Squawk Pod (CNBC Squawk Box) · · 40 min

DHS Secretary Mullin: We Are Not Under Attack 11/17/26

With James Stavridis, Markwayne Mullin

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin and CNBC's James Stavridis debated whether recent U.S. outages amount to cyberattacks on critical infrastructure. Stavridis pointed to the FAA outage, where one server in El Dorado, Arkansas took down 17 of 25 airport stations within six minutes, and urged a U.S. military cyber force and closer cooperation between banks and Cyber Command, NSA and CIA. Mullin said the homeland is secure, put the odds of a cyber threat at 98% against, and blamed aging equipment of about 50 years old, plus new technology pushed onto legacy systems, for incidents involving Microsoft, Chase and United. The episode also covered counter-drone security, where Mullin described a cat-and-mouse contest ahead of the 2028 Olympics, and Stavridis's views on a possible Trump-Putin meeting and the upcoming Trump-Xi summit.

Key takeaways

  • James Stavridis on Cybersecurity: Recent outages show a building trend and systemic single-point and attack-surface vulnerabilities in critical infrastructure.
  • James Stavridis on US–China relations: Trump and Xi meeting is a good thing; the two largest economies' leaders should talk.
  • James Stavridis on Russia & Ukraine: Trump should meet Putin and be direct, offering a negotiating team and a deal on security guarantees and land.
  • Markwayne Mullin on Cybersecurity: The outages are not cyberattacks; new technology is overwhelming outdated legacy systems, and more disruptions will follow.
  • Markwayne Mullin on Defense: Drone threats are growing, and counter-UAS defenses must keep evolving as adversaries adapt.

What was said, by company and theme

5 views from 2 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Cybersecurity

Where everyone stands on Cybersecurity

  • James Stavridis · The Carlyle Group

    Recent outages show a building trend and systemic single-point and attack-surface vulnerabilities in critical infrastructure.

    Stavridis admits he has no evidence of cyberattacks but sees a building trend in the outages, applying Ian Fleming's rule that a third incident is enemy action. He argues the FAA outage shows immense vulnerability and a single point of failure: one server in El Dorado, Arkansas took down 17 of 25 airport stations within six minutes. He notes roughly 40 to 50 billion internet-connected devices, each a possible entry point, against only 8 billion people, so vulnerability far outpaces defense. He describes two threat streams, internet dependence and AI, that may be crossing. He thinks China is unlikely to be behind it, while North Korea, Iran and Russia are more plausible. His remedies are a US military cyber force, which he calls overdue, and closer public-private cooperation, with banks working with Cyber Command, NSA and CIA.

    “I'm with you. I don't have any evidence of cyberattacks, but, boy, you feel like there's a building trend here.”at 12:24
  • Markwayne Mullin · U.S. Department of Homeland Security

    The outages are not cyberattacks; new technology is overwhelming outdated legacy systems, and more disruptions will follow.

    Mullin says the homeland is secure and no cyber threat is taking place, with near certainty (he says 98%). He attributes the FAA failure to equipment about 50 years old that should have been overhauled long ago. For the Microsoft, Chase and United incidents, he says companies are pushing new technology onto very old computer systems, which overwhelms them. He argues this has nothing to do with cyberattacks and expects more such disruptions as better technology rolls out. He compares it to an iPhone update that takes systems offline for a few minutes. He suggests companies schedule upgrades at off-hours and warn customers. He dismisses Stavridis's view as assumption without facts.

    “I can tell you with complete certainty that we are not under attack. There's no cyber threat that's taking place.”at 24:59

US–China relations

Where everyone stands on US–China relations

  • James Stavridis · The Carlyle Group

    Trump and Xi meeting is a good thing; the two largest economies' leaders should talk.

    Stavridis says controversy over the summit is expected, but the leaders of the two largest economies having a workable personal relationship and willingness to talk is a positive step. He expects them to discuss China's nuclear buildup, whether the trade truce will hold, and whether to begin arms control for AI. He thinks Trump and Xi are the two serious players in the room and that the meeting itself is very good. He sees the Mega Speed and Alice Wong matters as unlikely to come up.

    “we ought to step back and say it's a good thing that the leaders of the two largest economies in the world seem to have a reasonable personal relationship, are willing to sit down and talk.”at 16:22

Russia & Ukraine

Where everyone stands on Russia & Ukraine

  • James Stavridis · The Carlyle Group

    Trump should meet Putin and be direct, offering a negotiating team and a deal on security guarantees and land.

    Stavridis argues Trump should meet Putin despite the question of whether Putin deserves a seat. The meeting should be a declarative one: Trump should say Putin wants to end the war, that a US team can negotiate it, and that there is room to trade on security guarantees and land for peace. Trump should also press Putin firmly on his continuing unacceptable behavior. He frames the meeting as a way to hold a serious negotiation rather than as a blanket endorsement.

    “I think he should meet with Putin and be very declarative with Putin. Hey, Putin. You say you wanna end this war. I've got a team that can negotiate it. We've got some trade space to work out on security guarantees and land for peace.”at 18:56

Defense

Where everyone stands on Defense

  • Markwayne Mullin · U.S. Department of Homeland Security

    Drone threats are growing, and counter-UAS defenses must keep evolving as adversaries adapt.

    Mullin says the threat level has always been high and that drones are a growing problem. DHS is good at hardening sensitive sites with guards and perimeter fences, but drones now fly over those fences. He calls counter-UAS a cat-and-mouse game in which adversaries adapt as defenses improve. He says he has spent much of his time on this and met industry last week. He stresses the need to protect stadium crowds, with the 2028 Olympics approaching.

    “But I will say drones are a growing problem. We see that we're really good at hardening areas around sensitive places where we have security guards and perimeter fences. The new threat today is drones coming over the fences.”at 31:15

Topics

  • Trump–Putin meeting and peace talks
  • Trump–Xi summit diplomacy
  • counter-drone security
  • cyber threat to critical infrastructure

More from Squawk Pod (CNBC Squawk Box)

All Squawk Pod (CNBC Squawk Box) episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus