J.P. Morgan Making Sense · · 12 min

Financing the Future of Defense: Admiral Pierre Vandier on Innovation and Investment

With Pierre Vandier

Summary

Admiral Pierre Vandier, NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation, argues that the Russia-Ukraine war has exposed Western forces built for short crisis management, making industrial production and munitions capacity decisive; he cites Patriot air defense over Kyiv and Ukraine's shell shortfall against Russia, roughly 15 to 20 to one, which pushed Ukraine to adopt off-the-shelf drones and software-driven systems in place of artillery. He calls the main defense challenge adoption at scale rather than invention, and says NATO's innovation board has been turned into an adoption board, with procurement shifting from headquarters-set requirements to a customer-centric model. He proposes marketplaces with reference architectures, citing NATO's space-services marketplace, while noting that nations still want national identity on their systems and that European defense consolidation has not yet occurred because governments prioritize domestic jobs. On finance, he argues that defense has attracted little private capital over thirty years, and that banks can speed funding and attach new KPIs to direct money toward future capabilities, with most relevant technology now emerging in civilian, dual-use sectors.

Key takeaways

  • Pierre Vandier on Russia & Ukraine: Protracted Ukraine war exposes that industrial production, not just stockpiles, decides air defense and war-fighting capacity.
  • Pierre Vandier on Robotics & autonomous vehicles: Ukraine's cheap drones are replacing artillery and driving a continually updated, software-driven style of war.
  • Pierre Vandier on Defense: Europe must rebuild conventional stockpiles, but avoid building large stockpiles of obsolete equipment.
  • Pierre Vandier on Defense: Adoption at scale of new military technology, not innovation, is the main problem, and it is cultural.
  • Pierre Vandier on Defense: Defense has been underfunded for thirty years, so this is a reinvestment moment where private and bank capital is needed.

What was said, by company and theme

9 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

Defense

Where everyone stands on Defense

  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Europe must rebuild conventional stockpiles, but avoid building large stockpiles of obsolete equipment.

    The global military is too small today, so NATO needs more tanks, jets, frigates and submarines. That bulk of the 3.5% spending pledge goes to conventional forces. A thin layer, perhaps a few percent of the pledge, must target the changing character of war and be embedded in a digital factory. The dilemma is that a huge stockpile of things that become obsolete would not answer the question, so the goal is to keep technological edge without building stockpiles of old equipment.

    “So the first intent is to revamp the stockpiles... I say the global military is too low today. So we need more tanks. We need more jets, more frigates or submarines.”at 3:43
  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Military innovation now comes from the civilian sector, so the military is lagging and must absorb commercial tech.

    Technology and inventions have moved from the military side to the commercial side. Research and technology now happen mainly in the civilian sector, and the military is lagging behind. A major part of the transformation job is bringing these commercial technologies into the military. This changes training, command and operations, which is why the effect is transformational.

    “I see the technology and the inventions have turned from the military side to the commercial side. And so all the research and technology has been made in the civilian sector today and the military is lagging behind.”at 4:34
  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Adoption at scale of new military technology, not innovation, is the main problem, and it is cultural.

    Vandier argues that the main problem is not inventing new things but getting armed forces to adopt them at scale. This is a behavioural and cognitive problem: the transformation challenge is cultural, because new tools change how militaries train, command and operate and how they organize themselves. To address this, he has turned NATO ACT's innovation board into an adoption board. The aim is to give nations and their militaries an incentive to say that with the money they have, they need better performance.

    “is adoption at scale? Yeah. So it's why, for example, here in ACT, I transform my innovation board in an adoption board. Okay. Because the question is not that much innovating.”at 5:22
  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Military procurement is shifting from headquarters-set requirements to customer-led problem statements that industry must answer.

    For the past thirty years, headquarters set requirements and the needs, and then industry built whatever tool was asked for. Vandier says the military is progressively moving to a customer-centric approach, in which the customers themselves say which problem they want solved, and industry must respond to that.

    “We are progressively entering in a system where we have a customer centric approach in the military, which is absolutely not the way things have been done during the last thirty years.”at 6:34
  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    European defense consolidation has not happened; national governments want domestic industry for jobs.

    Vandier sees no consolidation of Europe's defense industry yet. Rising budgets encourage each nation to say it will be big enough to make all its military equipment itself. Governments are under pressure to show taxpayers that defense money creates jobs at home, because buying overseas looks like wasted money to the population. Political leaders constantly ask about jobs in their own constituencies.

    “What I see from here is not consolidation yet... Each nation to stand up and say, okay. I will be big enough to make all my military stuff myself.”at 7:39
  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Marketplaces with common standards are the best way to aggregate European defense demand without integrating supply.

    Modular capabilities such as drones, robotics and IT-centric systems can be organized through marketplaces. Standards would be set with a reference architecture, and suppliers could then offer components at the best cost, like assembling a LEGO set. NATO is already building a marketplace for space services, which lets nations rent services for a few days instead of launching a large satellite program. Vandier thinks this aggregates demand well. Full integration at the system level is less likely, because nations want their own national identity on the product.

    “I think when we see modular capabilities as drones are, so all the robotics, all the IT centric capabilities, then you can organize the world with marketplaces.”at 8:46
  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Defense has been underfunded for thirty years, so this is a reinvestment moment where private and bank capital is needed.

    Capital invested in defense over the past thirty years has been very limited, and research and investment were both low. Civilian capital, including banks, can bring speed, which matters because many defense players are struggling with finance. Banks can also bring new KPIs, attaching conditions to funding so money goes to the future rather than the past, as in the World War I shift from horse to car and from infantry to tank. Vandier sees finance of tomorrow's industry as a specific role for banking today.

    “I think the level of capital that has been poured, injected in the defense since the last thirty years have been very limited... and so it's moment of reinvestment.”at 10:06

Russia & Ukraine

Where everyone stands on Russia & Ukraine

  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Protracted Ukraine war exposes that industrial production, not just stockpiles, decides air defense and war-fighting capacity.

    Ukraine is entering its fifth winter, and the war has become protracted. The Western world built its post-Cold War forces for crisis management, with stockpiles and a military able to handle a short crisis but not a long war. Air defense over Kyiv shows the problem: the key question is how many Patriot systems are available, and the production and industry behind them is the decisive factor. Vandier therefore sees this war as creating a new link between industry and war.

    “and the production and the industry which is behind is the key question. So this is the first area where I think this war brings a new link between industry and war.”at 1:48

Robotics & autonomous vehicles

Where everyone stands on Robotics & autonomous vehicles

  • Pierre Vandier · NATO Allied Command Transformation

    Ukraine's cheap drones are replacing artillery and driving a continually updated, software-driven style of war.

    Ukraine was badly short of shells, with Russia outshooting it roughly 15 to 20 to one. Ukraine responded by using drones off the shelf to replace artillery. That pushed it into digitalization, software and AI, and the result is a new kind of war in which technology on the shelf is constantly updated rather than relying only on fixed existing systems.

    “And so what did Ukrainians? They went with on the shelf drones, and they say, we will replace artillery by drones. And then they they entered in a new world of digitalization of software and AI.”at 2:12

Topics

  • European defense consolidation
  • defense marketplaces and standards
  • defense procurement model
  • defense technology adoption
  • drones replacing artillery
  • dual-use technology
  • private capital in defense
  • protracted war and munitions production
  • stockpiles and obsolescence

More from J.P. Morgan Making Sense

All J.P. Morgan Making Sense episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus