Talking Markets (Franklin Templeton) · · 22 min

Anatomy of a Recession: Midterms and the Economy

With Jeff Schulze

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

Franklin Templeton's Jeff Schulze argues the US economy remains in expansion, citing a Recession Risk Dashboard with 11 of 12 indicators signalling growth, record-low four-week jobless claims, and October payrolls of 165,000 that beat expectations and lifted the market to roughly a 76% chance of a December Fed hike. He credits resilient consumer spending, led by high-end households boosted by a $13 trillion rise in net worth, and expects low-end consumers to join as 2027 begins. On AI, he sees the Anthropic S-1 as bullish, with compute spend per revenue dollar falling to about 55 cents, and argues a slower Texas data center buildout would make the cycle more sustainable. He also expects midterm seasonality, broad market breadth, and earnings growth above the 10% threshold to support stocks, while warning of a near-term sell-off before a possible final capitulation, a likely post-midterm bipartisan budget deal, and a debt-ceiling fight pushed into 2027.

Key takeaways

  • Jeff Schulze on US growth & recession risk: Recession dashboard is strongly green, with 11 of 12 indicators signalling expansion despite energy and rate headwinds.
  • Jeff Schulze on US jobs & labor market: October jobs report was strong across the board, showing a sound labor market foundation.
  • Jeff Schulze on US rates & the Fed: Fed will hike again in December unless November jobs are very weak or inflation cools sharply.
  • Jeff Schulze on US consumer: The US consumer is resilient despite high energy prices and rates, led by high earners; low earners to join in 2027.
  • Jeff Schulze (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic's revenue is outgrowing compute costs, a bullish sign for AI unit economics.

What was said, by company and theme

14 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Anthropic

Across the shows: 130 speakers in other episodes, 204 bullish and 101 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)Bullish

    Anthropic's revenue is outgrowing compute costs, a bullish sign for AI unit economics.

    The S-1 gave a cleaner view of AI economics, and he came away with a glass-half-full reading. Annualised revenue run-rate was almost $70 billion, slightly below the prior quarter but strong. Customer concentration is diluting: the number of $100,000-plus customers almost doubled from June to September, from 6,000 to nearly 12,000. Revenue is growing faster than compute costs, the largest cost item. Compute spending per dollar of revenue fell from about $10 in 2023 to about $2 in the first half of last year and is now about 55 cents. He sees compute as the gating factor to profitability and says economies of scale make this very bullish for the AI ecosystem and for returns on the application layer.

    “revenues are growing faster than compute costs... compute costs are the largest cost item for Anthropic. In 2023, Anthropic spent about $10 on compute to generate each dollar of revenue... right now it's about 55¢.”at 10:29

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    S&P 500 has risen in every 12-month period after midterms since 1950, so the seasonal tailwind should persist.

    Usually the S&P 500 crawls into midterm elections, averaging about a 1.3% price return since 1950. This year it was up almost 11% year to date. Historically the most important thing has been getting through the midterms. In the twelve months after midterm elections since 1950, the index has gained an average of 15.1%, and all 19 observations were positive. He argues solid economic and earnings foundations mean this seasonal tailwind should continue, even if earnings come down somewhat because of data center delays.

    “when you go back to 1950 and the twelve months after the midterm elections, the S and P five hundred has gained an average of 15.1%. And out of those 19 observations, every single one of them produced a positive price return.”at 15:35
  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Index pullback may be setting up a final capitulation before a more durable move higher.

    The institute had been waiting for the index itself to fall in a more material way, since the damage had been concentrated beneath the surface. The index had been relatively resilient, but he now sees it pulling back. He thinks this sets the stage for a final capitulation, after which markets can move higher on a more durable basis. This is a near-term call tied to the current sell-off.

    “You've seen a lot of carnage underneath the surface. The index has been relatively resilient, and you're starting to see the index pullback. And I think this is starting to set the stage for the final capitulation”at 17:32
  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Market breadth is broadening, with equal-weight, value and most stocks outperforming, so investors should stay diversified.

    The institute has long argued for broadening market participation, and he says it is now showing up strongly. In October the equal-weighted S&P 500 outperformed the cap-weighted index by 5%, its widest monthly spread since April 2009. The Russell 1000 Value beat the Russell 1000 Growth by 10%, its widest spread since 2001. A record 76% of S&P 500 stocks beat the index, the best breadth since 1986. This supports the case for staying diversified.

    “this broadening of market participation. We're seeing it in spades. If you look back to October, the equally weighted S and P 500 outperformed the cap weighted version by 5%”at 18:02

US deficit & government debt

Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    A bipartisan grand bargain between Democrats and the White House is likely after the midterms.

    After the 2018 midterms, a bipartisan deal produced the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2019. It raised defense and nondefense spending caps, and the Congressional Budget Office raised its 10-year deficit projection by $1.7 trillion. He expects a similar trade now. Democrats would likely seek to roll back, delay or soften Medicaid and SNAP cuts from last year's One Big Beautiful Bill. Republicans would likely want more defense spending.

    “I do think that there's an opportunity for a grand bargain between the Democrats and the White House because when you go back to the first Trump administration”at 12:15
  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Debt ceiling fight likely slips to 2027, with brinkmanship and a last-minute deal.

    He doesn't see room for Republicans to raise the debt ceiling through reconciliation in the lame-duck session, with too little time left. He expects the issue to be pushed into 2027. Treasury would hit the debt limit in Q3 at some point after exhausting extraordinary measures. He expects brinkmanship and possible volatility around that time. Based on past episodes, though, he thinks policymakers will find the will to lift the limit, with a deal struck at the last minute.

    “I do think that that gets pushed to 2027, and the treasury will run into the debt limit issues in Q3 at some time after they exhaust all of the extraordinary measures”at 14:16

US growth & recession risk

Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Recession dashboard is strongly green, with 11 of 12 indicators signalling expansion despite energy and rate headwinds.

    His Recession Risk Dashboard has held a strong green signal since summer. Eleven of 12 indicators flash expansion and only one flashes recession. He argues this is the environment in which expansion generally continues, even with higher energy prices, higher long-term rates and market volatility. He singles out initial jobless claims as the top-ranked variable, with a four-week average at its lowest since 1969 and continuing claims down double digits year over year.

    “the dashboard continues to flash a very strong overall green signal... 11 are flashing green expansion, and only one is flashing red recession.”at 1:06

US jobs & labor market

Where everyone stands on US jobs & labor market

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    October jobs report was strong across the board, showing a sound labor market foundation.

    October payrolls came in at 165,000 against roughly 70,000 expected, with large upward revisions of 84,000 to prior months. Wage growth was firm and unemployment fell. Job creation averaged 137,000 over three months, well above a breakeven rate he puts at about 25,000 to 30,000 because lower immigration and early baby-boomer retirements have reduced it. Falling jobless claims support the view that the labor market has a sound base and workers are not facing layoff stress.

    “The print was strong from top to bottom. Payrolls came in at a 165,000 versus 70,000 expected.”at 2:27

US rates & the Fed

Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Fed will hike again in December unless November jobs are very weak or inflation cools sharply.

    December hike expectations had fallen on fears of a slower AI buildout, but after the strong October jobs report the market moved to about a 76% chance of a hike. Given the labour market strength, he expects another hike in December. The only exceptions he names are a very negative November jobs release or a severe cooling in inflation, and he says that outcome is not his base case.

    “I think that we are gonna get another hike in December barring a really negative November jobs release or a severe cooling and inflation, which is not my base case.”at 3:32

US consumer

Where everyone stands on US consumer

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    The US consumer is resilient despite high energy prices and rates, led by high earners; low earners to join in 2027.

    Control-group retail sales have grown at a 5.2% annualised trend over six months, and Q3 consumer spending rose 3.8% annualised. Many expected the consumer to struggle with high energy costs and long-term rates, but spending has held. He credits high-end consumers, whose spending rises with net worth; household net worth jumped $13 trillion in Q2 alone. He expects the low-end consumer to join more aggressively as 2027 begins, since their earnings growth is stronger than that of middle- and high-end consumers. Relief on energy prices would help them further.

    “A lot of people were expecting the consumer to be struggling in this environment of energy and higher long term interest rates, and the consumer really hasn't batted an eye, and I find that very encouraging.”at 4:14

US elections & politics

Where everyone stands on US elections & politics

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Democratic midterm sweep was bigger than markets priced, and governor changes could slow data center buildout.

    He expected a Democratic House majority that could reach about 260 seats and a Senate of 54 seats with potentially two more. The scale surprised him most. Democrats also won Texas, Ohio, Georgia and Nevada, and he does not think markets priced in the breadth of the sweep. He argues that the change of governors in key states could affect the data center buildout expected over the next couple of years. Trump still holds the veto, so federal policy changes are unlikely without agreement, and the bigger market effect is at the state level.

    “I think that is what surprised me the most. I mean, the Democrats are gonna have a large majority in the house depending on how these uncalled races go.”at 5:17

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    A slower data center buildout would make the AI cycle more sustainable and limit the eventual bust.

    Texas, with 27% of US data center projects by gigawatts, elected a governor who campaigned on a moratorium on new data center approvals until the legislature sets rules. He argues a slower pace would make the cycle more sustainable. AI capex may grow more slowly, but overall scale will not, because compute demand remains huge. A smaller boom means a smaller bust when overcapacity arrives. Even halving AI capex next year, which he does not expect, would shave about 40 basis points off GDP. A 20% equity correction, also not his base case, would cut consumer spending by about half a point, so together the hit stays under 1% of GDP. He sees the real risk in 2028 and 2029 projects. Democrats' push for local community benefits may raise costs and timelines but should extend the cycle.

    “I don't view it as a negative. I actually think that this is a positive development because it makes the cycle more sustainable”at 7:41

Tariffs & trade policy

Where everyone stands on Tariffs & trade policy

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Tariffs are a known quantity with little meaningful economic impact, even with a 1–2 point increase coming.

    A Section 301 investigation into excess capacity is expected to conclude over the next couple of quarters. He expects it to affect a handful of countries and likely raise the tariff rate by a percentage point or two. He argues tariffs are already well understood, and companies have adapted to them remarkably well. He does not think they meaningfully affect the economy, and he says the same holds for trade policy more broadly. The main lever for Democrats would be the USMCA talks with Canada, where border states are suffering.

    “When that does, you are gonna see that affect a handful of countries and likely increase the tariff rate by a percentage point or two. But I think the key takeaway here is that even with that backdrop, tariffs are a known quantity.”at 13:15

Earnings & corporate profits

Where everyone stands on Earnings & corporate profits

  • Jeff Schulze · ClearBridge Investments (Franklin Templeton)

    Earnings growth above 10% after the peak supports stocks, and consensus is well above that threshold.

    Since 1980, peaks in earnings growth have been followed by very different market outcomes depending on what came next. When growth after the peak exceeded 10%, forward 12-month S&P 500 returns averaged 19.6%. Below that threshold they averaged 6.1%. Consensus expects earnings growth of almost double the 10% threshold. He says even if estimates are cut because of the data center delays, earnings will still clear the threshold, which supports a constructive view.

    “if you've had really strong earnings growth after that peak, that has given you a very different market experience... Forward twelve month returns for the S and P five hundred has been 19.6. If you've been below that 10% earnings growth threshold... twelve month returns have been 6.1%.”at 16:42

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • Anthropic130 speakers · 204 bullish, 101 bearish calls

Ask your AI who they are and what they said

Topics

  • bipartisan budget deal
  • compute cost per revenue dollar
  • consumer resilience
  • data center buildout pace
  • debt ceiling
  • earnings growth after peak
  • market breadth
  • midterm election results
  • midterm seasonality
  • near-term sell-off
  • payrolls and labor market strength
  • rate hikes
  • recession risk dashboard
  • tariff economic impact

More from Talking Markets (Franklin Templeton)

All Talking Markets (Franklin Templeton) episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus