The David Lin Report · · 48 min

Worst Housing Demand Ever: Where Prices Fall In 2027 | Reventure CEO

With Nick Gerli

Summary

Reventure CEO Nick Gerli argues US housing demand has hit record lows, with NAR pending sales at their weakest ever and existing closed sales at a 3.75M annualized pace, the lowest in sixteen years. He pairs this with a supply surge, active listings near 1.2M versus 566,000 in October 2021, and forecasts broad price declines in 2027, led by Washington, Utah, Arizona and Colorado, while Illinois, Connecticut and New Jersey are expected to rise. Using Reventure's 20-year home price-to-income metric, he says most states are overvalued, Florida has deflated from 34% overvalued to about 4%, and Austin looks undervalued despite a near-30% fall from peak. He also flags tech-hub weakness outside San Francisco, condo oversupply in Nashville, data centers having localized effects (Memphis weak, Abilene booming), and a buy-versus-rent premium of about 40%, while cautioning that reported medians are inflated by luxury-heavy closings.

Key takeaways

  • Nick Gerli on US housing: US housing demand is at record lows, worse than 2008-2009, with existing-home sales and contract signings collapsing.
  • Nick Gerli on US housing: Record-low demand plus the highest inventory in a decade means US home prices fall in 2027.
  • Nick Gerli on US housing: Tech-driven metro housing markets are falling nearly everywhere except San Francisco, which is an AI-driven outlier.
  • Nick Gerli on US housing: Buying a home now costs about 40% more per month than renting, so first-time buyers are priced out.
  • Nick Gerli on US housing: US housing supply has roughly doubled from 2021 lows, creating a glut and falling prices in many markets.

What was said, by company and theme

21 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

US housing

Where everyone stands on US housing

  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    US housing demand is at record lows, worse than 2008-2009, with existing-home sales and contract signings collapsing.

    The NAR pending home sales index for existing homes hit its lowest level ever in September 2026, below the 2008-2009 downturn. October 2026 existing closed sales ran at 3.75M annualized, the lowest in sixteen years and below any period in 2008-2009 except a few months in 2010. Mortgage purchase applications are at their lowest since 1994-1995, and that count includes applications not yet accepted. He attributes the collapse to home prices that outpaced incomes during the pandemic and to mortgage rates back above 7%, which leave buyers unable or unwilling to pay current prices. Investors are also exiting because rates above 7% kill rental cash flow. He says the demand downturn has lasted four years and keeps getting worse.

    “It was the lowest amount of contract signings for people to go out and purchase homes in the existing home sale market that we've ever seen.”at 2:32
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Record-low demand plus the highest inventory in a decade means US home prices fall in 2027.

    Active listings were about 1.2M in October per realtor.com, only 2% below pre-pandemic. Excluding the Northeast and Midwest, which still have shortages, supply in the South and West is the highest in over ten years. Washington has 29,000 homes for sale against a normal 18,000, 50-60% above normal. Days on market in weak states are about 65 versus 38 before the pandemic. He argues that lowest-ever demand combined with the highest supply in a decade means lower prices in 2027. Reventure's one-year forecast has 33 states declining, with Washington down 6.7% and Utah, Arizona and Colorado down 5-6%. Tennessee is also expected to fall sharply. Illinois (+5.3%), Connecticut (+6%) and New Jersey (+3.4%) are forecast to rise. He calls supply the driver in the biggest-decline states, not mortgage rates alone.

    “[Highest supply] in ten years. That combination means lower prices in 2027.”at 3:56
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Tech-driven metro housing markets are falling nearly everywhere except San Francisco, which is an AI-driven outlier.

    Excluding San Francisco, metro areas that rely on the tech industry are almost universally declining. Seattle is one of the worst US housing markets, and Microsoft just announced buyouts for 27% of its workforce. Austin and Denver are in free fall. San Francisco County values are up 15% year over year because Anthropic, OpenAI and xAI are headquartered within a 10-15 block radius, generating large amounts of money locally. He treats that as a local economic effect rather than a broader housing trend, and expects a handful of outlier markets to differ from the broader decline in 2027.

    “cities and metro areas that rely more on the tech industry, they're actually all almost universally going down.”at 4:52
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Most US states are overvalued against local incomes, with several near 20% overvalued.

    Reventure compares home values with local incomes over 20 years. Idaho, Montana, Wisconsin, Michigan and Indiana are close to 20% overvalued. Almost every state is overvalued; only a few, such as Louisiana, Mississippi and North Dakota, are undervalued. He argues that local incomes are the most important long-term driver of home values and that prices disconnected from incomes must correct, as in Florida during the pandemic when out-of-state cash buyers pushed prices past local affordability. Florida was 34% overvalued four years ago and is now about 4%. He warns that a Florida-style repeat of 2008-2015, when prices became deeply undervalued, is possible. Each market has its own baseline ratio: Florida 4.3-4.4, West Virginia 2.7, California 6.8. He says the metric has been very predictive of market trends.

    “Places like Idaho and Montana, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Indiana are close to 20% overvalued when you look at the historical trends on home prices and incomes.”at 7:22
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Buying a home now costs about 40% more per month than renting, so first-time buyers are priced out.

    Mortgage, taxes and insurance per month to buy a home is about 40% more expensive than renting the same house, versus roughly equal before the pandemic. In some markets the gap is far larger; he estimates Vancouver at around double. Buyers who pay this premium also cannot count on appreciation, since he doubts many people believe prices will rise and expects them to fall. For a first-time buyer, the monthly math makes buying irrational, and he says there is no strong financial case to buy right now, though space, security and stability remain valid reasons to own.

    “One of the craziest things for first time buyers is that the cost to buy a home today. Mortgage taxes insurance per month is about 40% more expensive than the cost to rent the same house.”at 12:49
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Reported home prices are propped up by a mix shift toward luxury and cash buyers, so they will fall later.

    Case-Shiller is at a record high, and the national median existing home price rose 0.4% in October even as sales fell. He argues this is a composition effect. Sales of $1M-plus homes are down only 6%, while other price points are down 11-12%, so a disproportionate share of closings are luxury homes bought by older, cash-paying buyers. He believes this mix is artificially inflating reported closing prices. When sales normalize and more regular buyers return to ordinary houses, the reported median should drop.

    “Their composition of the sales is higher on a relative basis than it is in normal period. That's something that my opinion is artificially propping up the reported close prices.”at 16:26
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Weak housing demand reflects affordability, white-collar job insecurity and falling births, so demand stays depressed.

    He argues several forces are combining to suppress demand. Affordability is the first: buying costs about 40% more than renting. Second, white-collar workers in finance, tech, HR and marketing feel insecure about their jobs. Companies such as Microsoft are offering buyouts to 27% of staff, and buyers need around $110-120K a year in median income to qualify for many mortgages. Third, US births have fallen about 35% over the last thirty years, which means fewer families forming and needing to buy and more renters. He says these combine to put housing demand on ice.

    “It's down about 35% the last thirty years. And we're seeing essentially an aging of The US population and then fewer younger people forming families and having kids.”at 19:52
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Sellers with 3% mortgages anchor to inflated prices, while post-2022 sellers cut and prices stay bifurcated.

    Sellers' mortgage rates shape how willing they are to accept lower prices. Owners who bought in 2020-2021 with about 3% mortgages see the value of their cheap loan as part of the house's worth, so they hold out for prices well above market clearing levels and do not sell. Owners who bought after 2022 with 6-7% rates are much more willing to make a deal. He sees this bifurcation across the US, even in the same city and neighborhood. Some sellers cut to market while others think their home is worth 30% more than it is and do not sell, even as inventory rises and prices drop next year.

    “[If someone bought post 2022] and has a six to 7% rate, they are so much more willing to make a deal on the house when they sell it.”at 20:51
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Condo markets are in free fall from oversupply, rising HOA fees and cheaper apartment rents.

    Nashville has one of the largest oversupplies and gluts of any downtown area in the US, and developers overbuilt and over-permitted. HOA fees rose sharply over the last five years, with newer Nashville one-bedrooms at $600 a month and some Florida condos at $1,500, so a mortgaged condo can cost around $4,500 a month. Nearby apartments compete directly, often renting the same unit about 50% cheaper and offering two to three months free. He also says second and third-home buyers, who are heavily invested in condos, are not comfortable taking on extra payments in this economy.

    “Nashville has one of the biggest oversupply and housing gluts of any downtown area in The US. It's condo markets in free fall.”at 22:08
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Austin is undervalued after a 30% crash, a good buying opportunity, though values may fall another 6%.

    Austin was the hottest market in 2020-2021 and has since fallen almost 30% from peak. Values are now only about 15% above pre-pandemic levels while incomes have kept growing, so Reventure's metrics show Austin as undervalued. Reventure still expects another 6% drop over the next year, but he thinks Austin is near the point where it is a good deal. He says he would buy single-family homes there rather than townhomes or condos, because land appreciates while the structure's value tracks the cost of labour and materials to rebuild.

    “but we actually think Austin is getting to the point where it's a good deal. So if I had $10,000,000 to just invest, I would buy up single family homes in and around Austin's housing market.”at 35:12
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Bearish on pandemic-built exurban and rural home locations with cheap land and heavy builder supply.

    Land value drives long-term home appreciation, but land in outlying suburb-to-rural areas where builders built heavily during the pandemic is low value. Builders can subdivide new plots cheaply and keep building, and US builders have already made large price cuts, so these locations have weak long-term value.

    “One area I'm kind of bearish on are those outlying suburb to rural locations where the builders just built, like, all of these homes during the pandemic.”at 36:25
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Single-family homes on the urban-suburban fringe in strong markets like Austin offer the best long-term land value.

    A home's structure is worth roughly its rebuild cost, so the value that grows over time is the land, which tracks local market dynamics. Pockets on the urban-to-suburban fringe of strong metros should appreciate most, and Austin is cited as a market that has actually declined, so it is a buying area. The view is about where land value is strongest rather than a near-term price call.

    “So I love the idea of buying a single family home in a maybe more suburban to urban area, kind of on that urban to suburban fringe in a market like Austin.”at 36:45
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    US housing demand is shifting back toward legacy big-city metros, while pandemic zoom towns are weakening.

    Migration is moving back toward large cities. San Francisco, New York and Chicago are doing relatively well because they have concentrated Fortune 500 job bases. Pandemic-era zoom towns, which saw a building boom, are doing worse.

    “we're seeing somewhat of a movement back to the big cities in The US. ... New York City is also starting to do really well.”at 38:23
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Buyers who bought at the 2021–2023 peak on FOMO overpaid and often compromised on home or location.

    Many people bought during the shortage on the belief that they would never be able to buy otherwise. The inventory data shows that buyers in October 2021, when supply was 566,000, likely settled for homes they did not love. Some of those buyers are now selling only two or three years later into a down market.

    “one of the biggest mistakes is people bought the FOMO, the fear of missing out.”at 41:15
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    US housing supply has roughly doubled from 2021 lows, creating a glut and falling prices in many markets.

    Inventory was about 566,000 homes in October 2021, when there was a true shortage. It has risen to about 1,200,000, with supply described as through the roof in Tennessee and Texas, and rows of new houses across Florida, Georgia, Arizona and Texas. Only places like Long Island and Westchester near New York City remain short of homes. As a result, prices are dropping in many markets.

    “Now supply is back up to 1,200,000. Right now, there's plenty of supply.”at 42:13
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Expects US mortgage rates to stay around 7% through 2027 absent an economic downturn.

    Rate forecasts have repeatedly been wrong because of inflation and bond-yield surprises. The Fed is hiking into a weak housing market, a pattern seen only in 1929 and briefly around 2006. Gerli is not counting on a meaningful drop in 2027, and expects rates to fall only if an economic downdraft occurs.

    “I'm not gonna bank on any meaningful decrease in mortgage rates in 2027. ... But short of that, I think we're going to see 7% for a little while.”at 45:59
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Buyers have leverage now; sellers are competing, so making many offers can secure good deals.

    Inventory is abundant in many markets, so sellers are competing with each other. From late 2026 into 2027, making enough offers should land buyers good deals, even though this is not a good time to buy outright.

    “It is a great time to make offers, particularly if you're in one of these housing markets with the abundance of inventory. Sellers are competing against each other.”at 46:47
  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Sellers must price realistically, below recent comps, since past sale prices no longer hold.

    Sellers anchored to prices from three to four years ago will struggle in a market where prices are falling. Pricing ahead of the market and below recent comps is more effective. A Nashville realtor reported that a seller who listed 10% below comps sold the house in two days.

    “do not look at what the people sold for three to four years ago. What you actually wanna do is price ahead of the market, price realistically, and come in even lower than you would think”at 47:29

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Data centers lift local home values only where economic growth exists; otherwise the effect is negligible.

    Reventure looked at several markets and found mixed results. Memphis, home to xAI's Colossus data center, has seen housing plummet since construction began in spring 2024, with a surge in supply and falling jobs. Abilene, Texas, where OpenAI is building Stargate, is booming, with values up 5-6% year over year. He concludes the effect is localized: a data center in an area with strong economic growth may lift values through construction jobs, but one in a place with weak demographic growth like Memphis is unlikely to help property values.

    “I'm not seeing one definitive narrative in and around data centers. I think if the data center is being built in an area that already has strong economic growth, maybe it'll be an uplift.”at 6:35

Canada, Australia & other developed economies

Where everyone stands on Canada, Australia & other developed economies

  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    Canadian home prices are already falling, and investors are exiting that market as well.

    He says investors in Canada were a big force in the market but are now bailing, as US investors are, because rates above 7% make rental cash flow hard. He infers that US prices will also fall because Canadian prices have already dropped significantly. He offers little data for Canada beyond general observations and an estimate for Vancouver's buy-versus-rent gap.

    “I'm also sure in the Canadian market, just judging by how much prices have dropped there already.”at 26:59

US Treasuries & yields

Where everyone stands on US Treasuries & yields

  • Nick Gerli · Reventure Consulting / Reventure App

    A 5% ten-year Treasury yield may be a return to normal rather than an anomaly.

    The 10-year Treasury is back above 5%, and yields are rising in Canada, England and France too. A 10-year yield of 5% was normal for much of the 1990s and 2000s. The low-rate environment of the last 10 to 15 years was the exception. Gerli wonders whether this is simply the new norm, while noting that very weak sales and falling prices could argue for lower rates.

    “a ten year yield of five was abundantly normal for much of the nineties and aughts, and, it was really in the last, like, ten, fifteen years where we had this lower rate environment.”at 45:02

Topics

  • Austin housing market
  • Canadian housing downturn
  • city markets
  • condo oversupply
  • data centers and local property values
  • home buying conditions
  • home price-to-income valuation
  • home sales demand
  • home selling conditions
  • housing affordability and buy-versus-rent gap
  • housing demand drivers
  • housing supply
  • housing supply and 2027 prices
  • long-term yields
  • mortgage rates
  • pandemic-era buyers
  • reported home price composition
  • seller pricing behavior
  • tech-hub metro housing

More from The David Lin Report

All The David Lin Report episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus