CNBC Closing Bell · · 46 min

NVIDIA Sell-Off, Anthropic IPO and Perplexity’s AI Growth

With Aravind Srinivas, Aswath Damodaran, Brad Gerstner, Brian Levitt, Brian Vendig, Dan Greenhaus

Summary

CNBC's Closing Bell episode centred on a Nvidia sell-off and the coming earnings test. Brian Levitt argued the stock is already pricing in much of the pain, calling it a growth business trading near 10 times forward earnings, while Dan Greenhaus flagged founder-led leadership succession under Jensen Huang as the key risk. Options strategist Oliver Renick warned that implied volatility into earnings is the highest in over 18 months, with a near 7% expected move and thin put protection below 150. The panel also debated Anthropic's IPO: Brad Gerstner called it a cornerstone compounder backed by a $5 billion Altimeter order, while Aswath Damodaran argued that about $80B in annualized revenue cannot justify a $1.5T valuation and flagged a weak governance structure. Aravind Srinivas used the segment to report that Perplexity crossed $1 billion in annualized revenue, up 4.7x year over year, and to outline enterprise agents and locally run secure AI tools.

Key takeaways

  • Dan Greenhaus (uncertain on NVIDIA): Nvidia risks long stagnation without founder Jensen Huang's visionary leadership; tomorrow's call won't solve it.
  • Brian Levitt (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia is a great growth business at 10x forward earnings after pain is priced in; downside concern is overdone.
  • Brad Gerstner (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic is a cornerstone compounder and the trade's direction, so Altimeter is placing a $5B IPO order.
  • Aswath Damodaran (bearish on Anthropic): A $1.5T Anthropic valuation is a stretch; $2T is too far, and governance will cause a discount.
  • Aravind Srinivas (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic has proven enterprise token charging works for AI; Perplexity draws inspiration and roots for it.

What was said, by company and theme

14 views from 7 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Anthropic

Across the shows: 120 speakers in other episodes, 177 bullish and 90 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • Brian Levitt · InvescoNeutral

    Recent IPOs have not started strong, so weak early trading in Anthropic's listing would not overly concern markets.

    Levitt notes that IPOs over the last year have typically not come out of the gate strongly. He says the market won't be overly concerned if Anthropic's initial trading days are lower. He is focused on whether the company can keep generating revenue over the coming years, not on first-week trading.

    “if we've looked at the IPOs over the last year, they have not come out of the gate typically strong. So I don't think the market will be overly concerned if initial trading days is lower.”at 7:59
  • Brian Levitt · InvescoBullish

    Anthropic has a strong head start, Claude usage is significant, and revenue and demand are strong.

    Levitt says Anthropic has a nice head start in the model race and Claude is used by businesses at a significant rate. Given the investment it expects to make, he expects its models to keep getting smarter. He adds that revenue growth and demand have been great so far, and hyperscaler backlogs show the AI cycle is still in play.

    “Clearly, they have a nice head start and clearly, Claude is being utilized by businesses at a significant rate and given the level of investment they expect to make, you would expect their models to keep getting smarter and smarter.”at 8:20
  • Brad Gerstner · Altimeter CapitalBullish

    Anthropic is a cornerstone compounder and the trade's direction, so Altimeter is placing a $5B IPO order.

    Gerstner says Anthropic has presented itself well and is in an excellent financial position, despite a bad backdrop of an election, chip-index declines and Nvidia's CEO change. Altimeter is putting in a $5 billion order, more than 5x its largest IPO order ever. He calls Anthropic a cornerstone compounder for a long period and says it is where the trade is going.

    “I think this is a cornerstone compounder for a long period of time. It's where the trade is going. I think they're going to benefit the most. And so we want to continue to be a major shareholder.”at 13:56
  • Aswath Damodaran · NYU Stern School of BusinessBearish

    A $1.5T Anthropic valuation is a stretch; $2T is too far, and governance will cause a discount.

    Damodaran says current numbers, about an $80B annualized revenue run rate, cannot justify $1.5T. The valuation is a bet on AI's potential, which he finds a stretch even if plausible. Going to $2T would need about $1 trillion in revenue, which he calls a bridge too far. He also sees a governance structure among the worst he has seen, a public benefit corporation with voting shares, which will cause a discount when operations disappoint.

    “Well, for me, it is. I mean, I'm already stretching to get to 1,500,000,000,000. A plausible path, but it's not a pathway that I want to put a lot of money on.”at 19:35
  • Aravind Srinivas · PerplexityBullish

    Anthropic has proven enterprise token charging works for AI; Perplexity draws inspiration and roots for it.

    Srinivas calls Anthropic a competitor in many ways but says he is excited for it. He says Anthropic has shown a business model that works for AI, which is charging enterprises for tokens. Perplexity has taken a lot of inspiration from that. He sees Anthropic owning a big chunk of the AI ecosystem and Perplexity wanting to grow the pie.

    “They've shown a business model to actually work for AI, which is charging for tokens in enterprise. We've taken a lot of inspiration from them. We are rooting for them.”at 34:35

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 153 speakers in other episodes, 145 bullish and 118 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • Dan Greenhaus · Solus Alternative Asset ManagementUncertain

    Nvidia risks long stagnation without founder Jensen Huang's visionary leadership; tomorrow's call won't solve it.

    Nvidia is founder-led by Jensen Huang, who has driven the company forward. Greenhaus cites other companies where the visionary's departure led to a long, sometimes unrecoverable period of stagnation and little innovation. He says Nvidia won't solve this on its earnings call, so leadership remains the key risk.

    “this is a company led by a founder visionary that has driven the company forward... when that not just founder, but that visionary, that driving force leaves. There is a long period, sometimes an unrecoverable long period of lack of innovation, of stagnation.”at 4:42
  • Brian Levitt · InvescoBullish

    Nvidia is a great growth business at 10x forward earnings after pain is priced in; downside concern is overdone.

    Levitt says a lot of pain is already priced into the stock. He describes Nvidia as a historically great growth business likely to grow earnings about 90% year over year while trading at roughly 10 times forward earnings. He reads this as a growth stock at deep value and is not overly concerned about further downside.

    “I'm not overly concerned about it. I think what investors need to realize is that this is a historically great growth business that's likely to grow earnings 90% year over year trading at a 10 times forward earnings multiple.”at 5:46
  • Oliver Renick · CNBCBearish

    Nvidia options positioning is not bullish; few puts below 150 leave room for a sharp downside shock.

    Implied volatility into Nvidia's earnings is at its highest in over 18 months, with traders pricing an almost 7% move. Put/call ratios have fallen with the stock, and calls now outnumber puts most since late September, but Renick says this does not signal bullishness. Few puts are open below the 150 level, so a bad shock could cause major downside, while any rally is likely to meet fast profit-taking. Neutral-to-bearish call sales made up about 25% of trades on a heavy-volume day.

    “But that doesn't scream bullish. For one, because there just now aren't many puts open below the one fifty level, which suggests any bad shock could carve out some major downside for Nvidia.”at 41:26

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Brian Levitt · Invesco

    Markets are near highs with defensive rotation into value outside tech; equal-weight index up 17% YTD.

    Levitt says the equal-weight index is up 17% year to date, in a year where rates went from pricing three cuts to multiple hikes. He notes the market is close to an all-time high and the equal weight is a percent or two from its record. He reads the move as a defensive feel, with investors looking for value outside the AI trade.

    “It's a little bit of both. I mean, the equal weight is up 17% year to date... There's a bit of a defensive feel to this. There's investors looking for value.”at 3:03
  • Brian Vendig · MJP Wealth Advisors

    Fears have manifested; investors should return to fundamentals, and tech and industrials could bounce back.

    Bendig argues that the market has already priced in its fears in a short period, including a hot services inflation print, a priced-in three Fed rate increases, and curbs on AI chip sales to sensitive competitors. He says it is time for investors to return to fundamentals, with Nvidia's earnings and China trade updates as the key tests. Defensive sectors have led the rotation out of energy and tech, but if the fears clear, tech and industrials can bounce.

    “I think the market has seen all its fears kind of manifest in such a short period of time... I think those fears have manifested, and it's time for investors to come back to fundamentals,”at 43:19

AI: overall outlook

Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook

  • Dan Greenhaus · Solus Alternative Asset Management

    The AI investment story will continue regardless of Anthropic's IPO because demand is there from everyone.

    Greenhaus argues Anthropic going public will not change the AI narrative for Nvidia or the market. He points to prior large IPOs such as Google and SpaceX, where the hype came and went. He says the AI story keeps going because demand is there from everybody, so the IPO adds only another valuation marker.

    “The AI story for both NVIDIA and the market in general is gonna keep going whether Anthropic came public or not. ... The demand is there from everybody, and I don't think any topic going public is gonna obviously change that narrative.”at 7:17
  • Aswath Damodaran · NYU Stern School of Business

    AI is an exceptional technology, but skeptics and advocates both overreach; it may not justify huge valuations.

    Damodaran says he has seen AI at work and respects its power, and that underestimating its ability to change businesses is dangerous. He sees a middle ground where AI can be an exceptional technology yet still not deliver enough to justify the large valuations being discussed. He disagrees with Warsh's view that AI could disappoint, while not being as bought in as Gerstner.

    “I've seen AI at work. I respect its power. ... AI can be an exceptional technology but still not deliver enough to justify a $1,500,000,000,000 valuation.”at 18:38

Open-source AI models

Where everyone stands on Open-source AI models

  • Aravind Srinivas · Perplexity

    American open-weight models need to exist, so Perplexity will open-source the models it trains.

    Srinivas says Jensen Huang wanted many players doing open source, not one company. Perplexity announced its Frontier Research effort and will open-source the models it trains for multi-agent orchestration and continual learning. He says American open-weight models need to exist and that the ecosystem must be cultivated.

    “We're going to open source all the models we train for multi agent orchestration, continual learning systems, and help make the ecosystem really work. American open weight models need to exist.”at 27:48

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Brian Vendig · MJP Wealth Advisors

    Believes AI spending and capex will continue, so tech and industrials can bounce.

    Bendig says that once the market clears its fears, the AI innovation trade is still in place and he believes spending and capex will still happen. He expects this to give sectors like industrials and tech a chance to bounce back. The argument rests on the belief that AI capex keeps going, not on a specific data point.

    “the AI innovation trade is still with us spending and CapEx, we believe is still gonna happen. Sectors like industrials and tech do have a chance to get a little bit of a bounce back.”at 44:41

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA153 speakers · 145 bullish, 118 bearish calls
  • Anthropic120 speakers · 177 bullish, 90 bearish calls

Topics

  • AI demand durability
  • AI's economic impact
  • American open-weight models
  • IPO demand
  • IPO trading performance
  • IPO valuation
  • Perplexity IPO timing
  • competitive position
  • enterprise AI agents
  • enterprise token pricing
  • geographic labor mismatch
  • hyperscaler capex
  • leadership succession
  • market sell-off and rebound
  • options positioning into earnings
  • revenue growth
  • sector rotation
  • secure local AI agents
  • valuation after selloff

More from CNBC Closing Bell

All CNBC Closing Bell episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus