We Study Billionaires · · 1h 21m

TIP862: Apple (AAPL): Is Apple Priced for a Massive Drawdown? w/ Daniel Mahncke & Shawn O'Malley

With Daniel Mahncke

ChorusBring the market's conversation to your AI. Learn more

Summary

Hosts Shawn O'Malley and Daniel Mahncke debate whether Apple (AAPL) is priced for a major drawdown. The bear case centres on App Store commission erosion from the Epic ruling and European and Japanese regulation, a stalled services growth rate, Apple's thin AI effort and talent losses, reliance on Google's Gemini, TSMC 3nm capacity constraints and memory-cost pressure, and a valuation near 40x earnings with buybacks yielding under 3% free cash flow. The bull case rests on Apple's pricing power on the iPhone, a services mix lifting margins, low hyperscaler-style capex exposure, a loyal ecosystem, and the possibility of AI-driven App Store and default-assistant revenue. Both hosts agree the business is excellent but conclude the stock is too expensive; Daniel would buy near $250 fair value or ~$200, and Shawn would be interested near $200, so neither owns it at current prices.

Key takeaways

  • Daniel Mahncke (bullish on Apple): Apple's minimal AI capex makes it a hedge against worries about AI spending.
  • Daniel Mahncke (bullish on Meta Platforms): Meta's glasses are gaining traction, and AI could finally tie its ecosystem together.
  • Shawn O'Malley (bearish on Apple): Apple's App Store take rate is falling toward 15% from 30%, already slowing services growth.
  • Daniel Mahncke (bearish on Apple): Apple's fair value is about $250 at a mid-twenties multiple; overvalued near 40x earnings.
  • Shawn O'Malley (bearish on Apple): Apple is overvalued at this price; Shawn would pass but would buy near $200.

What was said, by company and theme

44 views from 2 speakers. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Apple

Across the shows: 50 speakers in other episodes, 63 bullish and 41 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Apple

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple's minimal AI capex makes it a hedge against worries about AI spending.

    Apple spends only about $13B a year on capex, while Amazon spends about $220B this year and Microsoft, Alphabet and Meta each spend roughly $130-190B annually. Wall Street estimates the four hyperscalers will spend more over the next four years than Apple's entire roughly $5T market cap. Apple is not building AI data centers, so rising market worry about AI spending has pushed investors toward it as a hedge. Daniel adds that the midterm-driven pushback on data centers matters little for Apple for the same reason.

    “I mean, a huge part of that seems to be the market increasingly being worried about AI spending. And as you said, Apple was sort of a hedge against that in a way.”at 6:30
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Meta's glasses push makes Meta a bigger competitive risk to Apple than ever before.

    Apple canceled the second Vision Pro, a VR headset, and does not expect to ship glasses before at least late 2027. Meta's glasses are gaining traction as a smartphone alternative, and if AI ties Meta's ecosystem together, Meta becomes a stronger rival to Apple's device ecosystem. The argument depends on Meta's ecosystem actually coming together, which Daniel says is not yet given.

    “And that would also mean that Meta is a much bigger risk for Apple now than it ever has been in the past.”at 8:01
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple has barely raised iPhone prices in real terms, leaving pricing power unused.

    Adjusted for inflation, the iPhone 17 Pro at about $1,100 is roughly $890 in 2020 dollars, which is cheaper than the $999 Pro sold in 2020. Apple's iPhone revenue grew from $155B in 2015 to $210B last year mainly through volume and mix, not meaningful price increases. Demand at the top end is strong: a roughly $2,000 model reportedly sold out in pre-orders within thirty minutes. Apple has pricing power it is not using, though it has started raising prices mid-cycle because of rising memory costs, which is the first time it has done so.

    “Apple didn't take much price with its iPhone. So this is primarily an inflation adjustment at best, and they're not using the pricing power they undoubtedly have to sort of gouge the customer.”at 11:57
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Services mix shift, not hardware, drove most of Apple's margin expansion under Tim Cook.

    Services rose from about 11% of Apple's revenue in 2016 to 26% today. Services carry mid-70s gross margins against high-30s for hardware, and services now generate over 40% of gross profit. Daniel says this mix shift lifted overall margins by almost 10 percentage points, the biggest driver of the stock's roughly twentyfold rise under Cook. Buybacks of about $850B and a rising multiple added to this, but the margin mix was the main engine.

    “...taking services from 11% of revenue ... to 26% today, and that caused the overall margins to increase by almost 10 percentage points and was by far the biggest impact.”at 12:29
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple's innovation has faded; AirPods are its last successful new product, a decade ago.

    Daniel says Cook did a phenomenal job managing Apple as a mature company, but its innovative power has declined significantly. AirPods are the last new and successful product, launched about ten years ago. Compared with Meta's glasses, the Vision Pro did not make a big enough impact. Revenue grew about fourfold and profits more under Cook, but the lack of new hardware hits prospects beyond the current cycle.

    “I would say that Apple's innovative power arguably has significantly declined. So the last new and successful product, I would say, have been the AirPods, and that was ten years ago.”at 16:11
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple's ecosystem lock-in is very sticky, with nearly 90% of iPhone buyers replacing older phones.

    Apple's ecosystem lets users sync devices, photos and files seamlessly, and users tend to stay. Daniel reads that close to 90% of last year's iPhone buyers were replacing an existing iPhone, which suggests a very loyal base. Old iPhones also feed the ecosystem: they get passed to family, and new users then buy wearables and App Store content. Meta and Google reach users through other companies' phones, which Apple does not face. Daniel's evidence is partly anecdotal, but he says he knows no one who has switched from iPhone back to Android.

    “And that customer base is unsurprisingly incredibly sticky. So I read that close to 90% of people who bought an iPhone last year were replacing an iPhone.”at 19:39
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple's cheap Gemini licensing gives it leverage and removes the need for its own frontier model.

    Apple pays Google about $1B a year for the Gemini models behind the new Siri, while Google pays Apple about $20B a year for search defaults. That gap shows Apple's leverage in the relationship. Daniel argues Gemini's price is low, possibly deliberately, so Apple has little incentive to build a frontier model itself and can license the one it needs. Apple's small on-device models remain its own, so it is not entirely out of the race. Daniel also thinks Gemini is one of the weaker frontier models.

    “Apple is paying about $1,000,000,000 a year for that, and I only bring that up because it does show that, to some extent at least, they have the leverage there.”at 27:19
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple's App Store take rate is falling toward 15% from 30%, already slowing services growth.

    Courts are pushing App Store fees down. The Epic case led to a ban on commissions on link-outs, Apple can still charge a 'reasonable' commission, and Europe and Japan have forced lower rates, with fees around 26% for Apple payments, 20% for in-app payments on developers' own sites, and 5% for link-outs. Shawn expects the take rate to fall slowly toward about 15%. This is already visible: third-party trackers show US App Store consumer spending down about 6% in June after growing close to 10% a year earlier, estimates put Apple's US commission revenue down close to 20% this year, and services growth slowed from 16% to 12% last quarter. Daniel adds that the CFO cited the absolute take rate as a major reason for the shift.

    “So I mean, what is happening though is that the take rate is gonna go down slowly and it might end up at something closer to 15% than the 30 that we've seen in the past.”at 30:34
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkUncertain

    App Store lock-in holds for now, but AI-powered competition could eventually break Apple's developer toll.

    Developers have had no real choice but to stay in the App Store because most users spend their time there, so the reach is hard to replace. Meta's own app store effort, backed by heavy spending, saw few developers switch, which suggests the business is stickier than people assume. Developers now have more incentive to leave if they can, and a small but vocal group could reach a tipping point as the environment changes. Daniel thinks that if this happens, it is most likely through AI-powered competition, though he treats this as uncertain.

    “And if you pay 30% for that or 20 or 15, that's the deal that you gotta pay. ... which in this case, if it should ever happen, is most likely AI powered competition.”at 32:20
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkUncertain

    Apple's AI approach may be the most deliberate among the Mag 7, though whether it is right is open.

    Apple's early AI effort was messy: a new Siri shown in 2024 was delayed indefinitely in March 2025, and the foundation model team lost talent to Meta, OpenAI and Anthropic. Shawn argues that this is not a lack of strategy, and that Apple's approach of owning the device and renting the model is deliberate. Apple has about 2.5 billion active devices to roll out its AI features on. Whether this is the right call is the open question.

    “I would actually say that after looking into it, it might not be a lack thereof. It might even be, you could say, the most deliberate AI strategy in the whole [Mag] seven.”at 33:00
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple underpaid AI talent and stepped back from building frontier AI on its own.

    Apple's retention bonuses for AI and iPhone designers reportedly ranged from $200K to $400K over four years, while OpenAI paid salaries in stock and options worth about $1M to $1.5M per employee. Meta reportedly paid about $200M to poach the foundation model team lead, and OpenAI has hired more than 400 former Apple employees. Apple's head of AI retired in December. Apple chose not to enter the cost war, and Daniel thinks this is a major reason it moved away from building its own AI models, at least for now.

    “Apple is paying significantly less than competitors because they didn't want to enter any cost wars even here. So, ultimately, I think that's part of why they moved away from trying to do AI on their own at least for now.”at 35:16
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkUncertain

    Siri's strength is ecosystem context rather than model power, though reviews are mixed.

    The new Siri, built on Google's Gemini foundation and released in September, has mixed reviews. Some call it a major improvement, while others say it is far from agents like ChatGPT or Claude. Daniel thinks it is unfair to compare it to those tools. Apple's strength is the context it can deliver from everything it knows about the user in its ecosystem, not having the strongest model.

    “I think their strength is not in having the strongest [model] running the system, but more about the context that Apple can deliver just because of everything it knows about you in the ecosystem.”at 35:50
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Siri's edge is personal context, not model strength, making it useful for personal queries.

    Siri does not need to be the most cutting-edge model because its job is personal tasks. Shawn has used it for the first time in years. Asking when his next dentist appointment is makes it dig through texts, emails and calendar, which is fairly useful. Nobody has as much personal context as Apple, so Siri's advantage is its data about the user, not model quality.

    “Siri doesn't need to be the most cutting edge commercial model out there for doing your work on. It just needs to know my personal stuff and nobody has that context about me in the way that Apple does.”at 37:19
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Licensing rival models beats Apple's costly model training; its no-frontier-model AI bet is reasonable.

    Apple has chosen to license models rather than build frontier ones. Training a model costs tens of billions of dollars and gets leapfrogged roughly every six months, while licensing costs much less. Apple also cannot outspend competitors after its talent drain, and Daniel argues it can be wrong about AI and still be a wonderful business, unlike Mag 7 peers that need AI to succeed. Gemini was chosen and the hardware chief was made CEO, which doubles down on this strategy. Daniel says he goes back and forth on it, but calls the pragmatic bet reasonable.

    “And if you compare training a model, which costs tens of billions of dollars and basically gets leapfrogged every six months to just license it for significantly less money, I think the bet doesn't look that bad.”at 42:36
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple's R&D spending is more predictable than hyperscalers' data-center capex, making it better positioned.

    Hyperscalers spend around $600 billion this year on data centers, much of it on GPUs. It is hard to tell how much is growth capex and how much is maintenance. Apple's R&D spending is easier to predict, so Apple is at least much more predictable and possibly better positioned than the hyperscalers.

    “And Apple seems, if not better positioned, at least much more predictable with its R and D spending.”at 44:23
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple acts as a hedge: it wins if AI disappoints and stays involved if AI pays off.

    The market treats Apple as a safe harbor in a volatile AI and semiconductor space. If AI disappoints relative to lofty expectations from Anthropic, OpenAI and the Mag 7, Apple benefits because it spends less on AI. If AI keeps improving and pays off, Apple still controls the hardware and can partner with AI players to build on its ecosystem. Shawn calls that a valuable asymmetry.

    “Apple almost feels like a hedge for the possibility that AI will disappoint in some ways and not reach the highs that Anthropic and OpenAI and the Mag seven are preaching... Apple wins when AI is less valuable than expected.”at 45:33
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple has lost TSMC 3nm priority to Nvidia and others, leaving it supply constrained.

    Apple used to be TSMC's most important chip customer and got the capacity it needed for each new iPhone. Nvidia is now TSMC's largest customer. AI chips from Nvidia, AMD, Amazon and Microsoft all want the same three-nanometer capacity Apple needs. As a result Apple has been supply constrained for a year or two, and this is a cost of not spending heavily on AI infrastructure.

    “the AI chips from NVIDIA, AMD, Amazon, and Microsoft all want the same three nanometer capacity that also Apple needs for their iPhone. So the result is that Apple has been supply constrained over the last year or two.”at 47:16
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    AI data centers' memory demand hurts Apple's supply and iPhone pricing, with lasting impact in a few years.

    AI data centers are taking the high-end memory supply, so memory prices have exploded. Apple used to lock in supply years ahead, but it no longer has that priority with suppliers. This is why Apple raised iPhone prices mid-cycle for the first time and why its guidance was weaker than expected. Shawn sees the impact as short-term while demand normalizes, but he could easily see it hurting Apple a couple of years out.

    “Memory prices exploded because AI data centers take all of the high end memory in Apple, which used to lock in supply years ahead of time... It sounds like a short term story since demand for memory at some point should normalize, but I could easily see how that in a couple of years out, it does have an impact.”at 47:34
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    If AI improves fast, Apple could lose share before it can license its way to good models.

    Apple is becoming an outsider in AI relative to peers that have secured chip capacity. If AI keeps improving quickly, Apple might lose share before it can license its way into good models. Daniel compares this to Nokia and BlackBerry, which were convinced that the smartphone would be just a feature until it became a new interface that disrupted them. Strong brands like Nike can also lose share despite looking invulnerable.

    “if AI keeps improving as it has in the last few years and potentially even achieves faster improvement, well, then Apple might lose share before they can license their way into good AI models.”at 49:36
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    The smartphone will remain the dominant device for a long time; the iPhone is hard to displace.

    Despite AI improvements, glasses will need to be an order of magnitude better to replace the smartphone. They also need perfect voice recognition and must avoid seeming like spying in everyday encounters. Shawn says the iPhone is the greatest product in the history of capitalism and is hard to displace. Until a viable alternative arrives, Apple has many chances to get things right and to cement its role in the next platform.

    “it will still be a long time before we're talking about a really viable alternative to the smartphone. I mean, in my opinion, the iPhone is the greatest product in the history of capitalism.”at 54:30
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple can monetize AI through App Store fees and by auctioning the default AI assistant slot.

    If the phone stays the AI interface, Apple keeps earning from AI through the App Store. ChatGPT is the top-grossing app, and Apple takes a 15 to 30% commission on its subscriptions. Apple earned nearly $900 million from generative AI apps in 2025, with ChatGPT about 75% of that. The judge in the Google case banned exclusivity, so Apple could sell the default assistant slot the way it sold the default search slot. OpenAI, Google and Anthropic could bid against each other for it. iOS 27 already lets Siri hand general questions to third-party assistants.

    “So nothing stops Apple from selling the default AI assistant slot the same way they sold the default search slot on the iPhone. And OpenAI, Google, and Anthropic could all end up bidding against each other for that slot on Siri.”at 57:31
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    AI agents bypassing apps would threaten Apple's App Store commission on digital goods.

    In a scenario where agents replace apps, the storefront matters less because users no longer browse it. The transaction then happens outside the App Store. Apple earns about 5% on such transactions today, and possibly zero if there is no App Store connection, so the commission on digital goods, roughly a third of Services, is threatened. Who owns the agent is also unclear, and it does not look like Apple.

    “And then the commission on digital goods, which is probably a third of services right now, is definitely threatened because the transaction doesn't happen in app anymore.”at 59:34
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Even if AI glasses disrupt phones, Apple has a good shot at dominating that device too.

    A voice-first, screenless AI device could replace smartphones, and that could be the most likely disruption. Even so, Apple has a strong position, with patents, R&D spending of $45 billion, a consumer base that wants its products, and hardware it can build well. Daniel expects Apple could put out fantastic glasses at some point, so an AI-glasses shift does not automatically mean Apple loses.

    “even this scenario doesn't automatically mean that Apple loses because they have a good shot at dominating this product too.”at 1:04:57
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Huawei's rise and Apple's volatile China position are a growing threat to Apple.

    China is about 17% of Apple's revenue and hosts most of its manufacturing. Shawn says Apple's position there has been volatile. Huawei is now number one in China, growing about 20% a year in a shrinking smartphone market, with its own chips and operating system. He notes it is the only company that has copied the Apple model successfully. Daniel adds that the government is on Huawei's side. Daniel also points out that Apple had strong quarters recently, up more than 30% year over year, which narrows the gap again.

    “But Apple's position there has been very volatile and so the company Huawei is now number one in China, growing about 20% a year in what's actually a shrinking smartphone market with its own chips and its own operating system.”at 1:11:38
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple's buybacks at 40x earnings are far less attractive than the 12x buybacks of 2016.

    Shawn says Apple is buying back stock at about 40x earnings, a multiple value investors avoid. That gives a free cash flow yield under 3%. In 2016 the company bought back shares at about 12x earnings, a much better return on the same spending. Buffett has praised Apple's buyback discipline, but he has sold a large part of his stake, probably partly because of the high multiple.

    “And Apple is now buying back stock at 40 times earnings which is something we were sort of allergic to as value investors and that's a free cash flow yield of under 3%.”at 1:13:26
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Buybacks at Apple's current price are worse than holding 4% Treasuries.

    Daniel says buybacks only make sense when the stock is cheap. Apple has about $100 billion a year to deploy, and it is not spending it on AI capex. Apple's own cash earns about 4% in Treasuries. On pure arithmetic, holding that cash would beat buying stock at this price. Management would not like that, because buybacks signal that the company thinks its shares are not overvalued.

    “So the [buyback] is only great when the shares are actually cheap. ...technically, Apple's own cash runs about 4% in treasuries right now. So on pure arithmetic, that would probably be better off piling up cash than buying their stock at this price.”at 1:14:04
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple's fair value is about $250 at a mid-twenties multiple; overvalued near 40x earnings.

    Daniel splits Apple into iPhone, Mac, iPad, wearables and services. He gives hardware a 30% margin and services a mid-70s margin, with services growing about 10% a year and hardware in the mid single digits. Buybacks lift that to about 10% EPS growth, which he calls realistic but low. That does not justify about 40x earnings. He would pay only a mid-twenties multiple, which gives a fair value of about $250. He would want the stock nearer $200 before owning it.

    “I would probably only want to pay a mid twenties multiple for Apple. And if that's the case, you would get a fair value of about $250.”at 1:15:37
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple is overvalued at this price; Shawn would pass but would buy near $200.

    Shawn says he would pass at this price. He cites mid-single-digit growth, a 40x multiple, buybacks at under a 3% free cash flow yield, rising input costs and a large AI question mark. Together these leave more uncertainty than the multiple reflects. He wants a margin of safety, so he would be interested near $200. He does not short, because the customer base is sticky and the company buys back about $100 billion of stock a year. He calls shorting dangerous and says he is happy to stay on the sidelines.

    “Yes, I mean, for me, it's a pass at this price. ...if we did ever get the stock at a price closer to that $200 range, I would be very excited to take a look at Apple.”at 1:16:37
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Apple's minimal data-center and AI spending doesn't justify its premium 40x multiple.

    Daniel says Apple is not spending on AI, which is fine but not what he wants to see. Investors who think the other Magnificent 7 companies are overspending and on the wrong path find Apple's low data-center exposure attractive. He does not believe that is worth paying a premium 40x multiple for. He still expects Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Meta to benefit from their AI investment, and he is wary of GPU spending and its effect on maintenance capex. Overall, he won't own Apple unless it falls significantly, to roughly $200.

    “...the little exposure to the data center build out and also the AI expenses is attractive to investors who believe the other [Mag 7] are spending too much money and are on the wrong path, I don't believe that's worth paying a premium for that 40 x multiple.”at 1:18:07
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple has barely tested iPhone pricing power, so there is room to raise prices.

    Daniel was surprised by how little Apple has tested its pricing power on the iPhone, which suggests there is much more potential there. He still says that potential is not enough to justify buying the stock at today's prices, so this is a positive view on the business that does not carry over to the valuation.

    “What did surprise me though is how little Apple has tested its pricing power for the iPhone. So there's probably much more potential there.”at 1:18:07

Microsoft

Across the shows: 45 speakers in other episodes, 47 bullish and 11 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Microsoft

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Microsoft benefits if data-center pushback slows buildout, since it already has capacity.

    With the midterms approaching, voters appear to be turning against new data centers, which could slow AI capex over the next couple of years. Daniel argues this strengthens the position of incumbents such as Microsoft that have already built capacity, because new entrants would face the same permitting and siting obstacles. The argument is brief and depends on how much the backlash actually slows capex.

    “And I also made the argument that perhaps it strengthens the position of companies like Microsoft and Amazon that also matter because they have already built some capacity.”at 7:43
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Microsoft's enterprise AI focus is the right bet because enterprise is a better AI market than consumer.

    Microsoft's AI bet is enterprise-focused, with OpenAI as a partner, Azure as infrastructure and Copilot in Office. Microsoft has no consumer device, so focusing on enterprises instead of mass consumers makes sense for it. Anthropic's rise shows that enterprise is a better market than consumer.

    “And if you look at Microsoft, their bet is more enterprise focused... it only makes sense, right, for them to focus on enterprises instead of mass consumers. And as Anthropic has shown, that actually tends to be a better market anyways.”at 37:30
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Microsoft will benefit in the long run from its AI infrastructure spending.

    Daniel says he is a bit scared of GPU spending and what it means for maintenance capex. He still believes that Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Meta will benefit in the long run from their current AI investment. He gives no stated position in Microsoft.

    “And in the long run, I do believe that Amazon, Google, Microsoft, and Meta will benefit from those investments today.”at 1:18:07

Meta Platforms

Across the shows: 65 speakers in other episodes, 59 bullish and 34 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Meta Platforms

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Meta's glasses are gaining traction, and AI could finally tie its ecosystem together.

    Meta's glasses are its main hardware and are being positioned as an alternative to smartphones, and each release seems more successful. Daniel thinks AI could be the connective tissue that finally makes Meta's ecosystem work together, which it has not done for a long time. He says this is not certain but is possible. He holds Meta in his personal account and probably will add to it, and he is considering it for the Intrinsic Value portfolio.

    “Meta is trying to position its glasses, which is the main hardware it currently has, as an alternative to smartphones. And it seems more and more successful with the releases.”at 8:01
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Meta's Ray-Ban glasses are a success given where Meta started, despite small volumes.

    Meta sold more than 7 million pairs of Ray-Ban Meta glasses last year. That number is tiny next to iPhone volumes, but compared with where Meta started, it is a success. Meta sees the glasses as a new AI platform that could rival Apple's, and a recent Meta ad suggests glasses could let people stay present rather than filming on phones.

    “there have been more than 7,000,000 pairs of the Ray Ban Meta glasses sold last year... But compared to where Meta is coming from, I would think it's a success if you look at it.”at 39:58
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Meta will benefit in the long run from its AI infrastructure spending.

    Daniel says he is a bit scared of GPU spending and what it means for maintenance capex. He still believes that Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Meta will benefit in the long run from their current AI investment. His fund holds Meta, which backs up that view.

    “And in the long run, I do believe that Amazon, Google, Microsoft, and Meta will benefit from those investments today. Otherwise, we wouldn't be invested in Amazon and Google, and I wouldn't be invested in Meta either.”at 1:18:07

Alphabet

Across the shows: 73 speakers in other episodes, 62 bullish and 50 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Alphabet

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Apple's reliance on Google's Gemini gives Google leverage that could make the deal costly later.

    Apple now depends on Google for the most important software layer on its iPhone and for about $20 billion of Services profit through search. The Gemini deal costs about $1 billion a year, which is a bargain today. If Apple cannot build a competitive model itself, that bargain could become whatever Google wants to charge in five years, and Google would have a lot of leverage over Apple.

    “If Apple can't build a competitive model itself though and the talent exodus and lack of investment suggests that that is the case, then really this billion dollar bargain today could become whatever Google wants to charge in five years.”at 1:01:11
  • Shawn O'Malley · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBearish

    Gemini has underperformed rival models recently, so Google is not the best AI bet.

    Gemini has comparatively underperformed other models over the last few months, which makes Google less attractive as a horse to back in AI. Apple paying Google for models that underperform is a risk over the long term. Shawn notes that the market thought Google was far behind two years ago and was wrong, so betting against Google is generally a bad idea, but Gemini's recent performance is a real weakness.

    “we have actually seen Gemini comparatively underperform against other models over the last few months. So Google in some ways doesn't even feel like the best horse to bet on.”at 1:02:59
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Alphabet will benefit in the long run from its AI infrastructure spending.

    Daniel says he is a bit scared of GPU spending and what it means for maintenance capex. He still believes that Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Meta will benefit in the long run from their current AI investment. His fund holds Google and Amazon, which backs up that view.

    “And in the long run, I do believe that Amazon, Google, Microsoft, and Meta will benefit from those investments today. Otherwise, we wouldn't be invested in Amazon and Google, and I wouldn't be invested in Meta either.”at 1:18:07

Amazon.com

Across the shows: 46 speakers in other episodes, 65 bullish and 8 bearish calls, past 30 days

Where everyone stands on Amazon.com

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Amazon benefits if data-center pushback slows buildout, since it already has capacity.

    Voter resistance to new data centers before the midterms could slow AI capex over the next couple of years. Daniel argues this favours incumbents like Amazon that have already built capacity, since new capacity would face the same permitting and siting obstacles. The argument is brief and depends on how much the backlash actually slows buildout.

    “And I also made the argument that perhaps it strengthens the position of companies like Microsoft and Amazon that also matter because they have already built some capacity.”at 7:43
  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast NetworkBullish

    Amazon will benefit in the long run from its AI infrastructure spending.

    Daniel says he is a bit scared of GPU spending and what it means for maintenance capex. He still believes that Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Meta will benefit in the long run from their current AI investment. His fund is invested in Amazon, Google and Meta, which backs up that view.

    “And in the long run, I do believe that Amazon, Google, Microsoft, and Meta will benefit from those investments today. Otherwise, we wouldn't be invested in Amazon and Google, and I wouldn't be invested in Meta either.”at 1:18:07

Enterprise AI adoption & AI software

Where everyone stands on Enterprise AI adoption & AI software

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast Network

    Advanced AI creates more value as an employee tool than as a consumer product.

    Daniel says people use advanced AI much more as employees than as consumers. Consumers do not care how efficient they are getting at a task, so they do not need top-tier models. Enterprise users see tasks that took five hours shrink to two, which is why productivity matters to them. This explains why Apple's consumer-facing Muse-type products can succeed without matching frontier models like Claude.

    “I also think that's kind of the point where people use advanced AI much more as employees, and we talked about this, than as consumers.”at 41:48

AI infrastructure & data centers

Where everyone stands on AI infrastructure & data centers

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast Network

    Hyperscaler GPUs will add over $100 billion a year of depreciation, and growth versus maintenance capex is unclear.

    Hyperscalers spend about $600 billion this year on data centers, much of it on GPUs. GPUs depreciate over five to six years, so starting now a depreciation charge of $100 billion or more a year hits income statements, and it will grow with more investment. Amazon's management says AWS could reach a trillion dollars in revenue, but investors must work out how much of the spending is maintenance and how much is growth.

    “And those GPUs depreciate over five to six years... So starting now, there's going to be a $100,000,000,000 plus a year of depreciation hitting the income statements.”at 44:59

AI: overall outlook

Where everyone stands on AI: overall outlook

  • Daniel Mahncke · The Investor's Podcast Network

    AI could break the Mag 7's dominance, as Google's search moat was once thought invulnerable.

    Historically, most of the S&P 500's top five companies are not in the top five two decades later. The Mag 7 seemed invulnerable because of their network effects, scale, switching costs and brands, so it felt unrealistic that the same pattern would repeat. AI may be the first thing that changes that. Google's search business was also seen as indisputable until AI put it at risk, and Daniel thinks the Mag 7 may face the same risk.

    “And it just feels so unrealistic that the same repeats with the Mag seven. And now that AI came up, it's the first time ever that at least my gut feeling says, well, maybe this is what changes the picture”at 54:56

Across the shows

What other episodes Chorus covered said about the same companies in the 30 days up to this one.

  • Alphabet73 speakers · 62 bullish, 50 bearish calls
  • Meta Platforms65 speakers · 59 bullish, 34 bearish calls
  • Apple50 speakers · 63 bullish, 41 bearish calls
  • Amazon.com46 speakers · 65 bullish, 8 bearish calls
  • Microsoft45 speakers · 47 bullish, 11 bearish calls

Ask your AI who they are and what they said

Topics

  • AI glasses displacing smartphones
  • AI interface shift and Apple share loss
  • AI smart glasses
  • AI use by employees vs consumers
  • App Store commission take rate
  • App Store developer lock-in
  • App Store take rate on AI apps
  • Apple AI capex and data center exposure
  • Apple as hedge against AI disappointment
  • Apple valuation
  • Apple's AI model licensing
  • Apple's AI model strategy
  • Apple's AI strategy
  • Apple's in-house AI talent
  • China smartphone competition
  • GPU depreciation
  • Gemini model performance
  • Mag 7 durability
  • Siri personal context
  • TSMC 3nm capacity access
  • buybacks at high valuation
  • data center buildout backlash
  • dependence on Google's Gemini
  • enterprise vs consumer AI market
  • hyperscaler AI capex returns
  • hyperscaler capex
  • hyperscaler capex vs R&D
  • iPhone ecosystem loyalty
  • iPhone pricing power
  • memory prices
  • new hardware innovation
  • search default payments
  • services mix and margins
  • smart glasses and wearables
  • smart glasses competition

More from We Study Billionaires

All We Study Billionaires episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus