CNBC Closing Bell · · 52 min
AI Sell-Off, Nasdaq Rout and Bitcoin Breakdown
With Cameron Dawson, Courtney Garcia, Jeremy Siegel, Katie Stockton, Kevin Gordon, Malcolm Ethridge
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
CNBC's Closing Bell panel dissected a sharp AI-led sell-off that hit the Nasdaq and Bitcoin, with Nvidia accounting for close to a quarter of the S&P 500's decline. Courtney Garcia and Jeremy Siegel framed the drop as a pullback within a longer bull market, citing resilient consumer data, falling gasoline prices, a 10-year Treasury yield just under 5%, and forced deleveraging from margin calls and trend-following selling. Cameron Dawson and Katie Stockton were more cautious, arguing that 2027-28 earnings estimates are too high and that any near-term bounce should be treated as countertrend and a selling opportunity. Kevin Gordon and Malcolm Etheridge stressed the duration of the sell-off, its potential to erode household wealth-effect spending, and the reset in AI expectations, while Tania McHeal described Bitcoin as trading like a risk asset with heavy long liquidations.
Key takeaways
- Courtney Garcia on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility: Retail and institutional deleveraging will continue as markets fall, with year-end tax-loss selling adding pressure.
- Malcolm Ethridge (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's earnings call ended hopes for a second act from Jensen Huang, resetting AI trade expectations.
- Tanaya Macheel (bullish on Bitcoin): Many expect Bitcoin to get through the winter and enter a bull market in 2027.
- Oliver Renick (neutral on Anthropic): Anthropic options will be very expensive and in inelastic demand given its and overall market volatility.
- Katie Stockton (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia broke its long-term uptrend; rallies are countertrend and may offer selling opportunities near term.
What was said, by company and theme
33 views from 8 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 179 speakers in other episodes, 187 bullish and 186 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Malcolm Ethridge · Capital Area Planning GroupBearish
Nvidia's earnings call ended hopes for a second act from Jensen Huang, resetting AI trade expectations.
Etheridge says the sell-off reflects both a valuation reset and an expectations reset. He says investors were holding onto hope the AI leader would return to the helm, but Nvidia's earnings call made clear there will not be a second act from Jensen Huang. Once that hope faded, downward pressure on the stock set in and has not reversed, which he sees as resetting the AI trade.
“And so I think, yes, the reset in valuation multiples, but I think also it's reset in expectations of where we go from here as far as the AI trade is concerned.”at 5:48
Katie Stockton · Fairlead StrategiesBearish
Nvidia broke its long-term uptrend; rallies are countertrend and may offer selling opportunities near term.
Nvidia's contribution to today's decline was close to a quarter of the S&P 500 decline. The stock has broken down below key chart support and its long-term uptrend dating to the 2022 lows, so relief rallies now count as countertrend and are better selling opportunities. Sentiment is extreme, and a deep decline with this much downside momentum could snap back quickly in the short term from a contrarian view.
“So I do think that's the stock to watch still from a bottom up perspective, and it has broken down below some key support on the chart, meaning that it has broken its long term uptrend going back to the 2022 lows.”at 47:24
Bitcoin
Across the shows: 31 speakers in other episodes, 28 bullish and 15 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Bitcoin
Tanaya Macheel · CNBCNeutral
Bitcoin trades as a risk asset day to day, selling off with equities as liquidity tightens and leverage unwinds.
McHeal argues that despite the digital gold narrative, Bitcoin usually trades like a risk asset day to day. It sells off with equities when liquidity tightens, the dollar strengthens and leveraged positions unwind. She points to more than $500 million in long liquidations in four hours as evidence of this forced-selling mechanism.
“Bitcoin still can and usually does trade more like a risk asset day to day. So it sells off with equities as liquidity tightens, the dollar strengthens, and of course, as leverage positions unwind.”at 24:42
Tanaya Macheel · CNBCBullish
Many expect Bitcoin to get through the winter and enter a bull market in 2027.
McHeal says many investors remain bullish that Bitcoin will get through the current rocky transition from winter to summer. She expects a bull market in 2027 and believes concerns about the sell-off will fade as that happens. She acknowledges the current winter may last a while, so the view is for a recovery later rather than immediately.
“I think many are still bullish that we are going to get through this rocky transition from winter to summer, that we're gonna see a bull market in 2027.”at 27:25
Anthropic
Across the shows: 154 speakers in other episodes, 271 bullish and 136 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Anthropic
Oliver Renick · CNBCNeutral
Anthropic options will be very expensive and in inelastic demand given its and overall market volatility.
Anthropic had a 20% swing in the stock yesterday and is down about 10% now, making it a textbook case for hedging tools. Options expected to begin trading Monday will be extremely expensive because Anthropic's volatility is massive and overall market volatility is also huge. Demand will be inelastic, both from Anthropic employees and from everyone clamoring for options of all forms.
“Ant options will be extremely expensive, not just because anthropic's volatility is massive, but because market volatility overall is also now huge.”at 46:02
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Courtney Garcia · Payne Capital Management
The sell-off looks like a pullback within a longer bull market, not the start of a recession.
Garcia says the sell-off is not overly negative. Staples and healthcare are still up for the year, so the decline is not broad-based and investors are rotating rather than leaving equities. She notes that corrections of this size happen roughly every year. Given the positive underlying economic data, she sees this as a pullback in a longer bull market, not the beginning of a recession.
“But I think this is not overly negative. ... So I would actually see that this is much more of a pullback in a longer term bull market as opposed to the beginning of a recession.”at 4:22
Courtney Garcia · Payne Capital Management
Investors are rotating into value, energy, commodities and old-economy names, which have outperformed growth this year.
Garcia points out that value indexes have far outperformed, still up about 12% year to date while growth is down. Energy and commodities are also doing well, and older-economy companies have held up better this year. She argues this rotation is why investors should stay diversified across sectors, including within tech, between software and semis.
“Your value indexes have way outperformed. They're still up like 12% year to date, even though your growth is down.”at 16:11
Cameron Dawson · NewEdge Wealth
The market is oversold enough for a tradable short-term bounce, though not the ultimate low.
Dawson sees the market as externally and internally oversold, with RSIs low and a falling share of stocks above their 50- and 20-day averages. VIX spiking above 36 and a surge in put-call ratio show fear and indiscriminate selling. She expects a tradable bounce in the very short term, but does not think this is the ultimate low.
“I do think that we are oversold enough for some kind of tactical or tradable low in the market, at least in the very short term.”at 30:17
Kevin Gordon · Charles Schwab (Schwab Center for Financial Research)
Valuations are a poor market-timing tool, and tech-driven multiple compression weakens the valuation support case.
Gordon notes that almost 80% of the S&P 500's P/E decline this year has come from tech, and tech also drives most earnings growth. If next year's estimates must come down, concentrated in tech, valuations are a weaker argument for support. Historically, valuations have had no reliable relationship with one-year forward returns, making them a poor timing tool for a bounce.
“I think nothing has been a worse market timing tool than valuations because there is really no relationship between, you know, the one year forward performance...”at 33:39
Kevin Gordon · Charles Schwab (Schwab Center for Financial Research)
Bear market duration matters more than magnitude, given households' equity exposure now exceeds the 2000 peak.
Households' exposure to the stock market is now well beyond where it was at the 2000 peak. That exposure helps the economy when stocks are rising, but a protracted sell-off, especially amid already weak real wage growth, would start to erode economic growth. Duration of the sell-off therefore matters more than its size.
“That's why I think that duration matters a lot more than magnitude for bear markets in general. Because of that exposure that households have to the market, you're well beyond where you were at the peak in 2000.”at 39:15
Katie Stockton · Fairlead Strategies
Nasdaq 100 in pending breakdown; a rebound next week, with Thanksgiving seasonality, would bode well for year-end.
The Nasdaq 100 is in a pending breakdown that is widespread, though still localized to the AI trade. Oversold readings are widespread on a short-term basis, and Thanksgiving seasonality is typically positive. A rebound starting next week would show a reaction to those oversold conditions and would bode well for a strong finish to the year, allowing hedges to be put on and better selling in broken segments. Without that, the breakdown is more likely to persist.
“I think it's key that we see a rebound initiate next week. It doesn't have to be a huge rebound, but there are typically positive seasonal influences around the Thanksgiving holiday for one, and that would show a reaction to the oversold indications that we do have”at 49:25
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
Trend-following and margin calls on leveraged investors are amplifying the sell-off through forced selling.
Siegel argues the sell-off is being made worse by trend-following investors who sell as soon as prices break their trend lines. Leveraged investors also get margin calls from their brokers, which forces more selling. Together these mechanisms perpetuate the downturn in a week like this one.
“They have their trend lines. They've written it up, and as soon as it goes down, they're selling, and they're selling, and they're selling... Everyone who's leveraged gets a call from their broker. You need margin.”at 3:14
Courtney Garcia · Payne Capital Management
Retail and institutional deleveraging will continue as markets fall, with year-end tax-loss selling adding pressure.
Garcia argues the sell-off is being amplified by deleveraging happening across both retail and institutional investors. She expects this unwind to continue as prices fall further. She adds that Nasdaq losses for the year could trigger tax-loss selling into year-end, which would add more pressure.
“Yeah, I think that's happening both on the retail and the institutional level, right? So that's kind of happening across the board where you are going to see this deleveraging. And as the markets go down further, you're going to start to see some of that unwind.”at 3:54
Oliver Renick · CNBC
VVIX must spike to signal a proper volatility flush; it has not yet.
Renick notes VIX has been tracking the S&P one-to-one as stocks make new lows, but VVIX, the volatility of VIX, has been sluggish and under its monthly highs. This divergence can be read two ways. He leans toward the view that VVIX has to pop sharply to mark a true capitulation flush, which has not happened yet.
“but I think the price action makes me see the other version of the picture, which is that we probably wanna see VVX really pop in order to signal a proper flush.”at 21:00
Kevin Gordon · Charles Schwab (Schwab Center for Financial Research)
Positioning has not washed out; retail kept buying AI names indiscriminately, so a durable bounce needs a washout.
Gordon says after the post-election drawdown there was no real sentiment washout. Retail investors in particular kept adding to AI-related names on weakness, and their net buying was among the strongest seen. He will watch whether positioning clears after the close. He argues a true positioning washout is the condition needed for a more durable bounce.
“you had seen not a sentiment washout in positioning. There was actually, especially within the retail cohort, a lot of adding into that weakness, but kind of indiscriminately.”at 34:40
Kevin Gordon · Charles Schwab (Schwab Center for Financial Research)
Margin debt's year-over-year growth has peaked and is rolling over from extreme optimism, a weaker-returns signal.
Gordon says the level of margin debt is not the warning sign people usually cite. The useful signal is the change on a year-over-year or fifteen-month basis, which has peaked and is rolling over from extreme optimism. That pattern has historically been consistent with weaker returns and extended weakness, and he is watching whether it signals a cyclical bear market.
“when you do look at the year to year change or we like to look at it on a fifteen month change basis, that has peaked and is starting to roll over from this extreme optimism territory into a zone that is typically consistent with weaker returns.”at 36:48
US consumer
Where everyone stands on US consumer
Courtney Garcia · Payne Capital Management
Consumers keep spending despite weak sentiment, with balance sheets healthy, which should support the economy.
Garcia cites recent retail sales, retailer earnings and bank commentary showing consumer balance sheets are in generally good shape. She acknowledges consumer sentiment is poor but says spending continues anyway. Because consumers make up a large share of US GDP, she expects spending to continue unless it changes in the near term, which would keep the economy going into the holiday season.
“The consumer doesn't feel good, but that doesn't mean they're not spending. And I think that's something that probably will continue unless we see that change in the near term.”at 10:12
Malcolm Ethridge · Capital Area Planning Group
Consumer spending is increasingly funded by borrowing rather than cash flow, which is a concern for capacity to spend.
Etheridge separates consumer willingness to spend from capacity to spend. He says consumers remain willing to spend even though sentiment is weak, but reports suggest more of that spending is funded by borrowing rather than cash flow. If consumers lose the capacity to borrow, spending could weaken even when willingness holds, which he flags as a concern for the holiday period.
“we're hearing how much of that spending is being done on credit is being done by borrowing versus actual cash flow, and that's a bit concerning there.”at 11:36
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
Consumers saved most of the trillions in stock market capital gains rather than spending them.
Siegel cites a study by Jason Furman finding that consumers surprisingly spent very little of the trillions of dollars in capital gains from the last three or four years of the bull market. Instead they largely held the money in accounts. He hopes this means the current decline will not dent Christmas spending.
“That consumers really surprisingly spent very little of those... All those capital gains, which is trillions of dollars. And that... they've basically held it in their account, saved it.”at 12:59
Cameron Dawson · NewEdge Wealth
Consumer spending rests on the stock-market wealth effect; a protracted bear market would weigh on consumption.
Real income growth has been negative because incomes have not kept pace with inflation, yet real spending growth has been strongly positive. Dawson attributes that gap to the wealth effect from strong equity markets. If a protracted bear market removes that boost, consumption would likely weaken.
“We've been in a world where real income growth has been negative. Effectively, consumers' incomes are not keeping pace with overall inflation, ... but real spending growth has been really positive. The gap between those two, we think it's the wealth effect.”at 38:44
US growth & recession risk
Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
Siegel doesn't see a recession in the cards, citing solid jobless claims and ADP data.
Siegel points to economic data such as jobless claims and the weekly ADP reports, which he says have been good and strong. Combined with lower gasoline prices, he sees no recession in the cards. He thinks the market turmoil is not yet signalling an economic downturn.
“I don't see a recession, in the cards.”at 18:57
Kevin Gordon · Charles Schwab (Schwab Center for Financial Research)
A prolonged sell-off could push the economy to weaken by late 2027 amid monetary and fiscal tightening.
Markets are not currently pricing an imminent economic cliff. But if the sell-off lasts long enough, it could erode economic growth, and the economy could start to weaken and buckle into the back half of 2027. The risk is amplified because the economy faces both monetary tightening and fiscal tightening.
“But if it lasts long enough, you could certainly find yourself in a position, well into maybe the back half of twenty twenty seven where the economy does start to weaken and buckle a little bit, especially because you've got monetary tightening, but you also have fiscal tightening as well.”at 39:45
Oil & fuels
Where everyone stands on Oil & fuels
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
Gasoline falling about a dollar and diesel 60 cents is a tailwind putting money in consumers' pockets.
Siegel points to gasoline prices heading about a dollar below where they were two months ago, with diesel down 60 cents. He calls this one of two good tailwinds coming up. He expects the lower pump prices to put hundreds of dollars into many consumers' pockets, cushioning the stock market decline and supporting holiday spending.
“We have gasoline prices that are headed to a dollar lower than they were just two months ago, even diesel down 60¢.”at 8:33
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
The 10-year yield falling below 5% is a relief that lets stocks, especially non-AI names, rise again.
Siegel is pleased the 10-year Treasury yield has finally fallen below 5%, to about 4.92%. He argues stocks can only rise if interest rates are not as high as they have been recently. He expects the yield to stabilise, which would let the broader market, including non-AI stocks, recover.
“I was very pleased to see the interest rate finally crack below the ten year five percent [4.92%]. ... But they can only go up, I think, if those interest rates are not as high as they've been recently.”at 8:46
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
A 50 basis point Fed hike is dead; a 25 basis point hike is likely and the market could handle it.
Siegel says the 50 basis point hike Governor Waller floated a few days earlier is off the table in his view. He expects the Fed will probably move 25 basis points instead, and he thinks the market could absorb a move of that size. He ties this to the drop in long-term yields, which he is pleased to see.
“My opinion is that 50 basis point hike that Waller was talking about a few days ago, that I think is dead. ... I do think they'll probably be 25, and I think the market could stand that.”at 8:46
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Malcolm Ethridge · Capital Area Planning Group
AI infrastructure build-out spending accounts for about three-quarters of US GDP growth this year.
Etheridge says an estimate puts roughly three-quarters of this year's GDP growth as coming from spending to build out AI infrastructure. From this he argues investors should keep focusing on AI-related spending and current-quarter earnings as the main driver of the market, both down and up.
“it's estimated something like three quarters of all of our GDP growth this year has come from things related to spending to build out AI infrastructure.”at 12:08
Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Where everyone stands on Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Malcolm Ethridge · Capital Area Planning Group
Anthropic's roughly $8 million revenue per employee sets the enterprise AI productivity benchmark companies must match.
Etheridge cites Anthropic generating about $8 million in revenue per full-time employee. He says this is the productivity standard now set inside the enterprise. Companies spending hundreds of millions to infuse AI across their workforces will need to show tangible productivity gains they can report on earnings calls.
“We look at Anthropic, and they're doing something like $8,000,000 in revenue per full time employee. That is the standard that's been set in terms of productivity inside of the enterprise.”at 17:11
Private credit
Where everyone stands on Private credit
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
Widening hyperscaler CDS stresses private credit pricing, but most of it will be fine without a recession.
Siegel points to rising CDS rates on hyperscalers and other AI build-out companies, which pressures private credit pricing. He does not expect investors to get all their money back at par in every case. But he argues most private credit will hold up as long as there is no recession, since recessions are usually the big test for private credit.
“they've gone up, which, of course, puts stress on the pricing of a private credit... But I think most of it will be fine as long as we don't have a recession.”at 18:41
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Jeremy Siegel · WisdomTree
Expectations of 15-20% annual AI-driven returns are unrealistic versus the long-run stock market average.
Siegel says the long-run average annual stock market return is about [8 to 9%]. He argues that investors came to believe 15 to 20% a year would be normal because of AI, which he calls unrealistic. He says expectations must come down to reality, which is part of why the market is repricing.
“We had people began to think that 15 to 20 was gonna be the norm with AI. And we have to bring that down to reality.”at 19:28
Bitcoin & crypto markets
Where everyone stands on Bitcoin & crypto markets
Tanaya Macheel · CNBC
Bitcoin treasury companies that copied Strategy last summer may now be in trouble.
McHeal notes that many companies copied Strategy's bitcoin treasury approach in summer 2025. She argues those copycats are the ones most at risk in this downturn. Strategy, by contrast, holds far more bitcoin than any other treasury company and is taking steps to serve shareholders beyond bitcoin price gains.
“last summer [2025], you did see all of these companies come out trying to copy that strategy. And those are the ones that might be a little bit in trouble here.”at 26:44
Earnings & corporate profits
Where everyone stands on Earnings & corporate profits
Cameron Dawson · NewEdge Wealth
2027 and 2028 earnings estimates look too high, and the market is pricing in future cuts.
Dawson argues 2027 and 2028 earnings estimates are too high, and that the market is already signalling this. The S&P 500 trades at about 17 times and semiconductors at about 14 times, multiples that usually occur when investors expect earnings cuts. Her lesson from past sell-offs is to buy only once estimates actually start being cut, which is why she expects further lows.
“It's probably not the ultimate low is how we would assess things. When we look at earnings estimates for 2027 and 2028, they look too high, and the market is actually telling you today that they are too high.”at 31:42
Consumer & retail
Where everyone stands on Consumer & retail
Cameron Dawson · NewEdge Wealth
Hotels, leisure and cruise stocks are holding up; consumers may have a better year if rates and oil ease.
Hotels, leisure and cruise line stocks are not breaking down like other parts of the market, which is the silver lining in this sell-off. Dawson reads this as the market pricing in possible rate relief and oil relief, which could let consumers have a better year after underperforming under inflationary pressure.
“So it seems like the market is saying, hey. If we get some rate relief, we get some oil relief, maybe consumers can have a better year after underperforming so much under these inflationary pressures.”at 38:25
AI chips & semiconductors
Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors
Katie Stockton · Fairlead Strategies
Semiconductor sector's long-term uptrend is broken; rallies are countertrend, offering selling opportunities.
The breakdown is widespread across the AI trade, and Stockton says it changes the paradigm for the semiconductor sector. Rallies from here should be treated as countertrend and as better selling opportunities than the downdraft. Only later, on a downdraft, might it be an opportunity to add long-term exposure back to semiconductors.
“And now we have to think about relief rallies as countertrend, meaning they will present a better selling opportunity as opposed to looking at this downdraft ... perhaps as an opportunity to add long term exposure back to the semiconductor space.”at 47:38
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
Topics
- 10-year Treasury yield
- 2027-28 earnings estimates
- AI capex and GDP growth
- AI return expectations
- AI trade expectations reset
- Bitcoin as risk asset
- Bitcoin bull market outlook
- Fed hike expectations
- Nasdaq breakdown and rebound timing
- VIX of VIX and capitulation
- bear market duration
- bitcoin treasury companies
- capital gains spending
- consumer credit-funded spending
- consumer discretionary leisure stocks
- consumer spending resilience
- deleveraging and tax-loss selling
- enterprise AI productivity
- forced deleveraging
- gasoline prices as consumer tailwind
- margin debt
- options volatility and hedging demand
- private credit risk from recession
- pullback vs bull market
- recession odds
- recession risk from prolonged sell-off
- retail positioning washout
- sector rotation into value
- semiconductor trend
- short-term tradable bounce
- technical breakdown
- valuations as market-timing signal
- wealth effect and consumer spending
More from CNBC Closing Bell
- Anthropic’s Record IPO, AI Selloff and Market Rout · November 20, 2026
- Anthropic IPO, AI Trade Reset and Market Sell-Off on Closing Bell · November 19, 2026
- Nvidia Slumps, Anthropic IPO Looms and Markets Test Key Levels · November 19, 2026
- Anthropic IPO, NVIDIA CEO Search and AI Trade · November 18, 2026
- NVIDIA Earnings Beat, SEC Probe and AI Trade Reset · November 17, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus