Top Traders Unplugged · · 1h 11m

SI426: The Hard Part Isn't Buying Trend Following ft. Yoav Git

With Yoav Git

Summary

Yoav Git joins Top Traders Unplugged to argue that the hard part of trend following is not buying it but staying with it through drawdowns. He explains that bond trend has offered positive convexity across most inflation regimes, though inflation above roughly 4-5% pushes bond-equity correlation positive, as in 2022, and his bond-trend convexity claims failed recently when bonds rallied while equities fell. He contends equity trend protects mainly in protracted drawdowns, not sharp V-shaped selloffs like March and April 2025, and that equity dip-buying makes fast equity trend difficult. He presents commodity trend as the most efficient source of additive alpha, with low correlation to liquid trend and strong performance in stagflation, and he is bullish on AI infrastructure as a long-run revolution while doubting that hyperscaler capex itself will pay off. He also warns that high US debt limits crisis relief and that investor flows chasing trend performance are destructive, suggesting manager blending as a remedy.

Key takeaways

  • Yoav Git on US Treasuries & yields: Bond trend has positive convexity across inflation regimes, though its recent record has been poor.
  • Yoav Git on US stock market outlook: Equity trend protects in long drawdowns but comes too late in sharp crises like March and April 2025.
  • Yoav Git on US Treasuries & yields: Bonds fall initially as inflation rises, but offer strong convexity if yields keep rising.
  • Yoav Git on Commodities (broad): Commodity trend thrives in high inflation and underperforms when inflation is low and growth strong.
  • Yoav Git on AI: overall outlook: He is very bullish on AI, with real applications still to come, after a possible valuation shakeout.

What was said, by company and theme

18 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Commodities (broad)

Where everyone stands on Commodities (broad)

  • Yoav Git

    Commodity and FX trend are uncorrelated with equities, so they add diversification but no crisis convexity.

    Commodity and FX trend are essentially flat in equity downturns and are relatively uncorrelated with equities, so they show neither positive nor negative convexity. He says commodity trend, if anything, is slightly negative in equity downturns. Its value in a crisis comes from general alpha, since it works all the time, rather than from convexity. That still makes it better than most asset classes as a source of uncorrelated return.

    “If we look at the other asset classes, if we look at commodity trend and FX trend, what we see is essentially flat. They're actually uncorrelated.”at 29:00
  • Yoav Git

    Commodity trend thrives in high inflation and underperforms when inflation is low and growth strong.

    Inflation is the primary driver of commodity trend performance, and its behaviour is almost a mirror image of long bond exposure. Commodity trend has positive convexity to inflation because commodity prices are a major driver of inflation. It does very well in stagflation or overheating, as long as inflation is good for it. When inflation is low and the economy is doing well, bonds do wonderfully while commodity trend underperforms. Combining bonds and commodity trend gives an inflation-plus-4% defensive portfolio.

    “But inflation is actually the primary driver in terms of conditioning on commodity trend. And what you find is that they actually almost a mirror image of the way that long bonds exposure behave.”at 41:06
  • Yoav Git

    Industrial and energy commodities should rally if AI capex and industrial production hold up.

    Commodities are the feeder inputs to AI and to all industrial production. Strong industrial production drives demand for industrial commodities and energy futures, independently of inflation. Yoav cites US industrial production rising and capacity utilisation up as evidence that the outlook is not all doom. He concludes that a portfolio of copper, other industrials and energy futures would do well if AI and industrial activity play out. Even without the AI boom, commodity trend would still do well in stagflation.

    “a portfolio of, you know, copper, other industrial productions, other... Particularly in AI, energy futures are going to do wonderfully. Like, it's a long one leap exposure.”at 55:33
  • Yoav Git

    Commodity trend has only 20-30% correlation to liquid trend, so it adds real diversification.

    Historically, commodity trend has had only about 20 to 30% correlation with liquid trend, against 60 to 80% for alternative CTAs. Adding commodity trend lifts the Sharpe ratio from around 0.6 to 0.8. Once commodity trend is included, alternative trend adds almost no extra Sharpe. Commodity trend is therefore the most efficient source of additive alpha in a CTA portfolio, while equity and bond trend are highly correlated to the core trend exposure.

    “So commodity trend, if you look historically, has only maybe 20 or 30% correlation to liquid trend. So if you add it, that will bump up your performance 30%.”at 1:00:04

US Treasuries & yields

Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields

  • Yoav Git

    CTAs are far more capital-efficient in bonds than in equities, so bond exposure swings much more than equity exposure.

    CTAs target equal risk across asset classes, usually around 15% volatility. Because bonds are much less volatile than equities, a CTA delevers equity and levers bonds to reach that target. A 10% CTA allocation therefore gives roughly ±3.5% equity exposure but roughly ±10% bond exposure, depending on how bonds move. He concludes that the CTA is much more capital-efficient in bonds than in equities. Investors who want a dedicated equity-hedging CTA would need a large allocation, close to one-for-one, which is expensive in cash terms.

    “if I've got a 10% exposure to a CTA, it's almost equivalent to being plus minus 10% depending on how bonds are going.”at 22:26
  • Yoav Git

    Bond trend has positive convexity across inflation regimes, though its recent record has been poor.

    Bond trend has generally shown positive convexity in all inflation environments. Bonds' behaviour in equity drawdowns depends on the inflation regime, but trend following flips its bond positions as the bond-equity correlation changes, so it detects the regime shift. Even in high-inflation periods bond trend offers decent positive convexity, which he puts at roughly 20%, against roughly 35% for equity trend. Historically bond trend has had a higher Sharpe ratio than equity trend, and carry gives it a drift that helps long-term performance. He hedges this heavily: over the last four years bonds have traded sideways and bond trend has had a negative Sharpe. Convexity also failed in the recent month, when equities fell while bonds rallied and trend followers were short bonds. He says the relationship is not guaranteed and depends on the shape of the crisis.

    “bond trend generally have positive convexity over all inflation environments. And the reason why we look at inflation environment as the explainer is because bond themselves actually are very dependent on inflation regime.”at 26:57
  • Yoav Git

    Bonds fall initially as inflation rises, but offer strong convexity if yields keep rising.

    Rising inflation tends to lift rates. Bonds initially perform poorly for the same second-responder reason as trend-following, since positions turn slowly. But if yields rise in a sustained way, bonds eventually offer strong convexity. Yoav uses this to explain why bonds and commodity trend pair well as a defensive, inflation-plus portfolio.

    “If inflation starts rising, we tend to see rates rising. And what you find is that initially bonds will perform poorly exactly for the same reason that we discussed. There are second responders. But if we see sustained rise in yields, eventually bonds will offer a great convexity.”at 39:57

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Yoav Git

    Equity trend protects in long drawdowns but comes too late in sharp crises like March and April 2025.

    Equity trend's protection depends on the shape of the drawdown. Historically, when crises are sorted by length, equity trend is very helpful in protracted drawdowns because it changes its exposure and turns negative, so it really starts making money. In sharp drawdowns followed by fast recoveries it works the other way: equity tends to whipsaw in both directions. He cites March and the April 2025 'Liberation Day' selloff, where the equity part of the convexity arrived after the market had already recovered. Because a drawdown comes after a big rally, a trend strategy starts out long equity and loses money before it turns negative. Most of the crisis protection in those episodes therefore came from the bond portfolio.

    “When we see a sharp crisis, the equity part of the convexity actually is just too late to the party.”at 31:03
  • Yoav Git

    Equities deliver inflation plus 10-12% when inflation is low, but only inflation when it is high.

    Equities behave like a growth asset. When inflation is low or falling and the economy is benign, equities can deliver inflation plus 10 to 12%. In high-inflation environments they still roughly keep pace with inflation but do not provide the extra return. Equity returns are therefore inflation plus something that varies with growth, while bond plus commodity trend gives inflation plus a roughly constant amount.

    “So what you see is when inflation is going down or inflation is low, equity... will give you inflation plus 10 or 12%.”at 42:41

Market sentiment, positioning & volatility

Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility

  • Yoav Git

    Equities show short-term reversals as investors buy dips, which makes fast equity trend hard to run.

    Equity returns show negative autocorrelation: a down day is more likely to be followed by an up day because value buyers step in. ETF flow data supports this. After a down month, investors tend to add slightly more money the following month, which is buying the dip. This makes fast trend-following in equities difficult, while slow trend has worked reasonably well. He also argues that equity trend's historical Sharpe ratio is weak, around 0.1 to 0.2.

    “The problem with equity is that you see a lot of value players in the market. So you tend to see reversals. You tend to see negative auto correlation in equity. So if equity goes down on day one, it's likely to go up actually on day two.”at 35:41
  • Yoav Git

    Investors chasing trend-following performance through fund flows is destructive to their returns.

    Investors buy and sell trend-following through ETF and mutual fund flows that track recent performance, so their behaviour looks like trend-following itself. Yoav calls this very destructive from an investor's perspective, especially when an allocator uses only one manager and switches when performance changes. He cites the Quantica paper as demonstrating how destructive this is, and suggests blending managers to reduce the damage.

    “they look at our performance and the flows that we see in the ETF and in the in the mutual funds, they reflect very much a trend following behavior. ... I think it's it's it's very destructive from an investor's perspective.”at 1:07:01

Middle East & Iran

Where everyone stands on Middle East & Iran

  • Yoav Git

    Post-midterm repricing of Iran expectations caused the November reversal that hurt CTAs' long energy positions.

    Yoav argues that the midterm results changed market expectations about what would happen in Iran, reversing the commodity move. Markets priced one outcome, but the Iranians, he says, think otherwise. This reversal hurt CTAs, which were mainly long energy, so the November pain came mostly from energy positions. He presents this as the main driver of CTA losses that month.

    “I think what has been happening is that the midterms really switched markets' expectations of what's going to happen in Iran. But of course, the Iranians think otherwise.”at 7:06

US inflation

Where everyone stands on US inflation

  • Yoav Git

    Above roughly 4–5% inflation, bond-equity correlation turns strongly positive, so bonds stop cushioning equities.

    Looking at the ten most severe equity drawdowns over roughly 65 years, bonds cushioned equities when inflation was low, and also when it was high, up to a point. He puts the middle ground at around 4–5% inflation. Above that level bond-equity correlation turns very positive, so bonds fall with equities, as in 2022 when inflation hit about 8.8% and both sold off. This matters for a 60/40 portfolio because the bond allocation loses its diversifying role.

    “But when inflation is high, it's like what we are seeing at the moment, it's not necessarily so. I think around four, 5% is kind of the middle ground. Above that level, you definitely start getting a very positive correlation between bonds and equity.”at 27:52

US deficit & government debt

Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt

  • Yoav Git

    Debt near 120% of GDP leaves little room for policy relief in an equity downturn.

    Debt is now around 120% of GDP. That leaves much less room for central banks and governments to provide relief in an equity downturn. Yoav says this is why people are likely to be worried about a sell-off. The country is not named explicitly, but the context is US markets.

    “debt is now sitting at a 120 of GDP, a 120% of GDPs or thereabout. And that means that there's a lot of... Lot less space for central banks and for governments to really provide relief in the case of an equity equity downturn.”at 38:44

US growth & recession risk

Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk

  • Yoav Git

    Stagflation could follow if AI capex financing falters, though he doubts the AI outcome is settled.

    Clients asked what happens to industrial production if the economy tanks. Yoav says that is a real concern. If financing for the capex being spent on equities runs into problems, stagflation could become an issue. He qualifies this by saying the AI outcome may not play out as expected, and he is personally quite bullish on the infrastructure being built.

    “If we start seeing problem in financing the CapEx that we are seeing in in equities, stagflation might be might be an issue.”at 44:01

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Yoav Git

    Hyperscaler AI capex resembles dot-com pipe-laying, whose builders earned little of the profit.

    Yoav does not see hyperscaler spending as a bet on AI. He compares it to dot-com telecom pipe-laying, where the firms that built the cables did not make much money. The main winners were the cash-rich, low-capex businesses that ran on top of the infrastructure, such as Google, Amazon and Facebook. He reads the current spending as the start of hyperscalers becoming infrastructure companies.

    “By the way, they are not the beneficiary of that boom. So the people that benefited most were actually Google and Amazon and Facebook that built cash rich, low CapEx businesses on top of those pipelines. It's the people who laid the pipeline didn't actually make that much money.”at 44:44

AI: overall outlook

Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook

  • Yoav Git

    He is very bullish on AI, with real applications still to come, after a possible valuation shakeout.

    Yoav is very bullish on AI and sees the current hyperscaler build-out as the start of a revolution. The infrastructure is being laid to build LLMs, and what can be done with it has barely been explored. He draws a parallel with the dot-com bubble. Investors may need a valuation collapse before the real economy and real applications kick in, which is how the Internet eventually paid off. He believes that adjustment is the likely path.

    “so I'm actually very bullish on AI, but we are like... I think we are we haven't even started to see the benefit”at 45:29

Enterprise AI adoption & AI software

Where everyone stands on Enterprise AI adoption & AI software

  • Yoav Git

    Low-capex software companies that consume AI will capture the benefits first; he is more excited by them.

    Yoav argues that the real benefits of AI have not yet appeared. They will show up first in software and other low-capex companies that consume AI and improve their businesses with it, rather than in the companies building the infrastructure. He says he is much more excited about these companies than about the hyperscalers, although he admits he does not know how it will play out.

    “We haven't even started to see the benefit in the sort of the people... The software, the low CapEx companies which are just consuming AI and really improving. ... I'm much more excited about those type of companies.”at 45:38

Topics

  • AI benefits for software companies
  • AI long-run potential
  • CTA bond exposure efficiency
  • Iran expectations repricing
  • bond performance under rising inflation
  • bond trend convexity
  • commodity trend and inflation regimes
  • commodity trend as a diversifier
  • commodity trend diversification
  • data center capex
  • debt capacity for crisis relief
  • equity dip-buying and flows
  • equity returns across inflation regimes
  • equity trend protection in drawdowns
  • industrial commodities and industrial production
  • inflation and bond-equity correlation
  • stagflation risk
  • trend-following fund flows

More from Top Traders Unplugged

All Top Traders Unplugged episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus