CNBC Fast Money · · 54 min
All the Headlines From the Nvidia Earnings Call
With Chris Rolland, Colette Kress, Gene Munster, Harvey C. Jones, Seema Mody
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
CNBC Fast Money used Nvidia's quarterly earnings call as the anchor for a broader debate on the AI trade. Colette Kress reported Q3 revenue of $116bn, more than doubling year over year, with Vera Rubin shipping nearly $20bn in its first production quarter and fiscal 2028 growth outlook raised to about 75%. Panelists split on whether the stock, roughly 40% below its all-time high, is a buying opportunity: Guy Adami, Gene Munster and Chris Rolland were constructive, while Tim Seymour argued Nvidia has not reached a trough multiple, citing custom in-house chips from hyperscalers and a CEO-transition headwind after Jensen Huang's departure. Dan Nathan was the most bearish, flagging a roughly 300bp gross margin decline to about 71.9%, inventory risk, an SEC probe, and a past export-control loophole involving Singapore and Malaysia, and advised selling rallies in semiconductors, which Karen Finerman rejected as a possible inflection point. The panel also covered geopolitical risk from the Strait of Hormuz, a string of technology outages that Nathan and Courtney Garcia linked to possible cyber disruption, and stock-specific calls on Home Depot, Nike and XLU.
Key takeaways
- Dan Nathan (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's guided margin drop and inventory risk make the guidance unimpressive.
- Chris Rolland (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's leadership is stabilizing and the quarter was very solid, especially top-line.
- Tim Seymour (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's shares have not hit a trough valuation; custom in-house chips are eroding its multiple.
- Guy Adami (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's shares should trade far better after a 40% drop from the all-time high on an extraordinary quarter.
- Gene Munster (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's guidance above expectations shows customers returning despite China curbs; growth still beats investor expectations.
What was said, by company and theme
30 views from 7 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 168 speakers in other episodes, 169 bullish and 137 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Karen Finerman · Metropolitan Capital AdvisorsNeutral
A Huang reinstatement via shareholder slate would be hard, since top holders are blue-chip funds.
Nvidia is a Delaware corporation where all directors stand for election, so a slate could in theory be submitted. Apart from Huang, the top holders are blue-chip funds such as Vanguard and Fidelity, which Karen thinks would be much harder to sway, and she does not know how they would vote.
“one could, seek to submit a slate. ... one of the top 11 holders is Jensen, if you take those shares out. The rest are all, you know, Vanguard, Fidelity... that's going to be a lot harder, I think, to sway.”at 10:19
Guy Adami · CNBCBullish
Nvidia's record quarter should lift the stock 15-20%; it's flat, so it's cheap.
Guy says the stock is about 40% below its all-time high, and it was once a trough multiple versus peers and below the market multiple. The quarter was historic, with triple-digit year-over-year growth, a guidance raise, and a larger buyback. In normal times the stock should be up 15 to 20% on that, but it is basically unchanged, which he sees as a sign the valuation is undemanding.
“Now you look at it today, historic quarter. ... the question you have to ask yourself is okay if this was normal times the stock should be up 15 to 20% and it's basically unchanged.”at 12:40
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaBearish
Nvidia's guided margin drop and inventory risk make the guidance unimpressive.
Dan says the guided gross margin of about 71.9% is down 300 basis points from the 74.9% quarter, so margins face pressure. He sees a risk that Nvidia ends up with a lot of inventory from the wafers and memory it has committed to, while competitors such as AMD, Google TPUs, Amazon Trainium and custom silicon increase pressure. A margin rebound over the few quarters after next depends on demand and competition. Part of the guided revenue is receivables not yet collected, and orders do not always convert to bookings, as in past cycles. He also says the $150bn buyback is hard to execute under the SEC probe, which is likely the first of many investigations.
“So to me, I think there's a risk that they end up with a lot of inventory, which will weigh on margins going forward. So if you think about a reacceleration in gross margins over the few quarters after next one, it really comes down to demand. It comes down to competition.”at 14:43
Chris Rolland · Susquehanna Financial GroupBullish
Nvidia's leadership is stabilizing and the quarter was very solid, especially top-line.
Chris says the interim CEO and the chair are doing a fantastic job establishing stability in the absence of Jensen Huang. He calls the report very solid, particularly the top line, and expects more detail to follow.
“Both are doing a fantastic job. It's clear they're trying to establish stability in the absence of Jensen, and I think they're doing that well. This was a very solid report, particularly top line.”at 16:14
Chris Rolland · Susquehanna Financial GroupNeutral
Huang returning as CEO is unlikely; an outside advisory role would help bridge the gap.
Chris looked at 12 similar incidents involving direct reports, and none of those executives were brought back, so he sees no open door. He would ask whether the board would consider Huang as an outside consultant, providing technical and strategic advisory services that he thinks would be important to the company.
“I don't think it's gonna happen. We looked at 12 other incidents that were similar with direct reports. None of them were brought back.”at 16:59
Chris Rolland · Susquehanna Financial GroupUncertain
Nvidia's future commitments rose about 40% to over $500bn; leaning into financing raises questions.
Chris says Nvidia is not pulling back on financing, land, power or shell commitments. Total commitments rose about 40%, from about $350bn to well over $500bn. He reads this as the company leaning into its financing strategy, and says he would have some questions about that.
“They're not leaning out in terms of financing or land power shell. They're actually leaning in and those total commitments were up about 40% from about 350 to well over 500,000,000,000. ... I'd have some questions about that.”at 19:58
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset ManagementUncertain
Nvidia's multiple, not earnings, is the question; the stock has derated versus peers.
Tim argues the key question is what multiple investors should pay, not what earnings are. Nvidia has derated relative to its peer group since August 2025 and is not at trough multiples, though he says maybe it should not be in the age of AI. He expects a long process given a CEO search and regulatory headwinds of roughly six months, but sees the business as a cash machine over the next two years. He notes the stock fell only about 15% since Huang resigned, which he thinks is the real question if the risk was priced in before.
“And it's not what those earnings are, it's what multiple do we want to pay? And this is a stock that has been derating now really relative to its peer group August '25. ... By the way, we're not really at trough multiples.”at 21:01
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset ManagementBearish
Nvidia faces a six-month headwind from CEO uncertainty and regulation.
Seymour says he is not arguing the company is ready to accelerate. He believes Nvidia faces a six-month headwind tied to the CEO situation and the regulatory environment, even though he thinks demand for chips is strong and the industry is still early.
“I believe there's a six month headwind in terms of the CEO and the regulatory,”at 36:07
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset ManagementBearish
Nvidia's shares have not hit a trough valuation; custom in-house chips are eroding its multiple.
Seymour says Nvidia has not reached a trough valuation. He concedes Nvidia is the cream of the crop on margins and profitability, but argues the real question is whether it can hold its margins and multiple. He says the threat is not AMD or Intel but custom in-house chips from other large players, which he believes have been gnawing at Nvidia's multiple for a long time and which he sees as the more important question.
“It's some of the other custom players. It's the in house, I think these have been gnawing at the stocks multiple for a long time and I think it's a much more important question.”at 36:50
Guy Adami · CNBCBullish
Nvidia's shares should trade far better after a 40% drop from the all-time high on an extraordinary quarter.
Adami calls the quarter extraordinary on every metric and says management is encouraged by its visibility. Given the stock has fallen about 40% from its all-time high, he argues it should be trading markedly better than it is. He says investors buying at these levels would be piling in. Later he adds that if people think this is the last chapter of the Nvidia story, they need to think again, though he expects the bounce may only be short-lived.
“given the 40% haircut the stock has seen since its all time high, one would think even at 1.61, it would be trading markedly better than it is now.”at 37:27
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal MediaBearish
Nvidia's Singapore and Malaysia chip-routing loophole and undisclosed exposure make the situation risky for the stock.
Nathan argues Nvidia's CEO was deliberately trying to move away from the chip-routing loophole, since he knew where those chips were used. The loophole involved chips reaching data centers in Singapore and Malaysia through remote access. He cites roughly 22% of Nvidia's revenue in Singapore in the summer 2025 quarter, about $10 billion, and says the interim CEO, previously the CFO, did not know about it. He concludes there is 'so much hair on this situation' that a 10% rally is a chance to sell.
“He knows what those chips are being used for. This whole remote access situation that was the loophole with those chips going to data centers in Singapore and Malaysia.”at 41:25
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish
Nvidia's guidance above expectations shows customers returning despite China curbs; growth still beats investor expectations.
Munster says the company answered the key questions and is comfortable giving guidance above expectations for the January quarter and calendar 2027, even though it recognizes China export curbs as a risk. He reads this as customers coming back regardless. Geopolitics will weigh on growth, but he argues that growth will still be higher than investors believe for calendar 2027. He concludes the current business and outlook are rock solid, which gives time to find the next CEO, and that it is a buy here.
“they're still comfortable at giving guidance higher than expected for not only the January quarter, but for calendar twenty seven.”at 45:13
The Home Depot
Across the shows: 7 speakers in other episodes, 6 bullish and 3 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on The Home Depot
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset ManagementBullish
Home Depot is a stock to add to tactically, though guidance was weak after strong same-store sales.
Tim likes the stock, which has had a great run, and calls it a place to add tactically. He notes same-store sales were fantastic but the guide was not as strong, and transaction velocity has been weak while ticket size has grown. He would take profits if trading it short term, but says long-term holders should absolutely stay in.
“I like the stock. It's a stock that's had a great run. It's a stock that I think is where you want to be adding tactically, but these same store sales numbers were fantastic. The problem was that the guide wasn't so great”at 32:10
Courtney Garcia · Payne Capital ManagementBullish
Home Depot reported good numbers, so the post-earnings selloff is a buy-the-dip opportunity.
Garcia says Home Depot reported good numbers. She attributes part of the stock's decline to the CEO situation and to broader market selling, and she argues investors should buy the dip.
“Home Depot, they reported they were good numbers. I think some of this is on the CEO and broader market selling and buy that dip.”at 52:09
Nike
Across the shows: 8 speakers in other episodes, 4 bullish and 2 bearish calls, past 30 days
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset ManagementBearish
Nike's ambitious 2031 targets disappoint; investors wanted more conservative numbers.
Tim says Investor Days should be joyous, but Nike's turnaround plan was more ambitious than the market wanted. He thinks investors would have appreciated more conservative long-term targets through 2031. He also says a recovery to the earnings level the market hoped for is a long way away.
“They're ambitious, their long term targets through '31. I think people might have appreciated more conservative numbers, frankly.”at 31:54
Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset ManagementBullish
XLU is both a yield play and an oversold trade, separate from the data center trade.
Seymour argues the utilities trade has been confused with the data center trade. He says utilities' cost inputs are coming down, and some of the best utilities in the world also have growth exposure. He calls XLU a yield play and an oversold position, although it has just caught some rally.
“owning the XLU at a time when also some of those cost inputs for these utilities are coming down, some of the best in the world also have exposure to growth. I think the XLU is both a yield play and a play that's actually oversold.”at 52:31
AI chips & semiconductors
Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors
Guy Adami · CNBC
Semis (SMH, SOX) rejected at their 200-day average, a bearish chart signal.
Guy says the S&P closing below its 200-day moving average matters. He says SMH and SOX traded below their 200-day average, bounced back up to it last week, then fell back below it. There is also an unfilled gap from April. He hopes Nvidia's numbers can help the sector reclaim the level.
“I think even more interesting than that it's either the SMH or the SOX which traded below the two hundred day moving average on the bounce that we saw last week traded back up to it and then subsequently traded back down again.”at 29:44
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset Management
Nvidia faces rising competition from custom silicon and hyperscalers pulling back on capex.
Tim says the Nvidia debate is less about Huang than about the space: share is shifting to competitive forces such as TPUs and custom ASICs and silicon, and hyperscalers are pulling back on capex. He says there has been a question about the entire space, and that Nvidia's numbers were as expected.
“to other competitive forces, there's [TPUs], there's hyperscalers also pulling back on CapEx, there's all these ASICs, these silicon, custom silicon”at 35:36
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset Management
The post-earnings rally should put a floor under semiconductor stocks until hyperscaler capex guidance in January.
Munster says the earnings reaction should put a floor in the semiconductor group after its roughly 30% washout since July. The floor should hold until concerns return around hyperscaler capex guidance at the end of January and the December quarter. He qualifies that this does not mean Nvidia itself has a floor, because it still faces its own issue of who becomes the next CEO. He also argues that the idea of decelerating growth in the trade is not what he is hearing.
“I think this is gonna put a floor in for the next few... Until we get into concerns what will be, what's the CapEx, the hyperscaler guide at the end of January and the December quarter.”at 50:02
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
Sell semiconductor rallies; investors will use bounces to exit and more shoes will drop.
Nathan says he would sell rallies in semiconductors. The group could rally maybe 10%, but he expects investors to use the opportunity to sell, and he argues there is more downside to come.
“I think you sell rallies in the semis. Of course it could rally maybe 10% but I think investors are going to use opportunities to do it. There is more shoes to drop here.”at 51:55
Karen Finerman · Metropolitan Capital Advisors
Semiconductors may be at an inflection point, and she would buy, disagreeing with Dan Nathan.
Finerman explicitly disagrees with Nathan's call to sell semiconductor rallies. She argues the group may be at an inflection point and says she would be a buyer. She mentions holding a short position as a hedge and would step into the trade and buy to cover. The argument is brief and relies on the inflection-point view rather than specific data.
“I'm going to disagree with Dan on this. I actually think that we may be in an inflection point and I would be a buyer.”at 52:17
Cybersecurity
Where everyone stands on Cybersecurity
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
Recent outages seem to be a coordinated cyber attack on the economy, not glitches.
Dan says he is putting glitch in air quotes. Outages have hit Microsoft, Apple, Chase, United and the FAA, and the list is getting broader. Although the parties involved say there is no malicious actor, he thinks it seems like a coordinated cyber attack aimed at disrupting the economy, which he links to geopolitics.
“I know that we've talked about the whole glitch thing, and I'm doing that in air quotes. I mean, it does seem like there's a coordinated, some sort of cyber attack that's going on in our economy in an effort to disrupt, you know, our economy for all intents and purposes.”at 26:59
Courtney Garcia · Payne Capital Management
Outages should boost cyber stocks, yet they are not, signaling costly infrastructure upgrades.
Courtney says the outages show a clear need for infrastructure upgrades that will be more costly to businesses, so cyber stocks should benefit. Yet the software ETF IGV is rolling over and cyber stocks are not benefiting, which she calls a question for markets. She says the question of whether the outages are coincidences is one everyone is starting to ask.
“But it really should be benefiting the cyber stocks. So the fact they're not, I think that's a question to be had in the markets right now.”at 29:12
AI: overall outlook
Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook
Karen Finerman · Metropolitan Capital Advisors
Nvidia's results and Anthropic's IPO could mark a bottom for the AI trade, maybe only short term.
Karen says Nvidia's beat and guidance, together with Anthropic's IPO the next day, could be a very good bottom for the AI trade. She hedges that it may only be a short-term bottom.
“With this and Anthropic Tomorrow, I think this could be a very good bottom for the AI trade. Maybe it's only a short term bottom. I don't know.”at 4:02
AI pricing & unit economics
Where everyone stands on AI pricing & unit economics
Chris Rolland · Susquehanna Financial Group
Falling token prices are good, boosting demand; older-generation GPU pricing keeps rising.
Management said token prices have fallen nearly 60% since May while usage and compute demand accelerated, and GPU rental prices are rising across generations. Chris says falling token prices are good because they increase application usage and overall demand. He also notes that pricing even for older Nvidia generations keeps climbing, which is unusual for semiconductors.
“That's actually a good thing. You want token prices to fall. That'll increase overall applications, demand, etcetera, if that price does decrease.”at 17:55
US–China AI & chip race
Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race
Chris Rolland · Susquehanna Financial Group
Blocking all Southeast Asia GPU sales would be draconian; expect know-your-customer and geolocation rules instead.
Chris thinks a blanket block on Southeast Asia would be draconian. He expects know-your-customer rules and possibly geolocation on GPUs, but not a region-wide ban. He notes about $2bn of H20 sales into China this quarter might be in jeopardy, but he calls that a small amount.
“I think that would be draconian. I don't think it's all of Southeast Asia. I do expect some know your customer rules, maybe some geolocation on GPUs, but they're not gonna block an entire region out in my opinion.”at 19:10
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Tim Seymour · Seymour Asset Management
Hedge funds are significantly deleveraging while retail keeps its core overweights.
Tim sees significant degrossing in the hedge fund space. He thinks retail has not given up its core overweights and that this continues to slowly bleed the market. He points to charts breaking moving averages and says it would take a heroic end of the week to repair them.
“It really feels as if there's been significant degrossing in the hedge fund space. I don't think retail has really given up their core overweights here, and I think that's something that continues to slowly bleed.”at 25:28
Middle East & Iran
Where everyone stands on Middle East & Iran
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
Renewed Hormuz conflict could push crude, rates and the dollar higher.
Dan points to ships being attacked in the Strait of Hormuz, with WTI around 86 and Brent around 93.5. If the conflict reaccelerates, he thinks markets would have to question rates going higher, the dollar going higher and crude going higher, with consequences for the economy.
“And then if you think about what's going on in the [Strait of Hormuz]... there are ships that are being, you know, attacked... We have WTI at 86. We have Brent, at 93 and a half. If that were to reaccelerate, if this war came back... you start to have to question rates going higher, dollar going higher, crude going higher.”at 27:06
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Dan Nathan · RiskReversal Media
The S&P 500 should carry a discount for growing outage and tech-dependence risk.
Dan agrees with Melissa that the market should price in a discount for technological dependence. He cites United, Chase, Microsoft and Apple outages and says the list keeps growing. He ties this to geopolitical risk and to the effect outages would have on the cost to companies.
“...that's that discount I think you're kind of referring to, Mel. There probably should be one in the S and P 500.”at 27:31
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset Management
Hyperscalers will keep committing to strong AI infrastructure growth in calendar 2027 despite geopolitical risks.
Munster says the argument that the second derivative of growth is turning negative, and that the trade is therefore fading, is not what the company is hearing. He expects that despite geopolitical developments, hyperscalers will remain committed to growing a lot in calendar 2027. He cites customers wanting more as positive for the overall trade, while acknowledging it is a long way out.
“we will continue to hear, despite what's going on with the different geopolitics, that hyperscalers are going be committed to growing a lot in calendar twenty seven.”at 50:40
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA168 speakers · 169 bullish, 137 bearish calls
- Nike8 speakers · 4 bullish, 2 bearish calls
- The Home Depot7 speakers · 6 bullish, 3 bearish calls
Topics
- AI chip demand and outlook
- AI trade bottom
- CEO transition and regulatory headwind
- GPU export controls on Southeast Asia and China
- Huang reinstatement via shareholder slate
- Huang return as CEO
- Nvidia guidance and customer demand
- Nvidia share price after earnings
- Nvidia valuation after selloff
- Nvidia valuation multiple
- Q3 results and leadership stability
- Strait of Hormuz conflict risk
- chart breakdown below 200-day average
- coordinated cyber attacks on the economy
- custom AI chip competition
- custom silicon and hyperscaler capex competition
- earnings guidance and entry point
- export control loophole
- future commitments and financing
- gross margin trajectory and inventory risk
- hedge fund deleveraging
- home improvement retail
- hyperscaler capex
- outage-driven cyber stock demand
- outage-driven valuation discount
- semiconductor stocks
- token price declines
- turnaround long-term targets
- utilities sector
More from CNBC Fast Money
- Countdown to NVIDIA Earnings, Anthropic IPO Watch, and More Tech Issues at Airlines · November 16, 2026
- FAA Ground Stop, Anthropic IPO and What to Expect From Nvidia and Nike Next Week · November 14, 2026
- Nvidia Fallout, AI Financing Risk and Apple’s Safe-Haven Surge 11/12/26 · November 12, 2026
- Nvidia Shares Sink on New Allegations Against CEO Jensen Huang · November 11, 2026
- CoreWeave Earnings, Nvidia Fallout and Rate Hikes Back on the Table · November 10, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus