Bloomberg Surveillance · · 51 min

Nvidia's Leadership Crisis, US Retirement Gets a C+ & Anthropic's Big Debut Next Week

With Christine Mahoney, David Gura, Ed Morse, Eric Balchunas, Max Chafkin, Sarah Foster, Sarah Frier, Zijia Song

Summary

Bloomberg Surveillance covered three threads. Sarah Frier reported on a Bloomberg scoop that Nvidia chips shipped to Singapore reached Shanghai despite the company's assurances, raising questions about US-China export controls and Jensen Huang's involvement, and she argued that a CEO successor would struggle to replicate his personal deal-making. Ed Morse argued oil intensity of GDP is falling so a 1970s-style price shock is less likely, that OPEC's pricing power has faded now that the UAE is leaving and Iraq and Venezuela will keep producing, that a return to $50 oil is possible, and that China's official 4.6% GDP claim is not credible. Christine Mahoney, citing Marsh's index that grades the US C+, said the US relies on voluntary retirement plans, must reform Social Security before 2032, and will need double-digit savings rates. The hosts also discussed Anthropic's upcoming IPO, with Max Chafkin warning of weak post-IPO performance for recent listings and bearish implications for OpenAI if the deal fails, while Zijia Song reported strong retail demand.

Key takeaways

  • Eric Balchunas (neutral on Bitcoin): Bitcoin is part investment, part speculation, but its resilience through drawdowns makes it a respectable asset.
  • Sarah Frier (uncertain on NVIDIA): Nvidia chips shipped to Singapore reached Shanghai, making export-control compliance a central issue for Nvidia.
  • Ed Morse on Oil & fuels: Oil price shocks should be milder than in the 1970s because oil intensity of GDP is now falling.
  • Zijia Song (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic's IPO is drawing strong retail demand from investors who previously bought SpaceX.
  • Max Chafkin (uncertain on Anthropic): Anthropic's IPO outcome is uncertain; post-IPO trading for recent offerings has been poor, as SpaceX showed.

What was said, by company and theme

18 views from 7 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 146 speakers in other episodes, 134 bullish and 110 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • Sarah Frier · Bloomberg NewsUncertain

    Nvidia chips shipped to Singapore reached Shanghai, making export-control compliance a central issue for Nvidia.

    Frier says Bloomberg has a scoop that some Nvidia chips shipped to Singapore made their way to Shanghai. She says the company has said nothing out of the ordinary happened and that the chips are in Singapore, but Bloomberg found evidence they were in China. She argues this, and the question of what Nvidia did with chips that ended up in China, is at the heart of the story. It is about US-China relations and how much Jensen Huang was involved with the government, and she notes the Bloomberg team has been reporting on unaccounted-for chips for a while.

    “We had a great scoop just a few hours ago that some of the NVIDIA chips that went to Singapore did make their way to Shanghai.”at 6:35
  • Sarah Frier · Bloomberg NewsUncertain

    Replacing Jensen Huang at Nvidia will be very hard; a successor needs charisma and government connections.

    Frier argues that Nvidia's 'secret sauce' is hard for an outsider to replicate. Many of the deals Jensen Huang did were personally done. He had about 60 people reporting to him and gave the final sign-off on arrangements. So a successor needs both charisma and the connections that go with it, which makes a smooth replacement difficult.

    “it's a secret sauce that I think is going to be very difficult for an outside. ... we need somebody that has the charisma, ... that has the connections.”at 8:05

Anthropic

Across the shows: 116 speakers in other episodes, 173 bullish and 92 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • Zijia Song · Bloomberg NewsBullish

    Anthropic's IPO is drawing strong retail demand from investors who previously bought SpaceX.

    Song's reporting shows strong demand from the retail side. Many of these investors took part in the SpaceX IPO and are strategizing to maximize their allocation. She says the retail buyers for Anthropic differ from SpaceX buyers: they are tech workers and AI enthusiasts who read Anthropic reports and monitor industry benchmarks for model progress.

    “My reporting showed that there's strong demand from retail side. Of course, a lot of them have participated in SpaceX before, and they are strategizing to see how they can maximize their allocation.”at 44:05
  • Max Chafkin · Bloomberg BusinessweekUncertain

    Anthropic's IPO outcome is uncertain; post-IPO trading for recent offerings has been poor, as SpaceX showed.

    Chafkin says he doesn't feel qualified to predict the exact market dynamics, but the trends for IPOs in the period right after listing are not good, and SpaceX showed this. He also argues the AI market is in a tenuous place, and people buying into the Anthropic IPO should recognize that the outcome is uncertain.

    “The trends on initial public offerings in the period immediately after an IPO are not great, and we saw it happen with SpaceX. I don't feel qualified to predict the exact market dynamics... it's uncertain, and I think people who get into this should realize that.”at 46:39

Bitcoin

Across the shows: 28 speakers in other episodes, 25 bullish and 10 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Bitcoin

  • Eric Balchunas · Bloomberg IntelligenceNeutral

    Bitcoin is part investment, part speculation, but its resilience through drawdowns makes it a respectable asset.

    Balchunas says Bitcoin is 'a little of both' investment and speculation. He calls it 'teenager gold' because it has the traits of gold, and he argues it has been through drawdowns of about 75%. He says that resilience alone means investors have to respect it as an asset. He frames it as a tool in the toolbox if an investor wants one, not something they must hold.

    “It's a little of both. ... We call it teenager gold. ... But it has all the traits of gold, and it's been through [75%] drawdowns. ... That alone, I think you have to respect as an asset.”at 4:18

OpenAI

Across the shows: 39 speakers in other episodes, 17 bullish and 34 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on OpenAI

  • Max Chafkin · Bloomberg BusinessweekBearish

    If Anthropic's IPO goes poorly, that bodes very poorly for OpenAI, since they sell the same thing.

    Chafkin says conventional wisdom casts Anthropic and OpenAI as rivals, but the two companies are selling essentially the same thing. If the Anthropic IPO fails to find a market, he thinks it will be hard to imagine a market existing for OpenAI. His bearish view on OpenAI is conditional on the Anthropic IPO going badly.

    “If this IPO does not go well, I think that bodes very, very poorly for OpenAI because even though the two companies have their differences, they're kinda selling the same thing.”at 47:42

US entitlements

Where everyone stands on US entitlements

  • Christine Mahoney · Marsh

    The US retirement system earns a C+ because its lowest-income protection is weak and pension participation is voluntary.

    Marsh's global index grades the US a C+ against the Netherlands, Denmark, Iceland and others that score A. Mahoney says the biggest gap is how well the system protects the lowest-income employees, and that the US relies on voluntary pension plans. Employers do not have to offer them, employees do not have to join, and contribution amounts are optional, whereas the Netherlands has a mandatory structure. She also says the US needs to make Social Security more sustainable.

    “[The largest reason is the way we protect our lowest income] employees and the voluntary nature of our pension plans. ... Employers don't have to have them. Employees don't have to join them.”at 29:32
  • Christine Mahoney · Marsh

    Social Security will be fixed before 2032, though benefits will look different than today.

    Mahoney says she thinks Congress will act and is disappointed the country waited until it had to. She argues there is no choice but to do something between now and 2032. She says the question is no longer whether Social Security will be there but what it will look like, and that guarantees will not match what baby boomers received. Her priorities are to stop people withdrawing money before retirement, make sure money can be invested, and then raise the amount coming in, perhaps by phasing in mandatory contributions as Australia did.

    “I think they'll do it. I'm disappointed that we waited till they had to do it, but I actually don't think they have any choice but to do something between now and 2032.”at 31:59
  • Christine Mahoney · Marsh

    Retirement savings contributions must rise to double digits as a share of pay, well above current levels.

    Mahoney says the required savings rate depends on what someone wants in retirement, but the answer is double digits, which is significantly higher than what is being saved now. She notes the money does not all have to come from employees, since employers can match and government can be involved.

    “I think that's gonna depend on what you want in retirement, but it's a lot more than what we're saying... Double digits would be the answer.”at 33:26
  • Christine Mahoney · Marsh

    Demographics, especially faster-than-expected fertility decline, are the main reason the US retirement system is strained.

    Asked whether the US made a mistake by leaving defined benefit plans, Mahoney says demographics are what has caused the problem. The baby boomer cohort has been around a long time, but fertility rates fell much faster than expected. She also says net migration matters for countries' populations. She argues these large external forces are what the system is responding to, not just policy choices.

    “I think demographic is what has screwed this up. ... honestly, fertility rates dropped a lot faster. Net migration matters”at 33:48

Oil & fuels

Where everyone stands on Oil & fuels

  • Ed Morse · Hartree Partners

    Oil price shocks should be milder than in the 1970s because oil intensity of GDP is now falling.

    In the 1970s, world GDP grew about 4% a year while oil demand grew about 6%, driven largely by transport fuel and highway building, so oil intensity of GDP was rising fast. Morse says the world is now in a period where oil intensity of GDP is falling. That is why he tells listeners not to worry as much this time as last time, and why he does not expect the same price shock.

    “GDP was growing at maybe 4% for the world as a whole, and oil demand was growing at 6%. ... And we're now in a world where the oil intensity of GDP is falling.”at 15:27
  • Ed Morse · Hartree Partners

    OPEC has lost its power to set oil prices, so a return to around $50 a barrel is possible after the war.

    Morse says the UAE has announced it is leaving OPEC, which he calls significant. OPEC once could set a floor or ceiling on prices, but it now controls only about 30 million barrels a day of roughly 110 million barrels a day of total liquid consumption, so it counts for little. Iraq and Venezuela say they will not be held back from growing output, and like the UAE they can produce profitably at low prices. He says the world is very different from the era when he made his earlier call, so a return to $50 is possible, though he says whether it happens is an open question.

    “OPEC's role in the world of oil and liquids is really insignificant. ... in the 30,000,000 barrel a day range in a world where you look at total liquid consumption, it's 110,000,000 barrels a day. OPEC doesn't count much.”at 17:30

US stock market outlook

Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook

  • Eric Balchunas · Bloomberg Intelligence

    Governments will increasingly buy stocks during downturns; US government equity buying is coming.

    Balchunas cites the Chinese government buying stocks when they fall, including about $2B a day in equity ETFs, and Japan buying stocks. He notes the government bought Intel. From this he predicts that 'down the road' the US government will also buy stocks, which he calls a glimpse into the future and a hot take.

    “I mean, the Chinese government just buys stocks when they're down. ... They bought $2,000,000,000 a day in the equity ETFs. ... I think down the road, our government will buy stocks.”at 10:57

China's economy

Where everyone stands on China's economy

  • Ed Morse · Hartree Partners

    China's official 4.6% GDP growth is not credible; underlying growth is near zero and internal mechanisms are failing.

    When China joined the IMF as a donor and became a more advanced economy, the deal gave it the right to have the IMF use its official GDP numbers. China now claims GDP is rising 4.6% a year. Morse says there is no way it is growing at that rate. He cites Rhodium Group's finding that year-to-date Chinese GDP growth has been zero, and he says the country's internal mechanisms are failing, not just that growth has stalled.

    “So China now claims that their GDP is rising at 4.6% ... There is no way in the world China's GDP is growing at that rate.”at 18:54

Power demand & the grid

Where everyone stands on Power demand & the grid

  • Ed Morse · Hartree Partners

    The world is moving to higher electricity intensity of GDP, which will make some equities very attractive.

    Morse argues the most important trend misunderstood right now is that the world is shifting to a higher electricity intensity of GDP. The sources of power are controversial, because some are fossil fuels and some are not, so the transition will be difficult. He says whether an investor should pick equities or bonds will depend on how this energy intensity plays out, and that some equities will look very attractive as a result.

    “The main thing that is misleading at this moment is that we're ... in a world moving to a higher electricity intensity of GDP.”at 23:59

US elections & politics

Where everyone stands on US elections & politics

  • David Gura · Bloomberg

    The Democrats' centrist bloc is large and will shape the party's policy direction despite the progressive pressure.

    Gura says the Democrats' election victory was significant partly because their coalition includes a very large centrist block. He cites the message from Congressman Gregory Meeks that centrists remain the core of the party. He expects that block to come to the fore and govern the party's general policy trajectory, which he says will make things easier for whoever leads the House and Senate. He also expects Chuck Schumer to keep his leadership position.

    “but the centrist block of it is so large. And I think we're gonna see them coming to life, kind of governing the general policy trajectory of the party here.”at 36:48

Market sentiment, positioning & volatility

Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility

  • Max Chafkin · Bloomberg Businessweek

    The AI trade has been a retail, meme-stock-like phenomenon, and Anthropic may exploit the same dynamic.

    Chafkin argues the AI trade has been a retail phenomenon with meme-stock characteristics, citing Elon Musk and SpaceX, Tesla and Palantir as companies that benefited. He thinks Anthropic, if smart, will try to exploit the same dynamic, because many people are excited to gamble on AI and put money behind the idea of AI.

    “The AI trade has been a retail phenomenon, a meme stocky phenomenon when you look at some of the companies that have really benefited, most notably Elon Musk and SpaceX as well as Tesla, also Palantir.”at 44:38

AI: overall outlook

Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook

  • Max Chafkin · Bloomberg Businessweek

    The AI market is in a very tenuous place, with many AI stocks well down recently.

    Chafkin says the AI market right now is in a very tenuous place. He points to Nvidia's leadership issues and to many AI stocks being way down over the past couple of months as reasons Anthropic's decision to go ahead with its IPO inspires only a little confidence and is uncertain.

    “the AI market right now is ... in a very tenuous place.”at 46:59

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA146 speakers · 134 bullish, 110 bearish calls
  • Anthropic116 speakers · 173 bullish, 92 bearish calls
  • OpenAI39 speakers · 17 bullish, 34 bearish calls
  • Bitcoin28 speakers · 25 bullish, 10 bearish calls

Topics

  • AI IPO read-through
  • AI market sentiment
  • CEO succession
  • Democratic party direction
  • GDP growth accuracy
  • IPO demand
  • IPO performance
  • OPEC pricing power
  • Social Security reform
  • bitcoin as an asset
  • chip export diversion to China
  • demographics and retirement strain
  • electricity intensity of GDP
  • government equity purchases
  • oil price shock risk
  • retail speculation in AI stocks
  • retirement savings contribution rates
  • retirement system grade

More from Bloomberg Surveillance

All Bloomberg Surveillance episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus