Bloomberg Talks · · 11 min

Elizabeth Economy Talks APEC Summit

With Elizabeth Economy

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

Elizabeth Economy assesses the APEC summit mainly in terms of optics and great-power standing, arguing it lent legitimacy to Vladimir Putin and reinforced China's position as a coequal of the US, and she reads Trump's claims of historic importance as image-driven rather than substantive. She argues US China policy shows more continuity from Trump's first term through Biden to his second than Trump's warm rhetoric toward Xi Jinping suggests, so policy should be judged by actions on Indo-Pacific security and trade and technology competition. She expects a possible pullback from any G2 framing and a renewed focus on traditional allies, while warning that European allies, who see the relationship as one of interests rather than trust, will require substantial work to restore, and that the administration has treated Asian partners more kindly than European ones. She also flags the South China Sea dispute, where the Philippines' strengthened US, Japan and Australia ties form a defense network meant to constrain Chinese assertiveness.

Key takeaways

  • Elizabeth Economy on US–China relations: The Trump-Xi-Putin summit legitimized Putin and elevated China to coequal great-power standing with the US.
  • Elizabeth Economy on US–China relations: US China policy has been more continuous across Trump, Biden and Trump than his rhetoric suggests; China remains the top challenge.
  • Elizabeth Economy on US global standing & alliances: The next US president will likely drop the G2 framing and refocus on traditional allies.
  • Elizabeth Economy on US global standing & alliances: Europe's alliance with the US can be rebuilt, but it will take a lot of work and new trust.
  • Elizabeth Economy on US–China relations: US security ties with the Philippines have accelerated, forming a network that constrains China in the South China Sea.

What was said, by company and theme

6 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

US–China relations

Where everyone stands on US–China relations

  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    The Trump-Xi-Putin summit legitimized Putin and elevated China to coequal great-power standing with the US.

    Economy judges the summit mainly on optics and standing rather than substance. She argues it legitimized Vladimir Putin in a way he has not been since invading Ukraine. She also argues it reinforced the idea that China is coequal with the US as one of two great powers. She reads Trump's claim of historic importance as an attempt to appear to 'play with the big boys', not as a substantive breakthrough.

    “It legitimized Putin, frankly, in a way that he hasn't been since he invaded Ukraine. It reinforced the notion that China is coequal with The United States in terms of its standing as one of the two great powers.”at 3:08
  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    US China policy has been more continuous across Trump, Biden and Trump than his rhetoric suggests; China remains the top challenge.

    Economy argues that US China policy shows much more continuity from Trump's first term through Biden to Trump's second term than Trump's statements imply. Looking past his rhetoric of affection for Xi Jinping, she points to the administration's actions on Indo-Pacific security and on trade and technology competition. Those actions still treat China as the US's greatest long-term strategic challenge. She advises judging policy by what the administration does rather than what Trump says.

    “there's a lot more continuity in our policy from Trump one to Biden to Trump two than I think we often see based on president Trump's statements... We've continued to maintain sort of the sensibility that China is our greatest long term strategic challenge.”at 4:04
  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    US security ties with the Philippines have accelerated, forming a network that constrains China in the South China Sea.

    Economy describes a sustained South China Sea dispute. The Philippines claims exclusive waters against China's nine-dash line, which covers most of the sea. An international court ruled for the Philippines, but China refuses to recognize it. She says the US-Philippines security relationship has grown more robust since the Biden administration and accelerated under Trump. The Philippines' ties with Japan and Australia form a network of new defense relationships designed to support Manila and constrain Chinese assertiveness.

    “The United States and The Philippines have developed an increasingly robust security relationship... the Trump administration, it's only accelerated. ...there's been this network sort of of new defense relationships that are basically designed to support The Philippines and constrain China's aggression”at 8:32

US global standing & alliances

Where everyone stands on US global standing & alliances

  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    The next US president will likely drop the G2 framing and refocus on traditional allies.

    Economy expects a step back from Trump's apparent push toward a theoretical G2 with China, and a return to greater focus on traditional allies and partners. Her basis is the direction she sees moderate Democrats and moderate Republicans pushing in Congress. She presents this as a guess about the next administration rather than a settled outcome.

    “for the next president of The United States, my guess would be that there would be a step back from this effort to promote sort of a at least theoretical notion of a G2 that President Trump seems to desire, and a return to greater focus on our traditional allies and partners.”at 4:49
  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    Europe's alliance with the US can be rebuilt, but it will take a lot of work and new trust.

    Economy reports from a recent trip to Hungary, China and Japan that Europeans repeatedly say they will never go back to the old relationship. She expects a new form of relationship that needs fresh trust. Europeans describe the relationship as one of interests rather than trust, so shared interests must be found. She is less pessimistic than some Europeans and thinks a robust transatlantic alliance can be restored, but only with substantial work.

    “For the Europeans, their constant refrain is We are never going to go back... And so it will have to be a new form of a relationship. There will have to be some new trust built up... I do think that we can find our way back to a really robust transatlantic alliance, but it's going take a lot of work.”at 5:37
  • Elizabeth Economy · Hoover Institution, Stanford University

    The Trump administration has treated Asian allies far more kindly than European ones.

    Economy contrasts Asian and European views of the Trump administration. Asian allies saw Trump's return as something they had experienced before and expected to wait out, so they flattered him with gifts. She argues the administration has been much kinder to Asian allies and partners than to European ones, which makes the transatlantic relationship harder to repair than the Asian one.

    “this administration has been much kinder to our Asian allies and partners than they have been to our European ones.”at 6:29

Topics

  • Asian allies versus European allies under Trump
  • China policy continuity across administrations
  • G2 framing and return to traditional allies
  • South China Sea and Philippines security
  • summit diplomacy and great-power standing
  • transatlantic alliance rebuilding

More from Bloomberg Talks

All Bloomberg Talks episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus