CNBC Halftime Report · · 49 min

NVIDIA Fallout, Chip Volatility and the Case for 60/40

With Jason Snipe, Jim Lebenthal, Kevin Simpson, Liz Thomas

Summary

CNBC Halftime Report panelists Jim Lebenthal, Jason Snipe, Kevin Simpson and Liz Thomas dissected the sell-off in Nvidia, which is roughly 20-30% off its highs amid export-control concerns over China and Southeast Asian shipments, national-security scrutiny and CEO-succession headlines. Lebenthal and Snipe argued the fundamentals (forward multiple near 10x, strong margins, projected free cash flow above $300 billion) make the selloff an opportunity, with Lebenthal adding to his position and expecting capital-markets fundraising by AI labs such as Anthropic to flow into chip purchases. Thomas countered that semiconductors will stay range-bound without near-term catalysts, that a capex slowdown would be read negatively, and that the economy has become heavily dependent on AI capex, while urging a more defensive macro stance into 2027 amid sticky inflation and a hawkish Fed. The episode closed with stock picks (Caterpillar, Apple, Robinhood, Costco, Amazon, eBay, Palo Alto Networks, AutoZone) and Thomas's case for a 60/40 portfolio using Treasuries at a 5.13% 10-year yield, with commodities as a stagflation hedge.

Key takeaways

  • Jim Lebenthal (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia trades ~10x earnings with massive free cash flow; he's a long-term bull, expects near-term volatility.
  • Jason Snipe (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia trades at 10x forward with 70%+ margins after a sell-off; a stock he wants to lean into.
  • Kevin Simpson (uncertain on NVIDIA): Sold half of Nvidia on a price-based stop despite strong fundamentals; more CEO-related news likely.
  • Kevin Simpson (bullish on Caterpillar): Caterpillar is a long-term buy: power needs persist even if data center build-out slows.
  • Liz Thomas on US consumer: Not bullish on consumer names until inflation and oil prices fall; consumer sentiment is very weak.

What was said, by company and theme

28 views from 4 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 140 speakers in other episodes, 128 bullish and 96 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • Jim Lebenthal · Cerity PartnersBullish

    Nvidia trades ~10x earnings with massive free cash flow; he's a long-term bull, expects near-term volatility.

    Lebenthal sees a tug of war between bulls and bears over the next weeks, but argues the fundamentals are strong: a strong order book and projected growth, a forward multiple around 10, and over $300 billion of free cash flow expected in the coming twelve months. He acknowledges export controls will likely curtail the China business, which he puts at about 11% of revenue, but argues it won't go to zero, so the bear case is overstated. The stock is off about 30% from its high, which he says prices in much of the bad news. He is adding new money and holding his position, and expects volatility over the next couple of weeks as CEO-succession and investigation headlines play out.

    “I'm not selling it here. New money that comes into account, I am putting into Nvidia.”at 2:38
  • Jim Lebenthal · Cerity PartnersBullish

    Anthropic's roughly $60-80B capital raise will flow through to Nvidia and other chipmakers.

    Lebenthal expects the capital markets activity coming up next week with Anthropic, a raise of 60 to 80 billion, to flow through to Nvidia and other chip manufacturers. He links this to his argument that the hyperscalers' financing needs are being met through capital markets, so the money raised by AI labs ends up as chip purchases. This is why he thinks the next couple of weeks will be volatile in the stock but that fundamental demand is intact.

    “all of this that comes in from financing, and I'm talking about capital markets coming up next week with Anthropic, 60 to 80,000,000,000, is going to flow through to the likes of NVIDIA and the other chip manufacturers.”at 4:36
  • Jason Snipe · Odyssey Capital AdvisorsBullish

    Nvidia trades at 10x forward with 70%+ margins after a sell-off; a stock he wants to lean into.

    Snipe acknowledges a mountain of tactical headwinds, mainly export-control concerns about where advanced chips shipped to Malaysia and Vietnam end up, and national-security scrutiny. He argues the fundamentals are strong: revenue of roughly the quarter's guidance, 70%-plus margins, and a forward multiple around 10x. He says if you removed the name and looked at a stock like this, you would want to lean in. The stock is down close to 20% this month, so he sees a potential opportunity with more volatility to come as testimony and the story evolve.

    “trading at 10 times forward. I mean, if if you remove the name and looked at a stock like that, you're like, hey. This is something I wanna lean into.”at 7:05
  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningUncertain

    Sold half of Nvidia on a price-based stop despite strong fundamentals; more CEO-related news likely.

    Simpson says the fundamental case is accurate, but this is not a blind ticker; there is more to the story and more to come, since where there's smoke there is fire. His firm sold half its position on pure price action, following its rule based on the entry point. The position was bought near 200 and sold in the 160s. The firm kept half, and would probably lose the rest if the price keeps falling. The Rene Haas news might give some stability, which he would like to see.

    “Where there's smoke, there is fire. And yesterday, we sold, Frank, half of our position on pure price action alone.”at 8:21

Caterpillar

Across the shows: 6 speakers in other episodes, 6 bullish and 5 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Caterpillar

  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish

    Caterpillar is a long-term buy: power needs persist even if data center build-out slows.

    Simpson's firm looked at Caterpillar as an adjacent trade to AI. The stock moved too far too fast but has come down dramatically, so they added to a name they have owned for over a decade. It is not just an AI trade: even if data centers slow down a bit, the economy will still need power, and Caterpillar generates that power. It also has mining and industrial exposure. The stock has risen about 6.5% over the last week but is still down about 1.5% today.

    “even if you think about data centers slowing down a little bit, we're still gonna need power. We're still gonna need this company to generate that power... I think this is a great long term investment.”at 30:25
  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish

    Caterpillar is a buy: AI needs power, and the stock is down today.

    Simpson's final trade is Caterpillar. He argues AI needs more than chips and data center ships, and that it needs power. That makes power equipment a beneficiary of AI buildout. He sees today's drop in the stock as an opportunity.

    “I like Caterpillar. AI needs more than ships. They need power, and it's down today.”at 47:11

Arista Networks

Across the shows: 3 speakers in other episodes, 3 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • Jason Snipe · Odyssey Capital AdvisorsUncertain

    Arista benefits from Nvidia's fallout, but its revenue is too concentrated in Microsoft and Meta.

    Snipe argues networking is a key part of the AI infrastructure ecosystem and that customers may look for optionality beyond Nvidia's full stack, which he says is tied together through NVLink, InfiniBand and Spectrum-X. Arista is an independent player and a huge beneficiary of any move away from Nvidia chips. However, he has a concern about Arista's revenue, which is concentrated: Microsoft makes up 26% of revenue and Meta 16%.

    “names like Arista Networks are huge beneficiaries of this play. I think the concern sometimes with Arista for me personally is the revenue... So Microsoft is 26% of their revenue. Meta is 16% of their revenue.”at 16:55

Broadcom

Across the shows: 14 speakers in other episodes, 14 bullish and 6 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Broadcom

  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish

    AI demand for Broadcom is intact; the question is who pays, and a near-$400 target looks low.

    Simpson says Broadcom lowered its price target for economic reasons rather than because of demand. The challenge is who is going to pay for all this AI demand, not whether the demand exists. He thinks the price target may be a little bit low at just shy of 400. His firm owns Broadcom, and there will be beneficiaries of the Nvidia fallout, but competition is coming from other companies beyond just a handful of names.

    “Broadcom specifically, I think they lowered their price target for economic reasons. Their challenge is who's gonna be there to pay for all of this AI demand. They're not questioning the demand, but I think their price target may be a little bit low at just shy of 400.”at 17:47

Cisco Systems

Across the shows: 7 speakers in other episodes, 6 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Cisco Systems

  • Jim Lebenthal · Cerity PartnersBullish

    Cisco deserves a high-teens multiple, not mid-to-high twenties; a cheap way to play data centers.

    Cisco reported a good earnings report, but the stock fell because investors wanted a stronger guide up. Lebenthal says the market is wrong to value it as a mid-to-high twenties multiple stock; it is a high-teens stock that usually beats earnings by a few pennies rather than shooting the lights out. He has held it since 2015 and it outperforms the S&P 500 without much drama over time. He argues the fundamentals and demand are strong, and that if the data center build-out does not come to a crashing halt, this is a very cheap way to play it.

    “I think where the market gets this stock wrong is they think that this is supposed to be a mid twenties to high twenties multiple stock. It's not. It's supposed to be a high teen stock.”at 23:04

Apple

Across the shows: 51 speakers in other episodes, 66 bullish and 42 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Apple

  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish

    Apple's execution is outstanding; a face-ID flip phone could be a game changer; he's not cutting at 37x.

    Simpson argues the best trade is a company not making the most noise. Apple has been reducing capex while executing perfectly. His firm has a full allocation and believes in this company. He sees valuation as the only concern, since a 37 multiple is historically high for Apple, but they are not cutting. He thinks the next version of the foldable flip phone, which could use face recognition instead of a thumbprint, will be a game changer.

    “The execution is outstanding... We believe in this, company and and have for a very long time. I think the flip phone, probably the next version, they can make it work with the face instead of the thumbprint, will be a game changer.”at 24:58

Palo Alto Networks

Across the shows: 4 speakers in other episodes, 3 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Palo Alto Networks

  • Jason Snipe · Odyssey Capital AdvisorsBullish

    Palo Alto is a leading AI-era cybersecurity name; identity security acquisitions are accretive, target $380.

    Snipe supports the KeyBank upgrade to overweight. The stock has been a rocket ship most of the year but is down around 20% in the last month. He says its focus on identity security will be extremely accretive going forward, and it spent $30 billion on acquisitions this year, so execution is needed. He argues that as AI grows, cybersecurity grows with it and Palo Alto is one of the leaders, so there is a long runway. The price target of about 18% upside is the number cited.

    “Their focus has really been in ID security. I think that's gonna be extremely accretive for the stock going forward.”at 31:11

Robinhood Markets

Across the shows: 5 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 3 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Robinhood Markets

  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningBullish

    Robinhood can return to triple digits from $77 as it matures from trading app to wealth firm.

    Simpson calls Robinhood a generational fintech company that goes through ebbs and flows. It needs more assets to stay on the platform, not just more people trading, so it is trying to mature from online trading into a true fintech wealth planning firm. The stock is attractive at its current price. His firm sells calls against it to harvest volatility, and at $77 he expects it to get back to triple digits.

    “Remember, we sell calls against this, so we really harvest the volatility... At $77, I think you'll see it get back to triple digits.”at 32:36

Apollo Global Management

Across the shows: 4 speakers in other episodes, 3 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Apollo Global Management

  • Jim Lebenthal · Cerity PartnersBullish

    Apollo's private credit fears are overblown; he likes the stock and expects the data center financing concern to pass.

    Lebenthal says Apollo has been laboring under two clouds all year: private credit and its financing of data centers. He thinks the data center financing worry will eventually pass. On private credit, he never thought it was as big an issue as the market made it out to be, and he says the evidence is showing that. He says he really likes Apollo, and he owns it.

    “I really like Apollo... I think the data center thing will eventually pass, the concerns about it that is. And on private credit, I never did think that was as big an issue as it was made out to be.”at 32:50

The Home Depot

Across the shows: 5 speakers in other episodes, 7 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on The Home Depot

  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningUncertain

    Home Depot needs rate cuts or a new spending super cycle; expects little from earnings but holds long term.

    The stock has rallied roughly 18 to 20 percent over the past month, which leaves little room for enthusiasm. Simpson says the business needs a reduction in interest rates or a new super cycle of home spending, like the one during COVID. He expects that cycle to return in the next year or two, with spending on floors, wall coverings and appliances. He is not expecting much from this earnings report, but says he owns the stock for the long term.

    “I don't think we can have any enthusiasm about Home Depot. ... What we really need is a reduction in interest rates or a new super cycle spend. ... In the next year or two, I think we'll see it again.”at 39:11

Walmart

Across the shows: 19 speakers in other episodes, 17 bullish and 4 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Walmart

  • Kevin Simpson · Capital Wealth PlanningNeutral

    Walmart is a strong business for high and low-end shoppers, but multiples make chasing the stock risky.

    The stock has moved a lot, as Home Depot has, and Simpson does not want to chase it at current multiples, which are high across the group. He still sees Walmart as a company that benefits from both high-end and low-end consumers heading into the holiday season. He points to growing online sales and an incredible grocery business, and says Walmart has separated itself over the past three years as the go-to retailer.

    “I don't know that you wanna chase it here from a multiples perspective. ... But, really, it's a company that benefits from the high end consumer, the low end consumer.”at 39:56

AutoZone

Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 1 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • Jason Snipe · Odyssey Capital AdvisorsBullish

    AutoZone's commercial sales expansion is the opportunity, despite the stock being down about 3% this year.

    AutoZone is down about 3% this year. Part of the reason is that capital spending on megastores is starting to grow in Latin America. Snipe is more excited about the company's push into commercial sales, where it is starting to expand beyond its retail business. He sees that as a going-forward opportunity, and Snipe owns the stock.

    “But what I'm excited about is what they're doing in commercial sales. They're really starting to expand there away from retail.”at 40:35

Costco Wholesale

Across the shows: 5 speakers in other episodes, 5 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Costco Wholesale

  • Jason Snipe · Odyssey Capital AdvisorsBullish

    Costco is an earnings compounder: stock up 28%, a $4B buyback, and a 90% renewal rate.

    Snipe calls Costco an earnings compounder for his portfolio, with the stock up 28%. The company has just authorized a $4 billion buyback. It also has a 90% membership renewal rate. Holland adds that the stock stays relevant for value-conscious shoppers while inflation remains high. Snipe owns the stock.

    “This one's been a nice one. It's kind of an earnings compounder for us, up 28%. ... They just authorized a $4,000,000,000 buyback, 90% renewal rate,”at 41:02

Amazon.com

Across the shows: 50 speakers in other episodes, 66 bullish and 10 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Amazon.com

  • Jason Snipe · Odyssey Capital AdvisorsBullish

    Amazon is a buy on AWS growth of 39%.

    Snipe's final trade is Amazon, based on AWS growing 39%. That is a strong growth rate for the cloud business, which is the main case he makes for the stock. He does not state other reasons.

    “Amazon, AWS, 39% growth.”at 47:17

eBay

  • Jim Lebenthal · Cerity PartnersBullish

    eBay is a buy: the stock wants to go higher and has great fundamentals.

    Lebenthal's final trade is eBay. He points to the stock's strong run over the past year and over the past month as evidence it wants to go higher. He adds that it has great fundamentals, though he gives no specifics.

    “I'll tell you what's not punkish is eBay. I mean, look at this stock over the last year. Look at it over the last month. This is a stock that wants to go higher. It's got great fundamentals.”at 47:18

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Jim Lebenthal · Cerity Partners

    A slower data center build-out is healthy: it lets hyperscaler cash flows catch up with capex.

    Lebenthal argues that hyperscalers reported they will stick with their capex plans, and that the market's negative tone about a slowdown in the data center build-out is misplaced. He is strongly of the opinion that slowing the build-out is a good thing because it lets hyperscaler cash flows catch up with capital expenditure plans, which reduces the pressure on financing in capital markets. He sees the current peak-spending worries after the midterm election as a positive, since a bubble that inflates quickly would be a threat to pop, and a build-out spread over many years at a more sustainable pace is better.

    “I'm strongly of the opinion that slowing the data center build out is a good thing, that it allows cash flows from those hyperscalers to catch up with their capital expenditure plans, taking pressure off of financing in the capital markets.”at 4:18
  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    A hyperscaler capex slowdown would be read negatively; capex props up GDP more than the Internet boom did.

    Thomas disagrees that a capex slowdown would be viewed positively. She thinks the market would view it negatively even if it came from regulation, because it would mean the government limiting the growth of companies and capex. The market is already anticipating this, which is why the AI industry has been punkish for the last few weeks. Capex has been built into GDP numbers to a level not seen in a very long time, higher even than during the Internet boom, so the economy is heavily dependent on it.

    “That CapEx has baked into GDP numbers to a level that we haven't seen in a very long time, if ever, levels that are higher than even what we saw in the Internet boom.”at 21:46

AI chips & semiconductors

Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors

  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    Chip stocks won't regain summer highs soon; no near-term catalyst for a rebound.

    Thomas says the semiconductor overhang will remain for a while, and that the NVIDIA headlines exacerbate an existing trend, since semiconductors and the AI trade were already under pressure. Even though demand is strong and the fundamentals are still very strong, she does not think the SMH or SOX will reclaim their summer highs anytime soon. She does not see a near-term or even medium-term catalyst to bring them back, and sees more forces keeping the sector range-bound. She expects the trade to rely on fundamentals, with 2027 data center build-out capacity and regulation key questions.

    “I don't know that we're reclaiming those highs anytime soon. I don't see a catalyst for a huge bounce back up to those highs.”at 20:12

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    2027 will be a challenging transition year: tighter policy, AI leadership shifts and late-cycle hot inflation.

    Thomas notes the twelve months following a midterm election are usually quite positive for the market, but the third year of a presidential cycle is usually tough on technology. She thinks 2027 will be a year of transition and a challenging one because the economy is transitioning in several ways: to tighter monetary policy, perhaps to new AI leadership, and to a later part of the economic cycle with hot inflation that the Fed will be trying to control. Investors should watch for indicators and adjust their investments accordingly.

    “So if I look ahead to 2027, I think it ends up being a year of transition.”at 26:47

US rates & the Fed

Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed

  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    The Fed has much more work to do on inflation, given PPI at a four-year high.

    Thomas cites the expected release of PPI, which is set to hit its highest level in four years. She reads that as evidence that the Federal Reserve still has a lot of work to do to bring inflation down. Inflation is weighing on consumer and market sentiment in her view.

    “To your point, I believe highest PPI in four years also goes to be out saying the Fed has a lot more work to do when it comes to inflation.”at 41:39

US consumer

Where everyone stands on US consumer

  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    Not bullish on consumer names until inflation and oil prices fall; consumer sentiment is very weak.

    Consumer sentiment is very weak, so Thomas does not see much more upside for consumer names, especially discretionary ones. She expects the consumer to keep grudgingly spending but not to increase spending. She does not expect that to change until inflation is solved, inflation expectations come under control, and oil prices come down. She says value-focused stores can still do well, since shoppers are trying to save money.

    “I am not bullish on a lot of consumer names. I think that until inflation really gets solved and until people feel like inflation expectations are better under control, I don't see a ton more upside for a lot of these names, particularly in the discretionary space.”at 41:39

US Treasuries & yields

Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields

  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    Higher bond yields give Treasuries an alternative to equities and make a 60/40 portfolio likely to do better.

    Bond yields have revived, so Treasuries now offer an alternative to some equity exposure. Thomas has used the 10-year Treasury as her final trade on the show several times and sees a decent chance a 60/40 portfolio does better. She still likes Treasuries. She is taking the 10-year at a 5.13 level, after previously noting a 5.24 level. She cautions that the 60% equity sleeve needs to be more diversified.

    “I certainly think there's been a revival in bond yields, and there is now an alternative to some equity exposure.”at 45:36

Commodities (broad)

Where everyone stands on Commodities (broad)

  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    Add commodities or gold to a 60/40 portfolio, since stagflation would hurt a 60/40 badly.

    Thomas argues that if the economy heads into stagflation, a 60/40 portfolio is really going to struggle. Commodities or gold can help the portfolio struggle less. She is making the case for commodities as a diversifier that can cushion a 60/40 portfolio in an inflationary, slowing economy.

    “make sure that you throw into the mix something like commodities or even gold. Because if we are heading into a stagflationary environment, 6040 is really gonna struggle.”at 45:36

Credit markets

Where everyone stands on Credit markets

  • Liz Thomas · SoFi

    Be cautious with large investment-grade and high-yield credit allocations in a 60/40 portfolio.

    In the 40% bond sleeve, Thomas says investors should not hold too much investment-grade credit, which may be growing and becoming more of a supply on the market. She also says high-yield credit will have a high correlation with equities. That makes it a weak diversifier, and she reserves Treasuries as the better bond holding.

    “I would also caution investors to not have too much exposure to things like investment grade credit that perhaps is growing and becoming more of a supply on the market and high yield credit that's just gonna have a high correlation with equities.”at 45:36

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA140 speakers · 128 bullish, 96 bearish calls
  • Apple51 speakers · 66 bullish, 42 bearish calls
  • Amazon.com50 speakers · 66 bullish, 10 bearish calls
  • Walmart19 speakers · 17 bullish, 4 bearish calls
  • Broadcom14 speakers · 14 bullish, 6 bearish calls
  • Cisco Systems7 speakers · 6 bullish, 1 bearish calls
  • Caterpillar6 speakers · 6 bullish, 5 bearish calls
  • Costco Wholesale5 speakers · 5 bullish, 0 bearish calls
  • Robinhood Markets5 speakers · 2 bullish, 3 bearish calls
  • The Home Depot5 speakers · 7 bullish, 1 bearish calls
  • Apollo Global Management4 speakers · 3 bullish, 1 bearish calls
  • Palo Alto Networks4 speakers · 3 bullish, 1 bearish calls
  • Arista Networks3 speakers · 3 bullish, 0 bearish calls
  • AutoZone2 speakers · 1 bullish, 1 bearish calls

Topics

  • 2027 market outlook
  • AI chip demand funding
  • AI lab capital raises
  • Cisco valuation multiple
  • Fed policy on inflation
  • Nvidia position and risk
  • Treasury yields and 60/40 portfolios
  • chip sector recovery
  • chip stock valuation
  • commercial sales growth
  • commodities as stagflation hedge
  • consumer spending outlook
  • data center capex
  • e-commerce stock momentum
  • earnings compounding and buybacks
  • home improvement demand
  • hyperscaler cloud growth
  • iPhone product cycle
  • identity security acquisitions
  • investment-grade and high-yield exposure
  • networking customer concentration
  • power equipment demand for AI
  • power generation demand
  • private credit risk
  • retail brokerage wealth transition
  • retail valuation

More from CNBC Halftime Report

All CNBC Halftime Report episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus