Noahpinion ·

Roundup #91: Rocketing into the technofuture

By Noah Smith

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

Noah Smith's Noahpinion roundup covers a range of economic and technology topics. On US macro, he argues that inflation is re-accelerating toward around 5%, partly due to the Iran War oil shock, budget deficits, political pressure on the Fed and data-center cost pressures, so real wages are falling and voters are likely to be angered. He calls inclusionary zoning a shadow tax that cuts new construction by roughly a third (citing Kouchekinia 2026) and should be scrapped, and he judges cash baby bonuses effective but far too small to reverse fertility decline, using Michigan's Rx Kids program as the example. On fiscal and political economy, he says both parties favour tax cuts alongside higher spending, so the debt problem persists, and he calls the Democratic agenda incoherent, recommending a more modest platform. He closes on AI, arguing that Google DeepMind's non-LLM WeatherNext 2 shows AI can uncover 'cloud laws' in complex systems and could drive a rapid scientific revolution.

Key takeaways

  • Noah Smith on US housing: Inclusionary zoning backfires by cutting construction and raising rents, so the policy should be scrapped.
  • Noah Smith on US inflation: US inflation is creeping back up, around 5% recently, and is broad-based rather than just oil-driven.
  • Noah Smith on US deficit & government debt: US debt problem won't be solved until both parties stop cutting taxes and raising spending together.
  • Noah Smith on US tax & spending policy: Baby bonuses raise births but their effects are far too small to fix the fertility decline.
  • Noah Smith on US elections & politics: Democrats' economic agenda is incoherent; they should adopt a more modest program and stop chasing Sanders-style spending.

What was said, by company and theme

7 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the post's text (how).

US housing

Where everyone stands on US housing

  • Noah Smith · Noahpinion

    Inclusionary zoning backfires by cutting construction and raising rents, so the policy should be scrapped.

    Noah argues that inclusionary zoning, which forces some units in new buildings to be rented cheaply, backfires. Forcing developers to take losses on some units makes building less financially viable, and developers recoup losses by raising rents on the market-rate units. He cites Kouchekinia (2026), who finds the typical ordinance cuts annual new residential construction by nearly a third (31.8%) and pushes developments to lower-rent areas, with an affordable unit costing about $800,000 in excess rents paid by market-rate renters. He calls it a shadow tax on everyone in the area: the policy looks costless because it has no direct fiscal cost, but it is extremely costly. He concludes it is time for the policy to go, since it cannot be salvaged and makes cities worse.

    “As Kouchekinia points out, making housing more scarce acts as a shadow tax on everyone in the area. Inclusionary zoning looks costless, but it's actually extremely costly.”

US inflation

Where everyone stands on US inflation

  • Noah Smith · Noahpinion

    US inflation is creeping back up, around 5% recently, and is broad-based rather than just oil-driven.

    Noah argues that the post-pandemic inflation victory may be ephemeral because inflation is creeping back up, with most recent months around 5% (with some volatility). He says the Iran War oil price rise is an obvious contributor, but the new inflation is remarkably broad-based, so the old 'it's just X and Y' dismissal no longer works. Possible causes he lists include budget deficits, Trump pressuring the Fed to be dovish, and cost pressures from the data center buildout. As a result, real wages are falling: the cost of living is rising faster than paychecks, so Americans are getting poorer this year, which he expects will anger voters.

    “But that victory might prove ephemeral; inflation is creeping back up. Though there's some volatility, most recent months have come in at around 5%”

US deficit & government debt

Where everyone stands on US deficit & government debt

  • Noah Smith · Noahpinion

    US debt problem won't be solved until both parties stop cutting taxes and raising spending together.

    Noah argues that both major parties now favor cutting taxes on most Americans, including most wealthy and high earners, while raising spending at the same time. This means there will be no escape from the debt problem until this political equilibrium changes. He contrasts 1992, when presidential candidates competed to present deficit-fixing plans, to show a different equilibrium is possible. He adds that higher deficits and debt contribute to faster inflation, which has punished both Biden and Trump, so Democrats are deluding themselves if they think it can't happen to them again. He cites Levitz's estimate that the Democrats' agenda would push the deficit above $2 trillion a year, which would put upward pressure on rates and prices.

    “This is a big problem for the country, because there will be no getting out of our debt problem until this political equilibrium changes.”

US tax & spending policy

Where everyone stands on US tax & spending policy

  • Noah Smith · Noahpinion

    Baby bonuses raise births but their effects are far too small to fix the fertility decline.

    Noah argues that cash baby bonuses do work, but their effects are too small. Using Hartley and Jaros's evaluation of Michigan's Rx Kids program, a $7,500 bonus in Flint raised 2024 births about 7.5% above baseline, at roughly $107,000 of program spending per induced birth. The US total fertility rate is about 1.6 against replacement of 2.0 to 2.1, requiring a gain of at least 25%, far beyond what the program achieved. South Korea, at 0.8, would need a 150% increase, about 20 times the Michigan effect. He concludes that the country won't buy its way out of the baby bust with these payments, though he still thinks paying people to have kids is a good idea.

    “The issue isn't that these programs don't work. They do. The problem is that their effects aren't very large.”

US elections & politics

Where everyone stands on US elections & politics

  • Noah Smith · Noahpinion

    Democrats' economic agenda is incoherent; they should adopt a more modest program and stop chasing Sanders-style spending.

    Noah argues that Democrats' economic program is incoherent. He cites Levitz's point that the party promised to bring down inflation and interest rates, dramatically expand the welfare state, and raise taxes only on the very wealthy, and that these goals can't all be met. He says taxing only billionaires is insufficient to fund the agenda. He concludes that until fear of the deficit creates a fiscal-hawk equilibrium, Democrats need a more modest agenda. An anti-corruption drive, tariff repeal, and policies to spread AI's wealth would satisfy Americans, so Democrats should stop chasing the Bernie Sanders dream for a while.

    “Until then, Democrats need a more modest economic agenda. The American people can be satisfied with an anti-corruption drive, tariff repeal, and policies to spread the wealth generated by AI.”

AI: overall outlook

Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook

  • Noah Smith · Noahpinion

    AI will drive the most rapid and dramatic scientific revolution in history by uncovering 'cloud laws'.

    Noah argues that AI will cause a scientific revolution because there are many 'cloud laws': exploitable, stable causal relationships made of diffuse, densely interrelated weak effects that human minds cannot grasp or separate into chunks, but AI can learn and exploit. As evidence, he points to Google DeepMind's WeatherNext 2, which beats the previous state-of-the-art system on 99.9% of weather variables over 15 days and gives a 24-hour advantage in tropical cyclone tracking. It learned from isolated marginals without the joint systems, and it predicted complex joint structures anyway. Noah contrasts this with reductionist physics-based forecasting and guesses weather has cloud laws. He thinks other phenomena may also be governed by such laws, and if so, science is in for its most rapid revolution.

    “If so, we're in for the most rapid and dramatic scientific revolution in our entire history.”

Frontier AI labs & model race

Where everyone stands on Frontier AI labs & model race

  • Noah Smith · Noahpinion

    AI is more general than the LLM techniques frontier labs are focusing on, shown by Google's weather model.

    Noah points out that the model Google used for its weather forecasting breakthrough was not an LLM. He takes this as evidence that AI is more general than the specific techniques the frontier labs are currently concentrating on. The successful non-LLM approach, which learned weather structure from isolated data and beat physics-based systems, suggests the field's broader potential extends beyond the current LLM focus.

    “Also note that the model Google used here wasn't an LLM. This suggests that AI is more general than the specific techniques the frontier labs are currently focusing on.”

Topics

  • AI beyond LLMs
  • AI-driven scientific discovery
  • Democratic economic agenda
  • baby bonuses and fertility
  • deficits and debt
  • inclusionary zoning
  • inflation re-acceleration

More from Noahpinion

All Noahpinion posts

Ask your AI about this post

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this post and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus