Bloomberg Talks · · 9 min

NYC Comptroller Mark Levine Talks Anthropic IPO

With Mark Levine

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

NYC Comptroller Mark Levine argues that Anthropic's planned IPO is a poor fit for public shareholders, contrasting the company's own warnings about catastrophic AI risk and calls to pace frontier development with the growth and profitability pressure a public listing brings. He says the governance structure, with founder control and a long-term benefit trust that founders appoint, follows the model of SpaceX, Meta and partly Nvidia, leaving public holders with few avenues for activism, made harder by the SEC pulling back and a proposed change to Rule 14a-8. Levine also objects to fast passive index inclusion, noting his fund tracks the Russell 3000 and was refused a seasoning period for SpaceX, so he expects Anthropic to enter the index within weeks with no time to assess volatility or insider sales. He concludes that institutional investors should press Anthropic on how independent safety evaluations are run, whether results will be shared, and how safety-business conflicts are resolved, since he says no satisfactory answers exist yet.

Key takeaways

  • Mark Levine (bearish on Anthropic): Anthropic's IPO contradicts its own warnings; growth pressure will weigh against its safety work.
  • Mark Levine (bearish on Anthropic): Anthropic's governance, with founder-appointed trust control, leaves public shareholders with little power.
  • Mark Levine on AI regulation & safety: AI poses real risk of going rogue, harm and malicious use, and recent safety incidents show it.
  • Mark Levine (bearish on Anthropic): Fast Russell 3000 inclusion of Anthropic, without a seasoning period, brings volatility and insider-sale risk.

What was said, by company and theme

4 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Anthropic

Across the shows: 129 speakers in other episodes, 204 bullish and 98 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Anthropic

  • Mark Levine · New York City Office of the ComptrollerBearish

    Anthropic's IPO contradicts its own warnings; growth pressure will weigh against its safety work.

    Levine argues Anthropic has acknowledged its technology could lead to catastrophic risk and has itself called for pacing the frontier, so taking the company public is a contradiction. The IPO raises capital to accelerate development and adds pressure for growth and profitability, which will weigh against safety work. He says shareholders are being asked to take on this risk without adequate transparency or accountability. His fund expects to become a major shareholder through indexing, and he wants to know how third-party safety evaluations are run, whether they are independent, whether results will be shared, and how conflicts between safety and business teams are resolved. He says he does not think there is an answer yet.

    “And we have a company that acknowledges their technology could lead to catastrophic risk. And they themselves have called for pacing the frontier. So now it is kind of a contradiction that this very company is going public now”at 2:11
  • Mark Levine · New York City Office of the ComptrollerBearish

    Anthropic's governance, with founder-appointed trust control, leaves public shareholders with little power.

    Levine says the governance structure follows traditions seen at SpaceX, Meta and to some extent Nvidia, which he says disempower public shareholders. Founders keep much of the power, and through the long-term benefit trust, which the founders appoint, public shareholders lack the normal avenues for activism. He adds that the SEC has been pulling back from its role as a neutral referee between shareholders and managers, and a proposed change to Rule 14a-8 would make it very difficult, if not impossible, for shareholders to file resolutions. Despite this, his fund plans to be vocal, work with like-minded institutions and push for transparency and good safety protocols.

    “Unfortunately, the governance structure here continuing traditions that we've seen now in SpaceX and Meta and to some extent Nvidia, really disempowers public shareholders. They keep so much power with the founders”at 2:35
  • Mark Levine · New York City Office of the ComptrollerBearish

    Fast Russell 3000 inclusion of Anthropic, without a seasoning period, brings volatility and insider-sale risk.

    Levine's fund passively tracks the Russell 3000, which is owned by the London Stock Exchange. His fund asked for a seasoning period before SpaceX was added, but was refused, and he worried that would set a precedent. He expects Anthropic to be added to the index within weeks, leaving no time to watch for volatility or for insider sales. The argument is that rapid passive index inclusion forces index holders such as his fund to take on the IPO's near-term trading and insider-selling risks before there is any seasoning.

    “We worried that would set a precedent and it did. So it looks like this is going to be brought in that Anthropic will be brought into the Russell three thousand in a matter of weeks. No time to watch for volatility, to watch for insider sales.”at 5:34

AI regulation & safety

Where everyone stands on AI regulation & safety

  • Mark Levine · New York City Office of the Comptroller

    AI poses real risk of going rogue, harm and malicious use, and recent safety incidents show it.

    Levine says there have been months of serious AI safety incidents and a week of disruptions, some of which are undoubtedly AI-connected. He argues that the risk that AI could go rogue, cause harm or be used by malicious actors is no longer debatable. He presents this as the reason institutional shareholders must scrutinise AI companies' safety protocols before backing their IPOs.

    “And there is absolutely risk that AI could go rogue, that it could do harm, that it could be used by malicious actors. I don't think anyone can debate that anymore.”at 4:21

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • Anthropic129 speakers · 204 bullish, 98 bearish calls

Ask your AI who they are and what they said

Topics

  • AI safety governance
  • AI safety risk
  • IPO governance and shareholder rights
  • index inclusion of new IPOs

More from Bloomberg Talks

All Bloomberg Talks episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus