Masters in Business · · 29 min
At The Money: Shopping in an Era of Surveillance Capitalism
With Lindsay Owens
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Lindsay Owens of the Economic Policy Institute-style advocacy group argues that modern shopping is shaped by surveillance capitalism, in which loyalty programs and algorithms gather detailed customer data and use it to set personalised or volatile prices. She cites Kroger, where most transactions are tied to loyalty programs and customer data sales form a large share of profit, and describes a 'loyalty penalty' at Starbucks and McDonald's, where loyal customers receive fewer discounts because firms have profiled them as certain to return. She contrasts this with Costco's capped-markup, cost-plus model and the Savannah Bananas' lottery-based ticketing, and points to Delta's Fetcherr airfare pricing and Instacart's algorithmic pricing as cases where public backlash led companies to back down. She also covers John Deere's repair restrictions, AI shopping agents that may favour sellers over shoppers, and New York City's click-to-cancel rule, concluding that public pressure and clear rules are the fastest remedies.
Key takeaways
- Lindsay Owens (neutral on Starbucks): Starbucks stops offering perks to loyal customers once it knows they are reliable purchasers.
- Lindsay Owens (neutral on McDonald's): McDonald's scored a Wired reporter's lifetime attrition at zero, so it stopped needing to court him.
- Lindsay Owens (neutral on The Kroger Co.): Kroger's loyalty data is monetised heavily; data sales are a large share of its operating income.
- Lindsay Owens (neutral on Deere & Company): John Deere's repair restrictions are a form of price gouging that has drawn right-to-repair pressure.
- Lindsay Owens (bullish on Costco Wholesale): Costco's capped markups and cost-plus pricing make it a good model; it avoids dynamic or personalised pricing.
What was said, by company and theme
11 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Starbucks
Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 2 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Starbucks
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeNeutral
Starbucks stops offering perks to loyal customers once it knows they are reliable purchasers.
Owens describes a 'loyalty penalty': once a company knows a customer's regular purchases, it decides they are a sure thing and stops sending offers and discounts. She cites a Washington Post reporter who obtained a 55-page data report from Starbucks. Over time, as Starbucks learned he was a sure thing, he received no more perks, freebies or discounts.
“Once a company knows what you purchase on a regular basis, they figure that you're a sure thing and they no longer need to push you any of those offers or discounts... he learned that over time as Starbucks knew he was a sure thing, he didn't get any perks or freebies or discounts anymore.”at 6:39
McDonald's
Across the shows: 11 speakers in other episodes, 16 bullish and 14 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on McDonald's
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeNeutral
McDonald's scored a Wired reporter's lifetime attrition at zero, so it stopped needing to court him.
Owens cites a Wired reporter who requested his McDonald's app data and received a 500-page dossier. The data included a lifetime attrition score, a measure of how likely he was to leave McDonald's for a rival such as Burger King. His score was zero, meaning McDonald's saw him as completely loyal. She uses this as evidence that companies profile loyal customers and can penalise them in pricing and promotions.
“McDonald's had calculated this lifetime attrition score... And his attrition score was zero. They were like, he is absolutely hooked on McDonald's.”at 6:39
The Kroger Co.
Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, past 30 days
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeNeutral
Kroger's loyalty data is monetised heavily; data sales are a large share of its operating income.
Owens argues that loyalty programs are a source of corporate data harvesting. She cites Kroger as an example: about 95% of its transactions are tied to loyalty programs, and it has an alternative profits business that she says equals 30% of net operating income, with a large piece coming from selling customer data. She presents this as a reason consumers should see loyalty programs as a double-edged sword.
“Increasingly companies like Kroger, where 95% of transactions are attached to loyalty programs, they have an alternative profits book of business that is 30% of their net operating income and a big piece of that is the sale of your data.”at 8:35
Deere & Company
Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, 1 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeNeutral
John Deere's repair restrictions are a form of price gouging that has drawn right-to-repair pressure.
Owens argues that restricting repair is a form of price gouging, and a chain of charges: the initial product price, then proprietary parts, then proprietary labour, and sometimes a full replacement. John Deere is her main example. It made it impossible for farmers to repair their combines, so during harvest season they must wait for the dealer. She says the right-to-repair movement has won memorandums of understanding with Deere and has drawn movement from the Federal Trade Commission.
“John Deere, the tractor company, a real kind of corporate villain and the right to repair space made it impossible for farmers to repair their combines, which makes it hard if it's harvest season.”at 15:55
Delta Air Lines
Across the shows: 5 speakers in other episodes, 9 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Delta Air Lines
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeNeutral
Delta's AI pricing plans with Fetcherr were reversed after public exposure and rival pressure.
Owens says her organization revealed Delta's partnership with the pricing company Fetcherr. Southwest and American then publicly seized on it. She argues this pressure was a big part of why Delta walked back some of its plans. She presents it as evidence that consumer and competitive backlash can quickly change corporate pricing behaviour.
“And we saw that happen with Delta, their partnership with [Fetcherr] was revealed by my organization and Southwest and American jumped on it. And I think that was a big part of why Delta walked back some of their plans.”at 21:32
Maplebear Inc. (Instacart)
Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, past 30 days
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeNeutral
Instacart pledged to stop its pricing practices after a consumer backlash over a study.
Owens cites a study her organisation helped conduct on Instacart's pricing. She says consumer backlash to the findings was critical. Two weeks later, Instacart issued a corporate letter saying it would not use these practices. She uses this as evidence that public pressure is the quickest way to make companies stop pricing practices that consumers see as abusive.
“with the Instacart study, my organization helped conduct, consumer backlash was critical there. Two weeks later... their corporate issued a letter saying they would not use these practices.”at 21:32
Costco Wholesale
Across the shows: 7 speakers in other episodes, 8 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Costco Wholesale
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeBullish
Costco's capped markups and cost-plus pricing make it a good model; it avoids dynamic or personalised pricing.
Owens holds up Costco as a model for fair pricing. Costco caps its markup over input costs at roughly 14%, with the cap varying slightly for generic, own-brand and third-party products. It uses a cost-plus model, so shoppers do not see dynamic or personalised prices. She concedes its business model is different because membership fees generate much of its profit, but she still considers it a good example. She suggests Costco's consumer loyalty and enthusiasm for the brand help it succeed on this approach.
“they cap it at I think it's 14%... it's a cost plus pricing model. You're not gonna see dynamic pricing at Costco, you're not gonna see personalized pricing at Costco.”at 22:53
Savannah Bananas
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork CollaborativeBullish
Savannah Bananas' fans-first lottery ticketing, not dynamic pricing, is working because of fan loyalty.
Owens contrasts the Savannah Bananas with dynamic pricing in sports. The team does not auction seats to the highest bidder. It uses a lottery, so fans who are lucky get seats at a good price. She argues the team is doing well because it is taking a different path and has strong consumer loyalty and enthusiasm for its brand. She offers this as a counterpoint to rising ticket costs for sports fans and to FIFA's use of dynamic pricing for World Cup tickets.
“they have a real fans first pricing approach. They don't use dynamic pricing auctioning off the seats to the highest bidder, they use lottery system... they are doing well in part because they're cutting a different path”at 23:34
Consumer & retail
Where everyone stands on Consumer & retail
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork Collaborative
Algorithmic and personalised pricing means shoppers are charged different prices for the same item.
Owens argues that shopping has become more volatile and deceptive. Electronic shelf labels and algorithmic pricing mean prices change more often, and personalised or surveillance pricing means she and the listener can be charged different amounts for the same item. She calls this a new frontier of pricing and corporate profiteering. Her evidence is the pricing mechanisms themselves and the way they are used on individual shoppers.
“Prices are changing, prices are more volatile thanks to electronic shelf labels and algorithmic pricing. Prices are more deceptive. Sometimes you and I are charged different amounts for the same item thanks to personalized pricing or surveillance pricing. So it really is a new frontier of pricing and I would argue a new frontier of corporate profiteering.”at 3:15
US state & local policy
Where everyone stands on US state & local policy
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork Collaborative
Shoppers should be able to cancel subscriptions as easily as they signed up, as New York City now requires.
Owens says her organisation's Shoppers Bill of Rights includes a right to cancel a subscription the same way it was signed up, so a one-click sign-up should allow a one-click cancellation. She notes New York City implemented a click-to-cancel rule about a week before the recording, so companies operating there must offer the same cancellation method they offer for sign-up. She presents this as a model that can address subscription traps.
“the right to cancellation the same way you signed up. If they auto populated your address and your credit card information on the way in with one click, you can get out of that subscription with one click.”at 14:17
Consumer AI products
Where everyone stands on Consumer AI products
Lindsay Owens · Groundwork Collaborative
AI shopping assistants often return higher prices than lower ones, so agentic commerce is a serious concern.
Owens sees real promise in AI assistants that can compare prices, find flight deals, and cancel subscriptions for shoppers. She has serious concerns, though. Two early meta-analysis-style studies found that AI shopping assistants more often than not return a higher price, even when asked to find a lower one. She also warns that agents may work for the platform or merchant, such as Meta or Walmart's Sparky, rather than the shopper. She fears consumers could be giving agents access to their wallets and unleashing 'the most sophisticated snake oil salesman the world has ever known.'
“there are two early studies of AI shopping assistants, really big kind of meta analysis type studies. And both of them have come back with pretty sobering results suggesting that more often than not the AI shopping assistant, even when asked to go get a lower price comes back with a high one.”at 24:54
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- McDonald's11 speakers · 16 bullish, 14 bearish calls
- Costco Wholesale7 speakers · 8 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Delta Air Lines5 speakers · 9 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Starbucks2 speakers · 2 bullish, 1 bearish calls
- Deere & Company1 speaker · 1 bullish, 0 bearish calls
- Maplebear Inc. (Instacart)1 speaker
- The Kroger Co.1 speaker
Topics
- AI airfare pricing
- agentic shopping assistants
- algorithmic pricing
- loyalty data monetization
- loyalty program penalty
- pricing practices
- right to repair
- sports ticket pricing
- subscription cancellation rules
- surveillance pricing
More from Masters in Business
- Investing in Financial Security: Masters in Business with Salim Ramji · November 13, 2026
- Providing Capital to Tech Companies: Masters In Business with Ann Berry · November 6, 2026
- Economy of Scale: New Finance (Sponsored Content) · November 2, 2026
- The Future of Financial Advice: Masters in Business with Rich Steinmeier · October 30, 2026
- Embracing the Bond Market: Masters in Business with Robin Wigglesworth · October 23, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus