CNBC Power Lunch · · 47 min

NVIDIA CEO Fallout, AI Trade Risks and Retail Earnings Setup

With Gene Munster, Jeff Kilburg, Stephanie Link, Steve Sosnick, Tim Higgins

Summary

CNBC Power Lunch examined the fallout from Nvidia's CEO departure and whether the AI trade still holds. Stephanie Link sold Nvidia, judging the leadership saga would leave the stock dead money for months despite strong cash generation, and she bought more Micron and Broadcom instead, citing cleaner stories and AI segment growth. Gene Munster, by contrast, bought Nvidia on the dip, arguing AI build-out demand will outperform, though he doubts a founder-like replacement for Jensen Huang and puts Huang's return at 10%. The show also covered energy after a crude selloff (Jeff Kilburg favoring Marathon Petroleum and ExxonMobil), precious metals pullbacks in gold and silver, rising Treasury yield volatility that Steve Sosnick read as a warning for equities, and a retail earnings preview where Link highlighted Target and Dick's turnarounds amid a selective consumer.

Key takeaways

  • Stephanie Link (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's fundamentals are strong, but the CEO-saga overhang means she sold and will stay out near term.
  • Steve Sosnick (uncertain on NVIDIA): Retail dip-buying in Nvidia is risky; fundamental-news selloffs tend to pressure stocks longer.
  • Gene Munster (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia will likely outperform the AI trade over the next year, driven by undeniable AI demand.
  • Jeff Kilburg (bullish on Marathon Petroleum): Refiner Marathon Petroleum is a best-in-breed energy buy after the crude selloff; his fund owns it.
  • Tim Higgins on US elections & politics: Democrats winning Congress will curb tech leaders' political power, reversing their influence.

What was said, by company and theme

18 views from 5 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 141 speakers in other episodes, 131 bullish and 97 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBearish

    Nvidia's fundamentals are strong, but the CEO-saga overhang means she sold and will stay out near term.

    Link says Nvidia's fundamentals are excellent: the stock trades at about nine times fiscal 2028 numbers and will generate huge cash flow, almost $50 billion in one quarter and $300 billion next year. She still sold because the leadership saga will dominate headlines for many months, and she sees the stock as dead money while leadership changes and distractions play out. She compares it with Boeing: Boeing had structural problems, but Nvidia's problem is its CEO, not the company's moat, products or customers. She would consider buying back in six months to a year if a good CEO is in place and things settle.

    “the fundamentals are incredible. ... the overhang from this whole saga is just gonna dominate the headlines for the next many months. And so I sold it.”at 4:59
  • Steve Sosnick · Interactive BrokersUncertain

    Retail dip-buying in Nvidia is risky; fundamental-news selloffs tend to pressure stocks longer.

    Sosnick says he sold Nvidia earlier on profit-taking. He notes that customers have been buying the dip relentlessly, and buying volume is five times larger than a week ago. He draws a line between stocks that fall after earnings on decent news, which usually bounce, and stocks that fall on fundamental news that makes institutions rethink the company. Institutions leaving a big holding keeps pressure on the stock for a while. He cautions that retail buyers may be surfing a wave when the selling could be a tidal shift.

    “we've seen our customers buying the dip relentlessly in this stock.”at 6:30
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBullish

    Nvidia will likely outperform the AI trade over the next year, driven by undeniable AI demand.

    Munster bought Nvidia after the midterm sell-off and bought about four times as much after Huang lost his job. He is not calling a bottom, but he expects the stock to outperform the rest of the AI trade over the next year. The reason is the undeniable demand for AI below the surface. He expects the AI build-out to be much stronger than people expected, even with Washington's noise, and says Nvidia will benefit. The near-term worries about guidance, financing and a new CEO are surface issues that the market already prices in, which makes it close to a floor.

    “the reason why you should own Nvidia here, and I'm not calling the bottom, but I am saying that this stock will likely outperform the rest of the AI trade over the next year.”at 20:49
  • Gene Munster · Deepwater Asset ManagementBearish

    Replacing founder Jensen Huang with an urgent successor is next to impossible; Nvidia is no longer a clear decade-long compounder.

    Munster says he is not saying Nvidia is still a generational company or a stock to own for the next ten years. His central long-term concern is that replacing a founder who has urgency, like Huang, is next to impossible. Generational tech companies are typically founder-led with a wartime mentality against competition, and he cites Microsoft and Google as examples of what happens when founders leave. He puts the odds that Huang returns as CEO at 10%. He is open to whoever comes in, but the long-term view depends on whether the new leadership has urgency.

    “The central issue is that to replace a founder that has urgency, and Jensen is one of them, is next to impossible.”at 23:20

Micron Technology

Across the shows: 22 speakers in other episodes, 23 bullish and 14 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Micron Technology

  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish

    Micron is a cleaner, cheaper story than Nvidia, so she bought more ahead of earnings.

    Link bought more Micron after selling Nvidia. Micron is down about 30-35% from its highs, like Nvidia, but she sees it as a cleaner story with good fundamentals and no leadership overhang. It trades at about four times earnings and has a lot of free cash flow. She expects strong earnings next week and a buyback announcement, since the company has been restricted from buying back stock and can now do so.

    “I took the money and I put more into Micron ... Micron is just a cleaner story. It has good fundamentals, and yet they don't have this overhang. And by the way, trades at four times earnings”at 5:39

Broadcom

Across the shows: 15 speakers in other episodes, 15 bullish and 6 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Broadcom

  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish

    Broadcom is a high-conviction AI play; she would add to it and prefers it over AMD.

    Link owns Broadcom and would like to make the position bigger because she has conviction in its AI transition. She expects 100% growth in the AI segment alone in 2027 and 2028 and cites $20 of earnings power. She prefers Broadcom to AMD, though she thinks both will benefit from the current AI trade.

    “I own Broadcom, and I would love to make it bigger because I have conviction in their AI transition. 100% growth in '27 and '28, just on the AI segment alone.”at 12:32

Exxon Mobil

Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, 1 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • Jeff Kilburg · KKM FinancialBullish

    ExxonMobil is a best-in-breed energy buy after the crude selloff, one of his fund's picks.

    Kilburg calls ExxonMobil the biggest of the big oil companies, close to a trillion dollars in market cap. Crude's selloff in November creates an opportunity in essential energy names that will keep making money and growing. He says ExxonMobil is his fund's other energy pick, alongside Marathon Petroleum, which is the top weighting in his energy position.

    “ExxonMobil is not quite at a trillion dollars of market cap, but it is the biggest of the bigs. ... And ExxonMobil is the other pick there.”at 30:15

Marathon Petroleum

Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 1 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • Jeff Kilburg · KKM FinancialBullish

    Refiner Marathon Petroleum is a best-in-breed energy buy after the crude selloff; his fund owns it.

    Kilburg says energy is the best S&P 500 sector and that the opportunity is in best-in-breed names. Crude has fallen about $15.20 in November to around $88 for the front-month WTI future. He sees essential energy companies continuing to make money and grow for shareholders. His fund owns Marathon Petroleum, its largest weighting, and he prefers stock picking to the concentrated XLE ETF.

    “I think the opportunity is the own best in breed. So I look at Marathon Petroleum and ExxonMobil. ... These are essential names, and we're gonna continue to see them make money and grow”at 30:15

SPDR Gold Shares

Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, 1 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • Jeff Kilburg · KKM FinancialBullish

    Gold's pullback offers a buy opportunity; GLD has support near $3.10 and rate-hike fears are overblown.

    Gold is down about 10% this year after a 60% gain in 2025, and the metals have taken a breather. Kilburg attributes some weakness to expectations of more rate hikes but does not believe those have weighed on metals. He still sees a reason to buy, citing support at $3.10 in GLD (as stated on air). He sees a dip-buying opportunity in precious metals.

    “Well, Dom, quickly, let's look at gold and silver. It has been a rough year. Gold down about 10%. ... But I still think there's a reason to buy here.”at 31:15

iShares Silver Trust

  • Jeff Kilburg · KKM FinancialBullish

    Silver's roughly 30% drop is a buying opportunity, with support in the low $40s for SLV.

    Silver is down about 30% this year, after a gain of roughly 150% in 2025. Kilburg says the metals have taken a breather, and that rate-hike expectations have not weighed on them. He sees a reason to buy with support in the low forties in SLV (as stated on air), and says investors can dip back into precious metals.

    “But I still think there's a reason to buy here. There's support here at $3.10 in GLD ... and also in the low forties in SLV.”at 31:35

Target

Across the shows: 2 speakers in other episodes, 3 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish

    Target is a turnaround story; its new program is driving better sales and comps than Walmart.

    Link calls Target the turnaround story ahead of retail earnings. Her evidence is that the next-chapter program management has put in place is leading to better sales and better comps than Walmart. The host says Link owns Target, which makes her an investor in the name.

    “Target is the turnaround story... The next chapter program that he [has] put in place is leading to better sales, better comps than Walmart, by the way.”at 44:52

Dick's Sporting Goods

Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, 1 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • Stephanie Link · Hightower AdvisorsBullish

    Dick's is a buy: the stock is down about 30% on a fine core business and a top management team.

    Link argues the stock is down about 30% despite Dick's having one of the top-rated management teams. She says the core Dick's business is fine, with comps of 4% to 5%, and that the problem is Foot Locker, which is working through clearance inventory and launching new product. She adds that insiders have made record buybacks since August and that the stock trades at 12 times earnings with a yield of almost 4%. Kelly Evans notes Link doubled her position in Dick's.

    “the stock is down 30% for, like, one of the top rated company management teams out there. That the Dick's core business is fine. It's comps of 4% to 5%. It's Foot Locker that has the problem.”at 44:54

US Treasuries & yields

Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields

  • Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors

    Bonds become attractive to allocate to once the ten-year Treasury yield rises above 5%.

    Link says investors could start allocating to bonds when the ten-year yield is above 5%, and that there are switchers who will move in at that level. She sees opportunity in fixed income at that yield. She also notes the ten-year fell about 60 basis points from its peak to its recent low before rising, so volatility in fixed income is extreme.

    “I mean, even I was saying, like, you could probably start to allocate when the ten year is above five, you do get some switchers. There is opportunity.”at 14:32
  • Steve Sosnick · Interactive Brokers

    A sharp two-year yield rise suggests markets can't price low-risk assets, which raises concern for risk assets.

    Two-year Treasury yields rose more than 30 basis points this week, and the stock market reacted. Sosnick says this is a move he would not have predicted a week ago. He argues that a market that can't price low-risk assets calmly raises the question of how it is pricing high-risk assets. He treats the bond volatility as a warning sign for equities.

    “If I said a week ago, two year notes were going to go up by more than 30 basis points and the stock market was going to react. And when you have a market that can't price low risk assets, how are we pricing high risk assets?”at 15:22

Copper & industrial metals

Where everyone stands on Copper & industrial metals

  • Jeff Kilburg · KKM Financial

    Copper holding above $6 signals health in the economy, a positive read for the market.

    Kilburg says copper, known as Dr. Copper, is back above $6 and staying there. He treats this as evidence that there is health in the economy. He sees copper's price action as a sign of economic strength, alongside a dip-buying opportunity in other commodities.

    “look at doctor Copper. Doctor Copper is back above $6, ... staying above $6, revealing that there is health in this economy.”at 31:46

US elections & politics

Where everyone stands on US elections & politics

  • Tim Higgins · The Wall Street Journal

    Democrats winning Congress will curb tech leaders' political power, reversing their influence.

    Higgins argues that the broader shift in tech leaders' power is visible beyond Nvidia. About a week after the election, Democrats took control of Congress, and tech leaders will no longer have the same grasp on political power in the country that they did. He links this to a wider change in the power of Silicon Valley's founders and tech leaders.

    “Democrats taking control of congress. No longer are tech leaders going to have the same sort of grasp on how... Political power in this country as they did.”at 35:57

Antitrust & tech regulation

Where everyone stands on Antitrust & tech regulation

  • Tim Higgins · The Wall Street Journal

    Congressional scrutiny of how tech firms operated will distract tech leaders over the next two years.

    Higgins expects the next two years to be very confusing and potentially distracting for tech leaders. His mechanism is that Congress will get involved and look more closely at how major tech companies have operated over the past two years. The point is asserted with little concrete evidence.

    “the next two years are going to be very confusing if you're a tech leader and going to be incredibly distracting potentially as congress sticks its fingers, gets in deep, starts looking more closely at how some of these companies have operated”at 36:42

US consumer

Where everyone stands on US consumer

  • Stephanie Link · Hightower Advisors

    The consumer will keep spending while jobs and wage growth hold, with spending tilted to services.

    Link says the consumer is choosy after higher oil prices, price increases and higher interest rates. Back-to-school spending was strong but October was weak, so she wants to see November trends. She still expects the consumer to be okay as long as people keep their jobs and wage growth continues, because they are spending, with retail sales up 5.1% excluding gasoline. She notes spending is going to services rather than goods, which is why she advises being selective with retailers and favouring company-specific turnaround stories.

    “as long as they have jobs and they have wage growth, they are spending. I mean, retail sales are running up 5.1% ex gasoline.”at 44:08

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA141 speakers · 131 bullish, 97 bearish calls
  • Micron Technology22 speakers · 23 bullish, 14 bearish calls
  • Broadcom15 speakers · 15 bullish, 6 bearish calls
  • Marathon Petroleum2 speakers · 1 bullish, 0 bearish calls
  • Target2 speakers · 3 bullish, 0 bearish calls
  • Dick's Sporting Goods1 speaker · 1 bullish, 0 bearish calls
  • Exxon Mobil1 speaker · 1 bullish, 0 bearish calls
  • SPDR Gold Shares1 speaker · 1 bullish, 0 bearish calls

Topics

  • AI demand and build-out
  • AI segment growth
  • CEO saga overhang on stock
  • Treasury yield volatility
  • bond yield entry point
  • congressional scrutiny of tech companies
  • consumer spending
  • copper as economic signal
  • founder succession and culture
  • gold price pullback
  • memory chip stock valuation
  • oil equities after crude selloff
  • retail turnaround
  • silver price pullback
  • tech leaders' political influence

More from CNBC Power Lunch

All CNBC Power Lunch episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus