CNBC Power Lunch · · 47 min

Anthropic's Record IPO, AI Selloff and Market Volatility

With Andrew Ross Sorkin, Dan Ives, Dario Amodei, John Ford, Julien Dumoulin-Smith, Leslie Picker, Mackenzie Sigalos, Peter Diamandis, Scott Chronert, Steve Grasso

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

CNBC's Power Lunch covered Anthropic's record IPO against a backdrop of AI-linked market volatility. Dan Ives called the offering a watershed for AI and argued the selloff, driven by Nvidia, China worries and an AMD short report, is a panic rather than a broken thesis, while Andrew Ross Sorkin questioned whether Anthropic's enterprise premium and margins can hold as cheaper OpenAI and Microsoft models gain ground. John Ford argued the AI trade has fragmented, with Anthropic strong while many infrastructure names fell, and defended AMD against a short report by stressing its narrow export-control exposure. Other panelists debated Fed rate risk, managed care audits, semiconductor valuations and whether hyperscalers remain the place to be, while Julian Dumoulin-Smith highlighted Texas data center permitting and federal energy permitting reform as key policy items.

Key takeaways

  • Andrew Ross Sorkin (uncertain on Anthropic): Anthropic's enterprise premium margins may not hold as cheaper rivals and models undercut frontier pricing.
  • John Ford (bullish on Advanced Micro Devices): Short report overstates AMD's China export-control exposure; the claims don't add up.
  • Dan Ives (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic's IPO is a watershed event, foundational to the AI buildout and a signal for OpenAI's 2027 listing.
  • Steve Grasso on US rates & the Fed: The Fed should not hike rates; inflation is not the problem and demand is already being destroyed.
  • Scott Chronert on AI chips & semiconductors: Semiconductor stocks look terrific on fundamentals, yet single-digit P/Es reflect growth expectations still to be reset.

What was said, by company and theme

20 views from 7 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Anthropic

Across the shows: 143 speakers in other episodes, 251 bullish and 117 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • Andrew Ross Sorkin · CNBCUncertain

    Anthropic's enterprise premium margins may not hold as cheaper rivals and models undercut frontier pricing.

    Sorkin says Anthropic has found enterprise customers who pay an extraordinary premium with extraordinary margins. He questions whether that premium and margin can hold as competition grows. He cites OpenAI's lower-token-cost products and Microsoft's models at about 5% of frontier-model cost, and argues frontier models will not be used for everything.

    “Anthropic has been maniacally focused on the enterprise and they have found customers willing to pay and pay an extraordinary premium, with an extraordinary margin. The long term question about that premium and margin”at 12:01
  • Dan Ives · Yorkville Ives & Co.Bullish

    Anthropic's IPO is a watershed event, foundational to the AI buildout and a signal for OpenAI's 2027 listing.

    Ives sees the Anthropic IPO as a watershed event for tech. He points to the institutional appetite shown in the roadshow as evidence the offering is foundational to the AI buildout. He adds that it lays groundwork for an OpenAI listing in 2027.

    “Anthropics, a watershed event for tech. I think if you look at the success that you've seen here on the IPO, the appetite I think you saw it institutionally in terms of the roadshow.”at 27:40
  • Dan Ives · Yorkville Ives & Co.Bullish

    Anthropic could reach about a $23 trillion valuation within five to seven years if its plans succeed.

    Ives frames Anthropic's upside around the capex cycle. If the company reaches the revenue level he describes, he sees a roughly $23 trillion markup over the next five to seven years. He calls Anthropic a huge piece of the multiplier effect from AI spending, though the other frontier models also matter. The transcript garbles the revenue figure, so the exact revenue assumption is unclear.

    “[If] they're successful ... you go out next five, six, seven years, you're looking at something that could be a $23,000,000,000,000 mark up like as it all plays out.”at 29:26

Advanced Micro Devices

Across the shows: 20 speakers in other episodes, 27 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Advanced Micro Devices

  • John Ford · CNBCBullish

    Short report overstates AMD's China export-control exposure; the claims don't add up.

    Ford says the short report cites about $7.75 billion of AMD China exposure. That is its overall China business, roughly 22% per the latest 10-K. Actual export-restriction exposure is much narrower, about $1.5 billion, mostly the MI308. He adds that the BIOS and firmware allegations are not clearly tied to GPUs, so the report does not make sense to him.

    “this report cites AMD's China exposure as being in the realm of $7,750,000,000... that's not their export restriction exposure. From the 10 k, that is just 1,500,000,000 mostly in the MI 308”at 22:58

AI: overall outlook

Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook

  • Peter Diamandis · XPRIZE Foundation

    AI progress is hyperexponential; company formation has sped from 21 years to unicorn status to one year.

    Diamandis argues the pace of technology-driven change is accelerating faster than past industrial revolutions. He cites the time to unicorn status falling from about 21 years on average in 2020 to about one year today. He says this is hyperexponential growth and that society does not yet know how fast it will move.

    “We're not just in an exponential growth. We're in a hyperexponential growth. You know, we call this the singularity for a reason.”at 15:22
  • John Ford · CNBC

    Anthropic's IPO could mark the end of AI as one trade; infrastructure stocks are falling while Anthropic rises.

    Ford argues the AI trade has split apart. Anthropic is doing extraordinarily well while many infrastructure names are down. Cybersecurity sits in a split position because AI breaks old defenses while also creating new demand. He concludes the AI trade is no longer one thing.

    “this anthropic IPO could mark the death of the AI trade as we know it... So the AI trade is all over the place. It's not just one thing anymore”at 21:48
  • Dan Ives · Yorkville Ives & Co.

    Selloff is panic; AI buildout is less than 15% complete and the thesis is intact.

    Ives calls the current tech weakness a panic moment rather than a break in the thesis. He argues the AI revolution is less than 15% through its build-out, so Anthropic's results are only one piece of a larger foundational trend. He says the bold thesis has not been dented by the selloff, which he attributes to Nvidia, China worries and the AMD short report.

    “it's a panic moment, but it's not stopping. I mean we're less than 15% through the build out of the AI revolution.”at 28:12
  • Steve Grasso · Grasso Global Inc.

    The AI trade isn't over; leadership rotates between hardware, software and hyperscalers, and free cash flow decides winners.

    Asked whether the AI trade is over, Grasso says he does not believe it is. He argues tech is a game of musical chairs where hardware sometimes outperforms, sometimes software does, and the hyperscalers lead at other times. His consistent test is free cash flow: the market is now asking how much a company returns on its AI investment rather than how much cash it still holds, and that is what makes free cash flow king.

    “No, I don't believe the AI trade is over. I believe that we play musical chairs within technology.”at 37:44

AI bubble & tech valuations

Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations

  • Andrew Ross Sorkin · CNBC

    AI ecosystem was more bubbly in June than it is now, when the SpaceX IPO was happening.

    Sorkin compares the environment for Anthropic's IPO with the June environment around SpaceX. He points to the AI ecosystem, compute and memory names as evidence. He argues the market was more bubbly then than it is now, so the environment Anthropic is walking into is different.

    “I don't want to say it was more of a bubble, but it was more bubbleicious back then than clearly where we are now.”at 9:43
  • Dan Ives · Yorkville Ives & Co.

    This is not a 2007-style bubble given valuation growth; recent selloffs are buying opportunities.

    Ives compares the current drawdown to April 2025 Liberation Day and March 2020 COVID, which he calls opportunities. He argues the situation is not a 2007-style bubble, especially given how much valuations have grown alongside earnings. He also says bears who were hibernating are now coming out.

    “I think we're going to look back on this period just like April 2025 Liberation Day and March 2020 during COVID as the opportunity. This is not some sort of you know, bubble 2007 type”at 31:13

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Scott Chronert · Citi Research

    Excess demand for AI compute over supply favours hyperscalers and AI spenders, though capex paths and societal pushback are unknown.

    Kronert says the one thing they know is that AI compute demand exceeds supply, and that works in the hyperscalers' favour. He thinks the hyperscalers ultimately win and are the place to be, even as software names get beaten up on some days. He flags two open questions: the capex trajectory of the AI spenders, and gating factors such as societal pushback, which will be determined later.

    “we've got excess demand for AI compute versus supply. We've got that working for us. We don't know about the CapEx trajectories.”at 39:15
  • Julien Dumoulin-Smith · Jefferies

    Texas re-permitting data centers is a welcome first step, but the moratorium question stays open until next year's legislature.

    Dumoulin-Smith calls the Texas Commission on Environment Quality decision great news and a down payment, though an incremental one. Some had expected this action since the prior administration. The bigger question is whether the Texas legislature and the governor's office will lift the moratorium in the first half of next year. He also notes that companies had already said they were leaving Texas because of permitting ambiguity, so the immediate market reaction is unsurprising.

    “it's great news. It's a great down payment as far as it goes.”at 43:59

Venture capital & startups

Where everyone stands on Venture capital & startups

  • Peter Diamandis · XPRIZE Foundation

    Wealth from AI leaders will recycle into a flood of new startups, accelerating the next wave.

    Diamandis says companies like Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI are minting thousands of multimillionaires. He expects these founders to reinvest their capital in friends' companies. He sees a massive inflow of seed capital into areas like AI, robotics, 3D printing and synthetic biology, which he says accelerates the pace of change.

    “they're gonna take their capital and reinvest it in their friends' companies. So we're about to see a massive inflow of capital seeding the next series of”at 17:04

Cybersecurity

Where everyone stands on Cybersecurity

  • John Ford · CNBC

    Cybersecurity is caught between AI breaking old defenses and AI creating demand for new ones.

    Ford places cyber in a mixed position in the AI trade. AI can break old defenses, which is a harm, but it also drives demand for new ones, which is a benefit. He therefore sees cyber straddling the benefit and harm realms rather than being a clear beneficiary.

    “cyber that sort of straddles the benefit and harm realm where cyber is caught between AI breaking old defenses and driving demand for new ones.”at 22:01

US–China AI & chip race

Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race

  • Dan Ives · Yorkville Ives & Co.

    The US is two to three years ahead of China in chips, and that lead is not changing.

    Ives argues the US lead over China in chips is roughly two to three years despite Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's China comments. He says this gap is not changing and will keep playing out, which is why he sees China worries as overdone.

    “The US, despite Jensen, The US is two to three years ahead of China when it comes to chips and that continue that's not changing”at 31:10

Healthcare system & insurers

Where everyone stands on Healthcare system & insurers

  • Steve Grasso · Grasso Global Inc.

    New CMS managed-care audit lacks teeth, as the last attempt was thrown out of court.

    Grasso says managed care names are moving on CMS plans to audit. He argues the last attempt had no teeth and was thrown out of court, so managed care stocks are trading on how exposed each company is to Medicare.

    “The last time they tried to do this, it didn't have any teeth. It got thrown out of court. So when you see those managed care names and you look at all their charts, it's who is the most exposed to Medicare.”at 34:18

US rates & the Fed

Where everyone stands on US rates & the Fed

  • Steve Grasso · Grasso Global Inc.

    The Fed should not hike rates; inflation is not the problem and demand is already being destroyed.

    Grasso reads the market moves as signalling that Treasuries and the two-year yield spiked without the Fed. He notes breakevens have done nothing and real yields suggest this is not an inflation problem the Fed could fight. He argues demand destruction has already hit lower income brackets, so raising rates now would choke households already surviving on tight budgets.

    “It tells me that the Fed should not be hiking rates. ... If they raise rates now, they're actually going to choke people who are white knuckled on just surviving.”at 34:59

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Scott Chronert · Citi Research

    The market has a serious confidence problem; uncertainty relief has not come, so selling continues.

    Kronert says the market tends to sell uncertainty until it is alleviated, and it has not found that point. He sees two forces under the surface: a changing AI playbook moving away from semiconductor enablers into new areas, and the other half of the market trading on macro factors. He points to sticky inflation and an unclear Fed as unresolved, even as oil prices fall.

    “we've got a serious confidence problem. ... We haven't found a point where you're buying the alleviation.”at 35:40

AI chips & semiconductors

Where everyone stands on AI chips & semiconductors

  • Scott Chronert · Citi Research

    Semiconductor stocks look terrific on fundamentals, yet single-digit P/Es reflect growth expectations still to be reset.

    Kronert rates semis highly on growth, profitability and quality, and says the stocks can't get out of their way. He pairs this with a warning about valuation. The single-digit P/Es, in his view, reflect market expectations for future growth that have not yet been reset, so the group has not reached a clearing event where the market has priced in the worst case. He says his fund is not buying these stocks yet.

    “I think the semis look terrific on all metrics. Growth, profitability, quality metrics is to die for. Stocks can't get out of their way. They're trading at single digit PEs.”at 39:43

Power demand & the grid

Where everyone stands on Power demand & the grid

  • Julien Dumoulin-Smith · Jefferies

    The bipartisan permitting bill is the closest to real energy permitting reform in years and would benefit energy infrastructure.

    Dumoulin-Smith says the bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, due for a vote imminently, is the closest the country has come in years to real permitting reform. He thinks the hurdle is the House rather than the Senate. He argues it would benefit midstream and pipeline companies, oil and gas, and the renewable sector, especially as tax credits wind down. He calls it the biggest down payment on energy affordability the public can get, but notes that transmission remains controversial and will be the main debate in the legislature next year.

    “this is the closest we've gotten to in years of actually seeing real permitting reform getting done in this country.”at 44:51

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

Ask your AI who they are and what they said

Topics

  • AI IPO demand
  • AI bubble risk
  • AI buildout progress
  • AI compute demand
  • AI effect on cybersecurity demand
  • AI pace of change
  • AI trade fragmentation
  • AI trade rotation
  • Anthropic revenue upside
  • chip technology lead
  • data center permitting
  • energy permitting reform
  • export control exposure
  • frontier model margins
  • managed care audits
  • market confidence and selloff
  • rate hikes
  • safety-paced scaling
  • semiconductor valuations
  • startup capital inflow

More from CNBC Power Lunch

All CNBC Power Lunch episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus