Excess Returns · · 1h 22m

Show Us Your Portfolio: Meb Faber

With Meb Faber

Summary

Meb Faber walks through his own portfolio on Excess Returns, arguing that most US investors under-own foreign stocks and bonds relative to a global market-cap starting point, and that real assets such as TIPS, commodities, gold and farmland are needed as an inflation hedge that stocks and bonds fail to provide. He contends that T-bills and cash look safe only in nominal terms, since real returns have often been poor, and that a diversified buy-and-hold mix has delivered more yield without added drawdown. Faber also argues that buybacks now dominate shareholder returns, that market-cap weighting is effectively trend following with no link to fundamentals, and that ETFs beat high-fee, tax-inefficient mutual funds. Cullen Roche counters on bond aggregate construction, which he says becomes a poorly managed government bond fund, and on housing, which he sees as having delivered no real returns recently. The discussion closes with Faber's venture and angel approach, built on many small bets and QSBS tax treatment.

Key takeaways

  • Meb Faber on International equities: US investors hold almost no foreign stocks; foreign should be about a third of a global portfolio.
  • Cullen Roche on US Treasuries & yields: Bond aggregate indexes mostly buy the biggest issuer, the US government, so they lack competitive selection.
  • Meb Faber on Earnings & corporate profits: Net buybacks, not dividends, are how most US companies return cash; shareholder yield captures both.
  • Cullen Roche on US housing: Real estate could deliver zero real returns for five to ten more years until rates and affordability improve.
  • Meb Faber on Venture capital & startups: Startup investing needs many small checks over a decade to catch rare power-law winners.

What was said, by company and theme

20 views from 2 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Venture capital & startups

Where everyone stands on Venture capital & startups

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Startup investing needs many small checks over a decade to catch rare power-law winners.

    Venture returns come from a few power-law winners, so Faber makes many small checks over a commitment of about a decade. He plans to make 20 to 75 investments a year, which adds up to roughly 500 companies. Most of his early bets were long shots, and the plan assumes that a few of them will become 50x to 100x outcomes. His tax treatment and his deal flow from private markets (he has reviewed about 15,000 deal memos) support the approach. He says the two main mistakes are investing everything in year one and quitting after a year or two.

    “I understand the power laws. So I'm gonna do a lot of small checks that will add up over time.”at 1:05:32
  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Startups invested in 2021–22 at crazy valuations likely make a tough vintage.

    Faber says that if an investor started in 2021 or 2022, when valuations were crazy, that vintage is probably tough, and the portfolio likely has few winners. He argues that valuation at entry shapes vintage outcomes, and that this is why diversifying across years matters.

    “If you started in... I don't know. What was it? '21 or '22 when valuations were crazy... And that's probably a tough vintage.”at 1:12:24
  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Attracted to ex-US and emerging-market startups as the Y Combinator model spreads globally.

    Meb says he is particularly attracted to ex-US and emerging markets and that there is a lot going on as the Y Combinator-style accelerator model spreads around the world. He points to a YouTube playlist on startups in Africa as one of the most interesting parts of his long-running work in the space. The argument is brief and largely qualitative, with no figures or deal examples beyond that playlist.

    “I'm particularly attracted to Ex US and emerging markets, and there's a lot going on as that sort of y combinator model spreads around the world.”at 1:17:49

International equities

Where everyone stands on International equities

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    US investors hold almost no foreign stocks; foreign should be about a third of a global portfolio.

    Most US investors own almost no foreign stocks, and if no one owns foreign stocks, they almost certainly own no foreign bonds. The US is about two-thirds of world market cap, so a global market-cap starting point puts about a third in foreign assets. Meb also notes Vanguard's suggestion that foreign bonds deserve the highest allocation, which advisers would never adopt. His view is that the global market portfolio is the starting point, and US investors under-own foreign markets.

    “And so already, The US is two thirds world market cap, so a third should be in foreign.”at 19:55
  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Buyback activity is spreading beyond the US; cheap non-US firms, not just Korean and Japanese tech, are repurchasing shares.

    Over the past ten years the buyback trend has spread to China, the UK, Japan and Korea. Markets focus on the AI and tech names in Korea and Japan, but Faber points to a large group of companies trading around 0.5 times book value that have started buying back stock. That shift in capital return is a source of value in non-US markets that is easy to overlook.

    “Everyone gets obsessed with Korea and Japan about the tech stocks, the AI, but there's a massive component of a bunch of companies trading at, like, point five times book that are all of a sudden doing buybacks.”at 51:32

US Treasuries & yields

Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    T-bills, usually seen as the safest asset, have lost over half their real value historically.

    Meb argues that safety depends on whether returns are measured after inflation. Cash and T-bills are usually treated as safe, but in real terms they have fallen by over half in the past and would lose purchasing power over time. He argues a diversified buy-and-hold mix of stocks, bonds, real assets and some cash has historically delivered about two percentage points more yield than a cash account. It has shown no measurable increase in volatility or drawdown after inflation, so it is safer for preserving real wealth.

    “it's actually safer to splice a buy and hold portfolio, stocks, bonds, real assets with some cash, and you can add probably two percentage points of yield to a cash account with really no measurable pickup in volatility or drawdown on an after inflation basis.”at 23:53
  • Cullen Roche · Discipline Funds

    Bond aggregate indexes mostly buy the biggest issuer, the US government, so they lack competitive selection.

    A market-cap bond index holds the value of the total bond market. In the US, that means it mainly buys the largest issuer, the federal government. Equity index funds have a competitive feature, because firms that lose competitiveness are replaced by stronger ones. Bond aggregates have no such feature. They take whatever yield and duration the issuer chooses, so the aggregate increasingly becomes a US government bond fund that is poorly managed for investors.

    “A bond index fund buys the the value of the total bond market. But really what it's doing, especially in a country like The United States, is it's just buying the biggest issuer.”at 35:58

Asset managers, brokers & exchanges

Where everyone stands on Asset managers, brokers & exchanges

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Trillions sit in asset allocation funds charging 1.5–2% fees that are tax-inefficient; cheaper ETFs should replace them.

    Meb says that even investors who have a diversified portfolio often still hold trillions in mutual funds charging 1.5 to 2% a year. Those funds are also tax-inefficient. Strategic allocation can be obtained through tax-efficient ETFs at much lower cost. He expects the shift to happen only through events such as death, divorce or a deep bear market.

    “there's still, 1,000,000,000,000 in these mutual funds that charge one and a half, 2% asset allocation funds. They're terribly tax inefficient.”at 29:15
  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    ETFs structurally beat mutual funds; active mutual fund outflows keep flowing into cheaper ETFs.

    Faber says the ETF structure has been clearly superior from the start. Estimates put the tax and fee gap between ETFs and mutual funds at about 1.5% a year for equities. ICI yearly flows show active mutual funds losing money to lower-cost ETFs and some low-cost mutual funds. The mutual fund industry has held up only because stocks have risen tenfold since 2009, so performance has offset the outflows. He expects a bear market to expose the weakness of mutual funds.

    “It was very clear to me from the get go that ETFs were [a] better mousetrap.”at 41:29

Commodities (broad)

Where everyone stands on Commodities (broad)

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Real assets are a strong hedge because they tend to benefit from unexpected inflation, which most investors lack.

    Very few investors hold meaningful real assets such as TIPS, commodities, commodity equities or gold. Real assets typically benefit from unexpected inflation. Meb cites 2022 as an example, when stock-and-bond-only portfolios were caught off guard. He argues that stocks and bonds do not hedge each other reliably, so real assets fill the gap in a diversified portfolio.

    “very few people own a meaningful amount of real assets... that typically is a big beneficiary inflationary times, unexpected inflation.”at 20:38

Equity Markets & Valuations

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Market-cap index weighting is a trend-following rule: holdings rise with price and fall as stocks decline.

    A market-cap index weights each stock by price times shares outstanding, so it is effectively the simplest trend-following algorithm. Holdings rise as prices rise and shrink as prices fall until a stock is removed or goes bankrupt. This is why index investors also benefit from trend-like behavior, even though they rarely describe their approach that way. Meb argues that investors who accept index weighting should also accept trend following in the rest of their portfolio.

    “market cap weighting indices are trend following indexes at their very core. There is one single variable in a market cap index, which is price of stock times shares outstanding.”at 34:12

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Market-cap weighting has no tether to fundamentals; buying the biggest stocks regardless of earnings is crazy.

    Faber's default for stocks is market-cap weighting, but he argues it has no link to fundamentals. Buying the biggest companies ignores how much they earn and what they are worth relative to their price, so the weight a stock gets depends only on how far its price has risen. He calls that a crazy idea in theory and says it is hard to explain to younger investors.

    “You buy the biggest companies, but but there's really no tether to fundamentals whatsoever. Doesn't matter how much the company earns.”at 38:31

Credit markets

Where everyone stands on Credit markets

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Holding risky bonds that yield less than T-bills is a bad idea; spreads are now back to normal.

    Faber's 'T-Bills and Chill' research argued against buying risky bonds when the yield curve was inverted or when bonds yielded less than T-bills, and found this was a terrible idea historically. After bonds sold off over the past couple of years, many risky bonds are back to normal spreads over T-bills. The historical evidence and the spread comparison make the case that the compensation for credit risk is now more reasonable.

    “Looking at the risky bonds and saying, why would you invest in many of these when the yield curve was negative or the bonds yielded less than t bills? And it turns out it's a terrible idea.”at 38:57

Emerging markets

Where everyone stands on Emerging markets

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Many emerging markets look very cheap, nobody wants them, and they are trending up.

    Faber says his favorite investment is something cheap, hated and in an uptrend, and he gives emerging markets as a current example. Many of them are super cheap, no one wants them, and they are going up. He combines value with trend following, arguing that the two often line up.

    “So, think a lot of emerging markets or something today that are super cheap. No one wants them, and they're going up.”at 47:11

Earnings & corporate profits

Where everyone stands on Earnings & corporate profits

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Net buybacks, not dividends, are how most US companies return cash; shareholder yield captures both.

    Shareholder yield is defined as cash dividends plus net stock buybacks. Since the late 1990s most US companies have returned more cash through net buybacks than through dividends, a structural shift Faber says is 20 to 30 years old while investing 'is still stuck in the eighties.' Warren Buffett understood this early, and Berkshire has never paid a dividend while buying back stock. Faber's shareholder yield ETFs have three ten-year track records, all in the top decile, which he presents as evidence that the concept works in live performance.

    “And the net stock buybacks is how the majority of companies in The United States since the late nineties... have distributed their cash flows more than dividends.”at 49:46

China's economy

Where everyone stands on China's economy

  • Cullen Roche · Discipline Funds

    Weak share-count management in China may improve through activism and buybacks, which could drive a large re-rating.

    Roche says China has long been criticized for not managing its share counts well and for not running businesses to earnings per share. Buybacks are spreading across Asia, and more shareholder activism could change that. He suggests that if China and India keep growing, population could be a gigantic multiplier in these economies. He presents this as a possible narrative rather than a firm call.

    “You gotta think at some point, because this has been one of the big narratives around China is that they just haven't managed their actual share counts very well.”at 51:47

Agriculture & food commodities

Where everyone stands on Agriculture & food commodities

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    Farmland is one of his favorite asset classes, with uncorrelated regional sub-markets that are hard to access publicly.

    Faber's family has farmed for generations, and he has hosted dozens of farmland podcasts. He calls farmland one of his favorite asset classes. Within it, blueberries in the Northwest, rice in the Southeast and Midwest row crops are almost uncorrelated with each other. Public access is limited to a few farmland REITs and global agribusiness funds, so most exposure is individual or private. Farmland makes up part of the roughly two-thirds of his net worth that is outside public assets.

    “However, having been exposed to it... It's one of my favorite asset classes, but it's also one of the ones that's hardest to allocate to public markets.”at 54:47

US housing

Where everyone stands on US housing

  • Cullen Roche · Discipline Funds

    Real estate could deliver zero real returns for five to ten more years until rates and affordability improve.

    Roche says housing has delivered zero real returns for three or four years, and he would not be surprised if that continued for another five or ten. High prices and mortgage rates have priced people out, and this is driving negative sentiment in the economy. Once megatrends are absorbed and rates fall, affordability and demand can return. Until then, renters may find stocks and bonds more attractive than buying.

    “I personally believe that real estate could be... It could be a zero in terms of real return for another... It's been a zero for the last three or four years. It could be a zero. I wouldn't be shocked if it was a zero for five or ten more years.”at 1:01:28

IPOs, M&A & deal activity

Where everyone stands on IPOs, M&A & deal activity

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    SpaceX, Anthropic and OpenAI will enter the top 10 US market caps this year, a rare event for new listings.

    Faber notes that the last company to list and immediately rank in the top 10 by market cap was Ford in the 1950s. He expects three private companies, SpaceX, Anthropic and OpenAI, to enter the top 10 this year. He also suggests their combined size could exceed all of the 1990s IPOs combined. The rarity of such a listing is the evidence behind his claim.

    “We're gonna have three that are gonna enter the market cap top 10 rank in the... In this year, SpaceX, Anthropic OpenAI.”at 1:03:52

US tax & spending policy

Where everyone stands on US tax & spending policy

  • Meb Faber · Cambria Investment Management

    The QSBS startup-gain tax exclusion is among the most valuable recent legislation for startup investors.

    Faber says a law passed under Obama and later expanded lets investors in qualifying startups pay no tax on gains if they hold for five years. This is a major source of tax alpha in his startup investing. He calls it one of the most amazing pieces of legislation of the past two decades, and he argues that tax savings can offset percentage points of underperformance against the S&P 500.

    “If you're investing in startups... It's called QSPS. You get no taxable gain if you invest in a... Basically, you're paying no taxes on the gain if you hold it for five years.”at 1:06:47

Topics

  • China corporate share-count management
  • ETF vs mutual fund structure
  • QSBS tax exclusion for startup investors
  • T-bills as safe asset
  • US underallocation to foreign markets
  • allocation fund fees and tax efficiency
  • angel investing portfolio construction
  • bond aggregate index construction
  • buybacks and shareholder yield
  • buybacks in non-US markets
  • credit spreads over T-bills
  • emerging-market startups
  • emerging-market value and trend
  • farmland as an asset class
  • house prices and real returns
  • market-cap index weighting
  • market-cap index weighting as trend following
  • mega-IPO market-cap impact
  • real assets as inflation hedge
  • startup valuations by vintage

More from Excess Returns

All Excess Returns episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus