Animal Spirits · · 1h 13m
The Biggest Losers of the Year (EP. 491)
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Ben Carlson and Michael Batnick review the year's biggest losers, centred on Nvidia's sell-off. Carlson argues Jensen Huang's exit leaves a leadership vacuum, that the market is too calm about a stock trading near 11x forward earnings, and that semiconductor prices have diverged from rising forward earnings in an unprecedented way. Batnick counters that Nvidia still has dominant AI margins and growth, that hyperscaler demand is unaffected, and that the sell-off is an overreaction, while both note that leveraged long funds and herding by hedge funds around AI have amplified the swings. The hosts also discuss an inflation overshoot tied to energy and tariffs that they expect to keep rates high, weak housing affordability and first-time buyers, gold and silver falling as real rates rise, and the decline of original action films.
Key takeaways
- Michael Batnick (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's selloff is a severe overreaction, since hyperscaler demand for its chips is unaffected.
- Michael Batnick on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility: Leveraged fund assets have been flushed out, a good washout after too much leverage built up.
- Michael Batnick on US jobs & labor market: Energy- and tariff-driven inflation won't lift wages, so real pay is falling again.
- Michael Batnick on Gold & precious metals: Gold and silver's crash is driven by rising real interest rates and was predictable after huge gains.
- Michael Batnick on Media, music & entertainment: Original action movies have collapsed as IP franchises took over, so today's action films are worse.
What was said, by company and theme
7 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 167 speakers in other episodes, 175 bullish and 147 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth ManagementBullish
Nvidia's selloff is a severe overreaction, since hyperscaler demand for its chips is unaffected.
Batnick argues Nvidia is still the dominant player in AI, with roughly 70% gross margins, a software operating system moat beyond the hardware, and about 90% growth, and that we are early in a huge technological revolution. He sees no reason the executive scandal or the CEO's departure would slow hyperscaler demand, which he says investors are not seeing. He notes investors are punishing free cash flow burn at Meta, Google and Oracle, but he does not think that concern applies to Nvidia's chip demand. He reasons the market is over-reacting to Nvidia's sell-off, even if the reaction makes sense in the short term.
“I don't see how any of this slows down the demand that we're seeing from the hyperscalers. ... this will prove to be weirdly a severe overreaction even if it makes total sense in the short term.”at 30:17
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Leveraged fund assets have been flushed out, a good washout after too much leverage built up.
Batnick cites Strategas data showing assets in leveraged long funds fell 44% in the tariff episode, 54% in the 2022 bear market, 30% in March during the Iran shock and 37% in the current drawdown. He says there was way too much leverage in the system, and that this is a pretty good washout. He notes that much of the decline is price alone rather than investor behaviour, so the washout is partly mechanical.
“there was way too much leverage in the system... That's a pretty good washout.”at 31:49
US stock market outlook
Where everyone stands on US stock market outlook
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Money is rotating from Nvidia to staples on flows, not on a considered valuation call.
Michael argues that investors moving out of Nvidia and into Coca-Cola are not weighing five-year forward price-to-earnings multiples. He says there is so much money sloshing around that it has to go somewhere, and that investors are simply getting out of one place and into another. He notes that consumer staples are only about 5% of the index, so the rise in their valuations matters little to the overall market, and Ben agrees.
“I don't think anybody that is selling Nvidia and buying Coca Cola is thinking about the PE of one versus the other. ... There's so much money sloshing around that it has to go somewhere. So I don't think investors are making a five year forward PE call.”at 34:40
US jobs & labor market
Where everyone stands on US jobs & labor market
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Energy- and tariff-driven inflation won't lift wages, so real pay is falling again.
The labor share of income in the non-farm business sector has trended down for decades, and its early-2020s spike faded. In the early part of the decade labor had the upper hand while inflation ran, so wages rose with prices. Michael argues that this time the inflation comes from an energy price spike and tariffs, which doesn't push wages up, so inflation is again outpacing wages. Ben adds that this kind of inflation won't lead to higher wages.
“Well, and the thing that we're getting now is at least in the early part of the decade when we had inflation, labor did have the upper hand, and so your wages were going up with inflation. Now that's not happening because this kind of inflation from energy's price spike”at 39:48
Gold & precious metals
Where everyone stands on Gold & precious metals
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Gold and silver's crash is driven by rising real interest rates and was predictable after huge gains.
Gold and silver had enormous returns before, so their current crash is not a surprise. Michael attributes it to real interest rates and says it is not complicated. He also notes how quickly the narrative flipped: in the spring people talked about deficits and de-dollarization driving money into gold and silver, and now money is flowing out. Ben's observation that gold is down about 30% and silver about 60% from highs sets the context.
“Gold and silver had such huge returns before. So like that... The fact that they're crashing now is not a surprise. I think it's it's it's real interest rates. I don't think it's that complicated.”at 45:23
US housing
Where everyone stands on US housing
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
The housing market is in pain: first-time buyers are squeezed and home prices are flat in real terms.
Existing home sales are at their lowest level since the financial crisis, and Michael calls first-time buyers probably the biggest losers of the decade. Ben adds that home prices have been effectively flat for two years, about 1% growth, which is losing to inflation. Michael argues people are trapped in their homes, and while new home sales are roughly at their 2019-to-today average, the housing market continues in a world of pain.
“Obviously, we know people are trapped in their home. So it's about at at the at the 2019 to today average. But, yeah, the the housing market just continues to be in a world a world of pain”at 49:25
Media, music & entertainment
Where everyone stands on Media, music & entertainment
Michael Batnick · Ritholtz Wealth Management
Original action movies have collapsed as IP franchises took over, so today's action films are worse.
Using top-100 movie data from The Numbers, Michael shows original action film tickets sold fell from 175 million in 1996 to 31 million last year. The IP share of action films rose from roughly 50-60% to about 90%. He compares 1996's original hits such as Twister, The Rock and Eraser to today's franchise films, where the dinosaurs or monsters are the main characters and the story and characters are an afterthought. He concludes that the action movies of the 1990s were better and that the originals are now essentially gone.
“In 1996, there was 175,000,000 tickets sold... There was 31,000,000 last year. ... Now we get none of it.”at 1:02:58
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA167 speakers · 175 bullish, 147 bearish calls
Topics
- AI stock correction
- Nvidia leadership and competitive position
- Nvidia sell-off reaction
- first-time buyers and home prices
- gold price drivers
- hedge fund herding
- inflation fight
- leverage and washouts
- original action films
- public perception of AI
- retail dip-buying
- sector rotation
- sector valuations and rotation
- semiconductor valuations vs earnings
- small home construction
- tariffs and inflation
- wage growth
More from Animal Spirits
- Talk Your Book: The Anthropic IPO · November 16, 2026
- What the Hell Just Happened?! (EP. 490) · November 11, 2026
- Drowning Financially (EP. 489) · November 4, 2026
- Talk Your Book: Diversifying the AI Trade · November 2, 2026
- Why Baby Boomers Have All the Money (EP. 488) · October 28, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus