Prof G Markets · · 42 min

Could Jensen Huang Actually Return To Nvidia?

With Deirdre Bosa, Rohan Goswami

Summary

The hosts discuss whether Jensen Huang could return to Nvidia after his resignation as CEO, which followed a board ultimatum and reporting on personal conduct and possible export-control violations. Rohan Goswami expects Huang to raise capital for a new venture rather than return to Nvidia, and sees Colette Kress, a CFO without a visionary founder's profile, as a shaky interim leader given the DOJ probes and Nvidia's role as financier to AI labs such as OpenAI and Anthropic. Deirdre Bosa argues a return is plausible in Silicon Valley terms but would be very hard if Huang broke the law on China chip sales, and that Nvidia's roadmap should keep it performing for one to two years even as a successor may struggle to match its annual release cadence. Ed Elson frames the affair as a governance failure, citing a flattery-driven culture and absent succession planning, and argues Huang should not lead Nvidia. The panel also debates US export controls, with Bosa warning that restricting chips pushes China toward its own stack, and touches on AI lab concentration and neocloud financing discipline.

Key takeaways

  • Rohan Goswami (neutral on NVIDIA): Jensen Huang will not return as Nvidia CEO; the board's decision is effectively final.
  • Deirdre Bosa (bullish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's chip roadmap is set for the next one to two years, but longer-term leadership depends on the next CEO.
  • Rohan Goswami (bearish on NVIDIA): Nvidia's financing of AI startups was financially untenable, creating a circular web that now leaves markets uneasy.
  • Deirdre Bosa (bearish on NVIDIA): Losing Huang is Nvidia's biggest risk, since he drove an annual chip cadence and bet on GPUs over CPUs.
  • Ed Elson (uncertain on NVIDIA): Jensen Huang's China dealings show bad judgment; he should not remain Nvidia CEO.

What was said, by company and theme

16 views from 3 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

NVIDIA

Across the shows: 155 speakers in other episodes, 150 bullish and 122 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on NVIDIA

  • Rohan Goswami · SemaforNeutral

    Jensen Huang will not return as Nvidia CEO; the board's decision is effectively final.

    The board deliberated for hours and gave Huang an ultimatum to resign or be fired. Directors who have known him for three decades set a very high bar for reversing that, and they will not undo the decision to put Colette Kress in charge regardless of outside pressure. Huang has acknowledged one affair and there is reporting on two others. Rohan expects Huang to raise and contribute around $50 billion for a new venture and eventually return to building, but not at Nvidia.

    “Is he actually gonna return? Absolutely not, Ed.”at 4:19
  • Deirdre Bosa · Deirdre Bosa LiveUncertain

    Huang's return is plausible, not certain; unresolved legal questions would make it very difficult.

    Huang resigned rather than being removed by the board, which some people in the Valley think opens a path back. Silicon Valley's influence is large, and Sam Altman returned to OpenAI within days of being ousted, so a return is plausible in tech circles. Some argue his return would help shareholders, but she sees a long way to go. If he is found to have broken the law by getting Nvidia GPUs into China, she thinks it would be very difficult for him to return. The other affairs are governance issues, not as serious as breaking the law.

    “Jensen Huang was not kicked out of his CEO position by the board. He resigned, and some people around here believe that that maybe does open the way for him to come back.”at 5:17
  • Rohan Goswami · SemaforBearish

    Nvidia's fight against chip tracking and end-user rules suggests it knew its chips could reach China.

    Earlier this year Nvidia, through general counsel Tim Teeter, fiercely opposed three Commerce rules: destroying advanced chips at end of life, geolocation or tracking functionality, and certification of cloud customers' end users. He argues a company would only oppose such measures if it knew its chips might end up in China or elsewhere they were not supposed to go. The DOJ probes into Megaspeed and Super Micro ensnare Nvidia because its products are at issue, and the question of what the company knew and when is now central. Nvidia and Huang are not currently criminal subjects, but secondary charges are possible.

    “NVIDIA fought on all of those points... you would not be opposed to those measures unless ultimately on some level, you knew that your chips might be ending up in China or somewhere they weren't going to.”at 14:19
  • Deirdre Bosa · Deirdre Bosa LiveBullish

    Nvidia's chip roadmap is set for the next one to two years, but longer-term leadership depends on the next CEO.

    The roadmap was laid out years in advance, so the company is likely to keep performing well over the next one to two years. Beyond that, the question is much bigger, because Nvidia has stayed at the frontier by releasing a new chip every year, which made it the most valuable company in the world. She doubts a successor can keep that pace, and notes that Huang's paranoia about competitors such as Google TPUs, Amazon Trainium and OpenAI's chip efforts kept the company ahead.

    “this road map has been laid out years in advance. So it is likely to continue to do very well in that sort of one to two year road map. Beyond that is a much bigger question.”at 21:55
  • Rohan Goswami · SemaforBearish

    Interim CEO Colette Kress is set up to fail, much as Lehman's CFO was before the bank collapsed.

    Kress is a steady, well-known figure on the Street, and the product roadmap is set. But she is a CFO taking over without being the founder or visionary, and must reassure customers, vendors and suppliers while the Wachtell probe runs. He compares her to Erin Callan, Lehman's CFO, who did well on a reassurance earnings call, yet the bank was bankrupt within a few quarters. He adds that the company's engineering talent and customer confidence now depend on whoever takes over, and that the new leader must solve the customer, government and chip-leadership problems.

    “And in many ways, she's doomed to fail.”at 23:13
  • Rohan Goswami · SemaforBearish

    Nvidia's financing of AI startups was financially untenable, creating a circular web that now leaves markets uneasy.

    Nvidia was effectively the bank for AI companies like OpenAI and Anthropic, paying for much of their growth. Reporting from the Times and the Journal, which he says he can partly confirm, shows a deep conflict between Colette Kress and Huang and his future son-in-law Nico over how much to spend financing these startups. The result is a tangled, circular web. Without Huang, markets are unsure whether his successor will have both the desire and investor respect to keep writing massive checks.

    “They were the bank. They were paying for everything, and it was financially untenable.”at 25:05
  • Rohan Goswami · SemaforNeutral

    Nvidia's quarterly numbers barely matter; Colette Kress's call and demeanor matter more than the print.

    Demand for Nvidia's chips is insatiable, so the print is likely to be strong, but the numbers were largely known and are not the story. The market will watch how Kress handles questions about the probes, the customer base and the company's direction. Investors want reassurance from the interim CEO more than another quarter of numbers.

    “The numbers actually don't matter at all. ... We know that demand for their chips is insatiable, but it'll be the call Colette's demeanor.”at 30:01
  • Deirdre Bosa · Deirdre Bosa LiveBearish

    Losing Huang is Nvidia's biggest risk, since he drove an annual chip cadence and bet on GPUs over CPUs.

    Huang was able to iterate and release a new chip every year, and he believed in GPUs when the rest of the chip industry was focused on CPUs. Without him, the company's pace of innovation and its strategic bets are the main risk to the stock. She adds that the bigger risk is that the controversy accelerates China's drive to compete in AI, since China is already cut off from Nvidia's most advanced chips.

    “This is a man who was just able to iterate, create a new chip every single year, who believed in GPUs when the rest of the chip industry was all about CPUs. So that is the risk here.”at 34:50
  • Ed Elson · Prof G MediaUncertain

    Jensen Huang's China dealings show bad judgment; he should not remain Nvidia CEO.

    Ed argues Huang's conduct is a governance problem. He cites a relationship with a former Chinese state media TV reporter who became CEO of a Singaporean shell company turned compute provider, which then bought billions of dollars of ships for offices that turned out to be empty. He notes that violating US export law can carry up to 20 years in prison, though he stresses no guilt has been proven. He concludes that the pattern shows unfathomably bad judgment, and that Huang should not be CEO of Nvidia. He does not give a price view on the stock.

    “Well, then it would demonstrate what I think many would call unfathomably bad judgment. So, no, in my view, he should not be CEO.”at 38:12
  • Ed Elson · Prof G MediaBearish

    Nvidia's deferential, concentrated leadership makes its CEO likely to double down on mistakes, hurting shareholders.

    Ed cites a 2011 University of Michigan study of nearly 600 CEOs, the 'Icarus Paradox', which found that less pushback from subordinates led CEOs to rate their own judgment higher and to be less likely to change course after wrong decisions. He applies this to Nvidia: Huang has no board chair, no chief operating officer and no succession plan, has around 60 direct reports, and works in a culture his biographer described as having little tolerance for disagreement. He argues this flattery-driven culture explains the mistakes. Because every S&P 500 holder owns Nvidia, he says the cost of those mistakes falls on shareholders as well.

    “Put another way, they didn't just make mistakes. They doubled down on their mistakes. That was the price of excessive flattery, and it explains pretty much everything about the downfall of Jensen Huang.”at 39:12

US–China AI & chip race

Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race

  • Deirdre Bosa · Deirdre Bosa Live

    Restricting chip exports pushes China to build its own stack and export it; Huang's advocacy for competing on innovation matters.

    She strongly disagrees with the argument that tighter export controls help America. Without Huang arguing for competing on innovation rather than restricting technology overseas, she expects China to build its own AI chip stack and export it to Africa, Europe and other markets. She compares this to the Great Firewall, which pushed China to create its own internet giants. China's ban on Nvidia chips is creating homegrown demand that will make domestic chips better, since demand is the most effective way to improve. Selling lesser-generation chips to China keeps it on the American stack, which is good for American tech, though that argument is harder to make given the Huang revelations.

    “If Jensen is not in Washington arguing that we, America, should be competing on innovation versus restricting our technology overseas, that's gonna lead in the long term to China building its own stack and exporting that to other countries.”at 10:27
  • Rohan Goswami · Semafor

    Chip export fight has split the Trump administration more than any other issue, including immigration and elections.

    Marco Rubio, a longtime China hawk, is on one side and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick is closer to a big-tent approach to chip exports. Rubio was the author of the memo the Times reported, which catalyzed the storyline. He says this is politics as usual, a turf fight between two powerful figures using their camps to advance agendas, not a deep-state plot. Huang has been caught in the crossfire of that DC fight.

    “And this has really riven the administration in a way that no other issue has, not immigration, not the elections. This has become the seminal issue.”at 11:18
  • Rohan Goswami · Semafor

    US firms that partnered with China in the 1980s and 1990s ended up harmed by espionage and IP theft.

    He answers the dovish view that letting China build on the American stack is good for America. American companies entered China in the late 1980s and early 1990s seeing a fertile market, partnered with Chinese firms, and in many cases found that engagement became the harbinger of their own doom through industrial espionage and IP theft. He notes that chips are fast-moving, which makes the risk sharper, and cites the same pattern as a warning.

    “The contrary is we've seen this story play out before in the late eighties, early nineties as American companies came into China... what many American companies have found to varying degrees is that in the end, it became sort of the harbinger of their own doom.”at 16:09

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Rohan Goswami · Semafor

    AI infrastructure is hitting a rightsizing moment, between Huang's outsized bets and risk-off investors.

    He sees a middle path between Huang's outsized bets on the industry and the very risk-off approach some investors have taken. The moment may force the industry to adopt financial discipline, realistic capex forecasts and attention to investment-grade ratings. He frames the current volatility as a reckoning that could help the industry grow up, while acknowledging that this is only a maybe.

    “what we're looking at is sort of a rightsizing or a reckoning moment for this industry.”at 28:21
  • Deirdre Bosa · Deirdre Bosa Live

    Neoclouds are becoming more financially disciplined, taking more prepayments, so the AI trade can absorb the shake-up.

    She cites the latest CoreWeave and Nebius quarters, which show more customer prepayments. Neoclouds have already been adjusting their businesses, likely because of volatility in bond markets over recent months. The AI trade will be shaken, but neoclouds are becoming more disciplined and other players may pick up the slack.

    “I'm not saying it's over. I actually think that the [neo] clouds have done a pretty good job. I mean, if you look at the latest CoreWeave and Nebius quarters, they are getting more in prepayments.”at 28:48

Frontier AI labs & model race

Where everyone stands on Frontier AI labs & model race

  • Deirdre Bosa · Deirdre Bosa Live

    Without Huang, the AI industry risks being controlled by just Anthropic and OpenAI; many labs are needed.

    Huang strongly believed there should be many different labs, and was as big an advocate of that as he was against export controls. Anthropic is set to go public, which will consolidate capital, and the balance of power in AI could tilt toward two frontier labs controlling everything. With Huang gone, no one is arguing for the open-source world, which she sees as the key counterweight.

    “He really believed that there should be many different labs. ... that you shouldn't just have two frontier labs, Anthropic and OpenAI, controlling everything.”at 24:37

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • NVIDIA155 speakers · 150 bullish, 122 bearish calls

Topics

  • AI industry financial discipline
  • CEO leadership and governance risk
  • CEO succession
  • US tech engagement with China
  • chip roadmap and product cadence
  • earnings call and guidance
  • export control compliance and legal exposure
  • export control policy in Washington
  • export controls
  • export-control compliance and China ties
  • frontier lab concentration
  • neocloud financing
  • post-Huang leadership
  • vendor financing of AI customers

More from Prof G Markets

All Prof G Markets episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus