India is quietly doing great
By Noah Smith
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Noah Smith argues that India is quietly doing very well, citing a sharp fall in extreme poverty over two decades, a fall in inequality unlike China's, and growth of about 6.5% a year that has outpaced China since the pandemic. He says manufacturing is now growing alongside services, with a broad base spanning electronics and high-tech exports, despite China restricting technology and expertise to India. He credits a roughly fourfold rise in government investment, including fivefold highway and eightfold rail spending, while being skeptical that The Economist's emphasis on reforms and prudent macro policy explains the boom. He also contrasts India's simpler goal of escaping poverty with China's harder challenges, and notes he has grown more bearish on China, warning India's boom may not last beyond the next couple of years.
Key takeaways
- Noah Smith on Emerging markets: India is a big economic success story, perhaps the brightest economy in the world right now.
- Noah Smith on Manufacturing & industrial policy: India's manufacturing boom is broad-based and high-tech, a key driver of its growth, unlike Bangladesh's garment-led boom.
- Noah Smith on Emerging markets: India's government infrastructure spending is boosting growth now and will ease manufacturing and consumption later.
- Noah Smith on Emerging markets: Macro stability and reform headlines don't explain India's growth; most structural reform is still ahead.
- Noah Smith on China's economy: Increasingly skeptical China can eclipse the US and allies, lead in AI, reach Taiwan's income, or dominate Asia.
What was said, by company and theme
5 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the post's text (how).
Emerging markets
Where everyone stands on Emerging markets
Noah Smith · Noahpinion
India is a big economic success story, perhaps the brightest economy in the world right now.
India has cut extreme poverty sharply over the last two decades, a 'full tenth of humanity saved from deprivation', and did so while reducing inequality, unlike China. The World Bank attributes this to consumption growth, rising female employment and social transfers, and the author says growth must take most of the credit because there is less to redistribute without it. Since the pandemic India has grown faster than China. At about 6.5% a year, growth still roughly doubles living standards every decade, and the author notes China only slowed to India's current rate in 2014, when it was 40% richer than India is now. Growth is broad, with manufacturing, finance, real estate, business services and IT all expanding at once. The author concludes India is a big success story, perhaps the brightest in the world right now, and says its boom may not last past the next couple of years.
“for now, India looks like a big economic success story — perhaps the brightest in the entire world right now.”
Noah Smith · Noahpinion
India's government infrastructure spending is boosting growth now and will ease manufacturing and consumption later.
Government investment has risen about fourfold since before the pandemic even as the country's debt levels have fallen, which the author calls one bright spot. Highway spending has risen fivefold over the last decade and central government railway spending eightfold, correcting one of India's notorious chronic deficiencies. The author argues this boosts growth in the short term, and in the long term it will make both manufacturing and consumption much easier. It is also changing the physical look of the country, much as China's modernisation did in the 2000s and 2010s, and India is now building its own bullet trains.
“This is boosting growth in the short term, but in the long term it'll make both manufacturing and consumption a lot easier in India.”
Noah Smith · Noahpinion
Macro stability and reform headlines don't explain India's growth; most structural reform is still ahead.
The author is skeptical of The Economist's account that liberalising reforms and prudent macro policy drive India's growth. Fiscal consolidation is good, but India's long-term borrowing rates have not fallen much. A stable financial system is good, but the author does not see how it automatically accelerates growth. Most of the structural reform The Economist cites is still in the future. Business expectations of reform could drive growth, but domestic private-sector investment is not really driving the boom, and FDI has been sluggish until recently.
“Fiscal probity is well and good, but India's long-term borrowing rates haven't come down all that much”
Manufacturing & industrial policy
Where everyone stands on Manufacturing & industrial policy
Noah Smith · Noahpinion
India's manufacturing boom is broad-based and high-tech, a key driver of its growth, unlike Bangladesh's garment-led boom.
The author calls manufacturing growth 'another important factor' in India's growth story and says it corrects a long-standing deficiency. The old story was that India leapfrogged manufacturing into services such as call centres, BPO and software outsourcing, which hid a disappointment at not joining the industrialisation that lifted other countries out of poverty. Now manufacturing grows alongside services. The breadth is the key point: Bangladesh's manufacturing boom last decade ran mostly on garments, while India makes and exports many different high-tech products. The author also says this happened despite China trying to throttle Indian industrialisation by denying key technology exports and factory expertise. Manufacturing output and electronics exports data are cited from The Economist, not the author's own estimates.
“India's current growth is very broad-based — manufacturing is growing right alongside services.”
China's economy
Where everyone stands on China's economy
Noah Smith · Noahpinion
Increasingly skeptical China can eclipse the US and allies, lead in AI, reach Taiwan's income, or dominate Asia.
The author's previous post shifted him toward bearishness on China's continued economic and technological outperformance. He frames China's future success as whether it will eclipse the combined economies of the U.S. and its allies, seize the lead in AI, reach Taiwan or South Korea's income level, or dominate Asia. He says he is increasingly skeptical of China's ability to do all of these things. Contrast this with India, whose task is simpler: escape poverty and become an upper-middle-income country. The post gives no further data on China's economy.
“I'm increasingly skeptical about its ability to do all of those things.”
Topics
- China's growth outperformance
- India government infrastructure investment
- India growth drivers
- India's growth
- India's manufacturing growth
More from Noahpinion
- Roundup #91: Rocketing into the technofuture · November 18, 2026
Ask your AI about this post
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this post and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus