Bloomberg Talks · · 13 min

International Spy Museum Historian Mark Jacobson Talks Nvidia Crisis

With Mark Jacobson

Summary

Mark Jacobson, a former national security official now with the International Spy Museum, discusses the Nvidia controversy in the context of the US-China AI and chip race. He argues that restricting advanced chip technology is in US interests, since restrictions slow China and let America advance, though AI is harder to control than atomic energy because it sits mainly with private firms. He disagrees with Jensen Huang's case for sharing advanced chips with China and warns that Silicon Valley leaders underestimate their exposure to espionage from China and Russia. On enforcement, he notes the Commerce probe into suspected front companies has passed to the Department of Justice and that chip smuggling will persist. He also questions whether Beijing cultivated Huang, possibly via Alice Wong, to shape Trump administration policy, describing Wong as a possible unwitting participant and the White House as soft on China at times.

Key takeaways

  • Mark Jacobson on US–China AI & chip race: Silicon Valley AI leaders underestimate how seriously China and Russia will target them for espionage.
  • Mark Jacobson on US–China AI & chip race: China may use Jensen Huang's chip-policy advocacy to shape US policy, benefiting both Nvidia and China.
  • Mark Jacobson on US–China AI & chip race: Restricting advanced chips is in US interest, though it won't stop China long term; it only buys time.
  • Mark Jacobson on US–China AI & chip race: Chip smuggling through front companies will persist and must be shut down, with DOJ now leading the probe.

What was said, by company and theme

4 views from 1 speaker. Every quote is checked against the episode's transcript (how).

US–China AI & chip race

Where everyone stands on US–China AI & chip race

  • Mark Jacobson · International Spy Museum

    Silicon Valley AI leaders underestimate how seriously China and Russia will target them for espionage.

    Jacobson argues that tech and AI leaders in Silicon Valley do not appear to understand that they are serious targets for espionage. He says China and Russia in particular will make herculean efforts to gain a competitive advantage, especially in AI. He frames the Nvidia affair as part of a longer history of corporate and state-sponsored espionage, in which covert cyber operations, human sources, blackmail and influence are standard tools for acquiring restricted technology. Intelligence agencies' focus is on critical technologies such as AI and quantum.

    “I think what's challenging is that it doesn't appear that leaders in the tech, the AI space, Silicon Valley understand that they are serious targets and the Chinese and the Russians in particular are going to take herculean efforts to try and get a competitive advantage, especially when it comes to AI.”at 4:15
  • Mark Jacobson · International Spy Museum

    China may use Jensen Huang's chip-policy advocacy to shape US policy, benefiting both Nvidia and China.

    Jacobson argues the key question is whether China sought its relationship with Jensen Huang, possibly through Alice Wong, to influence Trump administration policy. The most valuable outcome for Beijing would be getting someone like Huang to advocate a position that serves China and also NVIDIA as a company. He describes Wong as possibly an unwitting participant, a 'useful idiot' pushed to take a position that benefits NVIDIA and China. He notes a policy debate between Commerce and Treasury, and says the White House has been soft on China at times.

    “Can you get someone like a Jensen Huang to advocate for a position that may not just be of interest to China... But even better when it's of interest to NVIDIA as a company?”at 6:08
  • Mark Jacobson · International Spy Museum

    Restricting advanced chips is in US interest, though it won't stop China long term; it only buys time.

    Jacobson, speaking as a national security professional, argues it is in the US interest to restrict chip technology. He says some technologies can be restricted, but restrictions will not limit China over the long term. What they do is let the US advance further. He argues AI is harder to restrict than atomic energy was in the 1940s and 1950s. Fission and later fusion were confined to a few government entities, whereas AI development sits largely with a private sector that is much harder to control. He disagrees with Jensen Huang's argument for sharing advanced chip technology with China.

    “I happen to think as a national security professional, it's in our interest to restrict the chip technology... there are certain technologies that you can restrict. It will not limit the Chinese in terms of the long term, but what it will do is allow us to perhaps advance a little further.”at 7:01
  • Mark Jacobson · International Spy Museum

    Chip smuggling through front companies will persist and must be shut down, with DOJ now leading the probe.

    Jacobson says the Commerce investigation into potential front companies has been taken over by the Department of Justice. Whether chip technology was acquired through illicit means will be a critical piece of the case. He says the smuggling needs to be shut down and hopes it already has, but expects it to remain a problem and says it will not go away.

    “Whether or not chip technology was acquired through illicit means, that's really going to be a critical piece of this. That needs to be shut down. I hope it's already shut down, but this is going to continue to be a problem. It will not go away.”at 9:19

Topics

  • China influence on chip export policy
  • chip export controls
  • chip smuggling enforcement
  • state espionage against AI firms

More from Bloomberg Talks

All Bloomberg Talks episodes

Ask your AI about this episode

Chorus gives Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants every view from this episode and every other show Chorus follows. Ask who agrees, who changed their mind, and what else was said about the same companies.

Setup guide

A weekly email with the calls that mattered from the most important voices in investing. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy

Chorus reports what speakers said. It isn't investment advice. How Chorus works · About Chorus