Thoughtful Money · · 1h 43m

US Home Prices Set To Fall Faster Than Even The Bears Expected | Melody Wright

With John, Melody Wright, Mike

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

Melody Wright argues that US home prices are turning negative year over year for the first time in three years and will fall faster than expected, driven by mortgage-rate pressure on $500K to $1M sales, rising insurance, tax and electricity costs, and accelerating foreclosures that she expects to reach 2007 levels by Q2 next year. She links the housing slump to a data center slowdown: Texas projects such as Stargate Abilene face permitting problems for behind-the-meter gas plants, lien filings from unpaid contractors, and drying-up private financing, with Oracle's exposure via Project Jupiter flagged as underpriced by its credit default swaps. Co-hosts Mike and John broadly agree on a multi-year housing sell-off and a richly valued S&P 500, with Mike warning of 20 to 30% housing declines and a possible 60% equity reset. They also cover the firm's defensive shift in equity exposure, a gold and silver bull market they see bottoming after a roughly 30% pullback, bonds as ballast, and a rallying dollar near DXY 103.

Key takeaways

  • Melody Wright on US housing: Foreclosures are accelerating; distressed selling begins in 2027 and foreclosure sales reach 2007 levels by Q2 next year.
  • Melody Wright on US housing: National home prices have turned negative year over year and will fall faster than she expected, possibly accelerating in Q1.
  • Melody Wright (bearish on Oracle): Oracle is highly exposed to data center builds, and its credit default swaps are not yet pricing that risk.
  • Melody Wright on Commercial real estate: Commercial real estate is hitting a debt maturity wall, with loans borrowed in 2021 now distressed.
  • Melody Wright on US housing: Housing faces only headwinds; nothing visible is coming to support home prices.

What was said, by company and theme

13 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Oracle

Across the shows: 31 speakers in other episodes, 10 bullish and 29 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Oracle

  • Melody Wright · Unicus ResearchBearish

    Oracle is highly exposed to data center builds, and its credit default swaps are not yet pricing that risk.

    Oracle is tied to the large Oracle-OpenAI Project Jupiter data center site on the Texas-New Mexico border, which has faced local pushback and a challenge from the New Mexico attorney general to its federal pipeline approval. Her view is that debt markets will decide the outcome more than politicians will. On what she saw on the ground, Oracle's credit default swaps are not yet wide enough, which she reads as the market underpricing how exposed Oracle is. The point is brief and not fully developed, so the conviction is moderate.

    “What I saw out there is that those credit default swaps are not wide enough on Oracle yet because they're so exposed.”at 20:44

US housing

Where everyone stands on US housing

  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Data center boomtowns like Abilene have distorted local housing, so a pullback would hit them hard.

    Data center build-outs have distorted housing in boomtowns. In Abilene, Texas, a town of about 130,000 people, home prices are up 26% year over year, and the median rent is $2,600 against a national median of $1,400. New Albany, Ohio, with 26,000 workers, is another example. Abilene's hotels were charging $447 a night, and a short-term rental colleague saw occupancy fall about 20% over recent months. If even a third of the construction workers leave, the local dynamics change a lot. Because the distortion runs through many places across the country, a slowdown would have a very big impact.

    “This is really distorted the market in many places across the country. So if you know, the air gets let out at all, it's going to have a very big impact.”at 5:04
  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Foreclosures are accelerating; distressed selling begins in 2027 and foreclosure sales reach 2007 levels by Q2 next year.

    Foreclosure sales were negligible in 2023 and did not weigh on median sales prices, but they are now accelerating and will keep accelerating because nothing is stopping them, especially in the FHA cohort. Prime-portfolio loans at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have started showing early delinquency over the summer. Loss mitigation options still exist, but she expects these loans to show up in the numbers in 12 to 18 months. She calls 2026 the year of the motivated seller and 2027 the beginning of the distressed seller. She expects foreclosure sales to reach 2007 levels by Q2 next year. A foreclosure moratorium would come too late, because the administration would have slowed things earlier if it wanted to, and the 2011 regulatory playbook did not stop the decline then either.

    “And now that those are accelerating and are going to accelerate because there there is nothing out there stop them, especially this FHA cohort.”at 14:24
  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    National home prices have turned negative year over year and will fall faster than she expected, possibly accelerating in Q1.

    Per Redfin's October sales data, national home prices are negative year over year for the first time in three years, which she calls a very significant corner. She had expected a slow grind lower but now says declines are coming faster than she anticipated. Drivers: rising mortgage rates are pulling regular sales back even more than in 2023, especially in the $500K-$1M range, where existing home sales show massive year-over-year declines; insurance, property taxes and electricity replacement costs have risen sharply; and foreclosure sales are accelerating. In 2023 the year-over-year declines were masked by high-end sales and government-subsidized transactions. If a stock market correction and a data center pullback hit too, she thinks the decline could accelerate in Q1. She also says a clear national downturn will be obvious to everyone by mid-next year, and only very large pay raises plus workers returning to the labor force would arrest it.

    “We could see home prices start to decline here faster than really I had anticipated. And if you add on kind of a stock market correction and then this data center pullback, we could really be looking at acceleration in q one faster than I would have anticipated.”at 14:31
  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Mortgage delinquencies will become a bigger public story by late this year or Q1 next year.

    At a mortgage servicing conference, servicers would not disclose delinquency rates, but their faces suggested the numbers were bad. Private non-qualified mortgages were already about 12% delinquent last year, and she thinks the situation is worse than that. Black Knight's delinquency report says delinquencies are back to 2019 levels, and Fed surveys show foreclosures and delinquencies ticking up, though it still looks minor. The FHA restrictions from October 2025 take time to bite, so borrowers will not run out of options until late Q4 and Q1. She expects delinquencies to become a bigger story by late this year or Q1 next year, and says servicers who have seen the loans already see the problem.

    “And so, yes, I think that by, you know, late end of the year, q one of next year, the delinquency story is going to be a bigger story.”at 32:52
  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Housing faces only headwinds; nothing visible is coming to support home prices.

    Home prices have seen massive year-over-year declines over the last several months, and the sellers who were holding prices up are now pulling back. Vacation-home owners, boomers and luxury-market speculators are offloading. Persil's stat that for every two vacation homes sold, one is bought shows the imbalance. Wright sees no offsetting support in the housing market, and she argues that affordability is at its worst and real wages are not growing fast enough.

    “And so, you know, it's it's just there's nothing coming for the housing market that we can see right now.”at 41:02
  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Rental prices are firming as 65-plus homeowners sell and become renters.

    Wright says rental prices are firming a little. The mechanism is that people are selling their homes, and the biggest group adding to the rental pool is those aged 65 and over. That supply shift is pushing rents up even as sale prices fall, though landlords are still offering concessions such as three months free.

    “Rental prices are firming a little bit. ... I think because there are people selling their homes, the biggest cohort adding to the rentals are the 65 plus so that they are actually firming up the rent right now.”at 42:50

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Texas data center projects lack proper air permits, so delays or denials will slow buildout and hit the economy near term.

    On her Texas data center tour she found that most projects going forward are behind-the-meter, building their own gas power plants rather than connecting to the grid. Developers got minor air permits, the kind for a dry cleaner, but these projects need major air permits, so their permits are in question. Some could be denied, and she thinks the more likely outcome is delay, which is enough to have a serious impact. Stargate Abilene peaked at about 9,000 construction workers and is already seeing that number roll over. A Microsoft expansion there is delayed because it lacks a permit. Local politicians, a federal lawsuit against Vantage in San Antonio, and a New Mexico challenge to federal approval for Project Jupiter all add to the delay. She says federal rescue is possible, such as buying land or saving projects, but it would still mean a significant delay. The slowdown will have a significant effect on the economy, beyond construction jobs.

    “And so all these permits are up in the air right now. And and some of them could get denied... It might just get delayed, which will be enough to have a serious impact.”at 3:41
  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Data center developers are running out of money as contractors file liens and private financing dries up.

    Public records show contractors filing mechanics liens on data center projects, such as Vantage, because they are not being paid quickly enough. These are construction workers and vendors who can file a lien against the property for unpaid work. Developers cannot pay them fast enough, so they are running out of money. At a Cloudburst neocloud site, construction had barely started, and the private financing it planned to use is drying up. She says cash running out is the biggest issue, bigger than the politics, and that it will produce a pause in construction that is enough to impact things in the short term.

    “But at the end of the day, what's going to happen, Adam, which I think is the more important thing is that all these people are running out of money.”at 7:11

US consumer

Where everyone stands on US consumer

  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Consumers are not doing well: rising gas and grocery costs force more spending, pushing up credit card balances.

    She is not optimistic about the consumer. Commentary that consumers keep spending misses that households have to buy groceries and pay more for gas, so spending goes up whether people want it to or not. Credit card balances are rising because people cannot afford everyday life. Consumer staples companies such as Home Depot are signaling danger. Existing home sales show the consumer under pressure in middle-market housing too.

    “Gas is more expensive. So I'm spending more whether I want to or not. And you're seeing on credit card balances, oh, you know, going up. Well, yeah, because people cannot afford just everyday life.”at 36:51

Commercial real estate

Where everyone stands on Commercial real estate

  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Commercial real estate is hitting a debt maturity wall, with loans borrowed in 2021 now distressed.

    Multifamily projects that were financed with debt have stopped paying their limited partners, and the problem has spread beyond a few sponsors to many investors. Wright says the cause is hitting a hard debt maturity wall: many deals borrowed in 2021 at low rates and assumed they could refinance, but the higher rates now are crushing them. She says the same pattern is playing out in commercial real estate.

    “I mean, it's because you're hitting that hard debt maturity wall, and a lot of them, you know, borrowed in '21.”at 38:14

Private credit

Where everyone stands on Private credit

  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    Private credit is still lending on investment properties, delaying a forced selling wave by short-term rental owners.

    Wright argues that short-term rental owners have not yet sold, despite the weakening market, because private credit funds are still lending on these investment properties. She says the market has not stopped completely. Once that lending stops, she expects a broad wave of selling across these properties.

    “Well, because private credit is still flowing, Adam. ... They are still lending on these investment properties.”at 40:23

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Melody Wright · Unicus Research

    A stock market correction is likely next year, and it would worsen the housing downturn.

    Wright believes a stock market correction is coming, based on what she observed on the road, and she says it would make the housing story even worse. A correction would push people to list vacation homes, and she calls the whole ecosystem very fragile right now.

    “barring some crazy thing, you know, we're going to see a stock market correction just based on what I saw on the road, because this stuff is... It's a very fragile ecosystem out there right now.”at 41:16

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • Oracle31 speakers · 10 bullish, 29 bearish calls

Ask your AI who they are and what they said

Topics

  • US stock valuations
  • bonds as portfolio ballast
  • city markets
  • data center boomtown housing
  • data center debt exposure
  • data center financing
  • data center permitting delays
  • debt maturity wall
  • dollar rally
  • foreclosures and distressed selling
  • gold bull market
  • home prices
  • household finances under strain
  • lending to investment properties
  • mortgage delinquencies
  • near-term US stock direction
  • near-term US stock risk
  • rental prices
  • software sector strength
  • stock market correction
  • valuation reset

More from Thoughtful Money

All Thoughtful Money episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus