The Compound and Friends · · 1h 9m
Nvidia Blow-up Beneficiaries, Retail Sells the Dip in Tech, the Case for Semis Here, Anthropic IPO Watch
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Josh Brown and Michael Batnick dissect the recent Nvidia selloff, with Josh arguing the fundamentals (revenue up from about $27B to over $300B) have outrun the share price, while still doubting the low will hold given leadership succession after Jensen Huang's exit, accounting scrutiny of circular AI financing, and eroding share as Meta, Amazon, Alphabet and Broadcom build custom chips. The hosts argue that compute buyers such as Anthropic and OpenAI gain bargaining power, that AMD (Helios racks), HPE, and Astera Labs are beneficiaries, and that Apple's margins should improve if Nvidia curbs its memory buying. They also cover pod-shop deleveraging that could keep semis under pressure, Adam Parker's research on semis earnings cycles and harsh penalties for cheap stocks that miss, and a debate on housing, where Michael rejects a boom thesis citing Floor & Decor's weak comps while Josh says homebuilders can still do well. Anthropic's IPO, with price talk of $70-78, closes the episode.
Key takeaways
- Josh Brown (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's fundamentals have outrun its share price; buyback at this low valuation is a buy signal.
- Josh Brown (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's moat is eroding as its own customers build custom chips and bargain on price per compute.
- Michael Batnick (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's share of frontier-lab compute deals has collapsed from 80-90% to 28%.
- Michael Batnick (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's share of frontier-lab compute deals has collapsed; it is no longer a one-man show.
- Josh Brown (bullish on Advanced Micro Devices): AMD's Helios rack-scale system makes it the most direct Nvidia share-gain story.
What was said, by company and theme
28 views from 2 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 169 speakers in other episodes, 173 bullish and 141 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Nvidia's fundamentals have outrun its share price; buyback at this low valuation is a buy signal.
Josh argues Nvidia is not expensive and has not been for a while. Revenue has grown from about $27B in the fiscal year before ChatGPT to over $300B this year, so the fundamentals have outrun the share price, especially after the latest drawdown. He says the company is generating far too much cash not to use it, and the $150B authorized buyback, announced when the stock trades near its lowest multiple in company history, is a clear opportunity. He says he is left holding his own position and is not selling.
“this company's generating way too much money to not take advantage of this share slide... This is where you pull the trigger.”at 7:02
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBearish
At $6 trillion Nvidia can't trade at a premium to the market, and its size makes it riskier.
Michael says Nvidia has the dominant position in a world-changing technology, is growing about 100% with roughly 70% margins, and yet trades at a severe discount to the market. He argues the discount is rational at this size: a stock of this scale cannot trade at a premium to the market because it would swallow the index. He adds that the bigger a stock gets, the riskier it becomes, since many things can go wrong, which limits upside.
“at six trillion dollars... it can't possibly trade at a premium to the market. It would swallow the market whole. Also the bigger, the bigger a stock gets the riskier it becomes.”at 9:14
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBearish
Nvidia's moat is eroding as its own customers build custom chips and bargain on price per compute.
Josh explains part of Nvidia's valuation discount. Two years ago Nvidia faced little competition, but that is no longer true. Its biggest customers (Meta, Amazon, Alphabet) are making their own chips, and Broadcom is building custom chips for Nvidia's top customers, including tensor processing units and other ASICs. CUDA still locks in GPU demand for the foreseeable future, but the conversations increasingly come down to the price per unit of compute, and these rivals have spent the last two years building alternatives.
“NVIDIA didn't really have any competition two years ago, and that's not true anymore. They compete with their own customers who are making their own chips, Meta, Amazon, Alphabet.”at 10:25
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBearish
Nvidia's share of frontier-lab compute deals has collapsed from 80-90% to 28%.
Michael cites a chart from Michael Semblist showing Nvidia held 80 to 90% revenue share of the AI chip market in 2024-25. Its share of announced frontier lab compute agreements is now only 28%. He presents this as evidence that the competitive position Nvidia held is no longer intact, which supports the discount the stock trades at.
“NVIDIA had 80 to 90% revenue share of the market... And now it has only 28% share of announced Frontier Lab compute agreements.”at 10:44
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBearish
After Jensen Huang's exit, the board cannot promote an internal successor and get the result it wants.
Josh argues Nvidia's governance problem is structural. He compares the company to a family where the head of household has left, so the siblings cannot be expected to listen to each other. None of the internal candidates looks strong enough to fill Huang's role, so bringing someone in from inside is unlikely to produce the result the board wants. He suggests the board needs a certified outside governance leader to rebuild the structure.
“I actually don't think you can bring somebody in internally and get the result that you want if you're the board.”at 25:01
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBearish
Nvidia's selloff is still being processed; he would not be buying now, even after the drop.
Asked whether a recent low would hold for a week, a month or three months, Josh says he does not think so. He argues the market has not yet fully processed what has happened, that the company is in shock and still facing accounting scrutiny of its circular financing, and that a new regulatory regime is coming. He says the stock could still fall further, and that if he were not already holding it he would not be running in to buy it. He also says he does not expect a return to the first three-year run of the AI trade.
“I don't even think the market has really processed fully what has happened here and what may still be to come. I think we're still in shock.”at 31:56
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementUncertain
Nvidia's overhang won't clear soon, but the low could hold for a couple of months.
Michael agrees with Josh that the overhang on Nvidia is not going away anytime soon. He disagrees that the market has to keep falling, pointing to how short people's memories are and how quickly markets move on, and concludes the low could be in for a couple of months easily. He earlier said he was not confident at all that the low would hold, so his view is mixed.
“I agree that this overhang is not going away anytime soon, but people have such short memories... The low could be in for a couple of months easily.”at 32:52
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBearish
Nvidia's share of frontier-lab compute deals has collapsed; it is no longer a one-man show.
A chart from Semianalysis shows Nvidia had 80-90% of frontier-lab compute agreements two years ago and now has about 20% of future agreements. Broadcom has 23% and AMD 18%. Nvidia is still a large share, but the market is no longer dominated by one supplier, and analysts' earnings revisions since the news have been substantial.
“NVIDIA had a 90... 80 to 90% share two years ago. Now of future compute agreements, it's 20%. It's still a massive number, but look at Broadcom, 23%.”at 37:29
Anthropic
Across the shows: 130 speakers in other episodes, 198 bullish and 104 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Anthropic
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Anthropic is a major winner as Nvidia's compute bottleneck loosens and buyers gain leverage.
Josh says that a year or two ago, anyone building AI had to depend on a small handful of people who could secure compute, and Nvidia's chip production was a brick wall. That is no longer definitively the case. Nvidia's leadership vacuum, internal investigation and possible supply glut strengthen the position of the largest compute buyers, which he names as Anthropic and OpenAI. Anthropic can now lean on second sources and negotiate from a stronger position, and Josh says its latest filing shows it can spin up Claude instances on alternative hardware.
“OpenAI and Anthropic to me are two of the biggest winners here.”at 34:11
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Shifting compute bargaining power to buyers helps Anthropic's valuation case ahead of its IPO.
Josh has argued that Anthropic and OpenAI could win as power shifts from chip companies and compute providers to buyers of compute. Nvidia's share of compute deals falling and AMD and Broadcom gaining supports this. Josh thinks this helps the valuation case Anthropic will make to investors in the IPO that week.
“as the balance of power shifts from the chip companies, the compute companies, to the buyers of compute. Like, I really do think this helps the anthropic valuation case”at 1:00:38
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Anthropic's IPO should open around $70-78 and rise to $90-100 on day one.
Price talk for Anthropic's IPO is $70-78. If it opens there, Michael expects it to rise to $90-100 on the first day. He thinks it will be a good IPO and does not know what happens after that. He is not sure about the opinion, and it may change every week.
“Well, 70 to 78 is the price talk. If it opens there, I think it gets to $90, 100 bucks... First day... I think it'll be a good IPO.”at 1:01:09
Apple
Across the shows: 50 speakers in other episodes, 62 bullish and 41 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Apple
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Apple is the biggest beneficiary if Nvidia stops hoarding memory after Jensen's exit.
Apru's CFO said memory prices explain all of the sequential margin pressure Apple has experienced, and Apple raised iPhone 18 Pro prices by $100 citing memory costs. Jensen Huang has been buying as much memory as he can, probably over-purchasing to protect Nvidia's position. A more disciplined post-Jensen Nvidia that curtails that memory buying would help Apple's margins and pricing power. Apple is up 30% in 2026 while Nvidia is down 16%, and Josh thinks Wall Street is pricing this in.
“if the new NVIDIA without Jensen... curtails some of that monopolization of memory, there is no greater beneficiary than Apple and its pricing power and its need for that same memory for its own devices.”at 44:14
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Apple's margins improve if Nvidia buys less memory; the market sniffed that out.
Apple stock fell 4% on a good quarter, and much of the focus was on memory-driven margin pressure. Michael agrees with Josh that the market recognized Nvidia as the biggest buyer of memory. If Nvidia buys less, Apple's margins should be better, which he calls an astute observation.
“The market sniffed this out, that Nvidia was the biggest buyer. And if there's a little bit less, this is gonna be better for Apple's margin.”at 50:20
OpenAI
Across the shows: 44 speakers in other episodes, 19 bullish and 38 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on OpenAI
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
OpenAI is a major winner as Nvidia's compute bottleneck loosens and buyers gain leverage.
Josh says that a year or two ago, anyone building AI had to depend on a small group of people who could secure compute, and Nvidia's chip production was a brick wall. That is no longer definitively the case. Nvidia's leadership vacuum, internal investigation and possible supply glut strengthen the position of the largest compute buyers, which he names as OpenAI and Anthropic. OpenAI can now point to second sources and negotiate from a stronger position with Nvidia.
“OpenAI and Anthropic to me are two of the biggest winners here.”at 34:11
Advanced Micro Devices
Across the shows: 20 speakers in other episodes, 25 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Advanced Micro Devices
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
AMD's Helios rack-scale system makes it the most direct Nvidia share-gain story.
AMD is the only other company besides Nvidia shipping a rack-scale AI system, and its Helios racks compete head to head with Nvidia's Vera Rubin. AMD has a product, not just a roadmap. Data center revenue rose 97% to $8.5B last quarter, and Q4 guidance of $17B implies about 66% growth at the midpoint. Hyperscaler procurement teams (Microsoft, Meta, Oracle) now have to show supplier-concentration plans, which favors AMD. AMD has also had the largest forward EPS upgrade, and its stock has been hit only because AI names were liquidated.
“Look. This is very simple. It is the only other company besides NVIDIA making a rack scale AI system. The Helios racks are going head to head with Vera Rubin. They're not selling a road map. They have a product.”at 39:03
Hewlett Packard Enterprise Company
Across the shows: 4 speakers in other episodes, 3 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Hewlett Packard Enterprise Company
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Shifts from Nvidia racks to AMD raise HPE's share of the bill of materials; HPE is undervalued.
HPE sells both Nvidia and AMD-based stacks, while Dell is largely Nvidia-centric. Every rack that moves from Nvidia to AMD probably increases HPE's share of the bill of materials. HPE raised its fiscal 2027 networking and growth outlook and said the increase was because of Helios. The forward P/E has been cut in half since October, so the stock is cheap if the market starts sorting winners from losers again.
“Every rack that moves from NVIDIA to AMD probably raises Hewlett Packard's share of the bill of materials. They also raised their fiscal twenty twenty seven network and growth outlook and specifically said it's because of Helios.”at 40:29
Astera Labs
Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, 1 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Astera Labs benefits as data centers shift to non-Nvidia chips; its valuation has de-rated.
Astera is the non-Nvidia connectivity supplier, which Josh calls the Switzerland of connectivity. It sells alternatives to Nvidia's NVLink. If data centers use a mix of Trainium, TPUs and AMD chips, Astera gets more business. Q3 revenue was $585M, up 154% year over year, with Q4 guidance of $730-750M. Forward P/E fell to 46 from 110 in June. The concern is that about 70% of revenue comes from one customer, which is why the stock is less popular.
“Astera is selling the non NVIDIA version. And so if we're gonna see a multitude of chips from Trainium to TPUs to AMD in these data centers, it's more business for Astera Labs.”at 41:39
Floor & Decor Holdings
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBearish
Floor & Decor is in a long, persistent decline; transaction and unit volumes keep falling.
Citing Alex Morris, Michael says Floor & Decor has reported 20 consecutive quarters of comparable-transaction declines. Average unit volumes are down 25% over five years. This is evidence housing-related retail is still weak and it does not support JC's housing boom thesis. Michael had bought the stock earlier and took a loss.
“Reported this from Alex Morris, the signs of hitting. Floor decor reported twenty consecutive quarters of comp transaction declines... With their average unit volumes declining by 25% over that period. It is black as night.”at 1:04:08
Berkshire Hathaway
Across the shows: 8 speakers in other episodes, 5 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Berkshire Hathaway
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Berkshire's breakout from consolidation was missed; investors focused on midterm noise.
Berkshire's stock rose from about 500 to 600 since October 1 after breaking out of a consolidation range, and Josh owns it. Investors were not excited at the breakout, which Josh attributes to midterm-election noise and a lack of a system for deciding what to watch.
“I own it, but, like, why weren't people freaking out when that breakout occurred? You know why? Because midterm election. Because people don't know what to look at first.”at 1:07:01
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth Management
The AI trade will not return to its first three-year run; trust in AI companies is now gone.
Josh says the AI trade has entered a new phase in which everything is suspect and investors give these companies no benefit of the doubt. Accounting and circular financing deals are now under the microscope, and new leadership at the SEC and IRS will bring more scrutiny over the next couple of years. He argues the sector will not get back to the easy, first three years of the AI trade.
“I really just don't think we're ever going back to the first three year run of the AI trade. I think we're in a new phase where shit is real, and everything is now suspect.”at 32:24
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Everything tech is being sold until the market sees the circular financing risk as not a worst case.
Tech is being sold indiscriminately because circular financing among AI players is under scrutiny, and software names like Salesforce were hit hard. Josh says the selling will continue until the market believes this is not a worst-case scenario.
“Everything tech is for sale until the market feels like this is not gonna be a worst case scenario.”at 51:34
AI chips & semiconductors
Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Semis are cheap, but demand is not slowing; a 20% earnings cut in three months is unlikely.
Adam Parker's research shows that historically, after forward earnings yield peaks in semis, forecast income growth falls about 20% three months later. Parker argues the economy has been resilient and that a 20% cut is not in the cards this cycle, so this time is different. Michael agrees, citing earnings reports that all say demand is not slowing down.
“We just don't think 20% net income growth reductions in three months times are in the cards this cycle. So, yeah, we will say it. We think it is different this time.”at 53:24
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Forced pod-shop selling will keep pushing semis lower; the low is not in.
Multi-manager pod shops own the same semiconductor stocks. Their managers face redemptions, margin calls and possible firing when their edge expires, so they are forced sellers. Josh argues that this process will wreck semis regardless of whether earnings grow 20% next year. Semis trade on whether there are more sellers than buyers, not on fundamentals. He does not think the low is in and expects rallies to be sold.
“All of these stocks are owned by the same people, and those people are getting redeemed. They just got flushed.”at 54:08
US housing
Where everyone stands on US housing
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Stock market gives no sign housing is near a turning point; homebuilders and suppliers look weak.
The stock market tends to lead the economy by six to twelve months at turning points, but Michael sees no evidence it is pricing a housing turn. The homebuilder ETF is falling, Lennar is down, Home Depot shows lower highs, Builders FirstSource looks terrible, and mortgage rates are back above 7%. Michael agrees housing is awful and will not improve soon, but he does not accept JC's boom thesis.
“I don't see any evidence at all that the stock market thinks we're near a turning point.”at 1:02:17
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth Management
No housing boom in the next year; mortgage rates would need to fall to 3-4% first.
Homebuilders can do well even when housing is weak, because construction and existing home sales are different. Existing home sales just hit a six-year low, while new-home construction is better because buyers want new homes. A real housing boom needs mortgage rates back near 3-4%, which requires a recession. Josh also notes that the Fed has a hike in December. He admires JC's contrarianism but does not buy the boom thesis.
“I have no faith in there being a housing boom anytime in the next year. ... the thing that you need to get a housing boom are mortgage rates at [3 to 4%] again, and you ain't getting that unless the economy goes into recession.”at 1:04:54
US–China AI & chip race
Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Jensen Huang's exit removes the loudest voice for selling advanced chips to China.
Jensen Huang was the most powerful and loudest voice in Washington for selling chips to China, and now he is out. A researcher's forensic audit reportedly showed leading Chinese models were trained on leading Nvidia chips, which pressured the US AI industry. That could give the US breathing room and possibly tighter export controls on national security grounds. US closed-model labs would face less pressure from Chinese AI companies if those companies get less access to Blackwell and Vera chips. Josh says this is speculative and offers it as the silver lining.
“the one thing that nobody can deny, he was the most powerful, loudest voice in Washington about the need to sell chips to China, and he's out.”at 45:14
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Cheap stocks that miss earnings are getting punished harder than expensive ones.
Adam Parker found the penalty for missing estimates has been harsher for cheap stocks than expensive ones, and the harshest for cheap stocks in 25 years. Valuation is not protecting stocks that miss, and cheap stocks that fall ahead of prints do not de-risk in advance. A chart of the top two dozen stocks shows cheap misses getting mauled. Michael finds it striking enough to call it important.
“Adam said the penalty for missing estimates has been harsher for cheap stocks than for expensive stocks and has been the harshest for cheap stocks in twenty five years.”at 50:42
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Josh Brown · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Neoclouds will cut 2027-28 buildout without Nvidia's support, hurting chip suppliers' forecasts.
Neoclouds are likely to scale back plans for 2027 and 2028 first, though they would not shut down existing projects. If Nvidia stops supporting them, they will curtail out-year projects. Semiconductor companies expecting to sell 30-50% of their output into those neoclouds will see forward expectations fall. Josh expects the stock reaction to be exaggerated because of leverage and hopes for a V-shaped recovery, and he thinks these stocks will not return to their July highs.
“They won't shut down existing projects. They will absolutely... If daddy Jensen is not handing out candy, they will absolutely curtail some of their projects in the out years.”at 57:37
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA169 speakers · 173 bullish, 141 bearish calls
- Anthropic130 speakers · 198 bullish, 104 bearish calls
- Apple50 speakers · 62 bullish, 41 bearish calls
- OpenAI44 speakers · 19 bullish, 38 bearish calls
- Advanced Micro Devices20 speakers · 25 bullish, 1 bearish calls
- Berkshire Hathaway8 speakers · 5 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Hewlett Packard Enterprise Company4 speakers · 3 bullish, 1 bearish calls
- Astera Labs1 speaker · 1 bullish, 0 bearish calls
Topics
- AI accelerator market share
- AI trade regime
- Anthropic IPO pricing
- breakout from consolidation
- chip export controls
- circular financing unwind
- compute access and bargaining power
- compute bargaining power
- custom chip competition
- data center connectivity
- earnings-miss penalty for cheap stocks
- home-improvement demand
- housing recovery timing
- leadership succession
- market share
- market share erosion
- memory prices
- neocloud capex
- pod shop deleveraging
- position management
- post-selloff price floor
- rack-scale AI systems
- semiconductor earnings cycle
- valuation after selloff
- valuation at $6T market cap
More from The Compound and Friends
- Damn it, Jensen! With JC Parets · November 13, 2026
- Can the Stock Market Survive a Tech Meltdown? · November 10, 2026
- You Ain’t Seen Nothing Yet with Daniel Clifton · November 6, 2026
- The AI Theme Isn’t Dead, Apple and Palantir Report, Alphabet’s Very Bad Day, HALO Is Back · November 4, 2026
- The Bulls Are Trapped with Alex Altmann · October 30, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus