Prof G Markets · · 32 min
Anthropic’s $1.5 Trillion IPO Is A Trap
With Joost van Dreunen, Paul Kedrosky
ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more
Summary
Paul Kedrosky and Ed Elson debate Anthropic's roughly $1.5 trillion IPO. Kedrosky is bearish: he calls oversubscription engineered by underwriters to draw in retail buyers, expects a first-day pop followed by a 20-30% decline over about six months, values the company at roughly $1-1.2 trillion, and warns that Anthropic's shift from leasing compute to building applications that compete with Microsoft makes revenue less predictable. Kedrosky also argues that Nvidia's circular financing and export-control workarounds through Southeast Asia, and rising costs of capital, put neoclouds under pressure. Elson is bullish on the deal's near-term success, citing about $26 billion of backing from Google, Amazon and Nvidia and a small float, but agrees the pop says little about fundamentals. Separately, Joost van Dreunen expects GTA VI to earn an order of magnitude more than Taylor Swift's tour, while arguing that consolidation, layoffs and AI-generated content are straining the games industry; Elson closes by praising New York's pied-a-terre tax and calling for redistribution.
Key takeaways
- Paul Kedrosky (bearish on Anthropic): Anthropic's heavily touted oversubscription is an engineered signal, and such oversubscribed IPOs tend to underperform over twelve months.
- Ed Elson (bullish on Anthropic): Anthropic's first-day pop looks almost assured because partner investment and a tiny float give structural price support.
- Paul Kedrosky (bearish on Anthropic): Anthropic's shares likely fall 20-30% within six months as true price discovery replaces engineered scarcity; fair value nearer $1-1.2T.
- Joost van Dreunen (bullish on Take-Two Interactive Software): GTA VI will generate about $2 billion in its first days, an unprecedented launch that rivals a Taylor Swift tour.
- Joost van Dreunen on Media, music & entertainment: The games slump stems from overpriced acquisitions, such as Xbox's $70 billion Activision deal, and the resulting headcount cuts.
What was said, by company and theme
12 views from 3 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).
Anthropic
Across the shows: 134 speakers in other episodes, 229 bullish and 111 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Anthropic
Paul Kedrosky · SK VenturesBearish
Anthropic's heavily touted oversubscription is an engineered signal, and such oversubscribed IPOs tend to underperform over twelve months.
Kedrosky argues the repeated leaking of Anthropic's oversubscription is a cynical exercise. Underwriters engineer the price, the allocation and the quantity, so oversubscription says little about the business. Its purpose is to attract retail buyers who can take the shares off the institutions and early-stage holders after listing. Worldwide data across the US, Hong Kong and Europe show that dramatically oversubscribed IPOs tend to underperform badly over the next twelve months, so even on that proxy the stock looks likely to lag. He still expects the deal to succeed in the short term.
“what the data says in terms of really dramatically oversubscribed IPOs is that they actually tend to underperform badly over the next twelve months.”at 5:43
Ed Elson · Prof G MediaBullish
Anthropic's first-day pop looks almost assured because partner investment and a tiny float give structural price support.
Elson argues the IPO is engineered to succeed. About $26 billion of investment is coming from partners including Google, Amazon and Nvidia, which supports the price. The float is only about 5% of the company, against a typical 15-20% for IPOs, so institutional buying can absorb a relatively small number of shares. He expects the stock to be fine and to get its first-day pop, but he thinks that tells us little about the company's fundamentals or what the market really thinks.
“So it seems as though they are setting this up such that it cannot go wrong.”at 6:45
Paul Kedrosky · SK VenturesBearish
Anthropic's shares likely fall 20-30% within six months as true price discovery replaces engineered scarcity; fair value nearer $1-1.2T.
Kedrosky expects a modest pop on the first day, then a SpaceX-style drop of 20-30% over about six months as price discovery takes over from the artificial scarcity of the IPO. He values the company at about ten times its current run rate, which gives roughly $1 to $1.2 trillion. He calls the current price rich even before considering the business transition and loss of distribution he raises elsewhere.
“I also think you'll see a SpaceX like 20 to 30% decline over the next sort of six months as price discovery actually happens”at 8:42
Paul Kedrosky · SK VenturesBearish
Anthropic's shift from leased compute to applications makes revenue far less predictable, and distributors and ex-data sources now compete with it.
Kedrosky says Anthropic is moving from 'Anthropic one', which leased compute and sold model access, to 'Anthropic two', which builds compute and sells applications on top of its models. That transition makes revenue far less predictable than the valuation implies. Over the past eighteen to twenty-four months the company has launched more verticalised products than new frontier models, and those products compete with Microsoft, which distributes its product. Rivals and former customers who now see Anthropic as a competitor are also less willing to share data, which he says makes the transition harder to pull off.
“they're in this rapid transition from Anthropic one to Anthropic two. Anthropic one largely leased compute and sold access to models. Anthropic two is building compute and is selling applications that sit on models.”at 9:21
NVIDIA
Across the shows: 174 speakers in other episodes, 184 bullish and 163 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on NVIDIA
Paul Kedrosky · SK VenturesBearish
Nvidia's Jensen Huang's conduct, including China compute via Southeast Asia, is indefensible and he cannot return as CEO.
Kedrosky argues Nvidia's conduct undermines board governance. Huang led an investigation the board had already decided was worth pursuing, and he resigned rather than take part. Kedrosky says Huang openly defended providing compute to China, using Southeast Asian clouds and data centers as regulatory arbitrage. Reporting suggests around half of this year's revenue now runs through a Singapore subsidiary, and Kedrosky says Huang wrapped the strategy in nationalism while serving his own company. He calls the approach aggressive and says Nvidia's interests were not definitionally America's.
“But the point is there were things going on where he was essentially wrapping himself in the flag of nationalism and saying, this is good for The US, and it's also good for me.”at 15:31
Take-Two Interactive Software
Across the shows: 4 speakers in other episodes, 10 bullish and 1 bearish calls, past 30 days
Where everyone stands on Take-Two Interactive Software
Joost van Dreunen · NYU Stern School of BusinessBullish
GTA VI will generate about $2 billion in its first days, an unprecedented launch that rivals a Taylor Swift tour.
van Dreunen compares GTA VI with Taylor Swift's biggest tour, which earned about $2 billion over two years. He expects GTA VI to match that by Monday, an order of magnitude that he says would make even Swifties weep. He ties the scale to the franchise's cultural weight, its story of the American dream, and its open-world freedom. Preorders have already reached an estimated $1.5 billion, and the console and PC demand supports the forecast.
“GTA six is set to make $2,000,000,000 by Monday. So it's an order of magnitude that makes even Swifties weep.”at 20:12
Media, music & entertainment
Where everyone stands on Media, music & entertainment
Joost van Dreunen · NYU Stern School of Business
The games slump stems from overpriced acquisitions, such as Xbox's $70 billion Activision deal, and the resulting headcount cuts.
van Dreunen says the video game industry has struggled since the pandemic. Cheap money led large companies to buy smaller studios, and then to overextend. Xbox paid $70 billion for Activision Blizzard, which he says did not work out as expected. Large empires lose track of quality control, so they produce mediocre hits that generate little return. Investors then grow suspicious, and the response is to cut talent, which is the most expensive input. Demand has fallen while headcount has been cut to match it.
“The slump really comes from an overexertion of acquisitions. Large companies started buying other smaller subsidiaries.”at 22:46
Joost van Dreunen · NYU Stern School of Business
Gaming will expand beyond play into multimedia, with films, theme parks and TV series built on game franchises.
van Dreunen describes gaming moving from two-dimensional, single-player products to multiplayer, three-dimensional worlds, and now to multimedia. Nintendo earns money from films and theme parks built around its games. Players are increasingly invited to create in-game assets they can share and monetise. Platforms such as Xbox, Netflix and Amazon want to make TV series and new ways to engage audiences. He sees this as the beginning of what comes next for the industry.
“As I see it is that gaming will be more than just play. ... The next era seems to be more multimedia in nature.”at 25:48
AI infrastructure & data centers
Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers
Paul Kedrosky · SK Ventures
Tightening capital costs hit neocloud compute providers hardest, since they already have the most expensive financing and are marginal compute suppliers.
Kedrosky describes Nvidia as the central bank of AI, using GPUs as currency and extending credit with no payment terms in a circular financing cycle. Nvidia's CEO-in-waiting said on the earnings call that it would be more discriminating with neoclouds, and Kedrosky reads that as a tightening cycle. Cost of capital has risen, so a plan that assumed a 10% hurdle now costs about 30% more. Neoclouds are the most exposed because they are the marginal providers of compute and already pay the highest cost of capital.
“There's the group most at risk, and they are both the marginal providers of compute as well as already having the most expensive cost of capital, and it just got more expensive.”at 13:33
Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Where everyone stands on Enterprise AI adoption & AI software
Joost van Dreunen · NYU Stern School of Business
AI will massively disrupt games development; platform makers are pushing it to cut costs, and the output is mostly unwanted 'AI slop'.
van Dreunen says the games industry is highly exposed to AI and that AI will disrupt it significantly. Epic Games, Unity and others push AI to offset development costs and claim it democratises game making. He thinks that is partly fair, but he says it mainly produces 'AI slop' that creators and consumers are skeptical of, and that nobody asked for it. AI is a further headwind on top of the layoffs and cutbacks already under way, and the right formula has not yet been found.
“it very much creates what they call AI slop across platforms. Both creators and consumers are very skeptical of what this will bring them.”at 24:26
US state & local policy
Where everyone stands on US state & local policy
Ed Elson · Prof G Media
New York's pied-a-terre tax is precise, fair and effective: it raised $500 million and taxes non-resident owners who already left.
Elson argues that critics who said wealthy New Yorkers would leave overlooked that the tax targets second homes, mostly owned by non-residents who already live in other states or countries and do not pay New York income tax. In a few months the surcharge on second homes worth over $5 million raised more than $500 million. That money helps fund roads, bridges, hospitals and police, and is nearly enough to cover a year of school lunches for every New York City child. He calls it a model for other tax policy.
“In other words, this is exactly the kind of tax policy that we need. A reasonable, precise piece of legislation that redistributes wealth from those who are already very wealthy and who are not contributing”at 28:37
Wealth, inequality & billionaires
Where everyone stands on Wealth, inequality & billionaires
Ed Elson · Prof G Media
US wealth inequality is untenable and must be redistributed, with the top 1% holding more wealth than the middle class.
Elson cites the top 1% now controlling more wealth than the entire middle class, and a wealth Gini coefficient of about 0.83, equal to pre-revolutionary France. From this he concludes that inequality in America is no longer acceptable and redistribution is needed. He says redistribution must be substantive, effective and fair, and he holds up the pied-a-terre tax as a model of what works.
“inequality in America is untenable. The top 1% now control more wealth than the entire middle class.”at 29:49
Across the shows
What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.
- NVIDIA174 speakers · 184 bullish, 163 bearish calls
- Anthropic134 speakers · 229 bullish, 111 bearish calls
- Take-Two Interactive Software4 speakers · 10 bullish, 1 bearish calls
Topics
- AI in game development
- IPO aftermarket price path
- IPO first-day pricing
- IPO oversubscription
- business model transition
- export control evasion
- gaming as multimedia franchise
- neocloud financing costs
- pied-a-terre tax
- video game industry consolidation
- video game launch sales
- wealth inequality
More from Prof G Markets
- Nvidia Is Better Off Without Jensen Huang · November 18, 2026
- Could Jensen Huang Actually Return To Nvidia? · November 17, 2026
- Nvidia’s $2 Trillion Scandal Is About To Get Much Bigger · November 16, 2026
- Here’s What It Will Really Take To Fix America’s Economy — ft. Kathryn Anne Edwards · November 13, 2026
- The Trillion-Dollar Cover-Up: What Washington Knew About Jensen Huang · November 12, 2026
Ask your AI about this episode
Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.
Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus