Monetary Matters · · 58 min
How Deficits Will Drive the Next Wave of the Commodity Supercycle | Rick Rule
With Rick Rule
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Rick Rule, speaking on Monetary Matters, argues that deficits and underinvestment will drive the next commodity supercycle, with copper the central case. He estimates the largest listed copper miners need roughly $250B just to sustain production, rising toward $375B by the 2030s, and sees a supply shortfall within five years absent a global depression. He also covers gold and silver demand from Asian savers, a falling dollar, and the valuation case for silver stocks versus physical silver, along with streaming economics where Wheaton's deals are priced at 15-16x EBIT for silver versus 5-7x for copper revenue. On nuclear and uranium, he contends that Japanese restarts, term-contracting by utilities, and NexGen's investment-grade offtakes are tightening supply, while noting that US permitting and political risk could still derail mine development.
Key takeaways
- Rick Rule on Copper & industrial metals: Copper miners will increasingly fund development by selling gold and silver byproduct streams.
- Rick Rule (bullish on Wheaton Precious Metals): Wheaton paid a fair price for its $4.3B silver-linked stream deal; streams trade at premium multiples.
- Rick Rule on Copper & industrial metals: Two decades of copper underinvestment will hit supply within five years, so price must ration demand.
- Rick Rule (bullish on NexGen Energy): NexGen can now finance its own mine via investment-grade uranium offtake, improving its negotiating position.
- Rick Rule (bullish on Uranium Royalty): Uranium Royalty's full-price soda ash royalty buy was the right move if it earns uranium-style multiples.
What was said, by company and theme
23 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Wheaton Precious Metals
Rick Rule · Rule Investment MediaBullish
Wheaton paid a fair price for its $4.3B silver-linked stream deal; streams trade at premium multiples.
The project will produce significant silver flows, and he thinks Wheaton paid a fair price. The instructive point is that BHP, the largest miner, had a higher cost of capital than Wheaton, yet a deal was accretive to both. Stream cash flow, especially silver, trades at 15-16x EBIT, while copper revenue trades at 5-7x EBIT. Streamers carry no capital cost, so the multiple gap, despite silver's volatility, enables very large deals that benefit buyer and seller.
“I do not. I do not. It's worthy to know that that project will have incredible silver flows. I think they paid a fair price.”at 7:07
NexGen Energy
Rick Rule · Rule Investment MediaBullish
NexGen can now finance its own mine via investment-grade uranium offtake, improving its negotiating position.
Rick says NexGen's position has changed. Six years ago it would have had to sell its deposit because it could not finance construction. Now, because it bought physical uranium and holds substantial cash, it can sign a supply contract with investment-grade utilities such as Duke, Southern Company, Ontario Hydro or Tokyo Electric and take that to banks to finance the mine. Rick argues that investment-grade offtake lowers the cost of capital. NexGen can now threaten to build rather than sell to Cameco, since Rio Tinto and Anglo Teck can also buy or build. Rick explicitly says this is not a recommendation of NexGen.
“NextGen, because they bought some physical uranium and they have a lot of cash on the balance sheet, can enter into a supply contract with Duke Power or the Southern Company or Ontario Hydro or Tokyo Electric Power.”at 48:41
Uranium Royalty
Rick Rule · Rule Investment MediaBullish
Uranium Royalty's full-price soda ash royalty buy was the right move if it earns uranium-style multiples.
Rick says Uranium Royalty's share price was full, and that it paid a very full price for the soda ash royalty, but it used its premium market cap to buy a long-lived royalty with no competition. He notes the deal included fee ownership of a large land package, although much of that land is at best lizard pasture. He says he would have done the same thing. The deal only pays off if the company turns soda ash and trona cash flow into uranium-style multiples, which he sees as a home run if it works.
“If they can perform the magic of using soda ash and Trona cash flow at uranium multiples, they will have hit a long ball home.”at 53:13
Gold & precious metals
Where everyone stands on Gold & precious metals
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Silver stocks discount $35-40/oz, offering better value and upside than physical silver.
He sold his physical silver after its parabolic January run and bought silver stocks with half the proceeds. He had judged silver stocks as discounting about $42/oz of future cash flows in January. They now discount roughly $35-40/oz by his net present value work. That gives more downside shelter and more upside leverage in silver stocks than in silver. The caveat: this requires investors to do the work to pick the right stocks, since the group is more demanding than holding physical silver.
“I think that the silver stocks now are discounting somewhere between 35 and $40 an ounce. So I suggest that there's still better value, more shelter to the downside and more leverage to the upside in the silver stocks than in silver.”at 3:00
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Small 'me too' royalty companies are overbid, lacking durable advantage and growing by outpaying peers.
He says the small end of the royalty space is overbid, with many competing for exploration-stage royalties, most of which will never pay. Third-tier royalty and streaming companies under about $250M market cap need a durable competitive advantage. Many grow by paying more than competitors in auctions, which he calls a non-viable strategy and a poor one. Companies that create royalties (Origin, old EMX), or have structural edges like First Nations control (Nation's) or a tie to an arranger (Empress), are different. Many newcomers entered because raising capital is easier in royalties.
“In theory, I think it's great. In practice, there are too many me too companies in the small space.”at 8:50
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Major miners must acquire to replace depleting reserves after 25 years of under- or misinvestment.
The mining industry has underinvested, or malinvested, for a long time. In 2000-2010 gold rose six or sevenfold while free cash flow per share fell, showing misallocated capital. Capital then became unavailable. Some exceptions aside, companies' development pipelines are small relative to their depletion schedules. Just to keep their ground, not to grow, they will have to acquire. He expects both strategic acquisitions that leverage existing infrastructure and tactical ones done for growth to occur.
“The consequence of that is that with some exceptions, the development pipelines of the companies relative to their depletion schedules means that... Never mind to grow, to keep their ground, they're gonna have to acquire.”at 27:27
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Structural gold demand from Indian and Chinese savers; Western investors are the only net sellers.
He cites a cultural habit of saving in gold among Indian expatriates in Dubai buying physical gold with part of each paycheck, and a millennium-long distrust of government in rural India. China's state still encourages gold ownership, bans gold exports and some derivative instruments, and the volumes suggest Chinese retail investors keep buying. North America and Western Europe are the only citizenries that are net sellers. An anecdotal conversation with six South Asian engineers in Silicon Valley, who saved mainly in gold, reinforced the view that the habit persists as incomes rise.
“the only citizenry on the planet that are net sellers of gold are in North America and Western Europe.”at 32:23
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Middle-class Africans will hold less gold than Westerners because local investment opportunities pay more.
Rick argues that Nigerians distrust government because of corruption and mismanagement, and that gold is one response to that. However, he suspects middle-class and upper-middle-class Africans will participate in precious metals less than Western investors. The reason is that local opportunities are better: private Nigerian businessmen expect higher hurdle rates and see higher-risk local opportunities as more rewarding. He says building out the Nigerian economy can offer much higher internal rates of return than precious metals ownership.
“I suspect that participation among middle class and upper middle class Africans will lag the participation that you see in Western countries.”at 37:45
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
An energy price surge is raising gold miners' production costs, citing Agnico Eagle's diesel cost warning.
Rick says the world runs on energy, and that the energy price surge is already showing up in the gold business. He cites Agnico Eagle's statement that next year diesel prices could add $80 an ounce to its production cost. He uses this as evidence that energy inputs are a growing cost burden for gold producers.
“Agnico Eagle said that next year, the diesel prices could add $80 an ounce to their production cost.”at 42:29
Copper & industrial metals
Where everyone stands on Copper & industrial metals
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Copper miners will increasingly fund development by selling gold and silver byproduct streams.
Copper projects need huge capital. Byproduct gold and silver cash flows are worth more when isolated in a precious metal stream than when combined with copper free cash flow, so copper companies will sell them to fund development. He argues the big streaming transactions that grew Wheaton are not a thing of the past but of the future. The copper capital need will create so much gold and silver stream volume that even Franco and Wheaton will need to syndicate deals, letting second-tier streamers participate.
“But with regards to the streaming deals, you ain't seen nothing yet. ... the copper companies are going to access capital for their development expenditures by selling gold and silver byproduct streams.”at 4:22
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Two decades of copper underinvestment will hit supply within five years, so price must ration demand.
A Wood Mackenzie-style study suggests the 10 largest listed copper companies need about $250B (2025 dollars) just to maintain production. Input costs rise roughly 8-10% a year, so that becomes about $375B by the 2030s, which the industry lacks. Rule checks projects one by one, sees capital intensity, cyclicality and long lead times, and cannot see where copper comes from in five years absent a global depression. Supply cannot meet demand without no growth at all, so 20-25 years of underinvestment will bite in the next five years. He is skeptical of some data-centre copper demand estimates, but argues a billion people lack electricity and electrification needs copper, so price will ration it in the future.
“twenty or twenty five years of underinvestment is gonna come home to roost in the next five years.”at 18:19
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
US mine permitting is becoming less onerous, making previously blocked copper projects more viable.
Freeport's decision last week on Bagdad expansion makes sense because US and Arizona permitting difficulties were extreme a decade ago. Permitting difficulties now appear less extraordinary, though the outcome depends on the election. Capital markets are also more favourable than when major financial firms saw mining as evil. Resource utilization is increasingly understood to reduce poverty, so he sees a more favourable climate for regulation, permitting and capital markets. He cautions it could change, pointing to Resolution copper, in permitting for 28 years, where boards are unwilling to commit $500M preconstruction spend.
“the permitting difficulties now are less extraordinary.”at 20:08
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
High copper prices will drive substitution and efficiency, but only over years; copper will become a mainstream narrative.
Rick argues that aluminium-for-copper substitution is a very long-term phenomenon. If copper follows the price path he expects over the next five years, buyers will have an incentive to substitute materials and use copper more efficiently, but that will not happen in the near term. He expects copper to become as pervasive in financial discussions as AI or the internet five years from now, and says the high price will validate the narrative while also encouraging substitution. He ties this to a general pattern from his career: the cure for high prices is high prices, and investors miss it because their horizon is a quarter rather than a decade.
“I think you need to understand those are very long term phenomenon. The cure for high prices is always high prices.”at 39:25
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Aluminium's price and supply depend heavily on energy costs and on bauxite exploration that has lagged.
Rick says energy is one of the most important contributors to the price of finished aluminium, so the ability of aluminium to substitute for copper depends on the energy intensity of aluminium production. He expects low-cost producers such as the UAE to become inefficient if they are slow to adopt nuclear power. He also notes that the industry spent little time in the last fifteen years looking for new bauxite supplies because existing ones were large, and says that will become a constraint. He calls the topic nuanced and says aluminium also has its own uses in lighter transport and long-distance power transmission.
“one of the most important contributors to the price of finished aluminum is energy.”at 40:38
Nuclear energy
Where everyone stands on Nuclear energy
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
US nuclear plant build costs are about six times China's and must converge, helped by better regulation.
Rick compares the cost of a new nuclear plant including the time cost of money. A US plant costs about $30 billion, while a Chinese plant can deliver the same output for about $5.5 billion. He says that gap needs to equalize. He argues that more nuclear use and investment, along with an improved regulatory climate, can bring the upfront capital cost of plants down, and that this matters for poorer countries needing access to electricity.
“The United States, they turn out a new nuclear power plant, if you include the time cost of money, brings them in at $30,000,000,000 a copy, and the Chinese can bring in the same output for $5,500,000,000. That needs to equalize.”at 43:23
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Japan will be the surprise uranium demand source as it restarts idle nuclear plants, which need no new build.
Rick says Japan's uranium consumption fell from second largest in the world to nothing after Fukushima. Polls that were 80% negative on nuclear after Fukushima are now 72–73% positive. Japan has 17 operating plants out of a fleet of 42, and Rick argues that political will from the public, government and industry exists to restart the idle ones. Restarts do not need to be built or financed, which makes Japan the lowest-hanging fruit in uranium demand.
“I would say within the next two years, the surprise user will be Japan.”at 44:28
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Uranium mine supply will respond slowly to high prices because permitting is hard and output has fallen.
Rick notes that the uranium contract price is around $100, up fourfold from about $20 when he would have said the world was short of $20 uranium, not short of uranium. Production has declined. He says he does not know the current incentive price, but he knows permitting challenges are significant. He suspects any supply response to the higher price will come over time rather than quickly.
“I suspect that any response to the incentive price will occur over time as opposed to quickly.”at 46:15
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Uranium's illiquid spot market is irrelevant; term contracts up to 30 years now set how supply is priced and financed.
Rick says the spot market is so illiquid that it is irrelevant. Sprott Physical Uranium Trust does four or five times the dollar volume of the spot market most days, so Sprott has become the spot market. Because of this, transactions are increasingly on the term market, where a supplier can know the quantity and price it can sell up to thirty years out. Builders and their lenders can lock in supply thirty years ahead. Lenders increasingly require developers to lock in enough supply to amortise the loan. Rick says this is not yet visible in uranium company share prices but is starting to show up in their cost of capital, debt and equity.
“That means that unlike any other commodity on the planet, in the uranium business, a supplier can understand the quantity that he or she can sell at the price they can sell it for in terms that go up to thirty years.”at 46:58
US elections & politics
Where everyone stands on US elections & politics
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
The US is among the world's riskiest jurisdictions for miners; Democrats likely to obstruct mining projects.
He has found the US among the riskiest jurisdictions politically, with his worst political-risk experience in California, versus better treatment in South Sudan and Congo. The risk comes from people like him, through legislatures and the rule of law, and is no less dangerous. The Biden administration blocked the access road to the Arctic copper deposit despite indigenous requests, after failing to stop it by other means. He observes Democrats likely feel more beholden to organized environmental groups, so similar obstructive bureaucratic interference may return.
“I have found that one of the riskiest jurisdictions in the world politically is The United States.”at 22:15
IPOs, M&A & deal activity
Where everyone stands on IPOs, M&A & deal activity
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Tactical mining mergers happen for index inclusion and passive buying, not operational synergies.
A large share of aftermarket trading in these equities is passive or index-driven. When two smaller miners merge, as Equinox with Orla, there are no strategic or operational synergies. The combined company's larger size brings larger index inclusion, which brings passive buying that grows it through regular payroll-deduction flows. Tactical acquisitions like this aim for growth and excess management capacity, where four plus two equals seven or eight rather than six.
“But if you put those two companies together, their resultant size means that they have larger index inclusions, which means that they get passive buying.”at 28:10
US dollar
Where everyone stands on US dollar
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
The US dollar is losing 75% of its purchasing power but should still beat most other currencies.
He draws on Doug Casey's line that the dollar is the worst currency except for all the others. He believes the dollar is in the process of losing 75% of its purchasing power. He sees no contradiction with it remaining the reserve currency, with reduced hegemony, and with gold doing well. Despite the decline, he thinks it will outperform most other currencies. Indian savers are not making a call against the dollar but against holding rupee-denominated savings.
“I believe that the US dollar will lose and is in the process of losing 75% of its purchasing power. But despite that, I think it'll outperform most other currencies in the world.”at 36:02
Power demand & the grid
Where everyone stands on Power demand & the grid
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Energy outlook is poor five to seven years out, good over ten to fifteen, because of underinvestment in energy.
Rick argues that everything is energy intensive and that the world will pay for underinvesting or misinvesting in energy sources. He thinks the world is on the right path and that more nuclear use, investment and deployment, together with a better regulatory climate, could improve the outlook. He concludes that the energy future is great if measured ten or fifteen years out, but not good if measured five, six or seven years out.
“I think the future in energy is great as long as you define the future ten or fifteen years from now. If you define it five or six or seven years from now, the outlook is not good at all.”at 43:54
Private credit
Where everyone stands on Private credit
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media
Family offices will enter royalty and streaming, reducing pressure on funds to sell packages to public companies.
Rick says demand for royalties and streams is not limitless, but he gets monthly calls from family offices and institutions seeking them. Funds such as Orion raise money in ten-year partnerships, so when those expire they must distribute assets in kind or sell them, which forces royalty packages onto the market. Family offices have no time limit and some hold large royalty packages for decades. He expects them to enter streaming in size, which would reduce the structural need for funds to sell or syndicate packages.
“But I think you're going to see the family offices, among other things, come into the royalty and streaming space. Particularly streaming space in size.”at 56:14
Topics
- Japan nuclear restarts
- aluminum energy costs
- copper substitution
- copper supply deficit
- dollar purchasing power
- energy supply investment
- gold demand from Asian savers
- gold ownership in Africa
- mine permitting
- miner production costs
- mining M&A
- nuclear build costs
- political risk for mining
- precious metal streaming deals
- royalty and streaming companies
- royalty and streaming financing
- silver stocks valuation
- streaming valuation and deal pricing
- tactical mining mergers
- uranium mine supply
- uranium project financing
- uranium royalty deal
- uranium term market
More from Monetary Matters
- The Anthropic IPO’s Massive Impact: Forced Passive Buying and a Liquidity Wave for Venture Capital | David Shapiro · November 17, 2026
- The Bond Squeeze | Jan van Eck on >5% Treasury Yields, Semis, Anthropic, and Gold · November 15, 2026
- The Case for Public Markets | Cromwell Coulson on Small-Cap Capital Formation, Disclosure, and SEC Offering Reform · November 14, 2026
- Too Much Compute: Why This Top Hedge Fund Manager Believes AI is Heading for a Massive Oversupply | David Orr · November 11, 2026
- Structural Flows Will Support Stocks Until the U.S. Treasury Crisis in 2027 | Cem Karsan & Noel Smith | Kai Asset Management · November 9, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus