE. Today, the earnings are so booming that the PE for the tech sector is like 18 or 19.”at 46:53

Earnings & corporate profits

Where everyone stands on Earnings & corporate profits

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Magnificent Seven's capex-heavy spending cuts shareholder payouts and caps their multiples; more payouts would lift them.

    The Magnificent Seven, almost 40% of the market, used to return about 90% of their earnings growth to investors via dividends and buybacks. That payout is now only 28% because they spend most cash flow on capex. Investors want the cash returned and won't pay for the spending. Comparing price-to-earnings with price-to-payout, their P/E could be almost twice as high if they returned cash flow. If market conditions or regulation force a shift back to payouts, multiples could rise.

    “They used to pay out 90% of their very formidable earnings growth back to investors via dividends or buybacks. Today, that number is only 28% because they're spending... Most of them are spending a lot of their cash flow on CapEx,”at 7:12
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Mag Seven payouts fell from about 90% to the 20s of earnings as AI capex replaced buybacks.

    Timmer describes a buyback era from the mid-2000s to now, when mega-cap growers produced free cash flow they had nowhere to deploy and returned about 90% of earnings via buybacks and dividends. Those cash flows made them bond-like cash cows in a discounted cash flow model. The capex boom has changed this. The Mag Seven's combined payout ratio has dropped from the 90s to the 20s, which changes the economics of owning them.

    “So they returned it to shareholders via share buybacks on top of dividends... The CapEx boom changed that because the payout ratio, so dividends plus buybacks as a percent of earnings for the max seven is down to the twenties from the nineties.”at 49:23

US rates & the Fed

Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Less Fed transparency raises the term premium, pushing yields up and conflicting with Treasury's preference for lower yields.

    Timmer argues Kevin Warsh's plan to remove forward guidance and reduce Fed transparency adds uncertainty for investors. Less certainty means investors demand a higher risk premium, which in bond markets is the term premium. He says part of the recent rise in yields reflects this, alongside growth, inflation and fiscal risk. This clashes with the Treasury, which wants lower yields, so he sees it as a dynamic worth watching.

    “But when you take away some certainty from investors, they will want a higher risk premium, which in the bond market is called the term premium.”at 40:50
  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Fed is unwinding its insurance cuts, expects one or two more, probably in December.

    Timmer does not see the Fed in a tightening cycle. The 2025 cuts were partly insurance against AI-driven job fears and a weak job market. Inflation has since risen partly because of the Iran conflict, and employment data show the job market is fine, so the insurance cuts are not needed. He says the Fed has made one undo so far, the market had been pricing two or three more, and he now expects one or two. There is no urgency, but he suspects the Fed will move in December.

    “I think of the current cycle as just they need to undo those insurance cuts. And so they've done one... They're looking for maybe one or two more, and that's the way I see it... I suspect that in December, they probably will.”at 43:02

AI regulation & safety

Where everyone stands on AI regulation & safety

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Slowing AI buildout now, whether by regulation or markets, avoids a worse crash later; he sees it as a positive.

    He expects growth in AI to be regulated, which he admits could mean losing the race with China. He argues the net effect is good: slowing development early means avoiding crashing or going off the rails later. He sees CoreWeave's bond signals as already pointing in that direction. Incumbent hyperscalers with generous cash flows would benefit, because the market may like lower capex spending.

    “if you slow down the development a little bit upfront, you avoid, you know, crashing or going off the rails later.”at 3:24

AI chips & semiconductors

Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Semiconductor earnings are peaking in their 40-month cycle; the picks-and-shovels phase is over.

    Semiconductors are cyclical and follow a roughly 40-month earnings cycle that is due to peak now. Year-over-year earnings growth is about 180%, and the second derivative is likely peaking, even though chip demand still outweighs supply. Markets look ahead, so semis are a cyclical trade. Chart evidence, including a KOSPI head-and-shoulders top, suggests the picks-and-shovels phase is ending and the AI trade is moving on to other pockets. Cyclicals can look cheap at peak earnings.

    “semiconductors are a cyclical industry, and they follow a forty month earnings cycle. And that earnings cycle is due to peak now, basically.”at 8:41

AI & jobs

Where everyone stands on AI & jobs

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Fed's 2025 insurance rate cuts over AI job-loss fears were premature and have had to be reversed.

    In 2025 the Fed cut rates as insurance because of fears that the AI story would eat jobs. That fear turned out to be premature, and the Fed now has to reverse those cuts. Rising rates have since weighed on equity multiples, which he links to the 1994 and 2022 analogies. The argument rests on the Fed's reaction function rather than on measured AI job losses.

    “It took out some insurance rate cuts in 2025 because of fears that the AI, story was gonna, you know, eat the jobs. And that in turn... That turned out to be premature”at 19:23

US growth & recession risk

Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Financial conditions are tightening, moving the economy past the best phase, though earnings growth remains historic.

    His investment clock pairs earnings growth with financial conditions from the Goldman Sachs index, which captures stocks, credit spreads, short and long rates, and the dollar. The economy spent a long time in the best quadrant of rising earnings and easy conditions. It has now moved past midnight, with short and long rates higher, the dollar strong, and high-yield spreads widening. Earnings still show a historic boom, but conditions are less supportive.

    “The financial conditions are getting a little tighter. And when I say that, I mean short rates, long rates, the dollar's pretty strong, and credit spreads, at least on the high yield side, are moving higher.”at 26:39

US consumer

Where everyone stands on US consumer

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Stock-market drops can hit consumer spending through retirees' wealth effect; stocks matter more to the economy.

    Stock market wealth affects the economy through a wealth effect, as housing did before 2008. Many baby boomers living on retirement assets in stocks would notice a 4% daily drop and could cut spending. Since the economy is about 70% consumer spending, the link between the stock market and the real economy is strong in the US. Europe's state pension systems create a weaker link.

    “And so the same applies to the stock market. ... if they're invested in stocks and all of a sudden you're down, you know, 4% in a day, you're you're gonna notice. And that could that could drive consumer spending.”at 28:03

Commodities (broad)

Where everyone stands on Commodities (broad)

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Commodities have taken over gold's diversifier role this year, driven by energy and copper.

    The role gold played as the star performer in 2025 has passed to the broad commodities complex this year. The move is driven by energy, along with other commodity indices such as copper. He includes commodities in a diversified portfolio because they behave independently of stocks and bonds, and they are part of the non-stock-bond bucket that is uncorrelated with the core.

    “That baton has been passed to the commodities, the general commodities complex, obviously driven by energy, but by other other, commodity indices as well, like copper.”at 34:29

Gold & precious metals

Where everyone stands on Gold & precious metals

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Gold is pausing after an overbought 2025 but remains a viable play on global liquidity under fiscal dominance.

    Gold rose 32% in 2025 with no correlation to other assets, but it got overbought as fast money moved from Bitcoin ETFs into gold ETFs. Gold is now licking its wounds. He views it as a play on global liquidity growth in an era of fiscal dominance, where fiscal policy drives the bus. Gold and Treasuries were also seen as liquidity sources during the Iran conflict. In the US gold is a sideshow outside the benchmark, but for Asian central banks and sovereign funds it is a necessity.

    “And so I think gold is just going through a pause because it it it got overdone, but it's still... To me, it's a play on on global liquidity growth and in an era of what I call fiscal dominance”at 35:12

US jobs & labor market

Where everyone stands on US jobs & labor market

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Employment data show the job market is fine, so the 2025 insurance cuts were not needed.

    Timmer says the Fed cut three more times last year, partly because of a weak job market and fears that AI was destroying or would destroy jobs. Those cuts were insurance, and the insurance turned out to be unneeded. Inflation has come back up partly due to the Iran conflict, and the latest employment numbers show the job market is just fine.

    “fears with the weak job market that AI was destroying jobs or was going to destroy jobs... those insurance cuts were not needed... the job market is just fine.”at 42:30

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    A capex slowdown could make cash-rich data-center incumbents the relative winners and keep the index up.

    Timmer argues that if capex slows, the large incumbents that already own data centers and do not need to borrow to build more could emerge as winners again. They have been sideways for over a year. Since they are almost 40% of the market, if they are the net relative winners of an AI bust, they could keep the index up. He is careful to say he is not calling a bust.

    “if there is a slowdown in CapEx, these big incumbents who already have the data centers and who don't have to leverage their balance sheet to build more could actually emerge as winners again.”at 50:44

International equities

Where everyone stands on International equities

  • Jurrien Timmer · Fidelity Investments

    Global allocation beats US concentration, since Europe and Japan payouts above 70% contrast with the Mag Seven's falling payouts.

    Timmer recommends painting the market with a broader brush through global allocation, which he calls a very good idea. The Mag Seven's payout ratio fell from about 90% to 28%, but non-US developed markets show the opposite. In Europe and Japan the payout ratio is now above 70%, so there are ways to reduce concentration risk beyond the S&P 500.

    “painting the market with a broader brush in terms of global allocation, is also a very good idea to consider... we've seen the opposite of that in non US developed markets. So Europe and Japan, where the payout ratio is now above 70%.”at 53:57

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • CoreWeave95 speakers · 33 bullish, 102 bearish calls

Topics

  • 1994 analogy and rate-driven bear case
  • 1998-2000 analog
  • AI buildout regulation
  • AI financing model sustainability
  • AI infrastructure credit
  • AI job displacement fears and monetary policy
  • Fed forward guidance & transparency
  • Fed inflation target
  • S&P 500 valuation
  • bond yields and equity multiples
  • buybacks vs capex
  • capex vs shareholder payouts
  • commodities as diversifier
  • employment strength
  • financial conditions tightening
  • global allocation
  • gold as liquidity and fiscal dominance hedge
  • headline vs core inflation
  • hyperscaler capex slowdown
  • inflation persistence
  • long-term return expectations
  • market breadth & concentration
  • rate cuts
  • real yields and bond income
  • real yields vs potential growth
  • semiconductor earnings cycle
  • stock-bond correlation
  • tech sector valuations vs 1999
  • term premium
  • wealth effect on consumer spending

More from Excess Returns

All Excess Returns episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus