CNBC Closing Bell · · 46 min

Closing Bell: NVIDIA Fallout, Anthropic IPO Test and Apple’s Record Run

With Drew Matus, Jeremy Siegel, King Lip, Meghan Shue, Scott Chronert

Summary

CNBC's Closing Bell centred on the fallout from Nvidia's leadership transition, with King Lip arguing that interim CEO Colette Kress must prove the company can run without Jensen Huang and that competition could erode Nvidia's roughly 80% AI chip share, even as AI demand stays strong. Lip read the over six-times oversubscribed Anthropic IPO as evidence that AI sentiment remains robust, and he remained bullish on Apple for its disciplined capital spending and pricing power, while noting its valuation of about 40 times earnings leaves little room for error. Jeremy Siegel framed the AI buildout as potentially the largest infrastructure investment in US history, forecast a single Fed rate hike in December despite falling gasoline prices, and saw the markets' recovery as a sign of confidence. Scott Kronert defended Nvidia's 2026 and 2027 fundamentals and said investors need conviction in management's long-term path, while Drew Matus warned that the economy's reliance on the AI trade makes it the key risk. Elsewhere, MacKenzie Sigalos described Bitcoin's six-week slide and outflows, and Alex Sherman and Michael Ozanian discussed rising sports rights costs and NHL franchise valuations.

Key takeaways

  • King Lip (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's shares will keep selling at a significant discount until its leadership transition is credibly handled.
  • Scott Chronert (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's fundamentals for 2026 and 2027 look in good shape despite the leadership disruption.
  • Drew Matus on AI infrastructure & data centers: The economy leans heavily on the AI trade, so doubts about AI could reverberate through the economy.
  • Jeremy Siegel on US rates & the Fed: Expects one more Fed rate hike in December despite gasoline relief.
  • Mackenzie Sigalos (bearish on Bitcoin): Bitcoin faces major headwinds from ETF outflows, Strategy's index removal, forced selling and a stronger dollar.

What was said, by company and theme

16 views from 7 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 142 speakers in other episodes, 132 bullish and 100 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • King Lip · BakerAvenue Wealth ManagementBearish

    Nvidia's shares will keep selling at a significant discount until its leadership transition is credibly handled.

    The key question is whether the current team, led by interim CEO Colette Kress, can run the operating machine Jensen Huang built. Lip wants proof that Nvidia is bigger than Huang. He sees a brain-drain risk, with engineers likely getting recruiting calls from AMD and Broadcom. Until leadership is credibly settled, he expects the shares to trade at a significant discount. He gives no timeframe for this.

    “Leadership is key here. It's really whether the current team with Colette Kress and the rest of the team can be able to carry out this machine that Jensen Huang had built... Until then, we think the shares are going to continue to sell at a significant discount.”at 5:11
  • King Lip · BakerAvenue Wealth ManagementBearish

    Nvidia's roughly 80% share leaves room for rivals to capture economics, eroding its dominance.

    Lip argues that the economics of AI chips may spread among Nvidia's competitors. Nvidia holds about 80% market share, so there is room for that share to be distributed. He adds that this would be overall stronger for the AI value chain, even though it is less favourable to Nvidia itself. AI demand remains very strong, so the risk is to Nvidia's share and economics rather than to demand.

    “I think the economics may spread out among NVIDIA's competitors. I mean, NVIDIA has an 80% market share. There's probably room for that to be distributed among its competitors.”at 7:28
  • Scott Chronert · Citi ResearchBullish

    Nvidia's fundamentals for 2026 and 2027 look in good shape despite the leadership disruption.

    Kronert says the near-term 2026 and likely calendar 2027 fundamentals are in pretty good shape, so the earnings call should not be dominated by them. What investors need is confidence that the path laid out over recent years still holds. That requires conviction on circular-financing concerns and a sense that a management team is steering the ship with a path beyond the next year. Competitive dynamics are at work, but he sees leadership as still central.

    “I think the immediate '26 and then probably calendar '27 fundamentals are in pretty good shape.”at 20:31

Anthropic

Across the shows: 114 speakers in other episodes, 165 bullish and 92 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • King Lip · BakerAvenue Wealth ManagementBullish

    Anthropic's IPO being over six times oversubscribed shows investors remain optimistic about the AI buildout.

    Lip sees the Anthropic IPO as the first real test of whether AI sentiment has really changed after the Nvidia leadership shock. He reports the offering is over six times oversubscribed. From that he concludes that overall sentiment is still very strong and that investors remain quite optimistic about the AI buildout.

    “[Anthropic's] IPO, I believe, is over six times oversubscribed. So from that perspective, I think investors are still quite optimistic about the overall AI build out.”at 8:35

Apple

Across the shows: 52 speakers in other episodes, 66 bullish and 42 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Apple

  • King Lip · BakerAvenue Wealth ManagementBullish

    Apple's disciplined capex and pricing power make it a winner, though its roughly 40x earnings leaves little room for error.

    Lip says Apple went from an AI laggard to a major winner because it kept its capital spending disciplined. Its supply-chain strength and brand let it command premium prices, and the $2,000 foldable iPhone sold out until late January despite higher component costs. Investors pay up for that predictability and defensiveness, especially with the AI trade uncertain. He also says the valuation is rich at about 40 times earnings, so management has to execute with little room for error. Lip says his firm holds Apple as a top position.

    “Apple has gone from what was an AI laggard, if you would, to this huge winner because they were such disciplined in their capital spend.”at 11:40

Bitcoin

Across the shows: 26 speakers in other episodes, 25 bullish and 8 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Bitcoin

  • Mackenzie Sigalos · CNBCBearish

    Bitcoin faces major headwinds from ETF outflows, Strategy's index removal, forced selling and a stronger dollar.

    Bitcoin is down 17% over the past month and on track for a sixth straight weekly loss. MSCI is dropping Strategy, the largest corporate holder, which will force index funds to sell. More than $500 million has left US spot Bitcoin ETFs this week, and $1.3 billion in leveraged positions were wiped out. A stronger dollar and surging bond yields pull money out of riskier assets. Negative futures funding rates may hint at a short-term bottom, but the headwinds dominate.

    “When you add on what's going on with strategy this week... These are two major headwinds for the crypto market in the last week alone.”at 31:34

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree

    The AI buildout will be the largest US infrastructure buildout ever, exceeding the railroads.

    Siegel argues that if the AI buildout goes ahead, it will be the biggest infrastructure buildout in US history, surpassing the railroads of the 1870s and 1880s. He calls AI a second industrial and information revolution that will change the economy. He acknowledges that the hope it creates comes with accompanying risks.

    “If this build out does take place, it will be the biggest infrastructure build out in US history, exceeding that of the US railroads... there's no question in my mind that the AI is, you know, the second industrial revolution.”at 17:48
  • Drew Matus · MetLife Investment Management

    The economy leans heavily on the AI trade, so doubts about AI could reverberate through the economy.

    Matus says much depends on the AI trade through two channels. One is investment feeding capital spending. The other is equity-market gains feeding consumer spending, which keeps the economy on an even keel. Both point back to the same concentrated risk, so any questioning of the AI trade could have real economic reverberations.

    “The risk is that there's so much depending upon the AI trade, whether it's the investment side of the equation feeding into CapEx or whether it's the equity market returns feeding into the consumer.”at 22:12

AI chips & semiconductors

Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors

  • Scott Chronert · Citi Research

    The semiconductor setup is one of the best fundamental setups he has seen, with strong growth and cash.

    Going into the quarter, Kronert looked at semiconductors and saw one of the best fundamental combinations he has seen. It pairs confidence in growth with strong compensation, free-cash generation and very high quality metrics. He says his team has been overweight the AI growth cluster, which includes data centers and their component suppliers. The Nvidia shock has put that visible setup into question.

    “We were looking at the semiconductor space saying, Wow, this is one of the best fundamental setups I've seen, combination of confidence in growth, comp, generation of free cash, quality metrics off the charts.”at 19:23

US growth & recession risk

Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk

  • Drew Matus · MetLife Investment Management

    Base case is another year like last year: growth stays okay and inflation keeps coming down.

    Matus expects the next year to look like the last one, with the economy growing acceptably. Inflation is probably still a little too high but should keep falling. He treats this as the base case, while the risk sits in the AI trade, which the economy leans on heavily.

    “The base case is another year that looks like last year. So growth is okay. Inflation's probably still a little too high, but probably coming down.”at 22:03

US rates & the Fed

Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed

  • Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree

    Expects one more Fed rate hike in December despite gasoline relief.

    Siegel's central forecast is a single rate increase in December. He acknowledges some good news on prices, with gasoline down more than 60 cents from its peak. Inflation is still too high for the Fed to ease, though, and the latest numbers have put it in a tight spot.

    “There's gonna be a raise. I think a single raise in December, but we're getting some good news.”at 24:34

Oil & fuels

Where everyone stands on Oil & fuels

  • Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree

    Gasoline prices can fall further, with wholesale prices pointing to more relief for consumers.

    Siegel notes gasoline is more than 60 cents below its all-time high and diesel is down less. Wholesale prices, which lead retail prices, show that gasoline can fall further. He expects that to put a few extra dollars in consumers' pockets.

    “I mean, gasoline is down more than 60¢ from its all time high... Wholesale prices actually show that, gas can fall further.”at 24:34

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree

    Major indexes near record highs signal investor confidence in earnings and the future.

    Despite the recent selloff over the AI build-out doubts, the Nvidia shock and a bad CPI report that pushed yields higher, the Dow and S&P 500 are less than 4% below their all-time highs. Siegel reads that resilience as confidence in the market, earnings and the future.

    “Both the Dow and the S and P five hundred are less than 4% below their all time highs. That shows confidence in the market.”at 25:07

Stablecoins & crypto policy

Where everyone stands on Stablecoins & crypto policy

  • Mackenzie Sigalos · CNBC

    The Clarity Act's failure to pass is a major overhang keeping Wall Street out of crypto.

    Sigalos argues that Coinbase and the industry poured money into the last election cycle, then the favourable Congress still failed to pass the Clarity Act. With political turnover, that does not bode well for the legislation. The argument is that the bill is what has stood in the way of Wall Street investing more and building crypto infrastructure, making it a major overhang.

    “And the overhang here is that the Clarity Act did not get passed into law when they had the most favorable senate and house set up for that legislation to go through.”at 31:04

Sports, betting & prediction markets

Where everyone stands on Sports, betting & prediction markets

  • Michael Ozanian · CNBC

    NHL franchise values are rising on limited supply, strong ratings and bigger media deals.

    Ozanian attributes the soaring NHL valuations to a broad appetite for sports teams, the limited supply of franchises and real-time content that people want to watch. The league has strong TV ratings and new arenas that improve economics. A new Canadian national TV deal more than doubled the previous one, and the US deal is likely to rise substantially in two years. Local revenue, including local media in Canada, matters greatly for valuations.

    “There's a lust for all sports teams in any league, limited supply, real content that people wanna see in real time.”at 33:58

Media, music & entertainment

Where everyone stands on Media, music & entertainment

  • Alex Sherman · CNBC

    Rising sports rights costs leave media companies less money for general entertainment programming.

    Sherman says media companies must spend more and more on live sports rights. Their total content budget is fixed, so the biggest sports take a larger share of it. The upcoming NHL deal is the first test, and it comes before the NFL renewal, which companies are already budgeting to cost over a billion dollars more. Each company will have to decide how much it can spend on non-NFL sports.

    “Each one of these companies now needs to dedicate more and more dollars to pay for the live rights of the major sports. That means less dollars for your general entertainment programming.”at 35:05

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA142 speakers · 132 bullish, 100 bearish calls
  • Anthropic114 speakers · 165 bullish, 92 bearish calls
  • Apple52 speakers · 66 bullish, 42 bearish calls
  • Bitcoin26 speakers · 25 bullish, 8 bearish calls

Topics

  • AI capex dependence risk
  • CEO transition and leadership
  • IPO demand
  • capex discipline and pricing power
  • crypto market-structure legislation
  • data center buildout
  • fundamentals through 2027
  • gasoline prices
  • growth outlook
  • market confidence after selloff
  • market share
  • price downtrend and outflows
  • rate hikes
  • semiconductor fundamentals
  • sports franchise valuations
  • sports rights costs

More from CNBC Closing Bell

All CNBC Closing Bell episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus