Monetary Matters · · 59 min

The Anthropic IPO’s Massive Impact: Forced Passive Buying and a Liquidity Wave for Venture Capital | David Shapiro

With David Shapiro

Summary

David Shapiro of OpenVC argues that Anthropic's coming IPO will drive forced passive buying, since Nasdaq's fast-track rules for mega-IPOs would likely pull the company into the Nasdaq-100 and so into QQQ-type trackers, while the 180-day lockup expiry could bring selling pressure that index demand partly offsets. He reads the recent softening of Anthropic's secondary price from about 1.48 to around 1.3 trillion as driven mainly by the NVIDIA-led AI selloff rather than regulation, and expects Anthropic to list before OpenAI, with OpenAI's timing following market signals from that deal. Broader points cover private-market indexing (OpenVC's 20% single-name caps, the AI concentration of venture indexes, and the case for low-fee private indexes and open-ended ETFs), the risk that token price declines commoditize frontier model margins, and the view that companies such as Stripe may stay private as liquidity improves. Shapiro also flags OpenAI's secondary index near $1 trillion as below its rumored primary price and Databricks as the likely next large IPO.

Key takeaways

  • David Shapiro (uncertain on Anthropic): Expect a waiting game and enhanced volatility when Anthropic's 180-day lockup expires.
  • David Shapiro (bullish on Anthropic): Fast-track Nasdaq-100 inclusion will force index funds to buy Anthropic shares soon after its IPO, adding liquidity.
  • David Shapiro (bearish on Anthropic): Anthropic's IPO valuation may fall from the $2T talk toward about $1.25T.
  • David Shapiro (bearish on OpenAI): OpenAI's secondary valuation sits below its rumored new round after it failed to raise the full $30B.
  • David Shapiro (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic will likely IPO before OpenAI, and OpenAI will watch Anthropic's market reception.

What was said, by company and theme

25 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Anthropic

Across the shows: 124 speakers in other episodes, 186 bullish and 91 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • David Shapiro · OpenVCUncertain

    Expect a waiting game and enhanced volatility when Anthropic's 180-day lockup expires.

    Most early venture holders are subject to a 180-day lockup or longer, and some strategic and large growth holders with special share classes may be locked up longer. Many holders are desperate for DPI after long private holding periods, so Shapiro expects additional selling and volatility around the lockup expiry and in the weeks after. He flags the 180-day mark as a key calendar date, alongside index inclusion and option expiry. The forced index buying he describes could partly offset this selling.

    “But we're gonna see a bit of a waiting game and then likely some enhanced volatility at the end of that lockup period.”at 1:28
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCBullish

    Fast-track Nasdaq-100 inclusion will force index funds to buy Anthropic shares soon after its IPO, adding liquidity.

    Anthropic will almost assuredly meet the scale test for Nasdaq-100 inclusion after its IPO, even if it prices at the bottom of the range. Nasdaq's new fast-track rules for mega-IPOs, first applied to SpaceX, mean that within a short time anyone holding a Nasdaq-100 tracker (QQQ or similar, in retirement or brokerage accounts) becomes a forced buyer. Shapiro expects this to add significant liquidity and to help venture and growth holders who are not subject to the longer lockups. He notes the index provider has discretion to exclude Anthropic, but argues that following the stated methodology implies inclusion.

    “anybody who holds a fund which tracks the Nasdaq one hundred, ... will become a forced buyer of the name. That will add significant additional liquidity to these markets”at 2:03
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCBearish

    Anthropic's IPO valuation may fall from the $2T talk toward about $1.25T.

    Investors were reportedly less enthusiastic about the roughly $2 trillion IPO valuation, and the secondary price fell from about 1.48 to the bottom of the range. Shapiro says it is now around 1.3, which suggests it could drop toward 1.25, the middle of a new $1–1.5 trillion range. He says the stock has not fallen much in secondaries because it is insulated from the semis selloff and because the promise of near-term liquidity is keeping the market stable. He attributes the recent decline mainly to the NVIDIA-driven AI selloff and fears around AI, with some effect from the election.

    “It's now teetering kind of at the one point... High one point threes, which yields one to believe it could get down to that kind of 1.25”at 34:51
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCNeutral

    Regulation from a Democratic Congress would not be very impactful to Anthropic's share price.

    Anthropic positions itself as the responsible player and is welcoming of regulation, so new rules would be less damaging to the company. If a Democratic Congress does pass AI legislation, Shapiro thinks it would not have much impact on the ultimate share price. He presents this as a partial reason for the recent price softness, and he treats the regulatory risk as limited.

    “one could argue Anthropic is trying to position itself as the good guy here, would actually be or it would be welcoming of regulation. And consequently, if a Democratic Congress actually manages to do something on that front, wouldn't be that impactful to the ultimate share price.”at 35:15
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCBullish

    Anthropic will likely IPO before OpenAI, and OpenAI will watch Anthropic's market reception.

    Shapiro argues that unless something drastic happens, Anthropic will beat OpenAI to the IPO. OpenAI will closely watch how Anthropic performs in the market and use that to set the timing, size and price range of its own IPO. Secondary-market pricing for both will then follow those signals, so the Anthropic listing is the key event for private-AI secondary markets.

    “It seemed like Anthropic unless something drastic happens is going to beat OpenAI to that IPO.”at 38:35
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCBullish

    A $1.5–2 trillion valuation for Anthropic's IPO makes a lot of sense.

    Shapiro's optimistic AI case: if the average leading LLM provider can make the American worker about 25% more productive, the revenue pool could be $5–10 trillion. If that is split among just a few providers, each could be worth $1.5–2 trillion, which he says makes sense for Anthropic's IPO.

    “The kind of 1.5 to $2,000,000,000,000 range, you know, for [Anthropic] IPO makes a ton of sense.”at 52:50

OpenAI

Across the shows: 41 speakers in other episodes, 17 bullish and 35 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on OpenAI

  • David Shapiro · OpenVCBearish

    OpenAI's secondary valuation sits below its rumored new round after it failed to raise the full $30B.

    OpenVC's secondary-market index price for OpenAI has hovered around $1 trillion, below the roughly $1.0–1.25 trillion range where the new primary round might price. Shapiro says OpenAI seemed unable to raise the full $30 billion it wanted, and that this is a driver of the index price staying below the rumored primary price.

    “It seemed like they couldn't raise the full 30,000,000,000 that they wanted and that certainly is a driver of our index price kind of hovering below where that new primary is rumored to be.”at 37:53
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCNeutral

    OpenAI's profitability looks comparable to Anthropic's, since token cost differences are negligible.

    From where investors trade OpenAI, its profitability seems commensurate with Anthropic's. Shapiro says that is no surprise, since the token cost gap between the two is de minimis. He admits OPenVC hears little about OpenAI's economics directly.

    “It seems to be commensurately profitable to Anthropic which is kind of no surprise to me. The token cost delta between those two is de minimis.”at 40:05
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCBullish

    OpenAI is gaining back enterprise share from Anthropic, which is good news for OpenAI.

    OpenVC's data shows a shift from enterprise customers, which had favored Anthropic substantially, back to OpenAI in some cases. The consumer share of the pie has shrunk, which Shapiro says is a very good sign for OpenAI.

    “So the percentage of that pie which is consumer has shrunk which I think is a very good sign for OpenAI.”at 40:34

Stripe

Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, past 30 days

  • David Shapiro · OpenVCUncertain

    Stripe may never go public because private markets now offer liquidity without an IPO.

    Private markets are now more liquid and have more latent liquidity, so the rationale for IPOs to raise large sums for strategic initiatives is weaker. Stripe is an example: Shapiro says it may never go public and that its founders have shown no reason to list. This undermines the traditional growth-equity model of holding for 5–8 years and exiting through a predictable IPO pipeline, so growth investors may need to rely on private-market appreciation.

    “So you see companies like Stripe, for example, amazing company. They may never go public.”at 16:32
  • David Shapiro · OpenVCNeutral

    Stripe will likely never go public, though Shapiro thinks that is shortsighted.

    Stripe has the market cap to list, but its founders may prefer control and avoid public reporting. Private secondary sales and tender offers already give employees and investors liquidity. Shapiro argues public markets are still the gold standard for liquidity, serving early employees and backers, so skipping them is probably shortsighted.

    “There's also Stripe which I mentioned will likely never go public.”at 49:01

Databricks

Across the shows: 1 speaker in other episodes, 1 bullish and 0 bearish calls, past 30 days

  • David Shapiro · OpenVCNeutral

    Databricks is a likely 2027 IPO candidate that investors will watch closely for near-term liquidity.

    By OpenVC's indices and market cap, Databricks is a very interesting target for investors. It is wrapped up in AI appreciation but is not a direct competitor to Anthropic or OpenAI, so investors will watch it closely for near-term liquidity. Shapiro frames it as the likely next large IPO after Anthropic.

    “If you go by our indices and you just go by market cap, certainly Databricks is a very interesting target for folks.”at 48:32

Venture capital & startups

Where everyone stands on Venture capital & startups

  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Private-market index concentration is similar to public mega-cap concentration and turns over by sector.

    OpenVC's private indexes cap single names at 20%, and several companies hit that cap, including Anthropic, OpenAI and SpaceX. Without the caps, AI would be over 65–70% of the index. Shapiro argues the concentration is no worse than in public equities, where the Magnificent Seven dominate. He also says concentration rotates by sector over time, citing defense and logistics two years earlier and Web3 before that, so the concentration reflects the current hot sector.

    “But there's very significant concentration at the top. If we didn't have those, you know, kind of caps in place on the index, I would say that AI would be over 65 to 70% of the index at this point.”at 10:15
  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Most pre-IPO growth is gone by listing, so investing before IPO stays a viable strategy.

    In past cycles, retail investors could capture substantial upside at the IPO stage, when companies were valued at several billion dollars. Today the appreciable alpha is largely captured before the company goes public, because companies now IPO at much higher valuations. Shapiro argues that getting in at some point before the IPO, rather than at the earliest stage, will remain a viable growth equity strategy, given the remaining appreciation in the private market.

    “is gone by the time these companies have actually gone public. So getting in not at the earliest stage, but at least at some point before these companies go public, is likely going to continue to be a very viable, growth equity strategy.”at 13:33
  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Passive indexing will take AUM from underperforming mid-tier VC managers charging elite-level fees.

    Public markets have seen passive share rise to over 50% of US stock dollars, and mid-tier active managers have lost assets to iShares, Vanguard and State Street. Shapiro expects private markets to follow. Only elite managers such as Sequoia and a16z deliver top returns, but a long tail of managers charge similar fees without matching returns. Low-fee private indexes, built on transparent secondary pricing with the NYSE, would pull assets from that middle tier. Elite managers would keep the high end and could use the index buyers as a source of liquidity.

    “a very long tail of other managers, sector specific managers, emerging managers. They're all charging Sequoia like fees. Very few are delivering Sequoia like returns.”at 20:15
  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Secondary prices mark down weak private companies rather than holding them at last round.

    Once a private company is large enough, secondary bids and asks give enough data to set a daily price, and OpenVC's indexes use that. Where the company is struggling, holders trade at lower prices, so the index shows declines rather than stale marks. In 2023 during the Web3 downturn, OpenSea was held at a double-digit billion valuation, but OpenVC's index fell to single digits because holders were willing to sell at that level. Shapiro argues that companies that are not doing well will actually decline in these indexes, and that they are unlikely to be included.

    “in all likelihood if the company is not doing well it will actually decline in our market... So the losers in your example, actually do decline and they probably won't be included in our indices”at 31:36
  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Many AI startups with headline raises fade within a year and are not heard from again.

    OpenVC's index requires a meaningful amount of capital raised relative to valuation, because it has seen AI companies announce big headline raises and then disappear within twelve months. He says the brightest stars can burn the quickest, so a large headline valuation is not proof of durable growth.

    “sometimes the brightest stars burn the quickest and particularly in AI we've seen folks you know put out crazy headline raises and then you don't hear about them in twelve months.”at 43:34

AI pricing & unit economics

Where everyone stands on AI pricing & unit economics

  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Falling token costs will pressure large LLM providers more than downstream second-tier AI providers.

    Investors are asking how much competitive advantage the top AI model providers keep as models commoditize. Shapiro says token costs will keep falling rapidly. That has significant implications for the large LLM providers, who have to compete on price, and it does not hit downstream second-tier providers in the same way, which buy inference and build applications on top.

    “And our token costs going to continue to decline, rather precipitously that has significant implications for the large LLM providers, that it doesn't have in the same way for some of these downstream, second tier providers.”at 28:07
  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Falling token costs could leave AI providers without the margins that would justify their valuations.

    Shapiro's downside case for AI is commoditization. If token costs keep falling and compute costs fall with them, the productivity gains may not carry margin for the providers. Even with a $10 trillion revenue pool, the providers might not earn the profitability that would justify owning that market. He says that remains to be seen and investors must weigh it.

    “Do token costs continue to decline? Do those productivity gains not come with the margin”at 53:06

Private markets for individual investors

Where everyone stands on Private markets for individual investors

  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Open-ended ETFs holding private assets will come once the cash-settlement problem is solved.

    Shapiro calls an open-ended ETF the holy grail of private-market indexing, but it needs a way to cash-settle the private portion of an index like OpenVC's crossover index. ETF arrangers would need to hold private or cash sleeves for 30–90 days while building positions. OpenVC is working with NYSE, ICE and others on corollary assets to solve this, and he believes open-ended ETFs will follow.

    “the holy grail of this space is an open ended ETF. To do that, you need to find a way to cash settle the piece of our crossover index that's private.”at 44:31
  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Existing vehicles giving access to private companies trade at large premiums or discounts to NAV, causing confusion.

    Shapiro says existing solutions can grant access to private companies, but they often trade at significant deltas to NAV. That gap can confuse investors about what they own and what they are paying for, which is why he thinks an open-ended, correctly priced ETF structure is needed.

    “existing solutions that while certainly can grant access oftentimes trade at very significant deltas to their NAV, which can ultimately lead to confusion”at 45:48

Frontier AI labs & model race

Where everyone stands on Frontier AI labs & model race

  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    OpenAI and Anthropic keep swapping momentum, and low switching costs keep the race fluid.

    Shapiro's data shows OpenAI and Anthropic trade places on growth speed every few months, as the market loves one new model and then forgets the other. Switching providers is cheap unless a customer is a mega enterprise or government agency, or has built its agent stack on one provider's rails. So the labs keep competing actively.

    “It's a very fluid market. The hurdles unless you're a mega enterprise or a government agency to switching between these providers are pretty low”at 40:41

Asset managers, brokers & exchanges

Where everyone stands on Asset managers, brokers & exchanges

  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Private-share trading will fragment across several ATSs rather than consolidating into one central exchange.

    Many groups are building alternative trading systems for private shares. Shapiro argues there will not be one winner because these venues are themselves brokerage businesses. Transactions need company approval and clean cap-table traceability, and each investor works best with particular companies or sectors. So he expects a few ATSs rather than one central market like public equities.

    “I don't think there will be one winner in that space because ultimately those are like brokerage businesses themselves as well”at 47:28

AI: overall outlook

Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook

  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    AI productivity gains could create a $5–10 trillion revenue pool concentrated in a few providers.

    Shapiro's optimistic case reads AI from a GDP angle. If the average leading LLM provider raises American worker productivity by about 25%, GDP should grow by the same share, and the providers would capture the extra value since no new workers are added. That implies a revenue pool of roughly $5–10 trillion, which would be phenomenal for the few providers that split it.

    “If you believe that the average leading LLM provider can make the American worker, call it 25% more productive.”at 52:00

Open-source AI models

Where everyone stands on Open-source AI models

  • David Shapiro · OpenVC

    Large AI labs have a vested interest in blocking open-source models that would lower consumer and enterprise prices.

    Shapiro sees the regulatory fight over open-source and Chinese models as the bigger issue. OpenAI and Anthropic have lobbied to keep such models out on national-security grounds, and that protects their pricing. If cheap, fully open models were allowed to compete, the commoditization argument would get stronger. He adds that DeepSeek-style scares have often turned out to be ports of existing US models, so the American edge is small but real.

    “there's a vested interest in the largest of the large AI companies in preventing open source models from lowering prices for the average consumer and the average enterprise.”at 55:38

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • Anthropic124 speakers · 186 bullish, 91 bearish calls
  • OpenAI41 speakers · 17 bullish, 35 bearish calls
  • Databricks1 speaker · 1 bullish, 0 bearish calls
  • Stripe1 speaker

Topics

  • AI commoditization & margins
  • AI productivity & revenue pool
  • AI startup funding durability
  • IPO decision
  • IPO decision and private liquidity
  • IPO pipeline
  • IPO pricing and valuation
  • IPO timing
  • IPO valuation
  • enterprise market share
  • index inclusion forced buying
  • lab competition & switching costs
  • lockup expiry volatility
  • open-ended private-market ETFs
  • open-source model competition
  • passive indexing of private markets
  • pre-IPO returns
  • private company price discovery
  • private-market access funds
  • private-share trading venues
  • profitability
  • regulation impact on Anthropic
  • startup valuations
  • token price declines
  • venture index concentration

More from Monetary Matters

All Monetary Matters episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus