Wealthion · · 46 min
The Bull Market May Be Over: Hedge Funds Are Already Selling | Kevin Muir
With Kevin Muir
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Kevin Muir argues the AI-led bull market may be ending, with hedge funds already degrossing: stocks they shorted, such as staples and Costco, are rallying on forced covering while the AI longs they funded fall, and XLP is at new highs despite little fundamental improvement. He contends that US earnings are inflated by hyperscaler capex, since suppliers book data-center spending as immediate revenue while buyers amortize it over about seven years, and he links Nvidia's vendor financing to dot-com-era warning signs. He expects a secular bear market as valuations reprice, with dealer short gamma and low index correlation raising downside risk. On macro, he expects the Fed to tighten into an oil supply shock from the Iran war and push the economy into recession, while gold struggles until the Fed turns dovish, and oil stays supported by strategic reserve refilling and commodity stockpiling.
Key takeaways
- Kevin Muir (bearish on Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund): Staples rally to new highs reflects short covering, not better fundamentals, and will reverse.
- Kevin Muir on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility: Hedge-fund degrossing and 2007-style quant unwinds are propping up the index and masking underlying damage.
- Kevin Muir on AI bubble & tech valuations: AI spending is inflating earnings, creating an earnings bubble that may not be sustainable.
- Kevin Muir on Gold & precious metals: Gold may struggle near term until Fed turns dovish; still bullish long term.
- Kevin Muir on Oil & fuels: Oil unlikely to return to $40–50; SPR refills create lasting demand.
What was said, by company and theme
22 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund
Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, past 30 days
Kevin Muir · The MacroTouristBearish
Staples rally to new highs reflects short covering, not better fundamentals, and will reverse.
XLP is running to new highs, and Costco is hitting highs as well, but neither business has improved much in the past month or two. Traders funding AI longs by shorting defensive names are being forced to cover, which pushed these stocks up. Muir expects the staples that were chased to fall back as the covering ends, and the index to roll over.
“XLP is running to new highs. ... Did Costco's businesses do that much better over the last, you know, month or two? No. What's happened is the stuff that these traders were funding their longs with ... they're being forced to cover.”at 3:56
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
The secular bull market is over; a multi-year bear market will reprice stocks to more appropriate levels.
Muir sees the recent Nasdaq push to new highs during the AI trade as the last gasp of the secular bull. He expects a secular bear market as valuations are repriced to more appropriate measures. He argues that the market is in an earnings bubble rather than a price bubble, so valuations look cheap only because earnings are elevated.
“So I happen to be much more in the camp that the secular bowl is over. That was the last gasp of it with the AI trade of last month when the Nasdaq, you know, punched out to new highs”at 6:19
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Index looks diversified but is concentrated in AI-linked tech; investors hold more tech than they realize.
Nine of the top 10 S&P 500 stocks are technology companies tied to the AI bubble. A Canadian adviser friend would not be allowed to build a 100-stock Nasdaq portfolio because of concentration limits. Buying QQQ or SPY is accepted as diversified, though it is the same concentrated exposure. Investors therefore carry more tech risk than they recognize.
“all you have to do is look at the top 10 stocks and realize that, you know, nine of the 10 are technology stocks that are very much tied to the AI bubble.”at 9:32
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Blue-chip brand stocks are priced for perfection, like the Nifty Fifty, and may return little for years.
Muir says the market now resembles the Nifty Fifty era, when brand-name stocks traded at extreme prices. Those stocks did not lose money, but they returned almost nothing over the following twenty years because optimism was already priced into earnings growth. Expectations were so high that even meeting them was difficult. Buying the brands for safety therefore carries the same risk.
“we're in an environment that's very much like the Nifty '50... And the reason it was zero was because there was so much optimism built into the expectations of the earnings growth”at 12:57
Gold & precious metals
Where everyone stands on Gold & precious metals
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
The People's Bank of China will keep buying gold for years or decades as a non-Western reserve asset.
After 2022, when the West froze Russia's bond reserves, China saw that its own bonds could be seized. It needs to diversify into a reserve asset that is nobody's liability, which is gold. The PBoC's reserves are huge relative to the small gold market, so it will keep accumulating gently, possibly for decades. This is the long-term bull case for gold.
“longer term, I think that the People's Bank of China will be on the bid for gold for many, many years to come, maybe decades”at 36:24
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Gold is struggling near term from higher real rates, a stronger dollar and liquidity withdrawal.
Gold traditionally moves with the US dollar and real rates. That relationship broke down in 2022, but it still matters at the margin because Western investors trade on it. Real rates are rising with the Fed talking hawkishly and the dollar has strengthened. Muir also sees liquidity tightening, citing repo trading outside the Fed's bands as a sign.
“So gold recently is struggling because not only are real rates headed higher with the Federal Reserve talking hawkishly, but the US dollar also went big.”at 37:23
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Gold may struggle near term until Fed turns dovish; still bullish long term.
Kevin sees a Fed that is getting tighter, a rising US dollar and drying-up liquidity hurting gold, which has fallen. Gold held around $4,000 to $3,950, then broke below that level. It briefly looked ready to rally back into the range, but it returned to the range instead, which he calls a failed technical signal. He had hoped for a better trade and has no short-term view, but says that long term he still loves gold. He worries the initial move lower could continue while liquidity is withdrawn. Although the People's Bank of China should be buying, it looks overwhelmed by Western investors selling. He expects gold to struggle until the Fed gets dovish. When the Fed has to shift quickly, everyone will rush into gold, which will lead the way out of the next move higher.
“And so until the Fed gets good and dovish, I think that gold might struggle.”at 40:45
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Hedge-fund degrossing and 2007-style quant unwinds are propping up the index and masking underlying damage.
Muir says the professional community is the one getting hurt and is degrossing, which resembles the 2007 quant quake. Stocks the hedge funds were short, like staples, are rallying while the AI longs they funded are falling; he cites the Goldman AI winners-versus-losers basket down about 40% and XLP at new highs. Because the professionals are chasing what they shorted, the index looks stronger than it is. He expects that as the chase fades, the index will roll over, which puts 401(k) money at more risk.
“the market is degrossing, the professionals are taking off risk, and it's making it look like the index is better than it is.”at 4:18
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Monetized hedges, short gamma and low correlation could turn a 5% pullback into a much larger sell-off.
Clients and traders monetized their puts after the month-long sell-off and then went long, so dealers are short gamma and must sell as prices fall. Stocks have been moving in low correlation, which suppresses index volatility; if correlation returns to normal, implied volatility rises and dealer hedging adds to the selling. Muir cites Vincent Deloire's estimate that at normal correlation the VIX would be 35 to 40, not 15 to 20. He still thinks about a 70% chance of a rally, but if the market rolls over it could fall well beyond 5%, with 10 to 20% possible.
“We're in the period of what's called short gamma so that the reality is that the market makers on the other side of this have to sell more as it goes down and buy more as it goes up.”at 20:09
US inflation
Where everyone stands on US inflation
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Inflation is structurally high but will surprise lower near term as the economy rolls over.
Muir believes the Fed has missed its inflation target for 68 months, so the economy has entered a sustained period of higher inflation. Within that trend, a cyclical swing is about to start. He expects inflation to surprise to the downside, but not because of productivity. It will fall because the economy is going to roll over.
“I suspect that inflation will surprise to the downside. And that not for not for good reasons, not because of productivity ... I think it's gonna swing to the downside because the economy is gonna roll over.”at 32:36
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Inflation is secular; cyclical dips will meet easy policy and reignite real-asset buying.
Kevin ties his commodity and oil views to a long-term secular inflation argument. He says that if inflation has a cyclical downdraft, policymakers will respond with easy monetary policy. That response will quickly lead to investors chasing real assets again. Investors therefore need to be nimble. The idea is that cyclical relief in inflation will not be lasting, and that the policy response will push prices of real assets higher again.
“I suspect that if we did get a cyclical downdraft in inflation, it will be met with easy monetary policy”at 44:28
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
The Fed will tighten into an oil supply shock and push the economy into recession, a classic Fed error.
The Fed has moved hawkish and put a 50 basis point hike on the table for the upcoming FOMC. Muir expects it to do what it always does and tighten into a supply shock from the war with oil, which will throw the economy into recession. He says the risk of this classic Fed error has increased tremendously.
“Looks like what I think is gonna happen is the Federal Reserve is gonna do what it always does. It's gonna tighten into a supply shock, which is the shock of the war with oil, and it's gonna throw us into a recession.”at 34:05
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Fed likely stays hawkish until markets crack, then pivots abruptly, as in 2018.
Kevin argues that the Fed is getting tighter, which is draining liquidity and pushing the dollar higher. He expects the Fed to keep talking hawkishly because inflation has been above target for 68 months. Eventually the stock market will break, as it did in 2018, when Powell said the Fed was a long way from neutral while raising rates and then the bottom fell out. He says the sell-off is nonlinear and moves exponentially once it starts. That is when the Fed has to shift quickly, and that move will drive investors into gold.
“Then all of a sudden, it's like, smokes, the bottom just went out. And that's the trouble. This is nonlinear.”at 39:54
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
AI spending is inflating earnings, creating an earnings bubble that may not be sustainable.
Muir says a hyperscaler such as Microsoft borrows about $100 billion to build data centers, and the suppliers recognize that spending as revenue immediately, which lifts index earnings today. The buyer spreads the cost over about seven years through amortization. Earnings are therefore elevated during the build-out. The One Big Beautiful Bill let companies expense this spending in year one, which encourages more spending now but raises future obligations and losses that cannot be deducted. Stocks may look cheap, but earnings could fall sharply once the build-out slows.
“I contend that we've been in an earnings bubble, not a price bubble.”at 6:50
Earnings & corporate profits
Where everyone stands on Earnings & corporate profits
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Expectations for AI and tech earnings were too high, so beats were not enough to lift stocks.
Stocks need to beat expectations, not just meet them, because meeting them is already priced in. Last quarter, companies raised guidance instead of cutting it, so stocks rallied into earnings. Companies then applied the same optimism to this quarter, with growth at levels rarely seen. Stocks could not reach that expectation, which made the setup an easy short.
“It's not enough that your stock does well. It needs to do better than what's expected. ... going into this earning season, the expectations for these stocks were so high that it just was almost impossible for the stocks to perform well.”at 14:01
US elections & politics
Where everyone stands on US elections & politics
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
The Democrats winning Congress did not cause the sell-off; the market reaction was not political.
Stocks rose the day Democrats took Congress, so the election itself did not trigger the sell-off. Most of the finance industry expected a market-clearing event that turned out to be a rally, and the consensus was wrong. Muir argues that prices drive the narrative, so the Democrats explanation was assigned after the fact. The more likely driver was hyperscaler borrowing spreads widening and their effect on AI stocks.
“If we think about the immediate reaction after Dems took congress, stock market was actually up that day. Right? It wasn't down. It was up.”at 23:28
AI chips & semiconductors
Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Nvidia's vendor financing shows GPU demand is not infinite, which undermines the AI earnings story.
Muir says Nvidia's vendor financing, which he compares to Nortel and Lucent in the dot-com bubble, is a sign that customers cannot afford the chips on their own. If there were infinite demand for GPUs, Nvidia would not need to finance buyers. He cites Odd Lots' Tracy Alloway, who argued that the financing undercuts the idea of infinite demand. He is not skeptical of AI itself but of the securities' prices and of the earnings they rely on.
“Well, that's exactly what Jensen was doing. And, again, if there's infinite demand for the GPUs, why do you need to do vendor financing?”at 27:32
US deficit & government debt
Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Huge US deficits make bonds suspect as a hedge against an equity slowdown.
Bonds used to protect investors in downturns, but they have become suspect because the US is running huge deficits. If the economy slows, bonds may not save investors, since the Fed could cut rates while the yield curve steepens and term premium rises. This leaves no easy solution for investors.
“even bonds have become somewhat suspect because the reality is we're running huge deficits. ... you don't know what's gonna happen if we get a slowdown. You know, our bond's going to save you. They might not”at 28:44
International equities
Where everyone stands on International equities
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Owning non-US stocks reduces exposure to the crowded US tech trade; Japan has outperformed the US.
The world is overweight US stocks and US tech, which is the most crowded trade. Holding other countries reduces that risk. Doubts about Europe and Japan's demographics have not stopped their markets from outperforming the US over the past year and a half. Japan's index is up about twice as much as the US year to date.
“One of the ways to, you know, protect yourself is to make sure you don't own the most of what everyone else is long. So go and diversify into other countries.”at 29:37
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
A more hawkish Fed is great for long-end bonds; he bought two-year bonds and forward-curve trades.
A hawkish Fed that is determined to bring inflation down is good for long bonds because the main risk to a long bond holder is inflation eroding its value. The Fed's shift toward tightening hurts stocks and the economy but helps bonds. Muir has started buying bonds for the first time, including two-year notes, and placed more complex trades betting that the forward curve will fall.
“So ironically, this Federal Reserve that has gotten more hawkish and serious about inflation over the last couple of weeks is great, great news for the bond market.”at 33:48
Oil & fuels
Where everyone stands on Oil & fuels
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Oil unlikely to return to $40–50; SPR refills create lasting demand.
Kevin is not hopeful oil will return to $40 or $50. Oil did not spike to $200 after the Strait of Hormuz closed during the Iran war, which surprised the market. He argues the strategic petroleum reserve release was much larger than people thought, and China likely had far more stockpiled oil than anyone imagined. That supply was met by SPR releases, which kept prices down. The US SPR is now almost down to zero, and no one knows the level in China, so future releases will eventually run out or slow. Countries have learned from the war the importance of SPRs and will need to refill them. India has doubled its SPR target and will be a buyer for months, quarters or possibly years. This refill demand undermines the bear argument that oil demand will fall, and it is one reason he thinks it is hard to be bearish on commodities.
“...they had an SPR that wasn't adequate, and so they've already announced that they've doubled the size of it. And so they're on the bid, and they're gonna be on the bid for months, quarters, maybe years to come refilling their SPR.”at 43:19
Commodities (broad)
Where everyone stands on Commodities (broad)
Kevin Muir · The MacroTourist
Hard to be bearish on any commodity as stockpiling rises amid world instability.
Kevin argues that as the world becomes more unstable, countries are less able to rely on buying a commodity at the flick of a switch. That means everyone needs to stockpile more. This coincides with countries trying to expand their economies and fiscal spending, because Trump has told them they cannot rely on the US anymore. These forces create demand that makes it tough to be bearish on any commodity in general. He ties this to the broader secular inflation argument.
“And this is also another reason why it's tough to get too bearish on any commodity in general.”at 43:42
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund1 speaker
Topics
- AI capex inflating earnings
- Fed hawkishness and long-end bonds
- Fed policy path
- Fed tightening into oil supply shock
- GPU demand and vendor financing
- blue-chip valuations and brand premium
- bonds as hedge given deficits
- central bank gold buying
- commodity demand from stockpiling
- diversifying away from US tech
- earnings expectations and guidance
- gold price outlook
- hedge fund degrossing
- index concentration in tech
- inflation downside surprise
- midterm election market reaction
- oil price outlook
- options positioning and downside acceleration
- real rates and dollar pressure on gold
- secular bull market ending
- secular inflation
- staples rally driven by short covering
More from Wealthion
- Is Your Portfolio More Exposed to Tech Than You Think? · November 16, 2026
- Your Gains Are at Risk: What Albert Lu Would Hold Before the Next Drop · November 13, 2026
- The Energy Supercycle Could Last Into the 2030s | Josef Schachter · November 9, 2026
- The Credit Market Warning That Could Hit Stocks | Jeff Snider · November 4, 2026
- 7% Treasury Yields by 2028? The Midterm Warning · November 4, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus