Thoughtful Money · · 1h 31m
Will Struggling Nvidia Take The Markets Down With It? | Lance Roberts
With Lance Roberts
Summary
Lance Roberts of Thoughtful Money argues that Nvidia looks oversold and cheap, trading near a 0.12 PEG and roughly 10x forward earnings, but that the stock is a tradable bounce rather than a buy-and-hold, with downside risk toward about $120. He ties the concern to Jensen Huang's unchecked control and lack of a succession plan, which he sees as key-man and governance risk for a company central to AI and national security, while noting that engineers still drive earnings. On the broader market, he expects a possible year-end tech rally driven by fund rebalancing, strong earnings and buybacks, supported by flushed leverage and bearish sentiment, while cautioning that markets can still fall. He also covers macro and policy: weak PPI that should pull PCE and rate-hike expectations lower, AI capex masking consumer weakness from oil-driven demand destruction, local opposition to data centers, the US-China AI race, midterm-cycle historical returns, and rising debt from continuing resolutions.
Key takeaways
- Lance Roberts (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's lack of CEO succession planning is a serious governance problem given its size and national-security role.
- Lance Roberts (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia is oversold and cheap at about 10x forward earnings with a 0.12 PEG; expects a tradable bounce.
- Lance Roberts on US stock market outlook: Hedge funds are underweight tech into year-end, so tech may rally on forced buying and buybacks.
- Lance Roberts on US stock market outlook: Sentiment and breadth point to a near-term rally; markets are oversold and everyone is bearish, so a rally is more likely.
- Lance Roberts (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia is a great company with super cheap fundamentals, though its stock is not performing now.
What was said, by company and theme
18 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 147 speakers in other episodes, 134 bullish and 110 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Lance Roberts · RIA AdvisorsBearish
Nvidia's lack of CEO succession planning is a serious governance problem given its size and national-security role.
Lance argues Huang ran a very flat organization and held complete control as chairman, CEO, face of the company and lobbyist, with no succession plan. He says that is a problem for a company this large with this many employees, and more so because Nvidia is central to AI development and national security. He compares it to a 'hit by a bus' scenario, meaning the company has no one ready to take over. Lance frames the issue as key-man risk and governance, and it is the main reason he thinks the scandal matters beyond the personal misconduct.
“There was no succession plan. He ran a very flat organization and he maintained complete control... And that's a problem when you run a company that large and you don't have a succession plan in place.”at 6:02
Lance Roberts · RIA AdvisorsBullish
Nvidia is oversold and cheap at about 10x forward earnings with a 0.12 PEG; expects a tradable bounce.
Lance argues Nvidia is very oversold, almost four standard deviations below its moving average, and trades at a 0.12 PEG on a roughly 10x forward P/E, so it looks cheap on fundamentals, especially with earnings growth this high. He expects a bounce but warns it is tradable only: sellers trapped in the stock will sell into rallies, so the stock may retest lows or set higher lows and need six to ten months to grind through. He notes Jensen Huang is not building the chips, engineers and employees are still producing, so losing the face of the company does not change earnings. He also says the monthly chart shows downside to about $120 from $160, a level that has held twice before on the four-year moving average. Against this, he cites a study of conduct-driven CEO removals where most stocks fell over the next year on average, though he also reports oversold cases rose about 4.7% over twelve months, so the outcome depends on the starting point. He is not telling people to buy outright, suggests small tranches with tight stops, and says his firm owns the stock but is underweight after taking profits.
“It trades at a 0.12 peg ratio on a 10 forward PE. I mean, if I can buy Nvidia at a 10 forward PE, it's pretty cheap.”at 20:57
Lance Roberts · RIA AdvisorsBullish
Nvidia is a great company with super cheap fundamentals, though its stock is not performing now.
Lance says Nvidia is a great company with super cheap fundamentals, but the stock is currently underperforming. He uses this to argue investors should not hold on to a stock they like just because it is down. He frames the price weakness as a gap between a strong business at a low valuation and its recent share price, which implies he sees upside. He gives no explicit price target or time frame.
“Nvidia, it's a great company. ... It's got super cheap fundamentals, but it's just not performing right now.”at 1:22:34
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Hedge funds are underweight tech into year-end, so tech may rally on forced buying and buybacks.
Lance argues beaten-down technology stocks could perform better into year-end for several reasons. Hedge funds and pension funds have been heavily liquidating positions and are now very underweight tech, so they will have to re-buy to fix their books for year-end reporting, creating buying pressure for growth stocks. Earnings season has been very good, and the buyback window is now open, with roughly $1.5 trillion in buyback announcements on track. He says this capital had been on the sidelines and now has to come back into the market, which supports a possible year-end rally, particularly in technology. He is not forecasting a specific index level.
“So if you want to start buying some of these beat down technology stocks going into year end, and there's a lot of reasons why tech should perform better in the year end, hedge funds and pension funds, etcetera, been grossly liquidating positions.”at 24:20
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Sentiment and breadth point to a near-term rally; markets are oversold and everyone is bearish, so a rally is more likely.
The market has gone nowhere since May and is trading below its 20- and 50-day moving averages, which act as resistance. Markets are oversold but not grossly so. Investor sentiment is very bearish, and money flow breadth is at extremely low levels; with the fear and greed gauge, he treats these as contrarian indicators pointing to a rally. Seasonality supports this: November and December are usually decent months, and the early-December selling by mutual funds distributing capital gains tends to create a buying opportunity for a year-end rally. He stresses that markets can still go lower, so he is holding extra cash and using stops.
“This is a really good set up. Everybody's expecting the market to go down lower. Nobody's really expecting the markets go up, which kind of puts you in the position that a rally is becoming much more likely than not.”at 39:27
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Stocks tend to perform well after midterms, and little changes regardless of which party wins.
Lance presents historical data on the 12 months following 19 midterm elections. Returns were positive on average (about 15%), and with a Republican president and Democratic Congress they were about 15.5%. The worst drawdown under such a split was in 1987, and most drawdowns are short-lived. Democratic-controlled Congress cannot do much given the veto, and gridlock tends to be good for markets. He concludes that headlines matter less than fundamentals and earnings.
“And regardless of what side of the aisle you're on, it just means really two things. One, stocks tend to perform well. B, nothing's really going to change.”at 1:03:21
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Beaten-down tech stocks may be bought back once they bottom and show positive buy signals.
Lance says his portfolio team has rebalanced and harvested tax losses, and their next step is to look for beaten-up technology stocks to rebuild to core portfolio weights. He wants to see the market and tech stocks bottom and turn up on positive buy signals before adding back. He says this could happen next week or the week after. The view is conditional on technical confirmation, and he supports it only with the general process, not with a fundamental case.
“we want to see this market start to kind of bottom here a bit, see these technology stocks start to bottom here a bit, turn up on positive buy signals, then we'll add back into them.”at 1:19:19
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
A federal data center moratorium is unlikely given the veto; state pauses only affect new, not permitted, builds.
With Trump holding the veto, a federal data center moratorium or repeal of tax cuts has very low probability. What states and cities can do is pause new plans, not the build-out of already permitted facilities. Texas, which accounts for about 25% of data centers, already has a moratorium on new data centers from Governor Abbott. Other changes would require legislation, which is unlikely. Hearings don't amount to anything, and the resulting gridlock is what markets tend to like. If states pass moratoriums on new build-outs, it would hit the economy and earnings of all companies, not just AI data center firms.
“You can only pause new plans, right? You cannot pause the build out on already permitted facilities.”at 59:32
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Public fears about AI data centers over water, power and jobs are largely false narratives, fed by poor communication.
Lance argues that voters have been inundated with negative headlines about AI data centers and their water use, power use and job losses, and that much of it is not true. Misinformation on social media scares people, so they vote against local data centers. He blames the media, tech companies and the administration for poor communication about why AI matters and why the country needs to win the race. He calls this short-term thinking and says better decisions require a longer horizon.
“there's so many false narratives about AI data centers in relation to water usage and power usage and job losses.”at 1:09:06
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Last Thursday's plunge was a one-day flush driven by forced liquidation of leveraged positions.
He says several hedge funds were liquidated during the sell-off, which is why the market rallied back so hard over the next couple of days as people repositioned. He links the flush to leverage: record margin debt in the markets and record leverage at hedge funds. He calls margin a double-edged sword, so when stocks fall it can force liquidations quickly. He says the market had become complacent and that the positioning got washed out.
“We have a look, we have record margin debt in the markets. We've got record leverage at hedge funds.”at 43:42
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Rate-hike expectations will reverse as softer PPI feeds through to weaker-than-expected PCE.
A hot CPI print pushed up rate-hike expectations and hit rate-sensitive assets. Lance argues that much of that expectation will reverse. PPI came in on Friday weaker than expected, and PPI feeds into PCE, so PCE will come in below current expectations. That should bring the hike expectations back down. Adam questioned how he could be so confident about the PCE number before it was released.
“A lot of that expectation is going to be reversed. PPI came in on Friday weaker than expected. PCE is going to come in weaker than expected.”at 49:40
Middle East & Iran
Where everyone stands on Middle East & Iran
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Trump's remarks on blockades suggest he may avoid kinetic military action against Iran.
Trump has made comments that the US doesn't need to deal with Iran directly and can use naval blockades to achieve the same thing, with allies supporting the blockade. Adam notes he also said there is no need for a peace deal and that the US will keep hammering Iran economically. Lance concludes that all of this sets the table for Trump not going kinetic. Oil prices have fallen to about $85 a barrel, and Adam says there is room for them to rise again if the situation changes.
“He's already made some comments potentially about, well, we don't really need to deal with Iran. We can just kind of use our naval blockades to do the same thing and our allies like the naval blockade.”at 51:34
US consumer
Where everyone stands on US consumer
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
High oil and fuel prices are destroying consumer demand, though the damage has not spread to the economy yet.
Oil prices feed directly into the economy through gasoline, diesel and food costs. Lance says demand destruction is already visible on the consumer side. He also says the weakness has not yet appeared in the broader economy because of AI capex. Oil's effect is disinflationary through this demand destruction.
“The demand destruction is showing up within the economy. We are seeing it on the consumer side.”at 53:19
US growth & recession risk
Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
AI data center capex is masking consumer weakness and keeping the economy growing faster than it would.
Oil-driven demand destruction is showing up on the consumer side, but it has not yet fed through to the broader economy. The reason is that capex spending is covering up much of that weakness. Capex added about 0.4 percentage points to growth last quarter. Lance says that without this flow of AI data center capex, the economy would be running much slower than it is now.
“It hasn't fed through yet to the broader economic environment because the CapEx expenditures are covering up for a lot of that weakness.”at 53:26
US housing
Where everyone stands on US housing
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Housing affordability cannot be fixed by demand-boosting policy; only high rates working through time will help.
Lance argues that policies like down payment assistance or lower mortgage entry costs would increase demand and make the housing problem worse, not better. The only way affordability improves is for high rates to work through the system over time. He says the affordability problem won't be fixed overnight.
“you cannot fix housing affordability. If you do anything like give down payment assistance or lower the mortgage entry costs or whatever, you're going to increase demand.”at 54:58
US deficit & government debt
Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Debt keeps rising under both parties because continuing resolutions add 8% a year to spending.
Lance argues the deficit will grow under Democrats just as it did under Republicans, because Congress cannot pass budgets and keeps relying on continuing resolutions. Each continuing resolution adds 8% to last year's spending. Using the rule of 72, debt doubles about every nine years at that rate, and he says the debt trajectory has roughly followed that path. He expects another government shutdown, but notes markets tend to perform well during shutdowns because they get resolved with continuing resolutions.
“And you want to know why the debt's going up? Because every continuing resolution adds 8% to last year's spending.”at 1:02:11
US–China AI & chip race
Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
The US must win the AI race with China, and poor communication is undermining that effort.
Lance argues the media, tech companies and the administration have been terrible communicators about why AI matters and why the US needs to win the race. Whoever dominates AI will dictate the future of the space. He asks whether people want China in charge of AI and says he personally does not think that is a good outcome. He ties the stakes to the country's long-term economic future.
“the media, the tech companies, the administration in particular, has been a terrible communicator around the importance of AI and the need that we need to win this race because it will dictate the future for whoever does dominate the space.”at 1:10:27
AI regulation & safety
Where everyone stands on AI regulation & safety
Lance Roberts · RIA Advisors
Political limits on technological advance would erode job creation and entrepreneurial opportunity.
Lance argues that if decisions impede technological progress, the environment for job growth and capitalism will weaken, and the outlook will be less bright. He supports this with the claim that there are more 18-to-24-year-old entrepreneurs today than ever, which he attributes to social media. He also cites online creators and YouTube as examples of technology creating income opportunities. He concludes that current political decisions are eroding this capability.
“if we impede that ability to continue to advance in technology, we're gonna take those opportunities away from people to run their own business”at 1:15:51
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA147 speakers · 134 bullish, 110 bearish calls
Topics
- AI capex masking consumer weakness
- AI race with China
- AI slowdown trade-offs
- Nvidia valuation
- US military action against Iran
- continuing resolutions and debt growth
- data center moratoriums
- data center public opposition
- forced liquidation and leverage
- fuel price squeeze on consumers
- housing affordability policy
- leadership succession
- midterm election cycle returns
- rate hike expectations
- short-term rally setup
- tech stock recovery
- tech year-end rally
- valuation after CEO exit
More from Thoughtful Money
- "There Are Lots Of Good Reasons The Market Should Crash" | New Harbor Financial · November 13, 2026
- Stephanie Pomboy: "Buckle Up" For 2027 - The Market Is Going To Be "Brutal" · November 11, 2026
- A "Perfect Storm" For Markets Lies Ahead Should Japan Repatriate Its US Assets | Lyn Alden · November 10, 2026
- "Bad Things" To Happen As US Dollar Strengthens | Brent Johnson · November 8, 2026
- More Market Bloodshed To Come? | Michael Lebowitz · November 7, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus