The Julia La Roche Show · · 59 min

#434 Dr. Lacy Hunt: Most Concerned In My Career — Intractable Deficit, Entrenched Inflation, No Way Out

With Lacy Hunt

Summary

Dr. Lacy Hunt, speaking with Julia La Roche, argues that the US fiscal position is the most serious problem of his career. The FY deficit of 6.3% of GDP sits at a cyclical peak, and he expects a mild recession to push it to 10-10.5% of GDP, which would exceed net national saving. He says interest expense near 20% of federal revenues could reach 20% of the budget within about five years, and that politics offers no fix because neither party will cut spending and Medicare for All would add roughly $300 billion a year. Hunt links this to persistent inflation, with core PCE near 4%, M2 growing about 6.5% annualized against a non-inflationary benchmark of 3-3.25%, and rising velocity, and he argues the Fed must raise rates to slow money growth. He also expects deglobalization, slower potential growth of about 2-2.25%, and an erosion of the dollar's reserve-currency privilege to push Treasury risk premiums higher.

Key takeaways

  • Lacy Hunt on US deficit & government debt: A mild recession would push the US deficit to about 10-10.5% of GDP from 6.3% at a boom.
  • Lacy Hunt on US deficit & government debt: Interest costs will reach about 20% of the federal budget within roughly five years, possibly sooner.
  • Lacy Hunt on US deficit & government debt: The US deficit is intractable because democracies cannot run boom-time surpluses and reform is politically blocked.
  • Lacy Hunt on US inflation: US inflation is entrenched and not mean-reverting; waiting for it to fade won't correct it.
  • Lacy Hunt on US rates & the Fed: The Fed is repeating 1970s errors by letting money supply grow too fast with no credible tightening.

What was said, by company and theme

22 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

US deficit & government debt

Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    A mild recession would push the US deficit to about 10-10.5% of GDP from 6.3% at a boom.

    The fiscal year just ended ran a 6.3% of GDP deficit at the top of a boom, about four times the roughly 1.5% average for late expansions since 1960. Deficits have historically risen about 4 points of GDP in downturns (excluding COVID). Hunt therefore argues that any mild recession would take the deficit to 10-10.5% of GDP, which would outstrip net national saving across the government, private and foreign sectors. He calls this an extreme situation the US has never faced before.

    “any sort of mild recession will take the budget deficit to somewhere between ten and ten and a half percent of GDP.”at 4:38
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Interest costs will reach about 20% of the federal budget within roughly five years, possibly sooner.

    Interest expense was just under 20% of federal revenues in the latest data, and it is already ingrained. Hunt says debt keeps growing and rising inflation pushes interest costs higher. His own calculation, which he admits is fraught with error, puts interest at about 20% of the budget within five years or a little longer or sooner. About a third of the debt is foreign-held, so roughly 30% of interest goes overseas. The rest flows mainly to the wealthiest corporations and top-quintile earners, because the bottom four quintiles had negative personal saving rates. This creates a deadweight loss and constrains fiscal flexibility.

    “I did a calculation which is fraught with error, but I think when in five years, approximately maybe a little longer, maybe a little sooner, the interest expense is going to be 20% of the budget.”at 5:33
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    The US deficit is intractable because democracies cannot run boom-time surpluses and reform is politically blocked.

    Hunt argues that Buchanan's point in Deficit by Democracy still applies. Democracies cannot run the surpluses in boom times needed to offset hard-time deficits. Tax cuts and programs have visible benefits to voters, while the benefits of fiscal discipline (stability for children, lower inflation) are not visible. He says the current administration failed to cut spending and that fresh spending is accelerating. Congress is split and the Democrats want more social spending, while the administration needs more defense spending. He notes the big bill's roughly $200 billion a year in Affordable Care Act reductions will likely be reversed, and that Medicare for All would cost about $300 billion a year per the CBO. He concludes the problems cannot be reversed in two or four years, so the revolving door of parties will continue.

    “people are gonna have to accept the fact, in my opinion, that the budget deficit is intractable.”at 7:54
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    The US deficit is intractable; no party has a program to cut it, and simple tax fixes won't work.

    A 6.3% deficit is treated as fine by nearly everyone, and no politician of standing in either party has a program to reduce it. Proposed fixes fail on his net saving framework: net national saving is household, corporate and foreign saving minus government dissaving. Raising corporate taxes cuts corporate saving because it cuts profits. Raising taxes on upper-income earners cuts saving, and they already do most of the saving. The fixes may look politically popular but will not improve the situation. He calls the deficit very serious and intractable, and says it is the most concerned he has been in his career.

    “the deficit at 6.3 is taken as just fine by virtually everybody. There is no one in either party of any stature that is... Has any program whatsoever to reduce it.”at 46:35
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Fiscal room is exhausted; a recession will push the deficit from about 6% to over 10% of GDP.

    The deficit is already about four times what it should be at this stage of the expansion. Fiscal room has been used up, so natural recession forces will make the deficit much worse. Fiscal policy will not be able to provide relief. The deficit is expected to rise another four percentage points, from 6% of GDP to over 10%. Some argue the Fed can print money to fund the budget, as it did during COVID, but he says that immediately sets off much higher inflation.

    “the deficit is gonna go up another four percentage points. We're gonna go from a 6% deficit of GDP to over 10.”at 48:34
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Heavily indebted states historically decline into languor and impotence; the US is moving down that path.

    Hume's 1752 essays on money, public credit and trade looked at highly indebted economies such as Mesopotamia and Rome. Hume concluded that when a state has mortgaged all its future revenues, it lapses into tranquility, languor and impotence. Ferguson's Empires on the Verge of Chaos shows debt overwhelming Mesopotamia, Rome and the Bourbons of France, and the British Empire after World War Two: Britain survived, but its empire did not. Asked whether the US is already in that condition, Hunt says the US is continuing down that path, with no fiscal room left.

    “when a state has mortgaged all of its future revenues, the state lapses into tranquility, langor, and impotence.”at 50:32

US inflation

Where everyone stands on US inflation

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    US inflation is entrenched and not mean-reverting; waiting for it to fade won't correct it.

    Hunt says inflation is not mean-reverting, citing the 1960s and 1970s when the Fed made excuses, Burns accelerated money growth in the 1972 election year, and Volcker needed four years of heavy lifting. Today, core PCE is close to 4%, goods are running just under 3% and services above 4%, with 67 to 68 consecutive months above target. Consumers' one-year inflation expectation is 3.9%, close to the CPI, and small businesses' planned price increases are at a six-year high. Wages are still tranquil, but the three-month wage trend is faster than its low, and labor shortages look like a tipping point that would make inflation more intractable. Hunt says the futures market's calm is not reassuring given flaws in those measures.

    “one of the things we have to understand here is that inflation is not mean reverting.”at 14:54
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Financing deficits by printing money would immediately set off much higher inflation.

    Some argue the Fed will print money to buy federal debt and fund the budget in a recession. The Fed did this during COVID, and it has been done many times in history. Hunt's point is that it immediately sets off much higher inflation. That is why the fiscal room has been exhausted and the Fed cannot offset a recession's effect on the budget without inflating prices.

    “But what that does is it it it immediately sets off much higher inflation.”at 52:30
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Inflation is not mean-reverting; money growth is above target and inflation is becoming more entrenched.

    The Powell Fed cooperated with COVID-era federal spending, then was unable to move against inflation. It hoped inflation would be transitory or mean-reverting, waited too long, and only began re-accelerating money supply growth last December with inflation well above target. Money growth is still well above target, and inflation is becoming more entrenched. Inflation is a real problem for most people, who cannot keep up with it. Hunt says he wrote a lengthy section on this in the latest letter.

    “Inflation is not mean reverting. I wrote a lengthy section in our latest letter on that.”at 54:48
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Money velocity has moved through five regimes and is now rising again, which drives inflation.

    Friedman's view that velocity was stable held from 1952 to 1984. Archival data back to 1900 shows five distinct velocity periods: falling, flat, rising, falling, and now rising again. Because of this, he has changed his view on monetary policy. Rising velocity combined with fast money growth is what makes inflation entrenched.

    “And then, of course, we have more data, and we see now we have five distinct periods of velocity. Falling, flat, rising, falling, and now rising again.”at 56:38

US growth & recession risk

Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    US potential growth is only about 2%, held back by stalled productivity and a stagnant labor force.

    Potential growth is the sum of productivity growth and labor force growth. Productivity has historically averaged about 2% in data back to 1949 and even 1929, and labor force growth used to run 1.5 to 1.75%, implying potential GDP growth of about 3.5 to 3.75%. Now the labor force is barely growing. Immigration has slowed sharply, the birth rate has been declining for years, and boomers are retiring and claiming Social Security and Medicare. Even with constant technological advances, productivity has been stuck at about 2%, which Hunt finds worrisome. So potential growth is now around 2 to 2.25%.

    “So the potential growth right now is only two or maybe a little bit better.”at 12:35
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    The US faces a capital shortage; savings are too low to fund onshoring, grid and high-tech investment plans.

    Hunt's textbook point is that real physical investment must be funded by saving, and net national saving (household, corporate, government and foreign) is very paltry. Printing money to finance investment would be inflationary. Demands for capital are rising from onshoring, just-in-time inventories, a decrepit electric grid, and the enormous capital needs of the high-tech sector. Hunt doubts all these plans can be carried out because there is not enough net national saving. A weaker economy would widen the deficit immediately from a 6.3% of GDP starting point, which he says is four times worse than it should be at this stage. That would push real interest rates higher.

    “I don't believe that all of these plans will be able to be effectuated because there's simply not enough net national savings.”at 34:54
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Real per capita growth fell from 2.3% to about 1.2%, cutting family income by roughly $20,000 a year.

    Real per capita GDP grew 2.3% a year from 1870 and was still growing at that pace in 1970. It has slowed to about 1.1–1.2% a year over the last twenty years. Because of compounding, slower growth has a large effect on income. Hunt's rough calculation, not fully up to date, assumed 2.3% growth continued. On that basis real per capita GDP per family would be about $70,000 rather than about $50,000. Compounding works against the economy in the same way compounding interest works against the government.

    “the real per capita GDP grew 2.3 per annum from 1870... And now we're down to 1.2% per annum, 1.1% per annum over the last twenty years or so.”at 42:55

US rates & the Fed

Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    The Fed is repeating 1970s errors by letting money supply grow too fast with no credible tightening.

    M2 has grown at a 6.5% annual rate since December, which Hunt views as far above the non-inflationary benchmark of about 3 to 3.25%. That benchmark is potential growth of about 2 to 2.25% plus the 2% inflation target, less about 1 point because velocity has risen about 1.4% a year over the last 12 quarters. Rising velocity makes money growth more powerful. Hunt says the Fed is accelerating money growth in the face of an oil shock, the same mistake Arthur Burns made in 1974. He says the Fed talks about inflation but has made no credible effort to throttle money growth. He also argues that administration pressure to cut rates, driven by burdensome interest costs, would only accelerate money growth and worsen inflation.

    “the Fed is accelerating money supply growth. Same thing that Arthur Burns did with the Fed in 1974.”at 16:29
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    The Fed must raise the funds rate until money supply growth falls to about 3–3.25%; talk alone fails.

    The Fed has to raise the federal funds rate until it brings money supply growth down to the 3 to 3.25% range, defined as potential growth plus the 2% inflation target, adjusted for changes in velocity. Without that borrowing, the Fed will not succeed. Talking about it and waiting for something good to happen is not a solution. He draws a parallel with the 1970s, when the Fed let money supply grow too fast.

    “they're going to have to basically raise the federal funds rate until they bring money supply growth down into the three, three and a quarter range... Talking about it and waiting for something good to happen is not a solution.”at 54:13

US Treasuries & yields

Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    The risk premium on Treasuries will likely rise as the deficit's intractability sinks in.

    Hunt argues the US fiscal position is substantially worse than France or the UK on debt level, interest expense as a share of GDP and of the budget. The US reserve-currency role has given it exorbitant privilege, with lower rates, as Eichengreen documented. Hunt warns that as markets understand the intractable deficit, that privilege will gradually erode. He also says net national saving is too paltry to fund needed investment, and a deteriorating economy would widen the deficit immediately. Together, these suggest the real interest rate and the risk premium on Treasuries will rise.

    “that the risk premium on treasury debt is gonna start to rise.”at 30:30
  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Long Treasury yields trend higher; recession declines will be muted because deficits keep growing.

    Long Treasury yields are volatile and move up and down. A recession would bring yields down, but the decline in the next recession will be much more muted than historically, because the deficit is rising from about 6% to over 10% of GDP. Rates will have periods of climbing and declining, but the trend is upward unless something unforeseen changes the picture. He also says the administration was worried about rates because of interest expense on the budget, which is moving higher and is not going to stay where it is. He expects the risk premium on Treasuries to rise.

    “but I think the trend is gonna be upward unless something fortuitous comes along to change the picture.”at 48:56

US consumer

Where everyone stands on US consumer

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Inflation hurts modest and moderate-income households most, skewing income toward business and away from labor.

    Hunt cites economic research that inflation robs everyone but hurts modest and moderate-income households the most. He says national income is being significantly skewed toward businesses and away from labor, so households are hard pressed by inflation. Although the stock market is booming, he argues that ordinary people are suffering.

    “inflation robs everyone, but it robs the modest and moderate income households the most.”at 20:57

Manufacturing & industrial policy

Where everyone stands on Manufacturing & industrial policy

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Globalization is unwinding, so reshoring and onshoring add inflation pressure to the economy.

    Hunt says the disinflationary period was driven by globalization, which brought economies of scale, a large outward shift in the world's labor supply, efficient factories, and cheap offshoring. Those forces are now reverting as firms shift to onshoring or friend-shoring and move from just-in-time to just-in-case inventories. Hunt admits the effects of scale are hard to measure but argues they are present and working against us. He had thought the debt constraint would keep producing disinflation, but in hindsight globalization was the main driver. The debt constraint now works the other way in an inflationary, deglobalizing era.

    “But today we're going into post globalization, that it's breaking up and it's reverting and firms are shifting to onshoring or fringe shoring.”at 26:25

US dollar

Where everyone stands on US dollar

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Foreign central banks are shifting out of the dollar, a growing risk to its reserve-currency role.

    Hunt says the US has benefited from reserve-currency status, but as the intractable deficit is understood, the US will see a gradual erosion of its critical role in transactions. Foreign central banks are moving money into gold, precious metals and other currencies and are clearly shifting out of the dollar. So far this hasn't hurt the dollar's performance, but Hunt sees it becoming a major potential problem down the road. The US is helped only because there is no obvious party to replace it.

    “the foreign central banks are putting money into gold and precious metals and using more foreign currencies, but they're clearly shifting out of the dollar.”at 31:34

Wealth, inequality & billionaires

Where everyone stands on Wealth, inequality & billionaires

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Slowing real per capita growth skews income away from the middle toward upper earners, hurting social cohesion.

    When real per capita growth starts slowing but stays positive, the typical result is that income skews away from the middle and below-middle earners toward upper-income groups. Hunt says this is not a welcome development for a cohesive society. The argument rests on his view of how growth slowdowns have historically distributed income, and it follows from his point that per capita growth has fallen from 2.3% to about 1.2%.

    “what typically happens is you get a skewing of the income away from the middle and below middle toward the upper income.”at 45:53

US tax & spending policy

Where everyone stands on US tax & spending policy

  • Lacy Hunt · Hoisington Investment Management Company

    Government spending multipliers are slightly negative, not the 4–5 he was taught.

    When he finished his doctorate in 1969, the dominant view was that fiscal policy was very powerful and the government expenditure multiplier was between four and five. The evidence now shows it is slightly negative. Together with his velocity finding, this is one of two major propositions where he has totally changed his mind based on better data. He expects more of this kind of learning as the economy operates under extreme interest expense.

    “The government expenditure model multiplier was somewhere between four and five... I believe it's found out slightly negative, and I think that's what the evidence shows.”at 56:06

Topics

  • Fed financing of deficits
  • Fed tightening to slow money growth
  • capital shortage
  • debt and national decline
  • deficit in recession
  • deficit intractability
  • deficit reduction politics
  • deglobalization and reshoring
  • fiscal multiplier
  • household purchasing power
  • income inequality
  • inflation persistence
  • interest burden on federal budget
  • long-term yield trend
  • money supply growth and Fed policy
  • money velocity
  • potential growth
  • real per capita growth
  • recession and deficit blowout
  • reserve currency status
  • term premium

More from The Julia La Roche Show

All The Julia La Roche Show episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus