CNBC Closing Bell · · 48 min
AI Sell-Off Hits Nvidia as China Chip Curbs Tighten
With Arjun Bhatia, Brad Gerstner, Donald Trump, John San Marco, Leland Miller, Ron Temple, Seema Mody
Summary
Ron Temple argues the AI-led sell-off, with the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index down about 35% from its June peak, is a necessary recalibration of excessive optimism rather than a finished correction, while the S&P 500 trades at about 17.7x forward earnings. He warns of broadening inflation, citing energy and AI capex spreading into rents, and expects the Fed to hike at least twice more, with mortgage rates near 7.1% hitting consumers more than AI investment. Leland Miller says China's chronic compute shortfall makes US export controls a direct brake on its AI race, and he calls Nvidia's smuggling and remote-access exposure a live risk while noting Commerce's new remote-access rule; Arjun Bhatia, meanwhile, makes a bullish case for Anthropic at roughly 7-8x 2027 revenue, and Mike Santoli sees Nvidia at about 11x forward earnings as a conditional buy if the AI ecosystem is intact. John San Marco expects consumer discretionary retrenchment as tax tailwinds fade and gas costs persist, though he remains bullish on Costco and TJX.
Key takeaways
- Ron Temple on US stock market outlook: US market looks more attractive: forward P/E below long-run averages, earnings growth above 25%, and tech now cheaper than the broad market.
- Arjun Bhatia (bullish on Anthropic): A $1.5 trillion Anthropic IPO valuation is attractive at 7-8x forward revenue given its growth.
- Leland Miller (bearish on NVIDIA): Revelations of Nvidia-linked chip smuggling and diversion to China are horrendous and getting worse.
- John San Marco (bullish on Costco Wholesale): Costco is expensive but a top pick, with spectacular earnings quality and inflation protection.
- Michael Santoli (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's low forward multiple gives a chance to reload if its ecosystem is not impaired.
What was said, by company and theme
20 views from 5 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Anthropic
Across the shows: 122 speakers in other episodes, 180 bullish and 91 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Anthropic
Arjun Bhatia · William BlairBullish
A $1.5 trillion Anthropic IPO valuation is attractive at 7-8x forward revenue given its growth.
Bhatia says the $1.5 trillion valuation looks large for a first IPO. But Anthropic is growing about 150% on an $80 billion ARR base, so the forward multiple is 7-8x 2027 revenue. That is a discount to SpaceX at 12x and Microsoft at 10x, and well below Snowflake, Palantir and CrowdStrike. Anthropic has no direct comparable, and the multiple falls to about 4-5x 2028 revenue, but growth is expected to slow only gradually. He thinks it remains a far faster grower than the typical peer at about 20%.
“But when you actually look at the revenue growth, you look at the scale that this business has already reached, it's actually quite an attractive multiple. You know, on a forward basis, using our 2027 estimates, [Anthropic would] be only between seven to eight times forward revenue.”at 19:50
Arjun Bhatia · William BlairBullish
Anthropic can meet its $900B compute commitments but remains about $1.5T short of compute needed by 2035.
Bhatia's model has Anthropic reaching $1 trillion in revenue by 2035. That would require about $2.5 trillion in cumulative compute, leaving it roughly $1.5 trillion short of the compute it needs on his estimates. He still thinks Anthropic should have no trouble meeting its roughly $900 billion in existing compute commitments. In the context of a potential trillion-dollar revenue business, he says those commitments are not that much.
“they're gonna need 2,500,000,000,000 in cumulative compute over that time. And so they're gonna be 1,500,000,000,000 short by our estimates, and I think they should have no trouble hitting their $900,000,000,000 in compute commitments.”at 23:16
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 153 speakers in other episodes, 146 bullish and 119 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Leland Miller · China Beige BookBearish
Revelations of Nvidia-linked chip smuggling and diversion to China are horrendous and getting worse.
Miller says the revelations about Nvidia are horrendous and keep getting worse. He cites documented problems: a huge smuggling problem, a huge chip diversion problem, and a remote access problem that lets Chinese firms use chips that are banned from export. He says an investigation is underway into whether the fault lies with the company or the government, and that these holes can now be plugged. The argument is that export-control exposure is a live risk for Nvidia.
“the revelations that have been coming out about Nvidia are horrendous. And there's more to come. Seem to be getting worse every day. So, right now we know there's a huge smuggling problem. It's documented.”at 37:25
Michael Santoli · CNBCBullish
Nvidia's low forward multiple gives a chance to reload if its ecosystem is not impaired.
Santoli says Nvidia trades around 11 times forward earnings. He argues the market has already discounted the next four quarters of reported numbers and does not want to pay up for them. The question is no longer the guidance but whether the ecosystem is impaired. If it is not, the low multiple gives investors a chance to add the stock. He frames this as a conditional bullish case that depends on the health of the AI ecosystem.
“the market has already said, you know, we do not really trust or don't want to pay up for what's on paper right now over the next four quarters. It's much more about is the ecosystem impaired or not. And if it's not, the market is really giving you a chance to kind of reload”at 46:38
Costco Wholesale
Across the shows: 6 speakers in other episodes, 6 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Costco Wholesale
John San Marco · Neuberger BermanBullish
Costco is expensive but a top pick, with spectacular earnings quality and inflation protection.
San Marco concedes Costco is dearly valued, but he says the valuation reflects a wonderful, well-executed business that is not controversial. He argues Costco is well hedged against inflation. Its high fixed-cost structure means earnings flow through when prices rise, and it passes price increases through more slowly than competitors. He says Costco has widened its gap on retail pricing and on labour and talent pay versus the market, so its earnings quality is spectacular. He expects it to keep reinvesting rather than harvest those earnings.
“You get what you pay for. It's a dearly valued stock... perhaps what folks are missing is the earnings quality at Costco is just spectacular. I mean, they've widened the gap.”at 41:34
The TJX Companies
Across the shows: 3 speakers in other episodes, 1 bullish and 2 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on The TJX Companies
John San Marco · Neuberger BermanBullish
TJX's stumble is a buy opportunity as merchandise issues are fixed and 2027 comparisons ease.
San Marco says TJX, which had long been considered bulletproof, has stumbled. He argues this is an opportunity to buy on weakness, which TJX offers about once a decade. The merchandise problems from the second quarter have been fixed, and traffic is starting to tick up. Product availability for opportunistic buys should be very good. He expects the recovery to be somewhat slower than he would have forecast three months ago, but he expects the focus to shift to 2027 and its easy comparisons once results are out.
“In about once a decade, TJX gives shareholders an opportunity to buy the stock on a stumble, and I think this is that opportunity.”at 42:35
US–China AI & chip race
Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race
Ron Temple · Lazard
Chip-security and AI export provisions likely to enter the NDAA and become law, restricting overseas chip sales.
Four provisions are in play: the Chip Security Act, the Remote Access Security Act, the MATCH Act, and the AI Overwatch Act. They were a toss-up for inclusion in the National Defense Authorization Act. Lazard Geopolitical Advisory now thinks they are likely to be included and signed into law. Temple says this matters for the opportunity set for overseas chip sales, and that the market needs to watch Washington closely.
“Now Lazard Geopolitical Advisory thinks those are likely to be included in the NDAA, and that's likely to be signed into law by the President.”at 7:39
Leland Miller · China Beige Book
US chip export curbs will absolutely slow China's AI race, since domestic supply cannot meet demand.
Miller says China's demand for compute is enormous and its supply is short. Even with domestic chipmakers such as Huawei producing all they can under government mandate and market incentives, output is nowhere near what China needs to compete with US frontier labs. He argues China has been stacking US advanced compute on top of its own capacity. Cutting off those chips therefore slows China down directly in the AI race.
“It absolutely will. I think the math that we need to be looking at here is simple supply and demand. China has an enormous demand... They have enormous demand for compute and enormous shortage of supply.”at 36:22
Leland Miller · China Beige Book
Commerce's new rule limiting remote access to chips is a welcome step to close export-control holes.
Miller argues that the documented smuggling, chip diversion and remote access problems are all solvable because the holes can be plugged. He says it is very encouraging that Commerce has stepped in with a rule limiting remote access to chips. The view is that tighter export rules are needed, while the investigation into who is culpable is still pending.
“we do know one thing. We can plug those holes. And so it's very, very, encouraging to see commerce step in this morning with a very important rule about limiting, remote access.”at 37:38
Michael Santoli · CNBC
Several export-control bills in Congress have a strong chance of passing after the chip-diversion revelations.
Santoli says Congress has a number of export-control bills, some of them significant, that look likely to pass. He reads the crisis as the point at which the US government is finally stepping up. He expects legislation to follow the Commerce action, although he gives no timeline.
“Congress is doing, a number of export control bills through your very big and important ones that look like, they they have a lot of, very strong chance of of getting through.”at 38:16
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Michael Santoli · CNBC
Tech is oversold and hedge funds have cut positioning, but the market has not yet responded to these bullish factors.
Santoli argues that tech has been oversold and hedge funds have sharply reduced their positioning, which he sees as a setup for a rebound. Seasonal tailwinds are also supposed to help. He has been making this point for about three weeks, and says the tape has not responded yet. He concludes these supportive factors have to prove themselves before the market turns.
“The fact that tech has been oversold and the hedge funds have really reduced their positioning. We've said that for like three weeks running. And so far we're not getting a response.”at 3:08
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Ron Temple · Lazard
The AI selloff was a necessary reset of excessive optimism, not finished yet, but becoming a buying opportunity.
The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index peaked in June and has fallen about 35%, and the S&P tech sector is down about 17% in five or six weeks. Temple says questions already existed about the return on the trillions being invested in AI between 2022 and 2030, and about how that spending is financed. Regulatory risk has grown, with state-level data center rules and possible federal action on AI exports. He calls the sell-off a necessary recalibration of excessive optimism, but says the correction is not over. Things are starting to look more interesting as a buying opportunity.
“I think it was a necessary recalibration of excessive optimism, but I don't think we're done yet. But things are starting to look more interesting as a buying opportunity here.”at 5:40
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Ron Temple · Lazard
US market looks more attractive: forward P/E below long-run averages, earnings growth above 25%, and tech now cheaper than the broad market.
The S&P 500 trades at about 17.7x forward earnings, versus a five-year average of 19.8x and a ten-year average of 19.1x, so valuation has come down. Three straight quarters of S&P 500 earnings growth above 25%, with this quarter near 32%, support the case. Temple says earnings expectations may still be a bit frothy, but even a 5-10% cut would leave the market not expensive. Tech is also cheaper than the broad market for the first time in a long time, which he argues makes the US market more attractive.
“I would argue maybe the earnings expectations are still a bit frothy. But even if you take those down five, 10%, the market doesn't look so expensive.”at 6:36
US housing
Where everyone stands on US housing
Ron Temple · Lazard
Rising mortgage rates at 7.1% are hitting consumers and housing more than the equity market.
Temple says higher interest rates have been less of a drag on AI-related demand than on consumers. The clearest effect is in housing, where mortgage rates are about 7.1%. He says the impact on consumers has been much more significant than on investment-related demand.
“I think for consumers, it's been much more impactful, especially in the housing market around mortgage rates at 7.1% today.”at 9:13
Credit markets
Where everyone stands on Credit markets
Ron Temple · Lazard
Private credit and lower-rung high yield spreads have widened sharply, but the financing impact has been mostly marginal so far.
Temple says private credit and lower-rated high yield have seen a significant widening of spreads, which means higher financing costs and tighter terms. He expects this to matter over time. For now, though, the effect has been largely on the margin. He argues that much AI-related demand is relatively insensitive to interest rates, so he thinks the financing channel is less important than the inflation problem.
“We have seen in the private credit markets and in lower rungs of the high yield market, a significant widening of spreads. ... I tend to think that financing element is less of an impact.”at 9:21
US inflation
Where everyone stands on US inflation
Ron Temple · Lazard
US inflation is broadening from energy to AI capex and now rents, with rent inflation picking up in top 100 cities.
Temple says the US has a broadening inflation problem. It began with energy after the war started, then spread to the AI capex boom. He is watching the Zillow Observed Rent Index, which he says has shown rent inflation picking up meaningfully across the top 100 US cities over the last seven months. He sees this broadening as the main concern, more than the tighter financing conditions.
“What I worry about more is, basically we've got a broadening inflation problem in The US. It started with energy after the war began, broadened to include the AI CapEx boom.”at 9:35
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Ron Temple · Lazard
The Fed has at least two more rate hikes to go, with futures pricing three.
Temple argues the Fed has not raised rates very much so far, but the long end has moved meaningfully. Rent inflation and broadening price pressures from energy and AI capex are the reason he expects more tightening. He cites the futures market pricing three hikes, and his own view of at least two more. He says the economic and market impact of these hikes will become more significant once they arrive.
“I think the Fed's got at least two more rate hikes to go and the futures market saying three rate hikes to go.”at 9:53
Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Where everyone stands on Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Arjun Bhatia · William Blair
Enterprise AI is still early, with usage mostly coding and finance, legal, sales and marketing still ahead.
Bhatia says AI has been commercialised for about three years, but the revenue to date is mostly from coding. Enterprises want to automate and change functions across finance, legal, sales and marketing, and that work is still ahead. He is confident this can become a very large business over the next several years, which underpins his view on Anthropic's growth.
“we're really talking about mostly coding. When we think about what enterprises want to automate and change with AI, you know, it's everything from finance to legal to sales to marketing. All that is still, I think, on the come...”at 23:43
US–China relations
Where everyone stands on US–China relations
Leland Miller · China Beige Book
The US–China truce could break down because China is not meeting its Busan commitments.
Miller says January 10 should matter far more to markets than it does. He argues the Busan détente was built on Chinese commitments to supply critical minerals and rare earths and to buy US agricultural goods. China has not delivered on minerals to the extent promised, and agricultural purchases are thin, with little soybean, corn or wheat buying. He says most of the US government thinks China is not adhering to its Busan commitments, and that there is a real chance the truce breaks down.
“January 10 is a lot... Should be a lot bigger date for markets than it is right now... The Chinese have not done that to the extent they promised... there is a real chance here that this truce breaks down”at 38:45
US consumer
Where everyone stands on US consumer
John San Marco · Neuberger Berman
Consumer discretionary spending will retrench as tax tailwinds fade, gas costs bite and real wages fall.
San Marco says the retail year that was supposed to be easy has been derailed by gas and energy prices, which netted out to zero against the roughly $250 billion of tax tailwinds. Those tailwinds are now exhausted. He expects more than a $100 billion annual headwind from gas to persist, plus cuts to SNAP and ACA subsidies and falling real wages. He expects this to show up as retrenchment in consumer discretionary categories, starting with this week's retail earnings.
“And that's exhausted now. And so prospectively, you're still dealing with over $100,000,000,000 annual run rate headwind from gas... Real wages are down. So I think you'll start to see some retrenchment in consumer discretionary categories”at 41:05
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA153 speakers · 146 bullish, 119 bearish calls
- Anthropic122 speakers · 180 bullish, 91 bearish calls
- Costco Wholesale6 speakers · 6 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- The TJX Companies3 speakers · 1 bullish, 2 bearish calls
Topics
- AI chip export controls
- AI trade correction
- AI valuations
- Anthropic IPO valuation
- China AI compute shortage
- broadening inflation
- chip export controls
- chip smuggling and diversion
- compute commitments
- consumer spending headwinds
- credit spreads
- enterprise AI adoption
- hedge fund positioning
- index valuation
- mortgage rates
- rate hikes
- retailer earnings and margins
- trade truce compliance
More from CNBC Closing Bell
- NVIDIA Sell-Off, Anthropic IPO and Perplexity’s AI Growth · November 16, 2026
- Markets End a Wild Week With Nvidia in Focus 11/13/26 · November 13, 2026
- Closing Bell: NVIDIA Fallout, Anthropic IPO Test and Apple’s Record Run · November 13, 2026
- NVIDIA CEO Fallout, China Chip Scrutiny and the AI Trade 11/12/26 · November 12, 2026
- NVIDIA CEO Exit, AI Trade Fallout and Tesla-SpaceX Deal Talk · November 12, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus