CNBC Fast Money · · 49 min
Anthropic Jumps in Massive Debut, But Broad Markets Sell Off
With Gene Munster, John Belton, John Furner
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
CNBC Fast Money discussed Anthropic's stock market debut, which jumped strongly on day one even as broad markets sold off. Panelists split on Anthropic: Brian Kelly and Gene Munster called it a compelling long-term holding, John Belton said he still owns it as a pure-play AI exposure, while Dan Nathan warned that frontier labs are losing heavily and that Anthropic's roughly $1 trillion compute commitments are unfunded. The broader debate centred on a growth scare, with Tim Seymour and Dan Nathan tying the selloff to a hawkish Fed that resembles Volcker, a strong dollar, falling commodities such as copper, and semiconductor and memory weakness. Kelly expects the S&P 500 to fill its gap below the 200-day average, with the VIX above 35 marking a possible low, while Belton and Munster argued AI and tech multiples now look oversold and that investors are rotating toward application-layer AI names like Snowflake. AMD drew a short report on China-linked export control risks, with Kelly bearish and Seymour arguing the stock remains a buy.
Key takeaways
- Brian Kelly (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic will become a foundational company, not just a token seller, so it may be worth far more.
- Gene Munster (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic is a great value versus other tech, with either premium tokens or broad expansion as upside.
- Tim Seymour (bullish on Advanced Micro Devices): AMD faces the same export controls as Nvidia and remains among the best chip companies, so the short report is no reason to sell.
- John Belton (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic is a one-of-one, founder-led company with growth never seen at this scale; he likes owning it long term.
- Dan Nathan (uncertain on Anthropic): A pure-play Anthropic bet may not be the winning way; its compute commitments are not yet funded.
What was said, by company and theme
34 views from 5 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Anthropic
Across the shows: 144 speakers in other episodes, 257 bullish and 117 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Anthropic
Brian Kelly · BKCM LLCBullish
Anthropic will become a foundational company, not just a token seller, so it may be worth far more.
Kelly says Anthropic will be one of the foundational companies of the new economy. He argues it is not only a token seller, since it will expand into biotech, software and a large conglomerate. If it is valued on that broader footprint rather than on token sales, there is much more upside. He flipped his allocation for a quick gain and says he would have kept it if the market had not sold off hard.
“they're not token sellers. You can't value this company that they're gonna sell tokens for the rest of time. What I think is going to happen with this company is they'll become a biotech company, they'll become a software company”at 11:01
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaBearish
Frontier labs may deserve a discount; they lose tens of billions and their products may commoditise.
Nathan says frontier labs have grown revenue astonishingly fast but are losing tens of billions of dollars doing it. Unless they will cure cancer, they sit in the application layer, where the offering is likely to become commoditised. Unlike Google in search, no single lab will run away with the market, so the incremental gains may go elsewhere. He thinks the value is more in enterprise adoption.
“they're losing tens of billions of dollars to do that. ... What they are offering is likely to come pretty commoditized.”at 13:00
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish
Anthropic is a great value versus other tech, with either premium tokens or broad expansion as upside.
Munster says his firm got an IPO allocation, scaled down and still likes Anthropic. He sees two paths: the frontier models have the smartest tokens and a faction of the world will pay a lot for them, or Anthropic becomes a competitor to much bigger companies across biotech, fintech and software. He calls Anthropic a great value proposition relative to tech and says the question is whether AI will exceed the hype.
“I think it's a great value proposition relative to tech that's out there.”at 15:50
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaBullish
In a growth scare, pure-play AI names like Anthropic could become defensive, though valuation will matter.
Asked whether Anthropic is more defensive as a pure-play AI company, Nathan says yes. There is a world where these names become defensive, and in a growth-scare environment investors flock to them. He says valuation will matter at some point, and that a company with an ad business, like Meta, could see contraction in ads, which makes a pure AI play more defensive.
“people flock to these names. Absolutely. Valuation's going to matter at some point. But to answer your question, I think it's yes.”at 19:00
John Belton · Gabelli FundsBullish
Anthropic is a one-of-one, founder-led company with growth never seen at this scale; he likes owning it long term.
Belton says he does not make much of day-one IPO action. He calls Anthropic potentially a one-of-one company: impressive, founder-led, well positioned, and putting up growth numbers the market has never seen at this scale. He still likes owning it over the long term and confirms he still holds his allocation.
“But I think this is a potentially one of one company. It's a very impressive founder led, well positioned company, putting up numbers that we've really never seen this type of growth at this type of scale before.”at 34:24
John Belton · Gabelli FundsBullish
Anthropic is a useful pure-play AI holding, a diversifier from the CapEx trade, though very volatile.
Belton's fund holds Anthropic and he says it works as a substitute for high-growth names and gives differentiated exposure to AI. He argues Anthropic is not a beneficiary of the CapEx trade but the reason for that spending, so it diversifies away from the tech names that depend on AI capex. He expects the stock to be very volatile for the foreseeable future, a risk he accepts for the exposure.
“I like having some exposure to this sort of pure play generative AI company. I think it's going to be very volatile, at least for the foreseeable future.”at 36:02
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaUncertain
A pure-play Anthropic bet may not be the winning way; its compute commitments are not yet funded.
Nathan says demand could pull back if Anthropic does not show a path to profitability. He notes it has committed close to a trillion dollars to build out compute and is spending about $3 billion a month with xAI. It is also building its own compute to reduce reliance on outside suppliers and competing with xAI on several fronts beyond the model. He argues the big commitments are contracts that have not been funded, so he is not sure a pure play will look like the right call a year from now.
“I'm not sure a pure play is going to be a year from now we're gonna look and say that was the way to go.”at 40:09
Advanced Micro Devices
Across the shows: 23 speakers in other episodes, 30 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Advanced Micro Devices
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset ManagementBullish
AMD faces the same export controls as Nvidia and remains among the best chip companies, so the short report is no reason to sell.
Seymour says AMD operates under the same export controls as Nvidia and other chipmakers. He argues that the government is not going to take apart its biggest tech companies. He notes that in a murky environment with few rules, buyers also found ways around the controls. He says AMD is one of the biggest chip companies and is still the best, so the short report is not a reason to sell.
“AMD is going to be under the same export controls as NVIDIA and other people. ... these are the biggest chip companies in the world. They're still the best, too.”at 21:47
Brian Kelly · BKCM LLCBearish
AMD should trade significantly below $489 once export-control and China risks are priced in.
After the short report alleging links to blacklisted Chinese firms, Kelly asks where AMD should price in this new world. His answer is that the stock is probably not worth $489 and should be significantly lower. The argument is brief and rests on the new China and export-control risk rather than on the company's fundamentals.
“Where does AMD price in this new world? It's probably not $489. It's probably significantly lower.”at 23:36
Snowflake
Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Snowflake
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish
Snowflake is in a wonderful place despite a recent 16% drop.
Asked about software, Munster says Snowflake is in a wonderful place. The stock has fallen about 16% over the past month, though many other AI trades have fallen further. He says investors are shifting toward the application side of AI, which is where he expects Snowflake's strength to come through.
“I think Snowflake's in a wonderful place.”at 17:28
Automatic Data Processing
Brian Kelly · BKCM LLCBullish
ADP is a long because its decades of data can be monetised with AI.
Kelly argues the market will reward companies that use AI rather than those that sell it. He compares Anthropic to a utility selling electricity and says the buyers of that electricity are the ones to own. ADP has years and decades of data that have not yet been tapped, and AI can now be applied to that data to extract much more value.
“one name that I'm longing is ADP. Years, decades of all kinds of data that they can now apply AI to and possibly get a lot more value out of that data.”at 20:02
Okta
Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaUncertain
Okta is on his watch list because it also onboards AI agents, though the market is tough.
Nathan says Okta is a name for him in the cyber space, and he will put it on his watch list because the market is tough right now. He notes Okta does more than cybersecurity, since it also onboards agents for companies. That combination is why he wants to watch it, though he is not yet ready to buy.
“Okta not only does cybersecurity, but it also onboards agents for companies.”at 31:13
Insmed
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaBullish
Insmed's fundamental story is unchanged after a halving, so it's a name to stay long on.
Nathan recalls that Insmed traded above $200, then got cut in half while the story never fundamentally changed. Now there is takeover news from Sanofi. He says if something happens, it would happen at a price above the current level, so the stock is one to stay long on.
“Again, this is one of those names. You've got to just stay long.”at 33:29
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 176 speakers in other episodes, 183 bullish and 172 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
John Belton · Gabelli FundsBullish
Nvidia remains a dominant company at a single-digit P/E; he holds it and sees it as cheap.
Belton has not added to Nvidia but has not sold it, so he is still holding. He calls it a dominant company whose next few years of fundamentals are largely set by the product roadmap Jensen Huang laid out. At a single-digit P/E the stock could get cheaper, but he sees it as one of the blue chips on sale among picks-and-shovels names.
“This is still a dominant company. I think the next few years of fundamentals are pretty baked in on the roadmap that Jensen laid out. We're talking about a single digit price earnings multiple.”at 38:40
Williams-Sonoma
Across the shows: 3 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Williams-Sonoma
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaBullish
Williams-Sonoma has de-rated toward a 20x multiple with growth still intact; a buy near $185-190.
The stock hit an all-time high a couple of weeks earlier on hot valuations, and the market is now punishing it. Nathan expects it to fall to about a 20x multiple, where he thinks the remaining growth becomes attractive. He says he would buy it with both hands if it closes in the roughly $185-190 area.
“the market's going to punish you... you're going to get down to about a 20 multiple at some point and you say, wait a second, there's still some growth here to like.”at 42:35
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
The AI trade is unwinding: semis rolled over in June and memory has been a disaster.
Nathan says semiconductors have been rolling over since mid-June and the memory trade has been an abject disaster since late summer. Tertiary AI names are also getting clobbered. He sees this as the culmination of a slow-motion move. The S&P has closed meaningfully below its 200-day moving average, which he calls a good thing because the market needed this reset.
“you look at semiconductors, have been rolling over since the middle of June. The memory trade has been an abject disaster since the end of the summer.”at 4:15
Brian Kelly · BKCM LLC
The S&P 500 gap from April will likely fill soon, coinciding with the VIX above 35 and the year's low.
Dan Nathan pointed out a chart gap in the SMH and S&P 500 dating back to April, and the S&P closed well below its 200-day moving average. Kelly says filling that gap is now inevitable. He expects it to happen relatively soon, coinciding with the VIX going above 35, and that this should mark the low for the rest of the year.
“I think there's inevitability now that we will fill at some point. I think it's going be relatively soon. I think that coincides with the VIX north of 35”at 4:44
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Brian Kelly · BKCM LLC
The Fed has made clear it is on a hiking cycle until inflation falls, which is driving the selloff.
Kelly says sentiment on the Fed changed in the last week or two. A month ago he thought the Fed would make one or two more hikes and then stop, which would let markets recover. Now the Fed has made clear it will keep hiking until inflation is down, and he says that is what the market is focused on and why everything is heavy.
“they've made it very clear over the last week that they are on a rate hiking cycle until we get inflation down.”at 5:15
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset Management
The Fed has turned far more hawkish, behaving like Volcker rather than Bernanke, and the market is reacting.
Seymour says the market sold off because investors were most worried that policy had tightened too far. He argues the Fed is now clearly much more aggressive than expected and looks more like Paul Volcker than Ben Bernanke. Combined with higher rates, that is what he thinks is driving the reassessment.
“you add in a Fed that looks more like Paul Volcker than Ben Bernanke”at 9:48
US growth & recession risk
Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset Management
This is a growth scare: rates and the market both peaked and are now falling together.
Seymour says the market's peak lined up with the peak in rates, and that rates have fallen as the market has fallen. He calls that a growth scare tied to technology, since tech is everything. He argues the economy had relied on the cyclicality of AI growth for a couple of years. Higher rates, a Fed that looks like Volcker, a strong dollar and crashing commodities all point to a growth scare, even though the labor market is still resilient.
“But once again, I'll tell you this is a growth scare.”at 6:16
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
This is a growth scare, with commodities and copper in freefall as evidence.
Responding to whether this is a growth scare, Nathan says yes. He points to commodities, which Seymour had noted, and says they are in an absolute freefall. Copper's slide in particular speaks to what is going on. He links this to AI growth, which the Fed chair has described as important to GDP.
“Is it a growth scare? Tim mentioned what's going on in commodities. These things are in an absolute freefall, to Tim's point.”at 19:03
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Brian Kelly · BKCM LLC
A 10–30% slowdown in AI buildout would hit GDP hard, given how highly stocks are priced.
Kelly says AI buildout has contributed between 20% and 50% of GDP growth, depending on the estimate. He says that is now slowing, and that data centers will cost more because of solar and payments to communities. He argues a 10%, 20% or 30% slowdown in that spending would have a big GDP impact, and that matters because stocks are priced at high levels.
“There's going to be some time a slowdown. Doesn't mean it stops, but a 10%, 20%, 30% slowdown on that has a big impact in GDP when stocks are priced at such high levels.”at 9:04
John Belton · Gabelli Funds
Hyperscaler capex may peak next year, but he believes current capex is productive.
Belton says there is a growing view that hyperscaler capex is closer to peak, perhaps peaking next year and declining in 2028. He thinks incremental concern on capex is driving the tech weakness, along with rates and Nvidia uncertainty. The key debate is return on invested capital, and he argues that the capex is productive, which is what will dictate things from here.
“growing view that hyperscaler CapEx is closer to peak, maybe peaks next year, maybe declines in 2028.”at 34:52
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset Management
The AI trade selloff is overdone, so Munster's firm bought more stock into the close.
Munster says that after positive Nvidia news, the AI trade had sold off hard. He called the bottom two days ago. Since then the Nasdaq has fallen another 2%, but his firm bought more stock in the final fifteen minutes because it thinks the selloff is overdone.
“we bought more stock in the final fifteen minutes of today because we think that this is overdone.”at 16:39
John Belton · Gabelli Funds
Growth-stock multiples have compressed sharply; growth index trades below value on 2028 P/E, unprecedented.
Multiples on AI and tech names are much cheaper than six to eight weeks ago and a few months ago. He has never seen a growth stock index trade at a discount to value on 2028 P/E. He reads this as concern about the sustainability of earnings, even though current earnings growth is still extremely strong. He says the picks-and-shovels blue chips are now on sale.
“Multiples are much cheaper now than they were six, eight weeks ago, and certainly than a few months ago... on 2028 PE it's trading at a discount to value. I've never seen that before.”at 37:58
Banks
Where everyone stands on Banks
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
Banks are very cyclical and the cycle is late, so bank stocks are vulnerable.
Nathan says he thinks banks have been in a slow-motion decline since September, when Brian Moynihan gave cautionary comments after banks topped in August. Those comments were unusual, since Moynihan has not sounded that way in fifteen years. Banks are very cyclical, and Nathan thinks the cycle is late rather than early.
“banks are very cyclical. And I think we're a lot late cycle than we are early.”at 26:45
Brian Kelly · BKCM LLC
Regional banks will be the place to be once a turnaround comes, though not yet.
Kelly says banks will be a tough trade for a while until it is clear whether this is only a growth scare or a real 2027 slowdown. But if a turnaround comes, whether from the Fed stopping rate cuts or from Treasury action, he thinks regional banks will be the place to be. He adds that any bailout will go to Main Street rather than Wall Street.
“the regional banks are going to be the place to be. It's not today, but any bailout or beneficiary is going to go to Main Street, not Wall Street.”at 27:54
US dollar
Where everyone stands on US dollar
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset Management
The dollar's rise is driven by Fed policy and central bank rate gaps, plus US growth outperformance.
Seymour says he would argue the dollar is doing what it is doing mainly because of the Fed and central bank differentials. He adds strength of the US economy relative to the rest of the world. He treats the dollar move as related to but separate from the broader market moves, and he notes it coincides with commodities falling.
“the dollar is doing what it's doing more related to the Fed and more due just to central bank differentials and the strength of The US economy relative to the rest of the world.”at 9:55
Software & SaaS
Where everyone stands on Software & SaaS
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset Management
Software in general will remain a tough place, even as AI disrupts application-layer names.
Munster says software in general is still going to be a tough place. He points to Snowflake falling about 16% over the past month, with many other AI trades doing much worse. This fits his view that investors are shifting toward application-layer AI, away from the software and infrastructure names.
“I think software in general is still going be a tough place.”at 17:28
Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Where everyone stands on Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset Management
Investors are shifting from AI infrastructure to application-layer AI, which is being valued more.
Munster says his firm is shifting what it buys, moving from chips and memory infrastructure toward the application side of AI. He thinks the trade will drift toward that area. He notes that software names like Snowflake fell about 16% over the past month, and that many other AI trades did worse, suggesting investors are beginning to value the application side more.
“we're moving from infrastructure, chips based, memory based ... I think you're starting to see investors value that application side more.”at 17:45
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
If the Fed pivots away from hikes because AI growth slows, that could be bearish for bonds.
Nathan says the AI build-out is central to GDP. If AI spending slows or is mitigated, the Fed is in an awkward spot. If it pivots away from rate hikes in response, he thinks that would be bearish for the bond market, somewhat counterintuitively.
“if they pivot away from rate hikes, I think that's bearish for the bond market somewhat counterintuitively.”at 19:18
US–China AI & chip race
Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
Chip makers will likely escape serious penalties for export-control violations, facing at most fines.
Nathan says companies have worked around export bans for a long time, so long as there were no direct sales into China. He suspects the chip companies will get a pass, with probably some fines. He adds that this is likely the second of many hardware revelations, and that the country still wants to keep these chips out of adversaries' infrastructure.
“I suspect all of our companies, to Tim's point, they're going to get a pass. I mean, there's probably going to be some fines”at 22:37
IPOs, M&A & deal activity
Where everyone stands on IPOs, M&A & deal activity
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
Anthropic is crowding out other IPOs, so the deal pipeline has been pushed to 2027.
Nathan cites Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon's view that Anthropic is crowding out a lot of other IPOs. Anthropic's deal raised about $13 billion and it expects $17 billion in sales this quarter alone. Nathan says deals matter but need a pipeline behind them, and right now the pipeline has been pushed out to 2027.
“right now, that pipeline has been pushed to 2027. There's a lot more fast money to come.”at 28:08
Cybersecurity
Where everyone stands on Cybersecurity
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
Cyber stocks have concerning valuations and he is not a buyer; weak delivery may penalise them.
Nathan says cyber names have traded poorly, though they are getting back on their horse. Valuation is concerning and always has been. He expects a bid despite valuations, but if companies do not deliver in a world of frequent glitches, some will be put in the penalty box. He notes that correlations are going to one and that defensive names are also down together.
“Well, I'm not a buyer of them.”at 30:14
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA176 speakers · 183 bullish, 172 bearish calls
- Anthropic144 speakers · 257 bullish, 117 bearish calls
- Advanced Micro Devices23 speakers · 30 bullish, 1 bearish calls
- Williams-Sonoma3 speakers · 2 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Okta2 speakers · 2 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Snowflake2 speakers · 2 bullish, 0 bearish calls
Topics
- AI applied to proprietary data
- AI trade selloff overdone
- Fed hawkishness
- IPO pipeline
- Nvidia valuation and roadmap
- S&P 500 gap fill and VIX
- Snowflake stock outlook
- agent identity onboarding
- application-layer AI
- bank cycle positioning
- bond market reaction to Fed pivot
- cybersecurity valuations
- data center capex
- defensive positioning
- dollar strength
- export control enforcement
- export control risk pricing
- export controls exposure
- founder-led growth at scale
- frontier lab business model
- frontier lab economics
- growth scare
- hyperscaler capex
- pure-play AI exposure
- pure-play AI investment thesis
- rate hikes
- regional bank rotation
- retail earnings and valuation reset
- semiconductor and memory selloff
- software sector outlook
- stock recovery potential
- tech valuations
- valuation vs public tech
More from CNBC Fast Money
- Anthropic IPO, Fed Shock Talk and Health Insurer Sell-Off · November 19, 2026
- All the Headlines From the Nvidia Earnings Call · November 17, 2026
- Countdown to NVIDIA Earnings, Anthropic IPO Watch, and More Tech Issues at Airlines · November 16, 2026
- FAA Ground Stop, Anthropic IPO and What to Expect From Nvidia and Nike Next Week · November 14, 2026
- Nvidia Fallout, AI Financing Risk and Apple’s Safe-Haven Surge 11/12/26 · November 12, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus