CNBC Halftime Report · · 52 min
Market Sell-Off, Anthropic IPO Volatility and the AI Trade Reset
With Amy Raskin, Kevin Simpson, Stephanie Link
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
CNBC Halftime Report discussed a sharp market sell-off and the reset in the AI trade, with Anthropic's volatile IPO as a focal point. Stephanie Link called the selloff a deleveraging event, argued data center spending will be trimmed but remains in the trillions, and remained bullish on Meta, Quanta Services, Zscaler, Palo Alto Networks and UnitedHealth, while blaming a hawkish Fed for overdone pressure and citing falling oil prices. Amy Raskin was more cautious, warning that AI capex still exceeds revenue, token price declines and about $900 billion in commitments cloud the business model, and that a 10-year yield near 5% is a key worry; she was bearish on Alphabet's search franchise but bullish on CrowdStrike, Verizon and Target. Kevin Simpson highlighted the lack of retail dip-buying, suggested waiting for a VIX capitulation near 70, and backed Texas Instruments, UnitedHealth, Amazon and a patient approach to Anthropic, while Nick Smith said Anthropic's 13% decline means it is not the IPO-window icebreaker the market needs.
Key takeaways
- Stephanie Link (bullish on Quanta Services): Quanta Services is a grid-repair opportunity; the grid is stressed and power is still scarce.
- Stephanie Link (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic is a long-term winner given its extreme revenue growth, though its IPO will be volatile.
- Amy Raskin (bearish on Alphabet): AI is eroding Alphabet's search monopoly, putting the core business it values the company on at risk.
- Amy Raskin (uncertain on Anthropic): Anthropic's business model is still unclear, with $900 billion in commitments, so she stays on the sidelines.
- Kevin Simpson (bullish on Texas Instruments): Texas Instruments is a buy: revenue up 28%, strong cash generation, and a 23rd straight dividend raise.
What was said, by company and theme
31 views from 3 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Anthropic
Across the shows: 149 speakers in other episodes, 266 bullish and 131 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Anthropic
Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish
Anthropic is a long-term winner given its extreme revenue growth, though its IPO will be volatile.
Link cites revenue growth of roughly 1,200% from one quarter last year to the third quarter of this year, going from about $375 million to $17 billion in quarterly revenue, plus net retention of 900%. She says that growth will not last at that pace but is still substantial. She says the IPO's volatility is typical and she wants to be part of the company long term. She did not take part in the IPO and would wait a couple of weeks before buying.
“From one q of last year to three q of this year, the company grew revenues 1200%. What company do you know that's grown that much? ... I think long term, they're a winner.”at 18:45
Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish
Anthropic and OpenAI could be amazing retail investments; buy in tranches, be patient.
Simpson says Anthropic and what happens with OpenAI later will make for amazing investments for retail. He says the initial trades are sketchy because of pent-up demand for liquidity from early investors. He suggests parsing in over time, waiting for pullbacks, and says Anthropic can be on the list but buying should be patient.
“the anthropic and what will happen with OpenAI at some point in the future make for amazing investor... Investments for retail investors.”at 19:53
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase TrustUncertain
Anthropic's business model is still unclear, with $900 billion in commitments, so she stays on the sidelines.
Raskin wants Anthropic to succeed and sees a US-based premier AI lab as valuable. But the S-1 shows fast revenue growth alongside falling token prices and about $900 billion in commitments whose financing is unclear. She says she still does not know the long-term business model, which keeps her on the sidelines.
“I still go back to this business model. I want Anthropic to succeed... I still don't know the business model, the long term business model, and that keeps me on the sidelines for it.”at 23:03
UnitedHealth Group
Across the shows: 4 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 2 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on UnitedHealth Group
Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish
UnitedHealth is number one on sale after a 16% drop on an initial CMS ruling, not a final one.
Link says UnitedHealth fell 16% in two days after an initial CMS ruling on Medicare Advantage, which she says is not final and will not be as harsh as feared. She cites its best-in-class balance sheet, the Optum business diversifying its revenue, improving medical loss ratio, and a $50 billion buyback. She also notes the CEO bought $25 million of stock after taking the job.
“down 16% in two days. So this is my definition of number one on sale... This is the number one company in the industry with the best balance sheet and the best CEO in the planet.”at 33:34
Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish
UnitedHealth's numbers are great; he still owns 2% and agrees with Link's bullish case.
Simpson says he agrees with everything Stephanie said about UnitedHealth. He wishes he had bought it at the lower level, but his stop loss triggered on half the position after a 15% drop. The full-year guidance raised in October was strong. He still owns 2% and can buy back in.
“I could wax poetic on all the reasons we love this company... I agree with everything Stephanie said about it.”at 34:42
Quanta Services
Across the shows: 5 speakers in other episodes, 6 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Quanta Services
Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish
Quanta Services is a grid-repair opportunity; the grid is stressed and power is still scarce.
Link says the grid needs spending regardless of data centers or AI, because it is stressed and the country still lacks enough power even if data center spend is haircut. She sees opportunity in companies that benefit from the grid repair and says she added to Quanta Services this week.
“I still think you need to spend on the grid... But the grid is stressed, and so the companies that have benefited from the repair, I think there are opportunities. I added to Quanta Services this week.”at 4:32
Meta Platforms
Across the shows: 67 speakers in other episodes, 62 bullish and 34 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Meta Platforms
Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish
Meta is a good buy during a spending slowdown because capex raises would stop.
Link has been adding to Meta on the view that if AI spending slows, the frenzy of capex raises will end. She says Meta has been at the forefront of those raises, so a pullback in spending would relieve it of that pressure. She is leg-ing in gradually because the dust may never fully settle.
“I've been adding to Meta because I think that if you do see a slowdown in the spend, you're not gonna have this frenzy of CapEx raises, and they have been at the forefront of doing just that.”at 4:53
Alphabet
Across the shows: 75 speakers in other episodes, 67 bullish and 51 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Alphabet
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase TrustBearish
AI is eroding Alphabet's search monopoly, putting the core business it values the company on at risk.
Raskin says the Mag Seven core businesses are slowly attriting, citing Google Search, where AI is eating at a cash-cow monopoly. The fundamental business she would value Google on is now in jeopardy. She sees the Mag Seven advantages as natural monopolies being undermined.
“their core sort of monopolistic businesses are attriting a little bit. Now you saw that with Google and Search... that fundamental business I would value Google off is in jeopardy.”at 22:24
Texas Instruments
Across the shows: 3 speakers in other episodes, 3 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Texas Instruments
Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish
Texas Instruments is a buy: revenue up 28%, strong cash generation, and a 23rd straight dividend raise.
Simpson bought a half-percent position and says he likes its cash generation more than the sales growth. Revenue rose 28%, with data centers a big contributor and industrials up 40% and autos up in the teens. Cost cuts on factory spending should lift free cash flow as factories become more profitable, and the dividend rose 7%. He will keep buying on weakness.
“[Revenue] was up 28%. Data centers were a big contributor. Industrials grew 40%... They've reduced their cost on factory spends... they also increased the dividend by 7% for the twenty third consecutive year.”at 30:35
Palo Alto Networks
Across the shows: 9 speakers in other episodes, 8 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Palo Alto Networks
Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish
Palo Alto is a strong cybersecurity name expected to post record earnings; she is keeping its position.
Link points to record earnings at Palo Alto and expects record earnings across the cybersecurity group despite the headline risk from tech outages and cyber threats. Palo Alto is up 90% this year, so she is not changing her position there.
“record earnings at Palo Alto, and I think you're gonna see record earnings across the board... I still love Palo Alto. Not changing anything there.”at 31:26
Zscaler
Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, 2 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish
Zscaler offers better risk-reward than Palo Alto, trading at a deep discount to its historical sales multiple.
Link added to Zscaler as a laggard, down 12% this year while Palo Alto is up 90%. She argues it trades at about a 50% discount to its historical enterprise-value-to-sales multiple. She expects RPO growth of about 27% and ARR growth in the mid-20s, and cites a long-term goal of $8-10 billion ARR. She sees it as a laggard that can catch up in a cyber group expected to post record earnings.
“I still love Palo Alto. Not changing anything there, but I think Zscaler offers a better risk reward. It's at a 50% discount to EV sales to its historical average.”at 31:38
CrowdStrike Holdings
Across the shows: 6 speakers in other episodes, 9 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on CrowdStrike Holdings
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase TrustBullish
CrowdStrike's market cap is far below trillion-dollar tech giants, so it still has room to rise.
Raskin argues cybersecurity is bigger than AI because of AI and is underappreciated. She owns CrowdStrike, having trimmed it in October, and says the stock is expensive but its market cap is only about $200 billion plus, not in the trillion-dollar range. That means it can still grow a lot without requiring huge growth from its current size.
“if you look at the overall market cap, they could still go up a lot. CrowdStrike's still, like, 200 plus billion dollar market cap. It's not in these trillion dollar market cap numbers.”at 32:42
Amazon.com
Across the shows: 45 speakers in other episodes, 65 bullish and 8 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Amazon.com
Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish
Amazon is a buy: strong retail store business and cloud, with the Anthropic stake a bonus.
Simpson picks Amazon on the strength of two businesses: its store, which draws people in, and its cloud. He says the company's stake in Anthropic is just a bonus on top of those. He gives no further figures or detailed mechanism.
“I'm gonna go with Amazon. Come for the store, stay for the cloud. Their Anthropic stake is just a bonus.”at 49:32
Verizon Communications
Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 0 bullish and 3 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Verizon Communications
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase TrustBullish
Verizon is attractive at a single-digit multiple with a 6% dividend yield, and SpaceX entering its business is not a worry.
Raskin picks Verizon on valuation and income. It trades at a single-digit multiple with a 6% dividend yield. She is not really worried about SpaceX getting into the telecom business, which is a potential competitive threat to Verizon's connectivity business.
“single digit multiple, 6% dividend yield, I'm not really worried about SpaceX ... getting into their business.”at 49:41
Target
Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Target
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase TrustBullish
Target's turnaround has arrived after a great quarter, with more upside left as it outsells Walmart.
Raskin calls Target's last quarter really great and says the turnaround is here, though there is still more to go. The evidence she cites is that Target has outcompeted Walmart three quarters in a row, with the figure of 5.6% she gives. Leslie Picker adds that transactions are up 5%, which Raskin's pick relies on as evidence that shoppers are coming back into the stores.
“So Target, really great quarter. I think the turnaround is here, but I think there's still more to go. They have now outcomped Walmart three quarters in a row.”at 49:41
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase Trust
Investors are on a buyer strike, reluctant to sell gains and unwilling to add to tech positions.
Raskin says there is almost a buyer strike. Most investors are overweight big AI winners because they have not wanted to realize capital gains, so the position is still large. Those holders are not rushing to buy more of Nvidia to rebalance, which weighs on the market.
“it feels like there's almost a buyer strike going on... most people are overweight because they haven't wanted to sell... Because they didn't wanna recognize the capital gains.”at 5:24
Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth Planning
Retail is not buying the dip for the first time since 2022, raising margin-call risk.
Simpson says nobody is buying right now and he does not think the market is about to see margin calls, though he believes that may be why there are no buyers. He says this is the first time since 2022 that retail has not come in to buy the dip, and that makes him nervous. Less capital on the sidelines means less support for the market.
“Nobody's buying right now. I don't... Think we're about to see margin calls... This is the first time since 2022 that we haven't seen retail come in and buy the dip.”at 14:41
Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors
This is a record degrossing market, so the selling is a positioning flush rather than fundamentals.
Link says the market has been degrossing for weeks. Morgan Stanley's prime brokerage saw record degrossing two weeks ago, and this selloff looks like another record. She treats the decline as a deleveraging event, with Anthropic's trading as a symptom rather than a fundamental verdict.
“I think this is just a degrossing day. ... it has been a degrossing market for the last couple of weeks. Morgan Stanley's prime brokerage desk saw record degrossing.”at 23:48
Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth Planning
VIX near 31 is attractive; a spike toward 70 would signal capitulation to buy.
Simpson watches the VIX for capitulation. He says a move to 70 would signal the market is ready for the trucks to buy, while the current level in the low 30s is still very attractive relative to the base that has been established. He says options can be used to generate hedging income above 30.
“If we see that go to 70, then you can probably, you know, put back the back the truck up... 31 and change. It's still very attractive off of the base that we've had.”at 25:21
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors
The Fed is being too hawkish, and combined with unknowns that is what the market dislikes.
Link says the market is selling off because of a mix of unknowns and a hawkish Fed. She argues the Fed should not be this hawkish given falling oil and moderating inflation, though she says she will get into that later.
“The unknowns plus a hawkish fed is what the market does not like. ... The fed should not nearly be this hawkish, but we can get into that.”at 2:23
Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth Planning
A 50bp December Fed hike would extend damage, while a 25bp hike would let markets celebrate.
Simpson notes that a Fed official said the Fed was too easy and needed a 50-basis-point hike. He says if the Fed delivers 50bp in December the damage is far from over. He also thinks the 50bp threshold may be overstated, since a 25bp hike would let markets say it could have been worse.
“But if the Fed does give us a 50 rate hike in December, I think that the damage is far from over... So if we only get a 25 basis point rate hike, then the market can celebrate a little bit.”at 10:44
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors
The blue wave selloff isn't the death of the AI trade; data center spending stays in the trillions through 2030.
Link argues the recent sell-off, which she attributes to fears that data centers are dead, is overdone. She concedes spending could slow or be haircut, so instead of the $7 trillion once discussed it might be $3-4 trillion or $2-3 trillion by 2030, but she stresses that is still trillions. She says power is still scarce and the AI buildout is far from finished.
“I do not think the blue wave is the death of the AI trade. Maybe we slow... Maybe we spend 3 or 4,000,000,000,000. Maybe it's 2 or 3,000,000,000,000, but you're still talking about trillions.”at 3:53
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase Trust
AI capex far exceeds revenue, with rising costs and depreciation; years before growth catches up.
Raskin says AI spending in the trillions still exceeds revenue, even when revenue is annualized. Data centers are more expensive to build as the cost of capital rises and subsidies are required. She expects it will be years before growth equals capital spending, and depreciation will rise sharply. She cites Howard Marks' memo on the uncertainty.
“You're spending trillions... you're still spending more than revenues coming in the door... it's going to be years before, in my opinion, before growth actually equals the capital spending. You know, depreciation numbers are gonna go way up.”at 6:08
US inflation
Where everyone stands on US inflation
Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors
Inflation is cooling as oil falls from its peak, so the Fed's hawkishness makes little sense.
Link points to oil prices down 27% from their peak, with WTI falling from $113. She says that is coming down, home prices are moderating rather than falling, and other parts of inflation are easing. She adds that AI will be a productivity enhancer over time, and questions why the Fed is so hawkish right now.
“[Oil prices are down 27%] from the peak. WTI was a 113. So it's like, that's coming down. I mean, home prices are not coming down, but they're moderating.”at 11:36
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase Trust
Oil price declines won't show up in core inflation until about mid-2027, with a January-February seasonal bump.
Raskin says small businesses are raising prices and inflation is seeping in more broadly than before. Oil's decline will pass through eventually, but January and February have seasonal resets. Higher oil prices are still in the year-earlier comparisons through November and December, so the drop will not show in core inflation until potentially mid-2027.
“you're seeing more small businesses say, I'm going to raise prices... it looks like it's going to be potentially mid twenty twenty seven when you finally sort of see these oil prices really being reflected in the inflation numbers”at 12:10
AI pricing & unit economics
Where everyone stands on AI pricing & unit economics
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase Trust
OpenAI's growth is slowing just as token prices fall, which undermines the AI business model.
Raskin asks whether cost per token falls faster than growth rises and says the answer is unknown. She cites OpenAI, where growth is slowing sharply as token prices decline. She sees this as a key overhang that will take time to resolve.
“If you look at both OpenAI, growth is slowing pretty dramatically just as the token prices are coming down.”at 6:48
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase Trust
The 10-year yield stuck near 5% while stocks fall means cost of capital isn't easing, so more downside.
Raskin says the 10-year yield is staying around 5% even as the Nasdaq turns negative, which is worrying. If cost of capital is not falling in line with the stock decline, that is a sign there could be more to fall. She says the equity gains of recent years make a pullback normal but the bond market is the key concern.
“you're seeing the ten year sort of stuck around five as the Nasdaq goes negative for the year... your cost of capital is not coming down commensurate with your decline in the stock.”at 8:17
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors
A 10% pullback won't draw value buyers; many stocks must fall further before value investors step in.
Link says a 10% pullback does not signal a time to buy, because the strong gains of these stocks still look large. Some names are down 30-50% from their highs but not yet cheap enough for value investors. She says the handoff from growth to value buyers usually takes a long time and is not pretty.
“a 10% pullback to me doesn't say, like, okay. You have to step in and buy. ... they're not low enough that value investors are gonna stop it.”at 8:58
US consumer
Where everyone stands on US consumer
Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors
Discretionary consumer stocks set up well as rates and oil fall; the consumer is still resilient.
Link says if rates and oil are coming down, discretionary stocks set up well. She cites good retail sales numbers this week and says the consumer still has a job. She points to beaten-down names like Starbucks and Estee Lauder as places to look for quality.
“Because I think if rates are coming down and oil's coming down, discretionary kinda sets up pretty well. The consumer has stayed pretty resilient with good decent retail sales numbers this week.”at 16:52
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase Trust
Mag Seven earnings may be overstated by pulled-forward capex, risking a housing-style GFC crash.
Raskin says some names look cheap but may be over-earning. Big capex spending may be pulling forward costs that should be spread over several years. She compares this to the GFC, when housing stocks never looked expensive but were over-earning and still crashed. Banks fell similarly.
“For some of the names, they're very low... are they over earning? And the answer is probably yes... They're well over earning, and then... They still crashed on the banks similarly.”at 21:33
Frontier AI labs & model race
Where everyone stands on Frontier AI labs & model race
Amy Raskin · Chevy Chase Trust
AI is not a natural monopoly; big tech advantages create consumer value but little corporate value.
Raskin contrasts the Mag Seven's natural monopolies with AI, which she says lacks a natural monopoly. The back-and-forth between OpenAI and Anthropic shows that. Big technological advantages create value for consumers but often do not create corporate value, which is a reason to doubt AI investment returns.
“AI to me is very different. It's not a natural monopoly... Often, [big technological advantages] create a lot of value for consumers. Often, they don't create a lot of corporate value.”at 22:47
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- Anthropic149 speakers · 266 bullish, 131 bearish calls
- Alphabet75 speakers · 67 bullish, 51 bearish calls
- Meta Platforms67 speakers · 62 bullish, 34 bearish calls
- Amazon.com45 speakers · 65 bullish, 8 bearish calls
- Palo Alto Networks9 speakers · 8 bullish, 1 bearish calls
- CrowdStrike Holdings6 speakers · 9 bullish, 1 bearish calls
- Quanta Services5 speakers · 6 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- UnitedHealth Group4 speakers · 2 bullish, 2 bearish calls
- Texas Instruments3 speakers · 3 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Target2 speakers · 2 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Verizon Communications2 speakers · 0 bullish, 3 bearish calls
- Zscaler1 speaker · 2 bullish, 0 bearish calls
Topics
- 10-year yield
- AI IPO investability
- AI capex vs revenue
- Amazon store and cloud
- IPO window
- Mag Seven earnings quality
- Medicare Advantage ruling
- VIX capitulation signal
- business model
- commercial growth
- competitive moats
- consumer resilience
- cybersecurity earnings
- cybersecurity market size
- cybersecurity stock valuation
- data center capex
- deleveraging
- earnings and free cash flow
- grid buildout
- hawkish stance
- hyperscaler capex
- inflation outlook
- investor positioning
- oil pass-through to inflation
- rate hike size
- retail dip-buying
- retail turnaround
- search dominance
- telecom valuation and dividend
- token price declines
- value buyers and the pullback
More from CNBC Halftime Report
- Anthropic IPO Shakes AI Trade and Market Sentiment · November 19, 2026
- NVIDIA Overhang, Anthropic IPO Demand and AI Trade Fallout · November 18, 2026
- Amazon CEO Andy Jassy on AI Buildout, Anthropic IPO and NVIDIA Risk · November 17, 2026
- Brad Gerstner on NVIDIA, Anthropic IPO and the AI Trade · November 16, 2026
- NVIDIA Fallout, Chip Volatility and the Case for 60/40 · November 13, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus