The Acquirers Podcast · · 40 min
Is AI Killing Adobe? We Discuss
Summary
Tobias Carlisle and Tim Travis discuss whether AI is threatening Adobe and other software and tech incumbents. Tobias sees Adobe as reasonably valued but at risk of losing seats and pricing power to AI tools, while Tim is more bullish, favouring put-selling on elevated implied volatility and comparing the moment to Adobe's earlier cloud transition. Both are wary of AI bubble dynamics: Tobias uses fiber-optic overbuild and the Gartner hype cycle to argue that AI builders capture little of the value created, while Tim bears on Apple's stretched valuation and sees margin risk for NVIDIA and Micron from competition and commoditisation. They also debate data center opposition, copper supply constraints, SpaceX's IPO pricing, and volatility as a market regime.
Key takeaways
- Tim Travis (bullish on Alphabet): Google's in-house chip business diversifies it against AI search disruption; hyperscaler troughs look attractive.
- Tim Travis (bearish on Apple): Apple is overvalued at current levels despite its brand loyalty.
- Tobias Carlisle (bearish on Space Exploration Technologies): Investors should avoid SpaceX's IPO; buying after the mania fades will offer a better price.
- Tim Travis (bullish on Adobe): Adobe is more attractive than Tobias thinks; high volatility makes selling puts a good way to enter.
- Tobias Carlisle (bullish on Adobe): Adobe's financials are strong, AI fears have discounted the stock, and he'd lean toward owning it long.
What was said, by company and theme
17 views from 2 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Adobe
Across the shows: 3 speakers in other episodes, 0 bullish and 2 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Adobe
Tim Travis · Value Options LetterBullish
Adobe is more attractive than Tobias thinks; high volatility makes selling puts a good way to enter.
Tim is more bullish than Tobias on Adobe. Implied volatility is high, so selling puts earns strong premiums and can create a cheaper entry price. The Value Options letter has previously sold Adobe options. He compares the AI margin worry to the earlier software-to-cloud rotation, when Adobe set the template by shifting to ARR-based recurring revenue and the stock did very well. He flags a risk: a CEO who managed that transition has left, and whether Adobe can repeat it is the thing to watch. Cost is also a factor, since large companies must retrain staff and pay for multiple platforms.
“I probably am more bullish on Adobe than you are. At least also, like, selling puts on it because the volatility is quite high, so you can get really good premiums”at 30:11
Tobias Carlisle · Acquirers Funds / The Acquirers PodcastBullish
Adobe's financials are strong, AI fears have discounted the stock, and he'd lean toward owning it long.
Adobe's financial statements look reasonably good value and it still earns lots of money on its assets, so it's a good business on paper. AI-driven fears that users will need less of its tools (natural-language prompts replacing skills built on Adobe software) are creating a discount. He is not bearish and would probably be inclined to own it long. The risk he flags is that its premium valuation, typical of high-margin online businesses, could go if Adobe cannot raise prices as before or loses seats to people who no longer need the capability.
“To be clear, I'm not bearish on Adobe at all. As I say, like, the financials still look very impressive. ... there's AI fears that are creating a discount in the stock, and I would probably be inclined to own them long.”at 31:24
Microsoft
Across the shows: 46 speakers in other episodes, 52 bullish and 10 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Microsoft
Tobias Carlisle · Acquirers Funds / The Acquirers PodcastBearish
AI tools like Claude are making real inroads into Microsoft's Word and Excel franchise.
Claude has launched a competitor to Microsoft's Word and Excel. Tobias says he will never open another Word document because he would rather dictate to Claude and have it produce the finished document. He concedes that Office is not most of Microsoft's business, but he thinks AI is making real inroads in these software businesses.
“I get that that's not the most part of Microsoft's business, but they're making real inroads in these software businesses.”at 1:46
Alphabet
Across the shows: 73 speakers in other episodes, 63 bullish and 48 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Alphabet
Tim Travis · Value Options LetterBullish
Google's in-house chip business diversifies it against AI search disruption; hyperscaler troughs look attractive.
AI models could cut into Google's search queries and ad revenue. Google's own chip business is growing hugely in volume and will sell chips externally, possibly becoming one of the biggest chip companies. Hyperscalers like Google have spread their bets so they are no longer one- or two-trick ponies. High-quality hyperscalers are in troughs with negative free cash flow from heavy capex, and they can now be bought at multiples not seen before. Berkshire Hathaway has bought Google substantially, and Tim says he is leaning that way personally.
“you also have huge disruption for companies such as Google potentially, where their search business could potentially be cut out a little bit by the AI models ... on the flip side of that, well, guess who's producing their own chips? Huge, huge volume now”at 10:28
Apple
Across the shows: 52 speakers in other episodes, 66 bullish and 42 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Apple
Tim Travis · Value Options LetterBearish
Apple is overvalued at current levels despite its brand loyalty.
Apple trades near the highest valuation in its history, above 10 times sales and in the mid-thirties on earnings. The market pays for predictability, since it is hard to tell how AI will disrupt the business, and Apple is a known quantity. Its brand loyalty means people buy the next iPhone whichever AI assistant they use, which is why it trades at such a rich price. Tim still says he doesn't like it at this price and thinks it is overvalued.
“I don't like it at this price. I think it's overvalued in my opinion.”at 17:19
Micron Technology
Across the shows: 22 speakers in other episodes, 22 bullish and 13 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Micron Technology
Tim Travis · Value Options LetterBearish
Memory is commoditised and Micron's margins at current levels are under pressure as competition rises.
If AI demand falls, unused GPUs already sit idle, which means excess supply and falling prices. Micron and SK Hynix can't switch off their factories because fixed costs are so high, so they must keep producing. That makes memory a commoditised product, much like homebuilding, where builders keep building to cover their cost basis. With margins at historically high levels and competition rising for Micron, Tim finds those margins hard to sustain.
“companies like Micron and SK Hynix, they can't turn off their factories because the fixed costs are so high that they have to keep producing, and that's why it's a commoditized product.”at 18:47
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 148 speakers in other episodes, 134 bullish and 111 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Tim Travis · Value Options LetterBearish
NVIDIA's historically high margins look hard to sustain as competition grows and its CUDA moat weakens.
NVIDIA's CUDA software has been a big part of its moat, bundled with top equipment. Tim believes Claude has made inroads in letting different chips work with different software, which chips away at that lock-in. NVIDIA's margins are historically high. If the earnings are where they are, the margins are hard to sustain given increasing competition, which is already happening for NVIDIA and Micron. He is less sure than Tobias on the margin detail, and he hedges that Tobias is better placed to speak to it.
“If you believe the earnings are where they are, the margins are historically high. ... you look at the margins of a NVIDIA or a Micron at these levels and it's hard to imagine that being sustainable when you see increased competition occurring”at 19:34
Space Exploration Technologies
Across the shows: 53 speakers in other episodes, 67 bullish and 25 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Space Exploration Technologies
Tobias Carlisle · Acquirers Funds / The Acquirers PodcastBearish
Investors should avoid SpaceX's IPO; buying after the mania fades will offer a better price.
Tobias's view is that investors should generally avoid IPOs, and SpaceX is an example. It went public at a very high price, and the buying effectively ended with that offering. Momentum buyers then pushed the stock up, but investors who wait for the retracement can get a better entry price after the hype cycle. Tim says the demand for SpaceX's IPO was unlike anything he has seen, but both agree that paying the IPO price is risky.
“you probably don't wanna participate in the IPO. And SpaceX is a great example of one that just recently... It went public at a very, very high price, and then that's basically the end of the buying.”at 22:57
AI bubble & tech valuations
Where everyone stands on AI bubble & tech valuations
Tim Travis · Value Options Letter
A bubble crash in AI is possible, though valuations differ from the 2000 tech bubble.
Warning signs include AI firms that cannot keep up with spending. If fewer data centers are built because of power, permitting or politics, many GPUs will sit idle, and falling demand leads to excess supply and falling prices. Margins in chips are historically high and increasing competition will make them hard to sustain. Tim sees a bubble crash as possible, though the valuations are very different from the tech bubble.
“I mean, I think that you could see, you know, a bubble crash. The valuations are very different than the tech bubble without a doubt.”at 19:25
Tobias Carlisle · Acquirers Funds / The Acquirers Podcast
AI can be world-changing technology and still be a bubble at the same time.
Tobias's historical work shows build-outs often overshoot. Fiber-optic cable was laid faster than it was lit, and it was financed with debt because Wall Street rewarded the cable laid rather than the capacity used. Today all that fiber is used and more is needed, but adoption took a long time to catch up. Tech revolutions follow the Gartner hype cycle: overestimation, overbuild, a trough of disillusionment, and then a more realistic plateau. The trough lies below the plateau, so investors can do better by avoiding the bubble phase and buying after the retracement.
“I think two things can be true at once. I think we can have this world changing technology, and a bubble at the same time.”at 20:59
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Tobias Carlisle · Acquirers Funds / The Acquirers Podcast
Local political resistance to data centers is strong, with voters rejecting new projects.
Political resistance is real. A $5 billion data center planned for a shopping mall car park was dropped after 25,000 signatures were collected. In the recent election, 41 propositions said no to more data centers, and 40 passed. That reflects the mood of the people, even though they say they want more data centers. Tobias finds the cancellation a travesty, since a data center is an inoffensive, air-conditioned room full of computers, not a polluting factory.
“There were 41 propositions in the election saying no to more data centers, and 40 of them got up.”at 33:25
Tim Travis · Value Options Letter
Data centers will still get built despite local opposition, because they make economic sense for localities.
Tim thinks the election result should not be overread. Many people depend on data center jobs near where he lives. Where it makes economic sense for a locality, such as Texas, Louisiana or Oklahoma, data centers will probably still be built. He argues that politicians can be bought and will sell out to special interests, so projects will go ahead. He is willing to bet a lot of money on it.
“But if it makes sense for localities from an economic standpoint, whether it's built in Texas or Louisiana or Oklahoma or whatever, they're probably still gonna get built.”at 34:25
Frontier AI labs & model race
Where everyone stands on Frontier AI labs & model race
Tim Travis · Value Options Letter
AI chatbot products have little competitive moat, which is a big risk for the labs.
Tim sees many similarities among AI products. He points to Meta's Muse, which is becoming more business-focused, and to the general similarity between ChatGPT, Claude and others. It doesn't seem there is a huge competitive moat separating them. Tim thinks this is a big risk.
“It doesn't seem like there's a huge commit... Competitive moat, between between those. So I think that that's a big risk.”at 10:05
AI pricing & unit economics
Where everyone stands on AI pricing & unit economics
Tobias Carlisle · Acquirers Funds / The Acquirers Podcast
AI model makers will capture little of the value created, since free AI keeps prices capped.
In his historical study of tech revolutions, the builders of the new infrastructure captured only about 2% of the value created, and 98% went to consumer surplus. Competition for the same attention (Google, Microsoft, Anthropic, Meta) makes it hard to see how the AI firms earn much profit. Labs such as Anthropic and OpenAI could be the retail layer or supply AI to every business like electricity or the internet. Either way, their pricing is limited, because cheaper or free AI models keep them honest. Only those needing bleeding-edge research must pay the top price.
“that's been one of the historical trends that I observed and I've written about in this paper that's the builders only capture about 2%. The innovators only capture about 2% of the valuation.”at 14:11
Big Tech platforms & digital ads
Where everyone stands on Big Tech platforms & digital ads
Tim Travis · Value Options Letter
AI platforms will monetise their attention, as Amazon's ad business did.
Tim uses Amazon as the analogy. It started by selling books, built scale and ease of use, then steered shoppers with sponsored placements. Its advertising business is now a multi-billion-dollar business with an attractive growth rate. He expects AI firms such as Anthropic, Google and Meta to find ways to monetise their users once they have the eyeballs, including through revenue shares on bookings.
“I'm sure that those companies, you know, once they have the eyeballs, you know, they can figure out ways to monetize that however that may be.”at 15:16
Copper & industrial metals
Where everyone stands on Copper & industrial metals
Tobias Carlisle · Acquirers Funds / The Acquirers Podcast
Copper supply cannot meet data center demand by 2030, as new mines are rare and slow to open.
Copper is used throughout computers, twisted-pair cabling and data center infrastructure. Finding and opening new copper mines is hard, and very few new discoveries have been made; he cites one in Chile, Escondido. By his estimate, eight more mines are needed to meet demand by 2030, which he says is plainly not going to happen.
“Copper's used all the way through computers and and twisted pair. ... we need eight more to sort of meet the demand by 2030, which is just plainly not gonna happen.”at 32:30
Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Where everyone stands on Market sentiment, positioning & volatility
Tim Travis · Value Options Letter
Volatility is now a real factor; the rising volatility cycle likely isn't over, so late 2026 should be eventful.
Tim cites last week's market selloff, when the volatility index rose about 70%, as evidence. Volatility is a major input to option pricing, so the spike generated five or six Value Options trade suggestions across sectors, including tech, real estate and consumer staples. He argues volatility has become a real factor and that the market is probably not past this rising-volatility cycle, so the end of 2026 should be eventful. He hedges with 'I would imagine' and 'probably'.
“But volatility has become a real factor. We're probably not past this rising volatility cycle, I would imagine, and so it should be eventful end of twenty twenty six.”at 39:09
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA148 speakers · 134 bullish, 111 bearish calls
- Alphabet73 speakers · 63 bullish, 48 bearish calls
- Space Exploration Technologies53 speakers · 67 bullish, 25 bearish calls
- Apple52 speakers · 66 bullish, 42 bearish calls
- Microsoft46 speakers · 52 bullish, 10 bearish calls
- Micron Technology22 speakers · 22 bullish, 13 bearish calls
- Adobe3 speakers · 0 bullish, 2 bearish calls
Topics
- AI bubble crash risk
- AI bubble vs transformative technology
- AI disruption to software seats and pricing
- AI erosion of Office
- AI search disruption versus in-house chips
- AI value capture
- IPO pricing and post-listing buying
- chip margins and competitive moat
- competitive moat of AI models
- copper supply
- data center siting and permits
- mega-cap tech valuation
- memory margins
- monetising AI assistant attention
- volatility regime
More from The Acquirers Podcast
- The Quality Growth Playbook for Biotech | David Ferreiro · November 12, 2026
- Why Bill Ackman Loves Uber at 16x Earnings + Our 2 Favorite Cheap Stocks · November 7, 2026
- The Best Business You've Never Heard Of | Todd Wenning · November 5, 2026
- Who Pays for the AI Boom? Big Tech’s Financing Problem · October 31, 2026
- Tim Melvin: Finding Value Where Wall Street Isn’t Looking · October 29, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus