Eurodollar University · · 21 min
Home Sales Just Crashed 18%. Everyone Is Missing the Real Warning
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Jeff Snider argues that the US housing market is already in a volume crash even though prices have held up, with pending home sales down about 18% over six months to a record low and buyer counts at their lowest since 2013 while sellers outnumber buyers by roughly 70%. He contrasts this with 2008: today's weakness comes from a disappearing buyer pool rather than forced foreclosures, so prices could eventually fall without distressed selling. He links the housing slump to weakening jobs and income, sluggish single-family construction and permits, and consumer retrenchment, describing a feedback loop that standard models miss. He also reads the flat long end of the Treasury curve as bond markets doubting the economy can sustain these headwinds, suggesting the Fed may eventually be forced to reconsider its hawkish stance.
Key takeaways
- Jeff Snider on US housing: Housing is in an activity crash: buyers are disappearing and pending sales hit record lows, before any price crash.
- Jeff Snider on US consumer: Consumers are defensive, delaying big purchases and carrying card debt, and the housing wealth effect is at risk.
- Jeff Snider on US growth & recession risk: The US economy is fragile, not resilient, losing forward momentum in a feedback loop across housing, jobs and consumers.
- Jeff Snider on US housing: Single-family construction is cracking, with permits at a nearly four-year low and builders cutting prices.
- Jeff Snider on US housing: Home prices may start falling, but from excess sellers rather than forced foreclosure selling as in 2008.
What was said, by company and theme
8 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
US housing
Where everyone stands on US housing
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
Housing is in an activity crash: buyers are disappearing and pending sales hit record lows, before any price crash.
Pending home sales fell about 18% over six months to a record low, and fell another 4.7% in October, the lowest since NAR began tracking in 2001. Pending sales lead closings by several weeks, so they signal weak completed sales ahead. Buyer demand is the problem: Redfin counted about 895,752 buyers nationally, the lowest since 2013, while sellers outnumbered buyers by about 70.5% in October, the sixth straight record. Snider says this is not 2008, where forced foreclosure selling drove prices down. Today the decline is in volume driven by a disappearing buyer pool, which he links to weakening jobs and income. He concludes the housing crash in activity has already begun, even though prices have held up so far.
“But that also doesn't mean what we're watching isn't becoming an honest to goodness crash in housing activity. Buyers are disappearing.”at 0:27
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
Single-family construction is cracking, with permits at a nearly four-year low and builders cutting prices.
October housing starts rose about 10% month on month, but Snider says almost all of that came from multifamily construction, which is very noisy (multifamily starts rose 23.6%). Single-family starts rose only 4% from September and were down 3.2% year on year. He treats single-family permits as the more important signal of what builders intend to do next, and they fell to a nearly four-year low and are falling quickly. He reads builders cutting prices, offering incentives and slowing the pipeline as a sign that they do not believe demand will last.
“Single family construction is starting to crack where permits have fallen to a nearly four year low.”at 20:39
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
Home prices may start falling, but from excess sellers rather than forced foreclosure selling as in 2008.
Snider says prices have stayed stable so far because homeowners are not being forced to liquidate at distressed prices, and fixed-rate, refinanced mortgages mean no wave of ARM resets. He argues that stability is misleading, because transactions have frozen as locked-in owners stay put and buyers cannot afford current prices. Once the buyer shortage becomes impossible to hide, prices can fall without foreclosures, because sellers only need to be willing or obliged to negotiate. With more than 70% more sellers than buyers and buyers at record lows, he expects prices to begin falling for a different reason than in 2008. He hedges the timing with 'may now be approaching'.
“And prices may now be approaching the point where they begin falling for a completely different reason than they did in 2008. Not because banks are dumping foreclosures, but because there are simply more sellers than buyers.”at 20:49
US consumer
Where everyone stands on US consumer
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
Consumers are defensive, delaying big purchases and carrying card debt, and the housing wealth effect is at risk.
Snider says consumers' behaviour contradicts the official story of strong spending. Survey after survey shows households delaying large purchases, carrying expensive credit card balances, and becoming reluctant to change jobs. He argues the spending strength rests on a wealth effect from rising home prices in 2021-2022, which led homeowners to refinance, borrow against equity and buy vehicles. That wealth effect works in reverse: if home prices fall, owners will borrow and spend less, buyers will wait, and the consumer argument that depends on asset values weakens.
“They're delaying large purchases. It's not just pessimism. They're carrying expensive credit card balances.”at 4:01
US jobs & labor market
Where everyone stands on US jobs & labor market
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
The labor market drives everything, and households already feel employment deteriorating despite official resilience claims.
Snider argues that mortgages are bets on future income, so the expected ability to pay matters more than the rate. Official data says employment is broadly resilient, but households are pointing to layoffs, hiring freezes and downward revisions to labor data, which show a weaker market than headline figures suggest. He says a household does not need to be unemployed to turn defensive; believing employment is deteriorating is enough. He concludes that the labor market, not inflation or rates, is what drives housing and the wider economy.
“It's the labor market that matters and the housing market, the labor market is the one that's driving everything.”at 5:20
US growth & recession risk
Where everyone stands on US growth & recession risk
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
The US economy is fragile, not resilient, losing forward momentum in a feedback loop across housing, jobs and consumers.
Snider lists weak pending home sales, slowing construction, weak builder confidence, poor hiring and very weak consumer confidence. He argues that no single item proves a 2009-style recession, but together they describe an economy with no forward momentum, which official data calls resilience. He describes a sequence: consumers lose confidence in jobs and income, delay home purchases, builders cut construction, construction firms cut hours and hiring, suppliers buy fewer commodities, and weaker employment income reinforces the pessimism. He says this feedback loop is what standard models miss, because each step looks manageable on its own.
“Together though, they describe an economy at least without forward momentum, and that's what they call resilient.”at 13:35
US rates & the Fed
Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
The Fed's hawkish script will fade, since housing stress would force it to soften and refocus on the economy.
Snider argues that if housing turns clearly, with prices showing stress, the Fed will not be as aggressively hawkish, and may not be hawkish at all. He concedes the Fed will likely keep emphasising inflation and sounding hawkish in the short run. But he says markets already price in a change in expectations at some point, and housing would be a major reason for the Fed to refocus on the economy. He also says the short end of the curve may keep pricing hikes while the long end asks whether the economy can sustain its headwinds. He sees the Fed's hawkish stance as something the market does not believe can be sustained.
“Suddenly the Federal Reserve, you'll see, won't be nearly as aggressively hawkish. It may not be hawkish at all if the housing market shows more obvious signs of stress and strain.”at 17:25
US Treasuries & yields
Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields
Jeff Snider · Atlas Financial
The bond rally reflects deteriorating economic capacity, not just bets on a few Fed rate cuts.
Snider reads the flat long end of the yield curve as asking whether the economy can sustain housing, construction, employment, credit and possibly AI-related headwinds together. He says the front end responds to central bank language, while longer maturities stay unconvinced, and swap spreads have not moved, which signals no durable change in Fed communication. He compares this to late 2023, when officials stressed inflation risk while bond markets priced eventual economic weakness. He concludes the bond rally was a response to deteriorating capacity, and that the Fed can delay recognising it but cannot reverse the consequences.
“The bond rally wasn't simply traders betting on a few rate cuts, it was a response to deteriorating capacity.”at 19:05
Topics
- consumer spending and confidence
- economic fragility
- home construction
- home prices
- home sales activity
- labor market weakness
- rate cuts
- yield curve signal
More from Eurodollar University
- Markets Are Being Liquidated...Here’s What’s Really Happening · November 19, 2026
- Commodities Are Signaling Something Very Strange Is About to Happen · November 18, 2026
- China’s Banks Have Never Done This Before · November 15, 2026
- Commodity Markets Are Preparing for Something · November 13, 2026
- Baby Food Prices Just Revealed a Dark Truth About the U.S. Economy · November 12, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus