CNBC Closing Bell · · 50 min

NVIDIA Earnings Beat, SEC Probe and AI Trade Reset

With Amit Daryanani, Cody Acree, Gene Munster, Jimmy Chang, Stephanie Link

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

CNBC's Closing Bell dissected Nvidia's latest earnings beat, with guidance of roughly $130 billion (plus or minus 3%) landing near consensus, alongside an SEC investigation report and an interim CEO transition that has clouded the outlook. Gene Munster argued the SEC probe is likely to bring shareholder lawsuits but is mostly noise, that China's roughly 10% revenue share is a manageable export-curb risk, and that the real long-term question is who can replace Jensen Huang's urgency, with the board's stance on his possible return a key swing factor for the stock. Stephanie Link and Mike Santoli were more cautious: Link saw strong fundamentals and a cheap valuation near 7.7x fiscal 2028 earnings but expected the stock to stay capped near term, preferring Broadcom and Micron, while Santoli questioned whether Nvidia's total addressable market is smaller than believed and noted the S&P was closing near its 200-day average with volatility above 25. Jimmy Chang and Cody Acree broadened the discussion to AI infrastructure, warning that financing, not compute, is now the main bottleneck for data center build-out, with neoclouds and second-tier builders most exposed if Nvidia or Broadcom stop backstopping loans.

Key takeaways

  • Jimmy Chang (uncertain on NVIDIA): Nvidia's guidance is unlikely to be cut, but an overhang remains until its financing plan is reviewed.
  • Michael Santoli (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's addressable market is smaller than thought, and it may not get the benefit of the doubt.
  • Gene Munster (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's AI chip demand is still early and will be stronger than investors believe, driving numbers higher.
  • Stephanie Link (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's fundamentals are strong, with 90% earnings and 91% revenue growth and high gross margins.
  • Cody Acree (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's quarter was solid across the board, with about $6B upside on beat and guide.

What was said, by company and theme

24 views from 6 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 165 speakers in other episodes, 159 bullish and 132 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • Jimmy Chang · Rockefeller Capital ManagementUncertain

    Nvidia's guidance is unlikely to be cut, but an overhang remains until its financing plan is reviewed.

    Chang says the stock's trading implies the market expects Nvidia to lower guidance. He doubts that will happen because the interim CEO took over only a few days ago and is unlikely to change guidance. Still, guidance and the financing plan, which is under review, remain overhangs, so volatility could continue near term.

    “The way NVIDIA is trading implies that the market expects it to lower the guidance, which I doubt it will happen because the interim CEO just took over a few days ago, so it's unlikely to change the guidance. So that remains an overhang.”at 7:35
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementNeutral

    SEC probe into Nvidia's disclosures is expected and likely noise; misleading investors seems hard to imagine.

    Munster calls the reported SEC investigation an expected outcome that will likely bring shareholder lawsuits. He finds it very hard to see how the company misled investors, and says that if there were a misleading issue, it would probably relate to China revenue share. He views this as ambulance-chasing and pure noise relative to the central questions about demand and leadership.

    “I think that this was an expected kind of outcome. You're probably gonna see shareholder lawsuits. ... I think it's very difficult for me to imagine that the company somehow misled investors.”at 10:52
  • Michael Santoli · CNBCBearish

    Nvidia's addressable market is smaller than thought, and it may not get the benefit of the doubt.

    Santoli says that compared with a few weeks ago, it is hard to avoid the idea that the total addressable market for Nvidia across the world is smaller than believed. Financing may also be harder than expected. With regulatory and judicial challenges ahead, the company will be playing defense for a while and may not get the benefit of the doubt.

    “it's hard to avoid the idea that the total addressable market in all parts of the world is not as big as we thought it was. Maybe things will be more difficult to finance than we thought before.”at 11:59
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish

    Nvidia's AI chip demand is still early and will be stronger than investors believe, driving numbers higher.

    Munster argues that AI adoption is still very early, which means the demand curve will be much better than investors believe. If so, Nvidia should be able to keep driving its numbers much higher over the next few quarters. He is not concerned about demand per se, though he will wait to see the guidance.

    “I think that the demand curve is gonna be much better than what, ultimately investors believe. And if that's the case, I think that they'll be able to continue to drive these numbers much higher over the next few quarters.”at 12:52
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementNeutral

    Nvidia's China and Asia exposure is about 10% of revenue; the accounting change is housekeeping, not a red flag.

    Munster says Nvidia rolled its Singapore disclosure into another segment. China was just over 8% of revenue last quarter, and Taiwan and other just under 2%, so the region is about 10%. He sees the change as good housekeeping, not suspicious. The real risk is export curbs cutting into that 10%. Even so, cutting it substantially would take calendar 2027 growth from about 70% to about 50%, which he considers highly unlikely.

    “from my perspective, I didn't feel like it was anything that was suspicious. My sense was that it was just kind of good housekeeping around that segment.”at 14:11
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementUncertain

    Nvidia is well placed for two years, but after that a CEO lacking Huang's urgency could fade the company.

    Munster says the next two years are in a great position because AI is early. The real risk is years two through five: if the next CEO lacks Huang's sense of urgency, generational tech companies start to fade into the background. He calls the ability to fill that role the leap of faith and says the Huang question is much more important than the current headlines.

    “The next two years are in a great position. The risk, the part you need to close your eyes about, is what happens in years two through five. If in fact we get a CEO that doesn't have that urgency that Jensen has, that can impact...”at 16:57
  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish

    Nvidia's fundamentals are strong, with 90% earnings and 91% revenue growth and high gross margins.

    Link says the earnings fundamentals are strong: about 90% earnings growth, 91% revenue growth, and 98% data center revenue growth. Gross margins have been de-risked in the 70s, and she expects roughly $50 billion of free cash flow on the way to $300 billion. She adds that the stock could bounce on good fundamentals, though the guidance and leadership issues dominate the stock's reaction.

    “the earnings fundamentals are gonna be strong, as Jean just mentioned. You're talking about 90% earnings growth, 91% revenue growth, data center revenue growth of 98%.”at 19:59
  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish

    Nvidia trades at 7.7 times fiscal 2028 numbers, cheap enough that she is very interested in buying.

    Link argues that at about 7.7 times fiscal 2028 earnings, the stock is cheap and the valuation case is clear. She is very interested in buying it. Her hesitation is about the short-term catalyst and opportunity cost versus other cheap names like Broadcom and Micron, not the valuation itself.

    “I mean, you're talking about 7.7 times their fiscal twenty eight numbers ... you can take that to the bank to be honest with you. So I'm very interested in buying it.”at 20:47
  • Michael Santoli · CNBCUncertain

    Nvidia's Q4 guidance is only a marginal nominal raise, suggesting less aggressive outlook than past quarters.

    Santoli notes the $130 billion guidance, plus or minus 3%, sits just around consensus and is a marginal nominal increase. Nvidia has routinely raised guidance above consensus and there was a buy-side whisper number, so relative to past quarters it does not appear to be pushing the outlook as hard.

    “130 plus or minus 3% is just a marginal nominal increase in guidance... maybe relative to some past quarters, they're not really pushing the outlook as aggressively as they have before.”at 23:10
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish

    Nvidia giving guidance without a settled CEO is a strong endorsement; the stock should move higher.

    Munster says it is hard to imagine an interim CEO putting her name behind guidance when it is unclear who the CEO will be. That shows strong confidence in the business, given the turmoil of the last 24 hours around the export curbs. He also expects the board might join the call and give some clarity on the CEO search, which would reassure investors.

    “I couldn't imagine a scenario where it makes sense for [Kress] to stand up and put her name behind guidance because it's unclear who the CEO is going to be. ... I would expect the stock to move higher based just on that alone.”at 23:50
  • Cody Acree · StoneXBullish

    Nvidia's quarter was solid across the board, with about $6B upside on beat and guide.

    Acree says the report was solid across all elements, with about $6 billion of upside on the beat and on the guide. Gross margin came in almost a full point better than expected. He notes that the board and succession questions will still dominate the discussion, though the numbers themselves are strong.

    “it's really solid across the board, upside by nearly 6,000,000,000 on the beat and on the guide, very solid, across all elements. Gross margin was better than we thought by almost a full point.”at 25:02
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish

    Nvidia's circular financing of data center buyers is reasonable and will continue; it anchors other money.

    Munster argues that Nvidia acts as an anchor bringing in other money to buy data center capacity, and about half of that spending flows back as Nvidia revenue. Any rational manager or CEO would keep the program going. Putting in $200 billion could draw roughly $800 billion more, so the program more than pays for itself, and dropping it would be a disservice.

    “it is totally reasonable that NVIDIA will continue to do these. If you think about what they do, they're the anchor that brings in other money, that buys a lot of data center, that they get half of that revenue from.”at 28:10
  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBearish

    Nvidia stock is capped near term by guidance, leadership uncertainty and investigations, despite strong fundamentals.

    Link says the reaction depends on guidance, leadership timing, the investigations and a new export control oversight committee, none of which will be resolved soon. Even though the stock is down about 35% from its highs, she thinks it is capped in the near term. Broadcom and Micron, which are cleaner stories, are down more and may be better places to own.

    “We just have to get through blue wave. We have to get through the noise of what's happening internally at this company. And that's why I think that this stock is capped.”at 30:34
  • Michael Santoli · CNBCBullish

    Nvidia's $4.4B capex is trivial, and it benefits as others spend heavily on capex.

    Santoli points out that Nvidia's capex of about $4.4 billion is trivial next to its revenue. He calls it a great business because it is the main beneficiary of other companies spending heavily on capex, much like Apple in past years, which did not need to spend as much.

    “It's kind of funny because they're the massive beneficiary of everybody else, kind of spending hand over fist on CapEx.”at 36:22
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish

    Nvidia's stock should rise 5-10% on the results, but leadership worries are muting the reaction.

    Munster argues that on the fundamentals alone the stock should be up probably 5-10%. It is only up about 3.5% after hours because investors are worried about the board's stance on Jensen Huang, a concern that is pulling the reaction down.

    “I mean, if you just take this in a vacuum, the stock should be up probably five to 10% just given all the variables here.”at 36:58
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBearish

    If the board closes the door on Jensen Huang returning, Nvidia's stock falls.

    Munster argues the letter in which Huang says he is open to returning was probably cleared with the board, so the board may not be ruling it out. The board has long tenure (average about 18 years against roughly eight for typical boards), so he thinks the lawyers and board are not fully disconnected from Huang. Munster says investors want Huang back and the stock has a bid tied to that. If the board rejects his return, he sees that as a negative signal about the company culture and the stock would fall, though he notes founder-led urgency could also explain it.

    “I do believe that investors want him to come back. And if they close that door, the stock is going lower.”at 38:32

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Jimmy Chang · Rockefeller Capital Management

    Deferred data center projects could hit picks-and-shovels orders; Nvidia's funding backstops matter for smaller builders.

    Chang argues that if most of the AI data center projects are deferred rather than canceled, there could be order risk several quarters out for picks-and-shovels providers, and neocloud and related suppliers sold off after the election. He also calls Nvidia the 'central bank of AI' that has provided funding and financial backstops to startups in open-source AI models and neoclouds. Without that backing, demand across that ecosystem could weaken several quarters out.

    “assuming some of these data center projects, most of them be deferred rather than canceled, there could be some order risk several quarters out for some of the picks and shovels providers.”at 5:37
  • Jimmy Chang · Rockefeller Capital Management

    Hyperscalers could benefit if AI spending slows, preserving cash flow and making existing data centers more valuable.

    Hyperscalers were criticized for burning cash and raising too much capital. Chang argues that if spending slows, they can preserve more cash flow, and their existing data centers become more valuable. That could make some mega-cap stocks do better than the chip and infrastructure names.

    “[they were] being criticized for burning cash and raising too much capital. Well, if things start to slow down, they can preserve more of their cash flow, and their existing data centers become more valuable.”at 9:21
  • Cody Acree · StoneX

    Financing, not compute, is becoming the data center bottleneck; second-tier neoclouds lose capital access without backstops.

    Acree says lack of financing is now the bigger bottleneck for data center build-out, not compute, memory or optical networking. Banks are sensitive to data center financing, and investors are scrutinizing cash flow and returns. Hyperscalers will slow capex growth toward the end of the decade, and neoclouds and second-tier builders are less creditworthy. Without Jensen Huang or Broadcom backstopping loans, they lose capital access and data center growth slows.

    “this lack of financing that becomes the bigger bottleneck for data center build out. ... without guys like Jensen and Broadcom backstopping and cosigning these loans, then those second and third tier investors or builders are not going to have the access to capital.”at 33:20
  • Amit Daryanani · Evercore ISI

    Neocloud demand is strong; the constraint is capacity and financing, not demand.

    Daryanani says Nvidia's commentary points to extraordinarily strong demand. He concludes neoclouds are constrained by capacity and financing, not demand, and that Nvidia's financing support addresses that. The relief in neocloud stocks reflects this. He adds that the open question is how durable the demand is. If it lasts, Nvidia and others will happily finance the deals.

    “the neo clouds are really more capacity and financing constraint, not demand constraint.”at 42:16

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Michael Santoli · CNBC

    Market lacks capitulation; relief rally possible, but the tape has lost the benefit of the doubt.

    The S&P closed near its 200-day average in a fight-or-flight posture, with volatility above 25 and no place to hide. Santoli says the market did not catch much of a bid even though tech was oversold, and capitulation has not been seen. A relief rally is possible, but the tape has lost its benefit of the doubt after missing seasonal tailwinds.

    “we didn't really catch much of a bid all day, even though in theory tech's been [oversold].”at 3:03
  • Jimmy Chang · Rockefeller Capital Management

    Healthcare and staples outperforming tech signals a defensive rotation; stock picking must be company-specific.

    Healthcare and consumer staples have outperformed technology year to date by a wide margin. Chang reads that as a defensive move in the market. Given that outperformance, investors need to be more company-specific rather than buying the sector broadly.

    “Both sectors have outperformed technology year to date by a wide margin, so it's a sign of the defensive move in the market. So you have to be more company specific given this outperformance.”at 9:47

AI bubble & tech valuations

Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations

  • Jimmy Chang · Rockefeller Capital Management

    The AI froth is out after 50%+ drawdowns; a slower, lower-amplitude boom-bust cycle is good for markets.

    Chang says many AI-linked names are down more than 50% from six months ago or from June, so the froth is out and a reset has happened. His long-standing fear was over-investment and a boom-bust cycle. If spending slows, the cycle can have a lower amplitude but last longer, which he sees as good for the market overall.

    “the froth is out. So compared to six months ago or even June of this year, so many of these names have come down more than 50%, and you get a reset. ... If you can slow things down, actually have a lower amplitude, but longer cycle, that's actually good for the market.”at 7:35

US–China AI & chip race

Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race

  • Amit Daryanani · Evercore ISI

    Blocking Chinese access to Asian clouds could free up GPU supply for US capacity.

    Daryanani says demand is stronger than supply in the US and the Western Hemisphere. If GPUs that are ending up in countries they should not reach are redirected, more capacity would become available in those markets. He calls it a secondary benefit, not a direct effect of what happens in Asia and China.

    “demand is stronger than supply in The US, Or in the Western Hemisphere. And so if I can take whatever that percent of GPUs are ending up in these countries they shouldn't have, do not go there, I could get a bit more capacity here.”at 44:08

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA165 speakers · 159 bullish, 132 bearish calls

Ask your AI who they are and what they said

Topics

  • AI chip demand
  • CEO succession
  • CEO succession and Jensen Huang's return
  • China revenue exposure
  • Nvidia valuation
  • SEC investigation
  • beat and guidance
  • chip export diversion
  • data center capex
  • data center financing
  • earnings growth
  • guidance
  • hyperscaler capex
  • near-term stock outlook
  • neocloud demand
  • post-earnings stock reaction
  • relief rally
  • sector rotation
  • valuation reset

More from CNBC Closing Bell

All CNBC Closing Bell episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus