Bloomberg Surveillance · · 47 min

Anthropic Debut and Trump's Xi-Putin Trilateral Meeting

With Elizabeth Economy, George Noble, Gil Luria, Huw van Steenis, James Crabtree

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

Bloomberg Surveillance covered the Anthropic stock debut and the Trump-Xi-Putin meeting. George Noble was bearish on Anthropic, pointing to a 315 million-share float with no lockup, about 3 billion more shares due to unlock in December, and a price near its 135 IPO level, along with decelerating growth and no economies of scale. He was also bearish on Nvidia, alleging export-control evasion by Chinese buyers and warning that unused chip inventory and circular financing leave the sector exposed. Gil Luria of D.A. Davidson was bullish on Anthropic's growth and research talent, but expected a volatile trading period given the small float and insider unlocks, and warned a weak IPO could slow hyperscaler data centre spending. On geopolitics, Elizabeth Economy argued the summit lent Putin legitimacy and elevated China's great-power standing with more symbolism than substance, while James Crabtree focused on Taiwan, the shifting Indo-Pacific military balance, and congressional pressure on chip export policy. Huw van Steenis outlined a coming European capex upswing, led by utilities, defence and AI infrastructure, and bank consolidation.

Key takeaways

  • George Noble (bearish on Anthropic): Anthropic IPO has about 315M shares free to sell immediately with no lockup, plus a large December unlock, pressuring the stock.
  • Gil Luria (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic's lead rests on a small pool of top researchers it has, though it must keep improving its models.
  • Elizabeth Economy on Russia & Ukraine: The Trump-Xi-Putin summit gave Putin legitimacy not seen since his invasion of Ukraine.
  • Huw van Steenis on Europe's economy: European capex intensity is set to reach a ten-year high next year, possibly a twenty-year high.
  • James Crabtree on US–China AI & chip race: Post-midterm Congress will make Trump's soft China chip policy face much more scrutiny.

What was said, by company and theme

24 views from 5 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Anthropic

Across the shows: 134 speakers in other episodes, 234 bullish and 114 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • George Noble · Noble Capital AdvisorsBearish

    Anthropic IPO has about 315M shares free to sell immediately with no lockup, plus a large December unlock, pressuring the stock.

    The IPO deal was about 900 million shares, but roughly 315 million can be sold right away with no lockup. About 3 billion more shares are due to unlock in December. Noble says the stock is not materially different from its 135 IPO price and is at about 143. He frames the supply overhang as a reason for caution, while saying he does not know what the stock does in the next few days or weeks.

    “I believe there are 315,000,000 shares that are available for immediate sale today. There's no lockup at all.”at 2:23
  • George Noble · Noble Capital AdvisorsBearish

    Anthropic lacks economies of scale and loses more as it sells more, so it is not an investment for him.

    Noble argues Anthropic's growth is decelerating and that the business does not scale. He says there are no economies of scale, so each additional sale adds to losses. He separates speculating from investing and says he would not buy the stock as an investment.

    “I'm not buying it. The company's got decelerating growth. It doesn't scale. There are no economies of scale. The more they sell, the more they lose.”at 3:15
  • Gil Luria · D.A. DavidsonUncertain

    Anthropic IPO should trade well on day one, but the stock will be volatile as insider shares and index flows arrive.

    Luria says demand is strong because the market has no pure-play AI listing, and investors have set money aside for one. He expects the first day to go very well. He then expects far more volatility as insider shares unlock faster than usual and as index and ETF inclusions create crosscurrents. He also says the float is only about 5%, which he says is deliberate and designed for a first-day pop.

    “The stock price is going to be very volatile. The demand is great because we haven't had a pure play AI yet. ... the market should be receiving this IPO very, very well. And then we're going to have a lot more volatility”at 12:35
  • Gil Luria · D.A. DavidsonBullish

    Anthropic is a very good company growing very fast, and its outlook reflects AI overall.

    Luria says D.A. Davidson spent a lot of time on Anthropic's financials because they have implications for other AI and technology stocks. Their conclusion was that Anthropic is a very good company growing very fast, with a good outlook. He says its outlook is the outlook for AI in general, which makes the company a read-through on the whole sector.

    “What we came away with is that this is a very good company growing very fast with a good outlook, and their outlook is the outlook of AI in general.”at 13:44
  • Gil Luria · D.A. DavidsonBullish

    Anthropic's lead rests on a small pool of top researchers it has, though it must keep improving its models.

    Luria estimates there are perhaps 100 people in the world smart enough to advance AI research. Most are at Anthropic and OpenAI, with some at Google, xAI, Meta and in China. He says Anthropic's team is very capable and well compensated, so the company's edge is its ability to keep improving models quickly. Without that, open-weight models would catch up and erase the lead, so Anthropic must keep improving to stay ahead.

    “Anthropic has a very good team that is so capable of advancing the AI research and so well compensated for doing so that's their mode.”at 14:38

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 175 speakers in other episodes, 184 bullish and 166 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • George Noble · Noble Capital AdvisorsBearish

    Nvidia chips reached China directly or indirectly in large amounts, and Noble says the company clearly broke the law.

    Noble argues that billions of dollars of Nvidia chips went to Chinese buyers, whether directly or indirectly, in breach of export controls. He says Jensen Huang must have known, and calls it the biggest case of industrial espionage or fraud in US stock market history. He also notes an unverified rumour about Commerce Secretary Lutnick. His case rests on his reading of the situation and his own inference, not on cited evidence, so it is an allegation.

    “it's very clear that billions and billions of dollars of chips from [Nvidia] were going to the Chinese, whether directly or indirectly. ... it's very clear they broke the law.”at 5:22
  • George Noble · Noble Capital AdvisorsBearish

    Unsold Nvidia chips sit in warehouses, and secondary chip prices are being held up, signalling weak demand.

    Noble says tens to hundreds of billions of dollars of chips are sitting in warehouses unused. Bulls point to resale prices holding up, but he argues Jensen Huang wanted secondary prices kept high so the market would not see that. If the loss-making VC-funded startups that buy these chips are gone, the chips have nowhere to go and would be sold off cheaply. He reads this as a demand problem, not a price problem.

    “There are tens and hundreds of billions of dollars of chips sitting around in warehouses collecting dust.”at 7:33
  • George Noble · Noble Capital AdvisorsBearish

    Nvidia sits at the centre of circular AI financing, so its problems would spread through the whole system.

    Noble says the AI system depends on external capital, and that it is reflexive. Diagrams of circular financing put Nvidia in the middle, which he compares to the heart in the circulatory system. If the heart fails, the rest of the system fails too. He says that if external capital is switched off, the whole thing chokes.

    “Imagine you have the circulatory system, NVIDIA is the heart. ... If you have a heart attack, what happens to the corpus?”at 9:43

US–China relations

Where everyone stands on US–China relations

  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    The summit reinforced China as coequal with the US, a view that Economy says the optics overstate.

    Economy argues the meeting reinforced the idea that China is coequal with the United States, as one of the two great powers. She sees Trump as using the event to play with the big boys. She discounts the stated importance of the outcomes, which suggests the symbolism outweighed substance.

    “It reinforced the notion that China is coequal with The United States in terms of its standing as one of the two great powers.”at 20:27
  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    US China policy has been consistent across three administrations, and the next president will likely move away from a G2 approach.

    Economy says policy has been more continuous from Trump's first term through Biden to Trump's second than his statements suggest. She judges the administration by its actions, which keep China as the greatest long-term strategic challenge in Indo-Pacific security, trade and technology. She expects the next president to step back from Trump's idea of a G2 and refocus on traditional allies, because moderates in both parties in Congress are pushing that way.

    “the good news, frankly, is that there's a lot more continuity in our policy, from Trump one to Biden to Trump two than I think we often see”at 21:14
  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    US-Philippines security ties are deepening and form a defence network that constrains China in the South China Sea.

    Economy describes a South China Sea dispute in which China claims most of the sea under the nine-dash line. The Philippines won its 2016 case at international court, which China rejects. She argues that US–Philippines security ties grew under Biden and have accelerated under Trump. Philippine defence ties with Japan and Australia add to a network designed to support Manila and constrain Chinese aggression.

    “What we've seen is that The United States and The Philippines have developed an increasingly robust security relationship.”at 25:38
  • James Crabtree · European Council on Foreign Relations

    Trump may trade away Taiwan policy for Chinese concessions, alarming Taiwan and China hawks.

    Crabtree says Taiwan's current status is that US policy has not formally changed, but China hawks in Washington and Taipei become nervous whenever Trump meets Xi. The assumption is that Trump does not care much about Taiwan or its democracy, and that he sees Taiwan as a bargaining chip. Crabtree says Trump believes Taiwan stole the US semiconductor industry. He notes that those who see Taiwan as strategically important do so for both geostrategic reasons and semiconductors. The worry is that Trump might change the Taiwan policy in exchange for something China offers.

    “He thinks Taiwan stole [the] US semiconductor industry, and he has come out and said that he sees Taiwan as a kind of bargaining chip.”at 39:16
  • James Crabtree · European Council on Foreign Relations

    China's military buildup means the US can no longer deter Taiwan action as it did in 1996.

    Crabtree says the big story of the last twenty to thirty years is that China has built a military with long-range missiles, submarines and aircraft carriers capable of pushing the US further away. In 1996 the US sailed two aircraft carriers near Taiwan and the Chinese were forced to back down, but that could not happen anymore. He says it is an open question whether the US could dissuade China from going to war over Taiwan simply because its military is too powerful. Many people are worried about the direction of the military balance, and think that at some point Xi may decide enough is enough and force the issue.

    “The US sailed these two aircraft carriers, into Taiwan, and the Chinese were forced to back down. Now that couldn't happen anymore.”at 40:42

Europe's economy

Where everyone stands on Europe's economy

  • Huw van Steenis · Apollo Global Management

    European capex intensity is set to reach a ten-year high next year, possibly a twenty-year high.

    After two decades of saying Europe underinvests and stagnates, van Steenis says capex intensity, measured as capex to sales, is set to rise sharply next year. The drivers are defence, electrification, grids, and AI and data centres, where Europe is behind but catching up. He says capex needs are starting to swell.

    “we look at CapEx to sales, the CapEx intensity. It's probably gonna hit a ten year high, may even break a twenty year high.”at 27:34
  • Huw van Steenis · Apollo Global Management

    Listed European companies will add roughly 80 billion in capex from 2025 to 2028, with 40% in utilities.

    Van Steenis estimates capex across listed European stocks will rise by about 80 billion between 2025 and 2028, with about 40% of the increase in utilities. He describes economic security, including protecting maritime cables and airports, as driving private-sector spending as well as government defence spending. He calls the utilities share a large part of the build-out, which is driven by grids and power demand.

    “there's roughly 80,000,000,000 increase in CapEx across the listed European stocks. ... 40% of that's utilities.”at 29:09
  • Huw van Steenis · Apollo Global Management

    The UK economy is stabilising after a rough decade, with a surprisingly strong GDP beat, and is improving.

    Van Steenis says the UK's latest GDP print was a surprising beat. After a rough decade, with some questions about political competence, the economy is now starting to stabilise. He also cites strong UK innovation and reasons to invest, and says the country is definitely improving.

    “Our GDP print was a nice beat. It's a surprising beat. ... But actually the GDP now is starting to stabilize.”at 32:33

US global standing & alliances

Where everyone stands on US global standing & alliances

  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    Transatlantic ties can be rebuilt, but it will take a lot of work; Europeans now see the relationship as interest-based.

    After a 17-day trip to Hungary, China and Japan, Economy says Europeans insist they will never return to the old relationship. They describe the ties as interest-based rather than trust-based, so new trust must be built. She is less pessimistic than some and believes a robust alliance can be rebuilt. She contrasts this with Asia, where the Trump administration has been much kinder to allies than it has been to European ones.

    “So I think there's gonna be work. I'm not as pessimistic as some of them are. I do think that we can find our way back to a really robust transatlantic alliance, but it's gonna take a lot of work.”at 23:09
  • James Crabtree · European Council on Foreign Relations

    US primacy on the first island chain is slipping as Middle East operations drain resources from the Indo-Pacific.

    Crabtree argues the first island chain (Japan, Taiwan, the Philippines) is the world's most important geopolitical dividing line because it is the only place the two superpowers could plausibly clash directly. He says the US has held this position for a long time, but its Middle East involvement is drawing resources away from the Indo-Pacific. He adds that administrations have said they are focused on deterring China while their actions suggest otherwise, so many people think the US position is gradually slipping away. He frames the question as whether Trump understands this geopolitical real estate. His closing view is that the US is the incumbent and China must push it out, so an American strategist should work to keep what it has, since retreat would make China very happy.

    “at the moment, the US's misadventure in the Middle East is drawing resources away from what it needs to be doing in the Indo Pacific.”at 38:00

Banks

Where everyone stands on Banks

  • Huw van Steenis · Apollo Global Management

    European banks have not financed a capex wave in twenty years, so long-dated capex funding will shift toward bond and private markets.

    Van Steenis argues the banking system in Europe has not had to finance a capex wave for twenty years, so its ability to do so is untested. Much of the needed capital is long-dated, which he says will naturally flow to the bond market or to private credit. Banks can still originate and distribute that lending. Hyperscalers are also issuing in Europe, which increases competition for capital.

    “the banking system in Europe hasn't had to finance a CapEx way for twenty years, so it's untested.”at 27:53
  • Huw van Steenis · Apollo Global Management

    Winner-takes-most dynamics are reaching European finance, so consolidation will stay mostly within national borders.

    Van Steenis says the winner-takes-most dynamic seen in tech is coming to finance, because the largest firms benefit disproportionately from scale. European consolidation has so far happened inside countries, with eight deals in Italy and some in the UK and Spain. Cross-border deals are worth watching, but he expects adjacent deals rather than mega-mergers between names such as Santander and Deutsche Bank.

    “The winner takes most dynamic that you see in tech is coming to finance in spades. The largest two or three firms in each financial sector disproportionately benefit.”at 31:01

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Gil Luria · D.A. Davidson

    A weak Anthropic IPO would sour investors on AI build-out and could stall data centre construction within quarters.

    Luria says Anthropic and OpenAI revenue depends on ramping up compute. That compute spending depends on hyperscalers buying chips, and they will only keep buying if the IPO goes well. A poor IPO would signal scepticism about the build-out. He warns that this could stall data centre construction over the next few quarters.

    “That only continues if this IPO goes well. If the IPO does not go well, that will relay a level of scepticism about the build out that may stall construction of data centers over the next few quarters.”at 16:06

Open-source AI models

Where everyone stands on Open-source AI models

  • Gil Luria · D.A. Davidson

    Western open-weight models, not Chinese ones, are the real competitive threat to Anthropic's lead.

    Luria argues that companies are unlikely to build infrastructure on Chinese models, so the US and Chinese markets will stay separate. Western enterprises will use open-weight models from American and European developers, because they will not risk sending sensitive information to China. He sees those Western open-weight models as the threat that matters most for Anthropic.

    “What really matters, [Anthropic], is the threat from open weight models that are made in the West.”at 16:42

Russia & Ukraine

Where everyone stands on Russia & Ukraine

  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    The Trump-Xi-Putin summit gave Putin legitimacy not seen since his invasion of Ukraine.

    Economy says the optics of the meeting legitimised Putin in a way he has not been since invading Ukraine. She also argues the summit did not produce a particularly historic outcome, despite the claims about its importance. The argument is based on the visual and diplomatic effect of Putin sitting alongside Trump and Xi.

    “It legitimized Putin, frankly, in a way that he hasn't been since he invaded Ukraine.”at 20:19

US–China AI & chip race

Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race

  • James Crabtree · European Council on Foreign Relations

    Post-midterm Congress will make Trump's soft China chip policy face much more scrutiny.

    Crabtree says that for China hawks the midterm results are good news. He argues that the China hawks think a Chinese Ministry of State Security action has made it much harder for Trump to ignore companies sending semiconductors to China. He adds that new voices in Congress are more orthodox, pro-Taiwan and keen to deter China, so the president's softly-softly approach to China will get much more scrutiny. He still says Trump is in charge and largely unconstrained when meeting Xi, so the China hawks and Taiwan's government will keep feeling heat at the upcoming meetings.

    “Well, if you're a China hawk, it's good news. ... it makes it much more difficult now for president Trump to turn a blind eye to companies who are sending semiconductors to China.”at 41:31

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA175 speakers · 184 bullish, 166 bearish calls
  • Anthropic134 speakers · 234 bullish, 114 bearish calls

Ask your AI who they are and what they said

Topics

  • AI IPO demand and trading
  • AI lab unit economics
  • China policy continuity
  • European bank consolidation
  • European capex cycle
  • IPO lockup and share supply
  • Indo-Pacific primacy
  • Putin legitimacy from summit
  • South China Sea security alignment
  • Taiwan Strait military balance
  • Taiwan policy
  • UK growth
  • Western open-weight model competition
  • bank financing of European capex
  • chip export control evasion
  • chip export controls
  • chip inventory and secondary prices
  • circular financing
  • growth and financial outlook
  • hyperscaler data center build-out
  • listed European capex growth
  • research talent and model lead
  • summit and great-power standing
  • transatlantic alliance rebuilding

More from Bloomberg Surveillance

All Bloomberg Surveillance episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus