Masters in Business · · 1h 16m
Adjusting for Credit Risk: Masters In Business with David Eichhorn
With David Eichhorn
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
David Eichhorn, co-CIO of NISA, joins Barry Ritholtz to argue that much of what active bond managers call alpha is really disguised credit beta, since outperformance often comes from overweighting spread product like high yield, ABS and corporates in a long, benign credit cycle that the Fed has cushioned. He is skeptical of private credit packaged in leveraged BDCs and interval funds, calling it expensive beta, and warns against pushing it into 401(k) plans. On macro, he sees US deficits, heavy Treasury issuance, AI-driven hyperscaler borrowing and sticky inflation from tariffs and an oil shock pushing rates higher, while he finds real TIPS yields near multi-year highs attractive. The conversation also covers insurer exposure to private credit, weak European reform prospects, Social Security reform, falling foreign demand for Treasuries, and the appeal of municipal bonds for taxable investors.
Key takeaways
- David Eichhorn on Asset managers, brokers & exchanges: Most active bond managers' excess returns are just long credit beta, not true alpha, so their fees are hard to justify.
- David Eichhorn on US Treasuries & yields: 30-year TIPS real yields near 3.5% are wildly attractive; TIPS are the safest security for individuals.
- Barry Ritholtz on Municipal Bonds: Municipal bonds at 4.6-4.7% tax-free are incredibly attractive for taxable individual investors.
- David Eichhorn on Private credit: Private credit's loan-level illiquidity premium is real, but fund leverage and fees destroy it.
- David Eichhorn on Private markets for individual investors: Putting private credit into 401(k)s is a recipe for disaster; semi-liquid interval funds are poorly understood.
What was said, by company and theme
16 views from 2 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
The long-end yield sell-off looks too large for a temporary oil shock; he cannot reconcile it.
Eichhorn says the war has pushed oil prices up, but he cannot reconcile why that is pushing the back end of the yield curve up as much as it has. He doubts anyone expects $100 oil for thirty years. The oil spike may last three months, six months or a year. So a shock that looks temporary is moving long-dated yields by more than the timeline of the shock would seem to justify.
“Why that's pushing the back end of the yield curve up as much? I don't think anyone thinks we're gonna have $100 oil or more for thirty years, whereas we may have it for three months or six months or a year.”at 49:02
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
30-year TIPS real yields near 3.5% are wildly attractive; TIPS are the safest security for individuals.
Eichhorn argues that rising nominal yields reflect higher real yields, not higher inflation expectations. Breakevens, the gap between TIPS and nominal Treasuries, have held in the low 2% range, which he reads as credibility in the Fed. That makes 30-year real yields near 3.5% attractive. He says TIPS are the safest security for an individual saving for retirement because they protect purchasing power, though their changing coupons confuse people. Real yields above 2% at ten years and over 3% at thirty years are wildly attractive. The 30-year TIPS is at all-time highs since it was first auctioned, and the 10-year TIPS trades near all-time highs too, though it was unloved when it first came out.
“the fact of the matter to get high 2% reels in ten year and over 3% reel rates of return in thirty years, wildly attractive.”at 51:07
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Foreign demand for Treasuries has waned as Japan and others offer higher local yields, though China dumping is unlikely.
Eichhorn says foreign appetite for Treasuries has waned. Japan now offers yields above the decades of ultra-low rates. The UK also offers more attractive yields, but with heavy fiscal challenges that may mean real credit risk is creeping in. On China, his chief economist wrote that Beijing could weaponise Treasury sales in a trade war to spike yields. Eichhorn doubts it, because China would hurt itself, and China has its own fiscal problems. He says he is not worried about that per se.
“So not worried about that per se, but just to your point, you can get higher yields everywhere now.”at 53:55
Private credit
Where everyone stands on Private credit
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Private credit's loan-level illiquidity premium is real, but fund leverage and fees destroy it.
Eichhorn says NISA does not invest in private credit. His team looked at loan-level data and found a real illiquidity premium, about 3% excess return for unlevered loans before fees. The problem is the vehicles. Typical BDCs and interval funds add roughly a turn of leverage, borrowed at around SOFR plus 200 basis points, and charge high fees. By his estimate that wipes out the premium and more. Over twenty years, publicly traded BDCs underperformed a high-yield index plus one unit of high-yield CDS, which gives the same extra risk in a liquid format. He calls the leveraged result expensive beta, not alpha. He says the issue is the packaging and engineering, not the asset class, and that clients can get levered exposure far more cheaply through Treasuries or the S&P 500.
“it takes what is in its organic native state a very nice risk premium and by our estimates, destroys all of it and then some.”at 1:00:06
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Insurers' growing private credit exposure, tied to pension annuities, is a worry that could require a taxpayer bailout.
Eichhorn worries that insurers have bought large amounts of pension annuities and have moved aggressively into private credit. Insurers are state-regulated, and their guarantee associations are effectively unfunded. The federal PBGC covers corporate pension plans but not plans that have transferred to an insurer. If a small insurer fails, the big insurers usually absorb it. If a large insurer failed, that backstop would not hold, and US taxpayers would likely pay for a massive bailout. He says he is not predicting this and hopes the concern is unwarranted. He also advises companies to choose a very strong insurer when they buy out a pension.
“obviously, a lot of insurers have moved more aggressively into private credit. That is a concern of mine, undoubtedly.”at 1:05:29
Asset managers, brokers & exchanges
Where everyone stands on Asset managers, brokers & exchanges
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Most active bond managers' excess returns are just long credit beta, not true alpha, so their fees are hard to justify.
Eichhorn argues that much of what bond managers call fixed income alpha is beta in disguise. Managers who beat the Bloomberg Aggregate by overweighting spread product (ABS, corporates, high yield, short-duration credit) are taking extra compensated market risk. When he regresses their excess performance against credit markets or the S&P, most of it shrinks, which shows they are systematically long credit. Treasuries make up about half the Aggregate, so they are an 'attractive nuisance' that tempts managers to add spread risk and call the result alpha. Credit beta is now cheap to buy through credit ETFs, so he sees little reason to pay active fees for it. Net of beta, most managers are long on average with zero or negative alpha. He notes a few managers do produce real alpha, mainly using leverage in investment-grade bonds or private credit, but they are relatively few.
“When I regress it, however, that excess performance on the credit markets or for that matter, the S and P, suddenly that excess performance shrinks a lot. Or said differently, they're just systematically long credit.”at 27:06
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
The Fed's rapid bailouts in crises have taught investors to take risk, which is a mistake in his view.
Eichhorn says that in the financial crisis and briefly during COVID, bond markets sold off until the Fed stepped in. In his opinion the Fed bailed investors out much too quickly, which he calls inexplicable. He argues this has taught markets that they cannot really make a mistake, so the Fed has 'bubble wrapped the economy'. The result is that risk-taking in spread assets is cushioned, and the cushioning masks how much excess return is simply beta. Because of this, the downside of spread-heavy strategies has not been tested in a real business cycle.
“you saw it briefly in COVID until the Fed for inexplicably, frankly, bailed investors out way too quickly, in my opinion. ... They've bubble wrapped the economy, so that you can't make a mistake.”at 29:53
Credit markets
Where everyone stands on Credit markets
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Credit spreads have ground tighter, so spread-overweight strategies are fragile and exposed to an eventual air pocket.
Eichhorn says that a common way bond managers outperform is by overweighting spread product. Credit has been in a long, benign environment, so spreads have been grinding tighter. Keeping the same excess return now requires owning more of these lower-spreading assets. That leaves managers badly positioned when the 'air pocket' eventually arrives. He adds that the US has not had a true business cycle downturn in a long time. In his view, the risk shows up mainly in a more distressed environment, not in ordinary rate shocks. The 2022 rate-hike selloff hit bonds hard, but credit spreads held up, so it was not a real test.
“If a big part of how you outperform is overweighting spread product, well, spreads have been grinding in because this has been a great a great credit environment. So to get the same excess performance, you need to own more of that lower spreading asset, which sets you up very poorly for if the air pocket occurs.”at 31:13
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Heavy index concentration makes it hard for equity managers to express negative views without shorting.
Eichhorn notes that US equity markets have become very concentrated in a few names. Without permission to short, a manager's ability to express negative views on individual stocks has shrunk dramatically. He argues that the ability to short modestly is valuable because most managers cannot short at all. His firm therefore favours many small bets, including modest shorts, rather than concentrated long-only positions. This is an argument about how managers can generate alpha, and it rests on the concentration of the index rather than a forecast for the market.
“What's interesting about equity markets, particularly with how concentrated they've gotten, if you don't give a manager ability to short a little bit... the amount of surface area they've lost of expressing negative views on stocks is is just shrunk.”at 32:20
US deficit & government debt
Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Procyclical US government spending is pushing rates higher; the fiscal path should be reversed.
Eichhorn says the fiscal house is not about to break, and he is not a doomsayer. He criticises both parties, Biden and Trump alike, for spending in ways that were procyclical, meaning spending more when the economy was already strong. He argues the government should have pushed money into people's hands after the GFC, and that instead it kept spending through a decade of a roaring economy. He says it should be going the other way. As a result, heavy US government debt issuance is pushing rates higher.
“Both parties spent money in environments that didn't make sense, meaning procyclical, you know, whether it be Biden or Trump.”at 46:04
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Hyperscalers' insatiable bond issuance is crowding markets and pushing yields and spreads higher.
Eichhorn argues that hyperscaler borrowing for AI buildout is a major new source of demand for capital, comparable to a government's financing needs. Unlike the usual crowding-out story, here the private borrowers are pushing others out of the market, and that pushes rates higher. Barry notes that these issuers borrow at higher yields than Treasuries, and Eichhorn agrees the market is forcing them to pay up. Many of the issuers are very profitable, so he sees no near-term default risk. Still, their spreads have widened, and he calls the pattern of repeated new issues a new-issue concession as they keep pounding the market.
“The hyperscalers just have an incredible insatiable appetite, and undoubtedly, that's pushing rates further and further up.”at 47:19
US inflation
Where everyone stands on US inflation
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Tariffs and the war are self-inflicted wounds keeping inflation sticky and pushing yields up.
Eichhorn says inflation has been sticky. His chief economist, Stephen Douglas, thought inflation was on the path back to target twice, but each time supply-side tariffs and then a war with oil impact interrupted that. He calls it a very self-inflicted wound. The war has spooked oil markets and injected concern about inflation. He says he is not a geopolitical thinker and cannot judge the war's aims, but he is clear about the price effects.
“But but I think just a sticky inflation. ... these supply side tariffs. ... Then the war. Like a very self inflicted wound.”at 48:34
Municipal Bonds
Barry Ritholtz · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Municipal bonds at 4.6-4.7% tax-free are incredibly attractive for taxable individual investors.
Barry argues that for individual investors, municipal bonds are incredibly attractive now. A yield of 4.6-4.7% that is triple tax-free equals about 8.5% on a taxable basis for someone in New York or California. He says the benefit is smaller in states such as New Jersey or Illinois, but still meaningful. He suspects that many investors avoid munis because of recency bias or because they seem complicated. Eichhorn agrees that for a taxable investor, cutting the tax bill is real return, though he cautions that some state and local governments are facing more fiscal problems.
“munis are incredibly attractive. You know, if you could get 4.6, 4.7% triple tax free, which is Mhmm. Eight and a half percent tax equivalent, if you're in New York or California”at 52:00
Europe's economy
Where everyone stands on Europe's economy
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Europe has greater structural problems than the US, including pension reform that is unlikely soon.
Eichhorn says he avoids American exceptionalism, but Europe has greater problems than the US. The UK faces significant fiscal challenges, and Brexit has hurt it. The UK's higher yields may partly reflect real credit risk creeping in, not just better value. Europe needs a lot of structural reform, and pensions are a large part of it. He says France's talk of lowering the retirement age is laughable and not physically sustainable. He does not expect these reforms in the near term in most of those countries.
“Europe has has US has its problems, just the Europe has has greater ones.”at 55:07
US entitlements
Where everyone stands on US entitlements
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Social Security needs reform: raise the cap and move back retirement ages, since 65 is not rational.
Eichhorn says Social Security needs reform and that politicians need to get serious. He sees the current arrangement as the greatest generational transfer of wealth, taken by one generation. He agrees with Barry on a plausible fix, raising the payroll tax cap, and says retirement ages must move back. Social Security was designed around a booming demographic dividend that has stopped because of lower fertility. He argues that thoughtful immigration reform could restore some of that dividend, while fertility cannot be willed higher. He says reforms are unlikely in the near term.
“We need to move back retirement ages. This is the greatest generational transfer of of wealth. I'll say being stolen by one generation.”at 55:46
Private markets for individual investors
Where everyone stands on Private markets for individual investors
David Eichhorn · NISA Investment Advisors
Putting private credit into 401(k)s is a recipe for disaster; semi-liquid interval funds are poorly understood.
Asked about the push to move private credit into 401(k) plans, Eichhorn calls it a recipe for disaster. He says a defined-contribution model carries its own risks compared with classic pensions, and that an investment product cannot fix a savings problem, since people must first save enough. He argues private credit is not a savior for 401(k) plans. He points to semi-liquid interval funds, which he says investors do not understand. When losses arrive and investors try to redeem, he expects ugly outcomes, because holders will find they did not appreciate what they owned.
“look. I think that's a recipe for disaster.”at 1:02:46
Topics
- Fed rescues and moral hazard
- Social Security reform
- TIPS real yields
- US deficits pushing rates higher
- active fixed income manager alpha
- credit spreads
- foreign demand for Treasuries
- hyperscaler bond issuance
- insurer private credit exposure
- long-end yield sell-off
- market concentration
- municipal bonds
- private credit
- private credit in 401(k) plans
- structural reform and pensions
- tariffs and war driving inflation
More from Masters in Business
- At The Money: Shopping in an Era of Surveillance Capitalism · November 18, 2026
- Investing in Financial Security: Masters in Business with Salim Ramji · November 13, 2026
- Providing Capital to Tech Companies: Masters In Business with Ann Berry · November 6, 2026
- Economy of Scale: New Finance (Sponsored Content) · November 2, 2026
- The Future of Financial Advice: Masters in Business with Rich Steinmeier · October 30, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus