Monetary Matters · · 53 min

The Case for Public Markets | Cromwell Coulson on Small-Cap Capital Formation, Disclosure, and SEC Offering Reform

With Cromwell Coulson

Summary

Cromwell Coulson of OTC Markets Group argues that small-cap capital formation is broken, centred on the SEC's proposed registered-offering reform. The proposal would preempt state blue-sky re-registration and extend at-the-market offerings to all exchange-listed issuers and to OTCQX and OTCQB companies, which he expects to transform access to capital. He defends OTC Markets' disclosure flags, tiering model and 30% operating margin, and says a shrinking public company universe is driven by roll-ups, tax treatment of acquired intangibles, and ESG burdens that fall only on public firms. He also frames AI as a bubble that draws capital into real innovation, notes that tokenization has limited but real uses, and urges large foreign companies to list in the US for the lowest cost of capital.

Key takeaways

  • Cromwell Coulson on IPOs, M&A & deal activity: Companies below about $750M float can't raise capital efficiently; they're pushed into discounted, dilutive private placements.
  • Cromwell Coulson on IPOs, M&A & deal activity: SEC proposal to preempt state blue-sky rules and extend ATMs to OTC issuers will transform small-company capital access.
  • Cromwell Coulson on Asset managers, brokers & exchanges: Most stock-promotion dollar volume has migrated from OTC markets to exchanges like Nasdaq.
  • Cromwell Coulson on IPOs, M&A & deal activity: Public company count is shrinking as tax treatment of intangibles and regulatory burdens favor private buyers.
  • Cromwell Coulson on Stablecoins & crypto policy: Tokenization will become useful plumbing for specific uses like fractional shares, not replace intermediaries like DTC.

What was said, by company and theme

10 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

IPOs, M&A & deal activity

Where everyone stands on IPOs, M&A & deal activity

  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Companies below about $750M float can't raise capital efficiently; they're pushed into discounted, dilutive private placements.

    Coulson argues small-company capital formation is broken. Only large public companies, with a shareholder float above roughly $750 million, can use shelf offerings with ATM programs to sell shares as easily as they buy back stock. Regulators historically allowed this only for the most liquid stocks because they did not trust the market price. Coulson calls that backward: regulators should make prices more trusted, not restrict issuers. Companies that cannot use ATMs, including newly listed firms, small floats and OTC companies, have to raise money privately, often at a discount. That is dilutive and resets value, and the capital providers are unregulated private funds, so companies can be opaque about the dilution. He says selling shares at half the public price is terrible for capital formation.

    “What happens is if you are not a large public company, and by large public company, I mean ... which has a shareholder float of over $750,000,000, you're not able to access capital efficiently.”at 9:04
  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    SEC proposal to preempt state blue-sky rules and extend ATMs to OTC issuers will transform small-company capital access.

    The SEC's proposal to modernize registered offerings would do two things. First, it would preempt state blue-sky rules for SEC registration statements, removing duplicate state re-registration while leaving states' anti-fraud powers intact. Second, it would extend at-the-market (ATM) offerings to all exchange-listed issuers and to OTCQX and OTCQB companies for the first time. Coulson says this will transform access to capital, because OTC markets have mostly been a secondary market for companies that already raised capital. He expects the rule's outcome to be known in Q1 of next year and its effects to show in the second half of next year. He also praises the SEC team as the best he has seen in almost thirty years, pragmatically reviewing rules to help capital formation.

    “And they're expanding ATMs to all exchange listed issuers, and they're expanding it to issuers that are on the OTCQX best market and our OTCQB venture market. So this is going to transform access to capital.”at 13:27
  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Large companies and international firms should list in the US to access the lowest-cost capital.

    Coulson argues that companies large enough for the S&P 500, the top of the Russell, or the QQQ should list on an exchange because it gives the lowest-cost access to capital. Many US companies are not primarily index-driven, and international firms whose business has moved to the US gain competitive valuations there. He says foreign companies that stay out of the US often lack the disclosure and investor engagement of their US-listed peers, which exposes them to lawsuits and activist investors.

    “[If you're a company] that can be in the S and P five hundred, the top part of the Russell, or the QQQ, you should list on an exchange.”at 35:28
  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Public company count is shrinking as tax treatment of intangibles and regulatory burdens favor private buyers.

    Coulson says the decline in public companies comes mainly from smaller listed firms being rolled up into larger public companies' cap tables. The tax system drives this: when a private equity firm or public company buys another company, the acquired intangibles can be written off over time, worth about a 15% premium to the price. Regulation adds to this, since ESG burdens fall only on public companies and politicians can see them, while private firms avoid those costs.

    “And so when a private equity firm or a public company buys another company, they get about a 15% premium to the price just in tax benefits of having intangibles that they can write off over time.”at 47:41

Asset managers, brokers & exchanges

Where everyone stands on Asset managers, brokers & exchanges

  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Financialization and technology will grow trading volumes over the long term, though down cycles will come.

    Coulson argues the world is financializing trading, investing and growth, which will increase trading activity over time. He says technology will create more trading over the long term. He is careful: he says he won't claim this time is different, the 2021 boom was driven by COVID-era trading from home, and down cycles will inevitably come. He notes that few people can time them, and that concerning trends exist. Stocks are not amazingly cheap now, but AI brings both pros and cons.

    “the world is financializing, trading, investing, growing... Will technology create more trading? Over the long term? Yes.”at 7:09
  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Most stock-promotion dollar volume has migrated from OTC markets to exchanges like Nasdaq.

    Coulson responds to the Stratton Oakmont example by saying those firms' stocks traded on Nasdaq, not the pink sheets, and that the boiler-room promotion they ran was their own call. He says that OTC Markets tracks promotion and publishes its data, and that the vast majority of promotion dollar volume has moved to the exchanges. Jack Farley reads this as promotion migrating from OTC into exchange markets, and Coulson confirms it is a huge amount. He says OTC Markets feeds this data to broker-dealers but does not publish promotion on its website, because it has no relationship with the issuers.

    “The vast majority of dollar volume in promotion has moved to the exchanges.”at 29:00

Banks

Where everyone stands on Banks

  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Community banks leaving Nasdaq for OTC is operational efficiency, not a disclosure arbitrage.

    Coulson says many community banks leave Nasdaq because the cost and complexity of a listing is high. They prefer to use their community bank filings and still give investors a baseline of information so the market can price them. He says this is an operational efficiency and not a disclosure arbitrage. He also concedes these banks won't be as proactive in investor relations as large-caps with professional IR programs, but says they still provide enough information for the market to get the price right.

    “And many community banks leave NASDAQ because of the cost and complexity, and they just want to use their community bank filings. Again, this is an operational efficiency. It's not a disclosure arbitrage.”at 20:46

AI bubble & tech valuations

Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations

  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Bubbles are how transformative technology attracts capital; the AI bubble will move the game forward despite losers.

    Coulson cites Matt Ridley's book How Innovation Happens to argue that progress has always included bubbles. Bubbles draw large amounts of capital and human talent to a new opportunity. He says AI is a big opportunity and nobody knows who will win. He compares it to the internet bubble around 2000, with failures such as Global Crossing and Ask Jeeves, which still moved the game forward. He adds that the S&P 500 index turns speculative stocks into a savings product, while individual stocks remain riskier.

    “And progress has always included bubbles. Bubbles are where we attract a bunch of capital and human brainpower to a new opportunity. AI is a big opportunity.”at 33:24

Private equity

Where everyone stands on Private equity

  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Private equity's heavy debt makes it vulnerable in downturns and limits its ability to fund organic growth.

    Coulson contrasts private equity with public markets. He says private equity companies carry much more debt, so downcycles are tough. Because they must service that debt, they cannot invest in organic growth. He presents this as a reason public markets, which he argues are more durable and transparent, should be made more attractive.

    “You know, private equity companies, they have a lot more debt. And the down cycles are tough. They also, because they're paying that debt, they can't invest in organic growth.”at 48:25

Stablecoins & crypto policy

Where everyone stands on Stablecoins & crypto policy

  • Cromwell Coulson · OTC Markets Group

    Tokenization will become useful plumbing for specific uses like fractional shares, not replace intermediaries like DTC.

    Coulson calls tokenization a real technology with use cases that can expand functionality and reduce costs, but not an answer to everything. He compares it to IP protocol, which transformed telecom and securities but was absorbed into existing networks where useful. He sees value in fractional shares, atomic settlement and collateral management. He argues dematerialization through DTC has lasting value, and holding a whole portfolio in a personal wallet is risky, so financial intermediaries will remain. Many promoted use cases may not matter.

    “It's a technology, it has use cases, it can expand functionality and reduce costs. It is not the answer to everything.”at 49:25

Topics

  • AI bubble risk
  • OTC market flags and tiering
  • US listings for international companies
  • community bank listings
  • exchange competition and pricing
  • market data demand
  • private equity leverage risk
  • public company decline
  • small-cap capital formation
  • stock promotion
  • tokenization
  • trading volume growth

More from Monetary Matters

All Monetary Matters episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus